Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Rob Cosman and Chisels

Posts

Rob Cosman and Chisels

#1

Rob Cosman and Chisels

Doug Reynolds

>I am working on a tall cabinet in cherry as a Christmas gift and was having trouble with handcut dovatails last night. I had sharpened my very finest English import blue-handled Marples to a fine 17 degree bevel as per Rob Cosman's instructions in a class I took from him at the Seattle Woodcraft Store. I kept ending up with a chip in the chisel after only one mallet strike. Thinking I may have written down the wrong bevel angle I sent Rob an e-mail asking for clarification. Much to my suprise, he called me shortly after I hit the send key. Rob said 17 degrees was what he uses for soft woods and has had equally good luck with our domestic hardwoods but, has found only the Lie-Nielsen chisels to be able to hold such an angle. Now, I have to buy a whole new set of chisels. Darn!

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#2

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

wilbur

>Or, you could just increase the bevel angle on your chisel to, say, about 25 degrees. And if that doesn't work, go a little bit higher.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#3

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Bob Demers

>17 degrees is more like in paring chisels territory, not mallet wacking range. I do not know many chisels that would hold that sort of an edge being wacked.

25 to 30 is more like the usual range of bevel for bevel edge chisels struck with a mallet. But dont fret the exact angle, just regrind to whatever work for you (varies with technique, wood, chisel steel etc)

While carving, i often will change the bevel angle on my tools if I encounter problem, ditto with chisels or plane iron. Its not that long, just play with microbevels. I dont care what angle I end up with, for me its whatever work for the work at hand

Bob

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#4

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Doug,

That really is a shame, having to buy some new chisels. Darn. Of course the Marples will still be good for carpentry and chopping holes in walls and stuff--everybody needs a set of those. So there's no waste, and it's Christmas.

Who am I to argue with Rob Cosman? But my take on it is that asking A2 to take a bevel angle of 17 degrees for chopping is asking a lot. LN recommends honing a 35 secondary bevel on theirs.

You might give some thought to Blue Spruce Toolworks (Dave Jeske). These come hollow ground to a really low angle (last one I received anyway). Like in the low-20's, given the hollow grind--check with Dave for his current practice. There is a choice between dovetail length and paring length. Adam Cherubini in a nearby thread was relating a story about Frank Klausz from Berea, where Frank bought some of Dave's.

Both LN and Blue Spruce are A2, so compare styles and price. I like Japanese myself, but that's another story.

Wiley

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#5

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ont

>Same here Wiley,

So I dabble in all three you mentioned ..

Oh the choices I have....

;-)

take care,

Jim

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#6

I am extremely skeptical, and an observation

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The chisels I made from CPM 3V tool steel, which is substantially tougher than any commercial chisel steel, will not survive with a 17 degree bevel and what I consider normal dovetail "bashing". There is more to this story than what is known.

On the other hand, why does one need a 17 degree bevel anyway? The best bevel is the steepest bevel the chisel metal will hold in the wood being worked. Several centuries of dovetail bashing with carbon steel and angles of more like 30 degrees suggests one can make furniture without LN chisels and 17 degrees, although this later metric may be best in a particular demonstration.

I am beginning to notice that most of the sources of advice we get on tools on this Forum, recent meetings and elsewhere is provided by people selling them. I am reminded about the LN representative telling Jeff Headly, during a trial of a LN saw, that he was sawing dovetails incorrectly. Now as a bystander who to believe, the person earning a living sawing dovetails or the person earning a living demonstrating LN products? Somehow I think the LN rep has not discovered something about dovetail sawing that a 3 generation cabinet have failed to discover.

After having recently taken a couple of classes with persons earning a living doing cabinetry I have become skeptical that the tool purveyors are the most authoritative source of tool advice for those of us making stuff.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#7

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

ThomD

>Something is wrong is you hit even a 17 degree bevel into wood and it chips. If you are prying a chip free that is another mater, though the blue chips I remember where softish and it still surprises me.

Without getting into a religious discusion on micro bevels, they could help you here. Just grind the 25 degree angle across the end of your 17 degree angle, you will get most of the additional penetration the 17 degree angle provides, and a tougher edge. Just keep grinding it back until the chipping stops, 25 degrees should be fine.

17 degrees is real thin for dovetails. Another option is to grind a long taper on the chisel end, narrowing it down like a knife and then put your 25 degree bevel there, again more penetration. Getting a lot of penetration is an assist in dovetailing, but in no way required, particularly with normal 3/4" ish stock it isn't going to save you much. It pays off on really fine drawer sides where you can actually remove the waste with one blow from each side. And other similar deals. It's like strokes off your score in golf, you can do a whole slew of things better on a particular hole and still end up with the same score. Getting past some marker where things happen significantly faster or neater is a whole other thing with dovetails. There are lots of cool tools and techniques but they may not make any difference in the final result.

I once customized a set of Blue chips for a guy. I cut almost half the blade off on the grinder, radically improved the chisel, and seemed to get into better steel, though it was at least 10 years ago, so I have no idea compared to todays stuff. Often the start of the chisel is stressed from something in the manufacture. While most people consider a long blade some kind of design feature, nobody threw them away when the first 1/4" was worn down, unlike today when most people are switching out for the "lattest best" before the first 1/16" is worn away. The chisel was designed to be used when it was shorter than how it came in the box, and who is to say where the sweat spot is.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#8

Re: Authority

ThomD

>Too true at some level. Authority mainly comes from the people viewing it, who are sometimes there to learn (ignorant, in other words), or sometimes there to observe (possibly more knowledgeable than the presenter). I have made points here over the years, that failed to get through, sometimes at length and repeatedly. Then out comes a video making the same points (far better of course, no argument there), and it is all of a sudden gospel, and the personal truth of the person who produced the video. What I take form that, and the stuff you mention, is that:

A) One has to keep trying to get stuff across as best one can, and improve communication, which is really what I am doing here, I don't get woodworking practice here, I get writing practice.

B) One needs to keep an open mind because sometimes there are two ways, or more; or a better way.

So as it happen over the years I have not given you many inches on some of your personal preferences, but I finally located the paste and the cast iron. I finally got both for around 10 bucks, and I am testing out your ideas for me, because there has to be something I can learn from it. So sometimes even when people don't agree minds are still slowly being changed.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#9

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>17�?????!!!!!! For dovetails? I don't think so. I've been making dovetails for almost 30 years and have yet to modify a chisel angle. Now, I don't know everything, so perhaps there are some benefits that derive from this adjustment; but I do know it's not necessary.

That said, Marples aren't what they used to be, and perhaps a batch or three weren't heat treated properly. OTOH, I once was in class at Homestead Heritage and broke my Funahiro 3/8" mortising chisel (just one of those forging flaws; so I used an inhouse 3/8" plain old Marples and proceeded to chop several more mortises with it, no problems.

Perhaps Thom's solution of grinding down the chisel an inch or so would work; but I'd certainly try putting a normal 25-30� angle on them first.

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#10

saw parameters

paul womack

>but, has found only the Lie-Nielsen chisels to be able to hold such an angle.

Curious; most people (including, IIRC Lie Nielsen) recommend a rather higher angle for A2 than O1.

BugBear

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#11

Amen

roninkokomo

>

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#12

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Charles

>What you were told, and the way you are trying to set up your chisels, is such a bunch of horsepuckey on so many levels it just boggles the mind.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#13

Re: I am extremely skeptical, and an observation

Charles

>"After having recently taken a couple of classes with persons earning a living doing cabinetry I have become skeptical that the tool purveyors are the most authoritative source of tool advice for those of us making stuff."

Ain't that the damned truth.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#14

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Tony - Memphis

>That's interesting. When I was having problems with my initial set of LN chisels not holding an edge, I returned them to LN and they ground a "bigger" angle on them to fix them. That didn't work and they recently replaced them. The new ones are much better. Anyway, their solution was to grind a larger angle.

Tony

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#15

Ellis Walentine

Chipped vs smashed edges

Ellis Walentine

>Regardless of the bevel angle, a blade that chips -- i.e., a piece of the edge breaks off -- is too hard, or at least too hard for the bevel angle. By this definition, I can't imagine why your Marples would be chipping. I have a Marples chisel that I use for utility work, and I've found the steel to be quite soft, compared to A2 steel or Japanese tools. Softer steels like this usually just get dented, not broken, when you exceed some combination of material hardness and bevel angle, unless you've fiddled with the temper somehow.

To me, the reason for a lower bevel angle is to reduce the amount of pressure you need to apply to remove the material in question, and the difference between that and a standard 25� angle shouldn't be an issue. If you need the lower angle for clearance in a tight spot, you'd probably be better off using a thinner chisel.

I've not spoken to Cosman about this, so I'm not sure of his rationale for the lower angle.

Ellis

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#16

A different view here

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Not to take Rob's defense (he can do that himself), but...

I got the same "pitch" from Rob a few years ago. A few things to keep in mind:

- Rob used mainly soft woods in his demos, and indeed low bevel angles work in these woods.

- Most of the wood to remove in his DTs is cut off with a coping saw, so there's very little wood to chop off (more like paring actually), and a chisel with a 17 degree bevel angle can survive the treatment as long as there's no prying involved.

This said, I doubt that only LN chisels can survive that treatment, given the properties of A2 vs. O1. I didn't try on my sole LN, but I did regrind one of my Blue Chip chisels to roughly that angle (maybe lower actually), and for that kind of use it has worked fine so far.

I have a suspicion that the hardness of the particular chisel makes a difference. If the chisel comes from a batch that's a bit harder than usual then chipping might be inevitable.

DC

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#17

Re: A different view here

Bob Demers

>Indeed 17 degrees will work if you are paring not chopping

It would in fact work better in that application.

Blue handle chisels would be fine at that angle, but i wouldnt want to whack on them. Edge failure would surely result. Probably more folding than chipping, but fail nonetheless.

Bottom line, nothing wrong with your Blue handle chisels (original poster), dont replace them yet, just learn to use them within their limits and your method of work.

Once you get the knack of it, then down the road treat yourself to a few 'great' chisels

Bob, back from his 'procedure' Certified lean mean fighting machine for another year :-)

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#18

Re: I am extremely skeptical, and an observation

Dave Anderson NH

>You've given me a great laugh for the day Bill. I must bust Jeff's chops about that one next month in Willaimsburg. Knowing Jeff though I'd bet he was a gentleman about it and didn't even make a comment to the guy.

My cynical view of life in general always made me define "expert" and "An authority" as someone from far away with a briefcase and a good sales pitch.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#19

Re: A different view here

Doug Reynolds

>The Marples that is chipping is always breaking in exactly the same place. It is a very small chip so I suspect there is something wrong with that one chisel. I've owned them for 20 - 30 years and have pretty much retired them to construction jobs and leave my Two Cherries and L-N for the finer cabinet/furniture work. I also use the coping saw technique so I am really just paring away a very little waste at a time.

I was really impressed that Rob took the time to call me on the phone and we had a nice conversation about his theories of bevel angles for various uses, of which there are many. His final comment was to experiment and find which bevel angle worked for me and the wood I was working with at the moment. We had a nice visit.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#20

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Rob Cosman

>Let me help unboggle your mind Charles. Your response makes me think perhaps a little more time in the shop and less on the key board!

I have cut a few joints in my 47 years, taught a few thousand to cut them as well. At a certain level of experience you (maybe just "me") start to split hairs in terms of improving the tiniest of problems. Perhaps the most annoying of those problems is the tendency of certain woods to crush and break out under the weight of the chisel rather than cut clean.

In the process of trying to correct this, I would saw as close to the line as possible, this helps but doesn't cure. The next approach was to use only a freshly sharpened chisel, (I am pretty sure I know what sharp is). One thing that did help was using a narrower chisel, I suspect this reduced surface area allows the fibers on either side to better support those under the chisel.

One bright sunny day I decided to experiment with lower angles of attack. This meant grinding the chisel to a more acute angle since increasing the angle made the situation worse. The later was discovered when LN started shipping chisels with 30 rather than the original 25 degree primary bevel. .

As I lowered the angle the problem lessened. At 17 degrees the problem dissappeared. I was using almost punky low grade Northern White pine, the faster growing stuff that has big spring wood compared to the smaller summer wood. Some of this stuff is like cutting white styrofoam. At 17 there is very little metal supporting the edge so I would only use this chisel in Aspen, Pine, Alder, Bass and similar woods. What was really nice was the way it would cut, a fraction of the resistance of higher angles, the narrow blade would get seated in the scribe line deep enough that by the time the pressure from the waste stared to build up there was no danger of it pushing the chisel beyond the scribe line.

I so liked the effect I started to use this chisel in harder woods, Cherry, Walnut, Poplar and found that if I was carefull the edge would hold. As Ellis mentioned, removing as much of the waste as possible is key! I try to not do things different at home than what I do in seminars/workshops so if I was going to use this low chisel I had to be prepared to explain it to others. My suggestion has been to take one or two from your set and grind them low for applications such as those I previously mentioned. Whacking on these in tough wood will surely cause them to fail, bend, break or chip. However, carefull mallet use in softer (prone to crushing) woods will leave a near perfect surface.

As per which brand chisel, I no longer have any ties to LN and have not since Jan/08 so there is nothing for me to gain in passing on a reccomendation. I have owned several brands over the past 30 years, some cheap and some expensive, the LNs are by far the most comfortable to use. Light in the hand, hold an edge better than any others "I" have used and in this case (17 degree) are the only ones that would not fold on the first few chops.

To satisfy Pam, no I have not tried any Japanese brands, dont care for them. I was there when the LNs were being developed, got to tryout some early prototypes, offered my feedback and have been a huge fan since. I offer my advice based on "this is what I do and what I use". I don't spend my days debating over price, testing and comparing brands, I found what works for me and because of my dvd and workshop/seminar exposure am often asked my opinion. You can take it or leave it, however be confident there is a fair bit of practical experience behind this opinion. Now have a Merry Christmas!

Cheers

Rob Cosman

www.robcosman.com

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#21

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>To satisfy Pam, no I have not tried any Japanese brands, dont care for them. I was there when the LNs were being developed, got to tryout some early prototypes, offered my feedback and have been a huge fan since. I offer my advice based on "this is what I do and what I use". I don't spend my days debating over price, testing and comparing brands, I found what works for me and because of my dvd and workshop/seminar exposure am often asked my opinion. You can take it or leave it, however be confident there is a fair bit of practical experience behind this opinion.

Perhaps you didn't notice that in this thread I only mentioned "Funahiro" to explain why I'd used a Marples only once recently and what the quality seemed to be. That is, not defective. At no time did I recommend getting Japanese chisels instead of LN.

But since you bring it up, there are lots of Japanese chisels much lighter than anything LN (no slam on LN intended) and they all work fine on dovetails. My experience, however, encompasses all kinds of chisels, western and Japanese, paring and bench, including some Marples 30 years ago. My advice is also based on my practical experiences, not what someone else has said (on the rare occasion I offer someone else's advice, I say that's what it is).

Maybe it's time to learn how to read for comprehension.

Pam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#22

Re: Woodwright

ThomD

>I made this chisel that has like a 3 degree overall grind and a tiny micro bevel on it. It was very loosely based on something that I saw on the Woodwright Shop, when Hedley and crew were featured. looks like a very fine door stop from the side. It is designed to take everything out of a socket without any relief cuts, just direct penetration. I haven't really played with it that much, and it is not what Rob has in mind, as he explained it below. Not sure what the history of these tools is, but it was a fun experiment.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#23

Slightly OT - carpentry chisels

Bill Houghton, sunny Sebastopol, CA again

>"I...have pretty much retired them to construction jobs..."

Over the years, I've picked up a few of the older Stanley yaller handled with a metal striking cap chisels for carpentry work - probably 1960's or 70's. We all dis recent Stanley a lot, but I've got to say, those are dynamite carpentry chisels. They hold an edge, even when being beat to death on gnarly wood; and being able to hit them with a hammer is nice, since the tool belt weighs enough already without adding a mallet. I do need to retire the checkered framing hammer, as I've been reluctant to test that metal cap with it. They're a little short - I occasionally have to get out the old framing chisels when I'm prying out a big chunk of wood that the sawzall can't remove - but until I reach that point, they're hard to match for what they were designed for.

I can't speak for their current chisels, but the old ones show up at garage sales around here all the time for about 50 cents to a dollar.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#24

Re: Slightly OT - carpentry chisels

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>I agree Bill. Those are good chisels, and for all the reasons you say. I still have a set of 4 from one of the Borgs, bought many years ago. First choice for carpentry.

Wiley

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#25

Re: Slightly OT - carpentry chisels

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I have a 4 chisel set of Nooitgedact (sp?) and 8 Chinese chisels for carpentry and whatever Jack wants to do with chisels. They're in plain view; but all the others are hidden in drawers and/or wraps.

Pam