Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Rob Cosman and Chisels

Posts

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#51

Okay, I got you now (long sorry)

Adam Cherubini

>I know that you feel this way and I agree and disagree. I think my most fervent agreement comes from the notion that we spend far too much time on these forums talking about tools and very very little talking about what we make or how we use tools.

I think it's telling that we identify ourselves as woodworkers and not period furniture makers or chairmakers or bowl turners etc. We identify with the process, or in our case, the material we work, which does seem kind of silly.

But I think that there ARE times when a certain initmacy or tool sympathy is helpful or required. In this particular thread, I'm reading the relationship between technique and some pretty fine details of how the tool functions, besides the cave man "ug, chisel cut, chisel no cut". This is certainly an example of when it isn't that easy.

And not to be argumentative, but i think this is a pretty good example of specifically where I would disagree with you. Really low angle chisels can be helpful. They do different things, allow different techniques, but may require special care and feeding.

In this case in particular, one craftsman had trouble repeating another craftsman's experiment. Looks to me like the difference is pretty complicated. What I'd like to leave this thread with is that understanding edge retention is fairly complicated. And I think at least some of the trusims don't hold water. Raising the bevel angle isn't necessarily the best thing to do to improve edge retention. I think I would (do) polish first. Probably (have done) back bevel second, then raise the bevel. (I'm writing in some theoretical sounding voise, but this is a road I've walked fairly long and far on).

So the devil is sometimes in the details. Not alwasys so easy to just do it. When I was starting out, I remember asking "is it me or is it the tool?" Sometimes it really was the tool. Sometimes it was the wrong joint in the wrong wood cut with the wrong tool.

So not only to I understand the tool fascination, I think it can be necessary.

This speaks to Charles' point so fee free to stop reading if you aren't interested in what he thinks:

I've been chosen twice for Early American Life's "top craftsmen" list. This is a fairly serious list with distinguished judges. But I find the top "craftsmen" problematic. When I think of a good craftsman, I think of someone who can saw straight and make a tight mortise. But the judges don't see this. What they (and I suspect everyone else) sees in our work is the art work. And in my case, that art work isn't even mine. At best, my work reflects my ability to execute someone else's esthetic. It's almost like being a lawyer arguing for someone else. It's certainly not easy to do and I take pride in trying to present someone else's view point authentically. But it is still the artwork people respond to. Our "success" as woodworkers (whether we're pleasing a judge, a spouse, or a customer) is largely judged on art work that we don't seem to focus on in ww magazines, or forums.

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#52

Re: glue properties

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>You said, "I suppose this ability and knowledge may be opaque to someone not involved in product development at a company with state of art technical resources." I believe the glue is opaque. I don't think the ability and knowledge is to those at R&D. You're probably right.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#53

Re: Okay, I got you now (long sorry)

wilbur

>There are two things that I think of whenever I hear concerns as to whether we obsess too much about the tools and not the end product.

First, tools do have a primary purpose that they must serve, which is to perform their function. They also have a secondary purpose, which is to be a part of our shop, and as part of our working environment, they do contribute to our inspiration to do work, whether it is the aesthetics of the tool, or the belief, founded or unfounded, that that particular tool helps us get the job done.

What I think is often missed is that no one, I mean NO ONE, gets to dictate to others where that line regarding the secondary purpose of the tool is drawn. I know I have my line. I know that I have tools that some might deem too fancy, and others might deem not fancy enough. But it's my line, and I get to put it where I want.

In other words, if Dickens obsessed over his pen and ink, or how a pencil is made, that's his prerogative, and no one can tell him otherwise.

The second thing I think of is if you are feeling bad because someone is critical of your choice of tools because a cheaper/used/less fancy tool could have done the same job, ask them to show you their bookcase made with cinder blocks and 2x construction material. It is demonstrable that a cinder block/2x material bookcase can support books every bit as well as any other bookcase out there. In fact, it probably does a better job since the shelf material is thicker than 4/4 stock. It is also probably the cheapest and ugliest way to assemble a bookcase. So if that person has a nicer bookcase than one made from cinder block/2x material... well, I'll leave it as an exercise for the student to locate the intellectual inconsistency here.

(I wish I had come up with that myself.)

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#54

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Alan DuBoff

>Rob,

Are you trying to tell me that I should take practical advice from someone like you who has actually tried it in the shop, rather than that of an arm-chair woodworker that knows all the buzz words or can pronounce all the Japanese tool names with a western dialect?

I don't know, I'll think about it...:-/

Funny how many responses criticized your use of 17 degrees without knowing the details, or without trying it in use.

It is folks like you that help this craft progress, finding new ways to use tools more efficiently in different situations, rather than just babbling off without trying something...happens all too much on the inet.

Curious about your saw though...please feel free to share your practical real world experience on it's design if you feel inclined.:-)

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#55

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yes, well I'll admit I don't have nearly Rob's experience making dovetails in pine, a relatively uncalled for task outsides the show circuit; and I would assume he has more experience making furniture - he does it for a living. However, any advice I give is based on MY experience unless I otherwise specify.

Pam, who really doesn't know all the Japanese plane and chisel type names, unfortunately

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#56

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

The inet is a dangerous place in the sense that sometimes all the information is not fully understood, and in many cases all the facts are not disclosed, not purposely, just the nature of the beast.

This thread is a real classic, it's like the scene in Annie Hall where Woody Allen and Dianne Keaton go to the movies and Woody Allen is explaining to her exactly what the point was the writer was trying to get across, when the writer turns around in front of them in line and says, (to paraphrase) "Well, I'm the writer, and you know nothing about my movie, or why I wrote it, I never intended it to mean that at all".

As to the use of pine, it is quite commonly used for drawers, so in that case it is not an "uncalled for task outsides the show circuit". Frank Klausz uses it in his drawers, he's also quite famous amongst the dovetail aficionados. I know a couple local folks that make their drawers with hardwood fronts and pine sides/back, so this might be more common than you think. Still, Rob points out that this works for him in hardwoods as well, with the LN chisels.

To make matters worse, Charles responds to Rob with a comment about not needing to waste precious time experimenting with an exercise in tool steel removal at the grinder...*sigh*

Speaking for myself, I appreciate the fact that Rob did take the time to test out and discover that lower angles work better for softwoods, and in some cases with hardwoods. Those types of facts are good for everyone to know.

Rob explains that he was not talking out the side of his mouth with some comments and explained how he tests it out in real life to make sure that when he does mention it he will feel comfortable knowing it works, and that is key.

Count me as one of the folks that Rob has taught to cut dovetails indirectly. Not just Rob, but I use several of the techniques that I have learned from his DVDs. He explains things well, and as such is a very good instructor. More than that, he teaches folks what he has learned the hard way, even if it meant wasting precious time grinding away tool steel to bring the masses the information about using a lower bevel for specific tasks. After seeing several folks on WC jump all over the original poster that his bevel angles were wrong, it was satisfying to see that they were right, and more so that Rob wasn't talking out the side of his mouth, that he did in fact have reason for offering such advice. I have a lot more respect for him now, a very honorable craftsman indeed. This industry should have more Rob Cosmans. Anyone can sit back and offer advice on the inet without testing it out, second hand information is dangerous...so it's good to see folks back up their comments like Rob did.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#57

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>OK, so you're of the group that thinks there are always rights and wrongs in woodworking methods. I disagree.

I've watched one Cosman dvd (actually a two dvd set) on dovetailing drawers. While I have no complaints about his results, I find them generally too fiddly. But then I'm of the Klausz school more than anyone else, maybe a little Kingshott mixed in. What's more, I joined that school way before I knew there was a Klausz or Kingshott. Once I realized, with the first set I cut almost 30 years ago, which were perfect, btw, the ramifications of marking the second board, whether tails or pins, with the first board cut, I started freehanding the first board. Of course, I find it trivial to bisect/trisect, as do most people once they try, so they come out very well spaced and I save 10 minutes per set and the imprecision of marking with pencils.

As to Annie Hall, it wasn't Woody who was trying to explain Marshall's ideas. He was complaining about all the men in line who were loudly explaining same to their dates, incorrectly. Woody imagined Marshall in line dressing down one of the very bad professor types. Sorry, but you just tried to quote one of my three favorite movies. Might want to pick one I haven't seen next time.

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#58

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Rick in Oakville

>I have always thought it was great that Marshal McLuhan was enough of a good sport to appear as himself in the movie Annie Hall. I also love Woody Allan's aside to the audience after McLuhan put down the pompous jerk in the movie line - "Don't you wish you could really do that?"

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#59

Perfect, a movie you know!

Alan DuBoff

>Pam wrote:

"Might want to pick one I haven't seen next time."

Oh, I think the fact you know the scene so well is a blessing, I could not have made my point better. The fact that I have not seen the movie since the 80s when it came out is actually impressive that I could get the scene as close to home as I did...*wink*, that is more than 20 years for me...

Pam wrote:

"Once I realized, with the first set I cut almost 30 years ago, which were perfect, btw, the ramifications of marking the second board, whether tails or pins, with the first board cut, I started freehanding the first board."

So, let me understand this correctly...30 years ago you were able to cut your first dovetails, which were "perfect", and now 25-30 years later you break a Funiharo chisel over at Homestead Heritage, which was evidently a bad forged piece of steel?

The odd thing I have to wonder is that another person had reported once that they had a vintage Stanley chisel that broke at Homestead Heritage also (also stated it was a bad chisel), and I have to ponder why all the bad chisels show up at Homestead Heritage?

Now, in contrast you came into this thread offering advice to the original poster that his bevel angle could be wrong, yet Rob Cosman (one of the leading instructors for dovetails, BTW;-) replies that the 17 degree bevel is correct as stated and offered the facts/reasons why that is so...

I think Rob offered good advice in this comment below (although to Charles, the context here is to the point;-), I'm going to try and heed it speaking for myself because here's a guy that is still searching how to make that perfect dovetail after all the years he has invested in cutting them by hand, and he obviously has a way to go in learning how to grind his chisels well enough to get decent work done in the shop, or even to reach that perfect dovetail that you were able to accomplish some 30 years ago...that in itself in an internet phenomena, as I see it, which we all experience on a daily basis.

Rob Cosman wrote:

"Your response makes me think perhaps a little more time in the shop and less on the key board!"

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#60

One of the best scenes ever

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>It was truly one of the best scenes in moviedom. Just think of all those years we've suffered having to listen to these pompous know-it-all's in movie lines.

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#61

Re: Perfect, a movie you know!

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>You know, the one thing I count on from participants here is that they read what I say if they choose to comment, which was to the effect that I don't know everything, so that while there may be some advantage to what Rob is recommending, it's not necessary. If you're not going to read the messages, what's the point?

As to pine drawers, maybe a hard pine like long leaf, but not borg pine. The stuff is too soft and easily compressed. I make my drawers from oak. In fact, one of the first recommendations voiced here when someone mentions problems making dovetails is to not use pine for their first efforts.

As to old movies, if you're quoting a movie or book it's important that you get it right. It's certainly easy enough to get a copy of the movie and check it out if your memory is often faulty. You owe us that on this forum. Now you could also state some caveat that your memory may be faulty.

Also, it turns out I'm a natural at woodworking. I know you don't like this idea, but I've been woodworking since age 11, when I built my first bookshelf. I didn't take it seriously for a long time because society didn't think women/girls should do woodworking seriously, I wasn't even allowed to take shop in high school. But when I did start taking it seriously, when I had to build my darkroom, I took a class in hand tool use at the DeCordova Museum in Lincoln, MA. My first dovetails in teak were perfect, they fit perfectly, the box ended up perfect, and you can't talk that away from me. Oh, yeah, and since I had to hand saw the pieces, the sawing was perfect, too.

As to broken chisels at Homestead Heritage, it is what it is. I know nothing about a Stanley chisel, IIRC, have never owned one. Based on your memory problems, it probably happened somewhere else or you probably remembered my mention of the event incorrectly.

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#62

Pine as drawer side material is a good topic

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>to pursue.

However, much of the rest of this subthread has gone personal. Please back off and steer away from use of the accusatory and attacking 'you'. The woodworking aspects of your discussion are interesting and commendable.

Wiley, as Moderator

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#63

Drawer side material choices

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>A respected furniture repair person, from whom I learned a lot, advocated softer drawer sides and hard rails. His reason was that it was easy to repair a worn drawer and difficult to repair the side rails if they were mortised into the font rail. With what seems to be this good advice in mind, I use poplar for sides and maple for the side rails and I raise these rails slightly proud of the front rail. I think soft maple would be an ideal drawer choice but it is less available than poplar.

There is a place in Shelbyville KY that carries a lot of English furniture with its oak drawer sides and mahogany front rails. It is common to see a huge groove worn into the front rail in this furniture.

As for white pine drawers, that material seems best for demonstrations where its favorable compression ensures a tight fit under less than ideal dovetailing conditions. I have used white pine for bottoms. It is strong enough and it makes a light weight drawer.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#64

Re: Drawer side material choices

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, probably a good way to do things. However, except for my shop cabinets with metal runners, I don't use side rails, instead I use a central bottom runner mated with a glued on piece of pine, poplar, whatever. Therefore, oak works great. :)

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#65

Re: Drawer side material choices

Alan DuBoff

>Bill,

Your not alone, there are a lot of furniture makers that do just as you, and one reason is cost. It cost more for hardwood, so some folks think of using softwoods as a way to save on cost.

Even some of the cabinet shops that use MDF and veneers will use softwoods for the drawer sides, not uncommon.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#66

Re: Drawer side material choices

Dave Anderson NH

>Up here in northern New England white pine was a common material for all drawer parts except the fronts in both the 18th and 19th centuries. Please understand though that is is not the soft material that we see both at the Borgs and even the best lumberyards today with 4-8 growth rings per inch. This hard and tough material of old growth from dense forests and had from 10-20 rings per inch and was strong enough to provide the mast stock for the Royal Navy before the revolution and for our Navy and merchant marine afterwards. Well waxed on the bottom edges, I've not had wear problems and like Bill I make the runners out of harder material, usually maple cutoffs because of the tight closed pore grain.

When I do a 18th century reproduction piece from New England I use white pine, tulip poplar, and even maple though poplar was usually only used in southern NE.