Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Rob Cosman and Chisels

Posts

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#26

Re: I am extremely skeptical, and an observation

John Pappas

>Dave, "Expert" is derived from two words: "ex" meaning has-been, and "spurt" which is a drip under pressure.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#27

Chisel angles for Doug

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I took a class with Alan Batty a while back. Alan apprenticed and then worked in the English trades for 50+ years. At one point he made drawers, several per day. I didn't ask to be sure but I presume they were typical English dovetailed drawers- oak sides and mahogany fronts. One has to believe that a shop making drawers for a competitive price would have discovered anything worthy of discovery about making drawers with these materials and under production conditions, most efficiently. At the start of the apprentice his job was sharpening tools. He said they were ground at 30 degrees.

This information does not suggest that you should grind your tools for your wood and your technique at 30 degrees. But it does suggest that 17 degrees isn't for everyone and it seems unlikely the optimum of 17 degrees has just been revealed after centuries of dovetail chopping.

I once asked a purveyor of lathe tools why they added some detail to the handle. To differentiate us from others was the answer. The same may be true of those doing demonstrations

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#28

re: marples,

James Watriss

>I think marples has been on a down slope recently.

5 years ago, when I was in my very first workshop, I saw one chip out pretty badly. 1" chisel, ground to ~28 degrees, (the NBSS general standard...) and it was missing a chunk, roughly 1/4" x 1/4".

I saw something similar happen when I was there a few years later as a full time student.

One review I read a few years back mentioned that the grain of the steel was much coarser in the Marples than in most of the other chisels. That may have something to do with the chipping issue. Another issue may be that Marples is now owned by Irwin, which is owned by Rubbermaid, and by the time everyone gets their slice of the pie, there's not much left to pay for the steel. who really knows.

That said, I still sold a lot of the Irwin-Marples chisels when I could to newcomers, because they were softer, and would give the owner a lot of practice sharpening... which is something that can't be bought.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#29

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

john jesseph

>Kind of interesting responses. I have an old quarter inch tang chisel that I modified a while back, for chiseling through dovetail pin sockets. It's ground on the sides to a near sharp edge, and the bevel is ground to a really low angle, with a small microbevel. Works great for chopping between tails. I never gave it any thought when I worked it out, just trial and error until it performed well.

After reading this thread, I went out and measured the angles on it, and it looks like about a ten to twelve degree primary long bevel with about a five degree secondary bevel. So it may be around 15 degrees, for sure way less than twenty. Works for me, but the mallet work is basically mild to moderate tapping.

One of the old texts that Joel linked described really acute bevels for plane irons. I thought I would re-link it here...


img

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#30

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Bob Demers

>Interesting indeed

There is really nothing new under the woodworking sun, we are just continuously rediscovering things.

The thing that never cease to amaze me, is that 'we' as a group are quick to scoff at anything out of the norm.

For years, we have been told that chisels are to be ground at 25-30 degrees, it therefore must be heresy to suggest we go down to 17..

Rob's explanation of how he got there make perfect sense to me. Experimentation is the key here. Whatever work for you keep doing it, but why not experiment a bit out of the beating tracks? Maybe just maybe, you'll discover something that work better for you.

Short answers to this original post could have just been:

If 17 degrees work for Rob, it ought to work for someone else.

There is no suggestion of heavy pounding here.

If your particular chisel always develop a small chip at the same place, then you got something wrong on that steel, at that spot (bigger chunk of grain)

Like I said earlier I dont fret about my angles, I just tweak them as I go, as I need, until it does the job I expect..

As a trained carver, I often stop and strop my edges anyway, so no biggie

Bob, who say make peace not war so I can retire :-)

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#31

Re: Chisel angles for Doug

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

30 degrees seems high for paring.

A couple of years ago I was in the market for some chisels that I could use specifically for dovetailing. Up until that time I was using a set of 4 (1/8, 1/4, 3/8 and 1/2) that I had ground from old Berg chisels. These were honed at 20 degrees as I only pared with them. The steel was quite impressive as it held up reasonably well in the Aussie hardwood. However I had a birthday coming up and Lynndy was looking for a gift, and I was looking for an excuse.

Ideally I was looking for a chisel that could be both hit with a mallet and pushed. An obvious (possibly only?) contender was the LN. They were comfortable in the hand and well designed. However, there was a concern about the bevel angle that was recommended, this being essentially 35 degrees (30 primary bevel and 35 degree secondary). My attention turned to the Blue Spruce, which were also A2 steel. The trouble was that these were also honed high, at 30 degrees. Again, that was off putting.

It occurred to me that my (Iyoroi) Japanese bench chisels (used with a hammer and not comfortable for paring) were all 30 degrees, and these were the sharpest blades I had ever experienced. Then Mike Wenzloff started to brag about his Blue Spruce, and that was enough for me - what can I say, I was weak - and I ordered a couple. It was very interesting to find just how sharp these got. Of course the BS chisels are wonderful to use because they are so well balanced and light. But the important fact is that the blades take and hold a very sharp edge. Now 30 degrees does not seem high any more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#32

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Charlie

>You 'da man.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#33

Obsequious post to Rob Cosman

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I'm coming at this from a different perspective, but I'm reaching similar conclusions. I just made a few sets of really thin chisels (not unlike Blue Spruce really) and I find that I prefer really low bevel angles. I can easily "get away" with 25 degree angles. I find that the combination of thin and low angle requires me to move less wood. It's akin to the difference between a thick saw with a lot of kerf and coarse teeth and a fine saw with a small teeth and little set. Conventional wisdom says you need a coarsely toothed saw to cut wood fast, but the thinner kerf of the other saw....well you get the idea.

One thing I'm finding is that unless you are removing only the thinnest cut, your chisel will seek to "submarine". Pressure on the bevel from the waste seeks to force the chisel back, causing an undercut. A little back bevel helps.

Your super low angle chisels may hold up a little better if you can ditch some of that bevel side pressure (which is bending stress). What I think is given two chisels with 17 degree bevels, the chisel with the back bevel (so maybe it's 3 and 14) SHOULD hold up better.

So the question is: Have you tried this and if you do will you let us know? Okay 2 questions.

Adam

P.S. Just off the top of my head, have you tried Blue Spruce chisels? I think they have advantages for this sort of work. The LN chisels feel like punches to me. They are nice. I'd like to have a set. But they are really nothing like my chisels.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#34

Not true Ellis

Adam Cherubini

>"Regardless of the bevel angle, a blade that chips -- i.e., a piece of the edge breaks off -- is too hard, or at least too hard for the bevel angle."

This just isn't a fact. It's actually more complicated than that. It's actually a LOT more complicated than that. You're thinking about the difference between plasticity (deformation) and a fracture. And that's right. There's a difference. But what you see at the end of your Marples could be either or both.

I suspect the Marples chisels are just too soft. I think one could harden them and the chipping would go away. It's not difficult to do. The only problem I can think of is how one would temper them without melting the handle. I temper in the oven in my kitchen.

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#35

Ellis Walentine

Tell me more

Ellis Walentine

>I'm sure my reply was too simpistic, Adam, but I'm just recalling my experience with chisels. I know little about the complexities of metallurgy.

I used to have some Japanese mortising chisels that were too hard and the edges chipped off, which I assumed meant that the steel was too hard for the task at hand. (Of course, there must be other variables besides bevel angle and hardness, not least of which would be the characteristics of the wood being chopped.) I learned later that this is a known phenomenon and that Japanese craftsmen would pound their chisels into a block of wood several times to anneal the edge somewhat and make the steel more resilient. This was confirmed by Jim Blauveld at the Berea conference. I suppose the heat of friction at the cutting edge is enough to draw the temper, though I can't imagine how they control the annealing effect.

As far as the other variables, maybe you can illuminate a bit more. It sounds like you're saying edges can chip and compress simultaneously and I'm not understanding how that is possible. It seems like an either/or proposition. Does soft steel bend to a point and then break? Is the "grain" structure of the steel so variable? Is the tempering so localized?

Ellis

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#36

Re: Tell me more

joel

>"I learned later that this is a known phenomenon and that Japanese craftsmen would pound their chisels into a block of wood several times to anneal the edge somewhat and make the steel more resilient."

I don't actually believe this - pounding a chisel into wood will warm it up but not to 400 or so degrees. What I actually think is happening is that you have new chisel you pound it into wood. If the chisel is on the money then it's fine. If it isn't the pounding chips the crap out of the edge and have to grind back and resharpen - bringing to fore slightly softer steel as the tips are usually a little harder.

When someone asks why you pounded the chisel into the wood in the first place you now have a good reason as opposed to it was a brand new tool and I was just playing with it.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#37

The Four Humours

Adam Cherubini

>This is called fracture mechanics and it's really complicated. What I think is that edges see a combination of bending and compression stress. But failures are probably not a function of gross section properties. So it's possible Cosman can use a technique for sharpening and usage that allows him to maintain really low angles.

What happens to an edge after it goes plastic is beyond me. When steel is tested, it's polished to a mirror polish. Scratches reduce the properties of steel greatly. They are exactly like the perforations in a roll of paper towels. They will begin the failure, but the failure may or may not follow them. Once you begin the tear, things change, angles change and sometimes you don't get a clean edge right? That's just paper towells. Steel is much more complicated. Microscopically, its non-homogenous/non-isotropic.

What we need to do is trust our experience. But we need to be careful about assigning explanations to what we see. If one wanted to dabble in this subject, the thing to do is to study exactly how a tool is sharpened, what surface finish and shape the edge really has, and then precisely how it's used. Otherwise, we end up with the 4 humors. Soft=folding Hard =chipping is the metallurgical equivalent of blood letting. May be helful, but probably not for the reasons we thought.

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#38

what the steel manufacturers say on the topic

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>At the substantial risk of beating this dead horse yet again............

Briefest summary: Agreeing with Rob I thought that a mortise chisel should be ground to as steep an angle as the steel would enable for best penetration. (same thinking valid for dovetail chopping) So I called the tech staff at CPM Products and asked them what physical properties a steel needed to be able to stand being pounded into wood if the tool had a steep bevel angle.

I have a great deal of faith that the companies that make steel use their considerable resources for experimentation and testing to find out how to use their products to advantage. Their customers make multimillion dollar decisions based on this knowledge, so it can be expected to be correct.

That said, I was told that I needed a steel that could be hardened as much as possible as this would mitigate against deflection from chiseling forces. However, the steel also had to be tough so that it would not readily break(chip) if it was deflected by these forces. These properties are not independent and where one makes the compromise in balance between them will depend on the details of usage.

For the way I use my "pounding" chisels I have not seen any evidence to disagree with what I was told. Steel that can be hardened to a higher degree without loosing toughness can be subjected to mallet induced chisel forces at steeper bevel angles than softer-less tough steel. Through microscopic examination of used edges I can clearly see deformation failure(not hard enough) and chipping failure( not tough enough) from various steel I ahve tested.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#39

Ellis Walentine

Might be interesting to investigate

Ellis Walentine

>Joel, the first I heard of this technique was from Toshio Odate many years ago, and as you know he is very confident of what he says. I could speculate on how the heating effect is increased at the cutting edge, but my speculation is what led us down this path to begin with. :-)

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#40

Re: what the steel manufacturers say on the topic

Adam Cherubini

>With all due respect, there are no multi million dollar companies making woodworking edge tools out of CPM. There may be no industrial cutting tool companies making tools out of CPM either, not that the two are in any way related. I've heard of CPM wrist pins, linkages, things that can be "cast" or formed. No woodworking chisels except yours. I think CPM is a great idea. But let's be clear. CPM is not researching wood chisel fracture mechanics. What they said is sophmore level materials. Correct, but not really applicable here. Ellis wants to know why. I'm saying no one knows. I don't think CPM knows.

I called Franklin and asked them for the coefiicent of friction of Titebond. No idea. Never been asked. I asked for Young's Modulus, the stiffness of the dried glue. Again, no clue. These folks make wood glues for a living and don't have basic properties. No steel producer will know what exactly happens when you sharpen a piece of metal and pound it into wood beyond what we know already. If there were chisels on the Stealth fighter, we'd know all about this. Until chisels are needed to land a man on Mars, we're probably going to have to leave these topics where they lie.

I trust your experience and wisdom Bill. I value Ellis' experience. But when it comes to the discussion of what is really happening and why, we're in the dark ages.

Speaking of the dark ages, I came across a cure for baldness from 1500 years ago. Burn the bodies of bumble bees. Spread the burned bees on the bald spot. Say 2 Our fathers and the creed. This was not magic but science (tho religion, magic and science were closely related then). Bees are furry. Bald men need more furry. I tried it and with all that ash on my head, I looked a lot less bald!

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#41

Re: what the steel manufacturers say on the topic

Paul Kierstead

>I trust your experience and wisdom Bill. I value Ellis' experience. But when it comes to the discussion of what is really happening and why, we're in the dark ages.

Well, it is nice to see at least one other person believes this.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#42

glue properties

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Young's Modulus is an indeterminant property of a viscoelastic material such as dried glue, so it is little wonder a value was not to be found in company technical literature. The modulus is dependent on the frequency of the stress. I can assure you these data are known internally at Franklin, and would be part of any adhesive development effort, but perhaps not available to the casual inquirer.

Order a few tank cars full and you will get the data, or even have a polymer tweaked to meet your specific need. Their polymer chemists will know exactly how to achieve performance properties through changes in composition and structure. I suppose this ability and knowledge may be opaque to someone not involved in product development at a company with state of art technical resources. (my daughter is a polymer chemist, but not at Franklin)

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#43

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

Charles

>Rob, I'm sure, in fact quite sure, that you're not the first woodworker to put mallet to what amounts to a paring chisel and achieved good results in the short term - in your case working in softwoods for about the length of time it takes to do a woodworking demonstration.

For those without a bottomless wallet, or free supply of tools from their employer (ex-employer or whatever), woodworking is about compromise. If I had thirty + chisels hanging on the wall I'd probably set them up in one degree increments starting at about thirteen and going up to thirty and then have a few duplicates to put into play when the edges broke down a little on the lower angle ones.

That scenario does not represent the real world in my opinion, nor does planting myself in front of a bench grinder wasting good steel (not to mention precious woodworking time) "experimenting" with the few good chisels that I do own. And besides that, I manage to get along reasonably well with my meager attempts at the craft.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#44

Re: glue properties

Charles

>Oops, another beautiful theory murdered by a gang of brutal facts.

Touche'

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#45

Re: what the steel manufacturers say on the topic

Charles

>Reading your post made me happy to realize that I don't have to know how they get the graphite inside a wood pencil to be able to use one to solve a Calculus problem.

Ever heard the saying "that's a nickel holding up a dime"?

I'm glad Robert Oppenheimer didn't stop to ponder pencil lead in the 1940s.

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#46

Re: glue properties

Adam Cherubini

>You're right again, Bill. I didn't think about visco elasticity.

And in truth, I don't care about that at all. Maybe I asked the wrong question. What I want is the modulus of the bondline. I recognize that Titebond specifically, and this data in general would need to take into account the effect of the material bonded. The modulii I have access to are for epoxies which really aren't visco-elastic.

In reality, that fact that Tite bond is elastomeric means that it's modulus is probably crud anyway. What I was after was a comparson of stiffness of hot hide and PVA. I believe hot hide's E is much higher than PVA. Luthiers and other muscial instrument makers think so too. There are times when glue stiffness is helpful in furniture and times when it is not.

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#47

Not sure I followed

Adam Cherubini

>I'm not sure I got your point Charles. I've spent the last 20 years wrestling with the difference between testing and analysis. 19 years ago, I learned that testing is usually better. This may be one reason why I like 18th c technique so much. I'm more willing to accept tested techniques and approaches than my own creations.

Engineers are taught to take complex systems and break them down into simpler, small chunks. I guess that's a better approach than the alternative. But what I've learned is that the world is a very complicated place.

Adam

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#48

Re: glue properties

Paul Kierstead

>What? Facts? Where?

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#49

Re: Not sure I followed

Charles

>Adam, sometimes you just pick up the pencil and write with it *hopefully* secure in the knowledge that what you write is vastly more important than how the pencil was made.

Get it?

Re: Rob Cosman and Chisels

#50

Re: Not sure I followed

Charles

>Or think about it like this... what if Charles Dickens had become fascinated with pens and inks themselves instead of what he put down on paper?