Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels
Rob Cosman
>Let me help unboggle your mind Charles. Your response makes me think perhaps a little more time in the shop and less on the key board!
I have cut a few joints in my 47 years, taught a few thousand to cut them as well. At a certain level of experience you (maybe just "me") start to split hairs in terms of improving the tiniest of problems. Perhaps the most annoying of those problems is the tendency of certain woods to crush and break out under the weight of the chisel rather than cut clean.
In the process of trying to correct this, I would saw as close to the line as possible, this helps but doesn't cure. The next approach was to use only a freshly sharpened chisel, (I am pretty sure I know what sharp is). One thing that did help was using a narrower chisel, I suspect this reduced surface area allows the fibers on either side to better support those under the chisel.
One bright sunny day I decided to experiment with lower angles of attack. This meant grinding the chisel to a more acute angle since increasing the angle made the situation worse. The later was discovered when LN started shipping chisels with 30 rather than the original 25 degree primary bevel. .
As I lowered the angle the problem lessened. At 17 degrees the problem dissappeared. I was using almost punky low grade Northern White pine, the faster growing stuff that has big spring wood compared to the smaller summer wood. Some of this stuff is like cutting white styrofoam. At 17 there is very little metal supporting the edge so I would only use this chisel in Aspen, Pine, Alder, Bass and similar woods. What was really nice was the way it would cut, a fraction of the resistance of higher angles, the narrow blade would get seated in the scribe line deep enough that by the time the pressure from the waste stared to build up there was no danger of it pushing the chisel beyond the scribe line.
I so liked the effect I started to use this chisel in harder woods, Cherry, Walnut, Poplar and found that if I was carefull the edge would hold. As Ellis mentioned, removing as much of the waste as possible is key! I try to not do things different at home than what I do in seminars/workshops so if I was going to use this low chisel I had to be prepared to explain it to others. My suggestion has been to take one or two from your set and grind them low for applications such as those I previously mentioned. Whacking on these in tough wood will surely cause them to fail, bend, break or chip. However, carefull mallet use in softer (prone to crushing) woods will leave a near perfect surface.
As per which brand chisel, I no longer have any ties to LN and have not since Jan/08 so there is nothing for me to gain in passing on a reccomendation. I have owned several brands over the past 30 years, some cheap and some expensive, the LNs are by far the most comfortable to use. Light in the hand, hold an edge better than any others "I" have used and in this case (17 degree) are the only ones that would not fold on the first few chops.
To satisfy Pam, no I have not tried any Japanese brands, dont care for them. I was there when the LNs were being developed, got to tryout some early prototypes, offered my feedback and have been a huge fan since. I offer my advice based on "this is what I do and what I use". I don't spend my days debating over price, testing and comparing brands, I found what works for me and because of my dvd and workshop/seminar exposure am often asked my opinion. You can take it or leave it, however be confident there is a fair bit of practical experience behind this opinion. Now have a Merry Christmas!
Cheers
Rob Cosman
www.robcosman.com