Okay, I got you now (long sorry)
Adam Cherubini
>I know that you feel this way and I agree and disagree. I think my most fervent agreement comes from the notion that we spend far too much time on these forums talking about tools and very very little talking about what we make or how we use tools.
I think it's telling that we identify ourselves as woodworkers and not period furniture makers or chairmakers or bowl turners etc. We identify with the process, or in our case, the material we work, which does seem kind of silly.
But I think that there ARE times when a certain initmacy or tool sympathy is helpful or required. In this particular thread, I'm reading the relationship between technique and some pretty fine details of how the tool functions, besides the cave man "ug, chisel cut, chisel no cut". This is certainly an example of when it isn't that easy.
And not to be argumentative, but i think this is a pretty good example of specifically where I would disagree with you. Really low angle chisels can be helpful. They do different things, allow different techniques, but may require special care and feeding.
In this case in particular, one craftsman had trouble repeating another craftsman's experiment. Looks to me like the difference is pretty complicated. What I'd like to leave this thread with is that understanding edge retention is fairly complicated. And I think at least some of the trusims don't hold water. Raising the bevel angle isn't necessarily the best thing to do to improve edge retention. I think I would (do) polish first. Probably (have done) back bevel second, then raise the bevel. (I'm writing in some theoretical sounding voise, but this is a road I've walked fairly long and far on).
So the devil is sometimes in the details. Not alwasys so easy to just do it. When I was starting out, I remember asking "is it me or is it the tool?" Sometimes it really was the tool. Sometimes it was the wrong joint in the wrong wood cut with the wrong tool.
So not only to I understand the tool fascination, I think it can be necessary.
This speaks to Charles' point so fee free to stop reading if you aren't interested in what he thinks:
I've been chosen twice for Early American Life's "top craftsmen" list. This is a fairly serious list with distinguished judges. But I find the top "craftsmen" problematic. When I think of a good craftsman, I think of someone who can saw straight and make a tight mortise. But the judges don't see this. What they (and I suspect everyone else) sees in our work is the art work. And in my case, that art work isn't even mine. At best, my work reflects my ability to execute someone else's esthetic. It's almost like being a lawyer arguing for someone else. It's certainly not easy to do and I take pride in trying to present someone else's view point authentically. But it is still the artwork people respond to. Our "success" as woodworkers (whether we're pleasing a judge, a spouse, or a customer) is largely judged on art work that we don't seem to focus on in ww magazines, or forums.
Adam



