Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Posts

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#51

Re: Japanese plane length

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Yeah, but I find myself using several western planes to do some typical tasks that don't seem to be amenable to using Japanese planes. For example, a 15" jointer is not nearly so capable for very long edge planing as the C&W 30"+ jointer. The Mosaku jointer is great for shorter lengths. I have yet to see a Japanese scrub type plane (maybe they used yarikana?). Therefore, given that I do these tasks all the time, I assume Japanese furniture makers and carpenters also do these tasks routinely. What do they use? Are we seeing an abbreviated set of planes in the US? Or do they magically perform these tasks with the set we've seen?

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#52

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Charles

>Larry, what would be the lead time for a C&W jointer in the thirty inch range?

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#53

Re: Wandering OT: lapidary saws

Don McConnell

>Bill,

I don't recall the details at the moment, but the claim that a Shaker sister invented the circular saw has already been thoroughly debunked. As I recall, there are British mentions of circular saws from the latter part of the eighteenth century.

I considered omitting Neve's listing of lapidary saws since it is not related to woodworking, but, decided to include it as part of the complete entry. And because it engendered some curiosity on my part. I agree that it seems to hint at some kind of rotational action. I'm hoping someone else can shed some light on this, as I know nothing of lapidary work.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#54

Re: Wandering OT: lapidary saws *LINK*

Bill Houghton, sorta sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Wikipedia's entry on the subject cites evidence of circular saws, at sawmill sizes, back in the sixteenth century, but makes no reference to lapidary-related circular saws.

An interesting, though of course off-topic for this forum, subject.


Wikipedia's entry

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#55

Re: Dado planes?

Don McConnell

>Wiley,

According to Mark & Jane Rees ( in Goodman's _British Planemakers from 1700_), the earliest extant examples of dado planes are three "proto-dado" planes made by William Madox. His working dates were 1748 to 1775. They also report that the first textual mention of dado planes is a 1793 entry in the Gabriel ledger, followed by the Seaton chest inventory of 1796.

Creating dados without specialized planes can be done in a variety of ways, but I doubt the basic approach has changed all that much over the years. A fair idea of this approach can be found in David Denning's _The Art and Craft of Cabinet-Making_, first published in the 1880's, I believe. For through dados, the width of the dado is defined using a square and striking knife. The knife lines may, or may not, be turned into a V-groove with a chisel, then the waste is isolated using a saw to cut down to the depth gauge lines. This may, or may not, be done using a thin batten to guide the saw. Then the bulk of the waste can be readily removed with a chisel. If the depth of the dado needs to be uniform, the dado can be finished up with an "old woman's tooth," or a rabbet plane if you have one narrow enough.

For stopped dados, Denning indicates that the saw can be "partially" used in the above manner, the isolated waste removed with a chisel, then finish up with a "old woman's tooth" - advancing the blade a little at a time until reaching full depth, ending at the "stop." An alternative is to create a cavity, behind the "stop," using a centre bit and chisel, to provide a place for the toe of the saw to run into. The stopped dado can then be finished up as with a through one.

Denning finishes up by observing: "A special plane, called a trencher, is made for cutting cross grooves, but it is not often seen [in cabinet shops]." So, apparently, it was still common, in the late nineteenth century London cabinet shops, to create dados without specialized planes.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#56

Greber

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Don,

Thank you for your scholarly and detailed answer. Inspired by your example, I went to see what Josef Greber had to say on the subject. He doesn't mention the dado plane, but rather describes the procedure precisely as you have: Scoring the channel lines, wasting out with a chisel, and then cleaning up as needed with a router (p. 129 in the EAIA translation). Greber shows some amazing sculptural routers of German make.

Whelan in The Wooden Plane (p. 139) states that the dado plane as we know it was not used at all in continental Europe, which jibes with the fact that Greber makes no mention.

Relative to Larry's point above about fillisters, Greber says the fillister was used less than the rabbet by English, French, and German cabinetmakers, but that builders and carpenters used a long standing fillister, as long a jointer.

I certainly like my C&W moving filletster, made by Larry's own hand, but look forward to practicing the technique you have rediscovered from Sheraton, involving snipes bills and a rebate plane.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#57

Re: Japanese plane length

wilbur

>"Therefore, given that I do these tasks all the time, I assume Japanese furniture makers and carpenters also do these tasks routinely. What do they use? Are we seeing an abbreviated set of planes in the US? Or do they magically perform these tasks with the set we've seen?"

I think that they did/do. My guess (only a guess) is that the mechanics of pulling a Japanese plane are considerably different than pushing a western plane, in that for a Japanese plane downward pressure is maintained more or less at the front of the plane though the entire stroke (except at the very end when the plane is coming off the wood), whereas for a western plane, the downward pressure transitions from the front to the back as you make the stroke. Which might explain why western planes were made longer.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#58

Re: Greber / dado planes

Andreas Winkler from Germany

>Wiley,

as you have already find out, dado planes have not been very common in continental europe. But they have still existed. In German they are called "Jalousiehobel". Does not have anything to do with "jealous", I would translate them "shutter planes" or "blind planes" or something like that. There are two links to Wolfgang Jordans fabulous hompage about that planes :

http://www.holzwerken.de/museum/nuthobel/jalousiehobel2.phtml

http://www.holzwerken.de/museum/hersteller/kataloge/ott2_19.phtml

In tradtional Continental Europe or German woodworking dadoes are not made with a special plane. Dadoes (in German "Quernuten") were marked out and then precut with a gent�s or grooving saw, almost in the same way as you want to cut a sliding dovetail�s groove.

http://www.holzwerken.de/werkzeug/gratsaege.phtml

After that the wood will be chiseled out and fianally, but only if it is necessary, the groove�s ground will cleaned up with a router plane.

http://www.holzwerken.de/werkzeug/grundhobel.phtml

Despite of the special term in German these planes are nothing else than dado planes. Probably Continantal European and German woodworkers have always been contented with their way of making dadoes, Jalousiehobel were mostly used in the true sense of their name : to cut recesses into shutters slats ("Rolladenlamellen" in German).

When handwoodworking was actual (until 1920�s), wooden shutters ("Holzroll�den" in German) were not common because of their expensive production. When shutters became more popular (from 1940 onwards I would say), electric routers have already been introdouced and shortly after that (from 1960 on), wooden shutters have been almost compltetely edeged out from plastic and aluminium shutters. So there was no great demand for Jalosiehobel. I think because of that they are not very common on the second hand market.

Whelan mentioned Jalousiehobel in "The Wooden Plane" on page 139 with a metal plated version. Don�t have seen such a metal plated version, maybe that version is showed and mentioned in the 1909-Johann-Weiss-catalog. In my opinion that catalog has strongly influenced Whelan in many references and drawings of Continental European planes in his famous book.

Greetings from snowy Germany, Andreas

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#59

Re: Greber / dado planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Hello Andreas,

Thank you very much for your extensive report! I wish we could have some snow here in California--it is a perfect drought here, one sunny day after another. I think the powers above are withholding rain until the legislature passes a balanced budget. That could be a long time.

Well, as you say, the plane on Wolfgang's site is every centimeter a dado plane! Of course, there are design differences between the straight-bladed jalousiehobel and the skew-bladed British/American dado. Apart from the straight blade/skew blade difference, there is no depth stop on the jalousiehobel, but the German design probably assumes that the user will prepare a fence which is the right thickness to double as a depth stop.

Your post makes me wonder whether the British/American dado plane was primarily a specialist's tool, like the jalousiehobel. Perhaps the typical cabinetmakers on both sides of the ocean, continued to saw and chisel their dados for the most part.

Wolfgang's website is a wonderful undertaking, as it puts together the German woodworking heritage! This brings to mind the thought that all of us in the handtool community enjoy being connected to our heritage.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#60

Re: Greber / dado planes

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Perhaps the reason that hand cut dados seem to be more prevalent on this side of the Atlantic is that larger dimension lumber was available. Very large dado planes are not very common, at least out here in the West. More old pieces with dados that I have worked on were sawn and chiseled.

Seven eights inch thick shelves (shelves being the most common dado) are rather common. I have seen one piece with 5/8" dados that was done with a skew dado with deep set nickers.

Mercer doesn't mention dados by name.

Stephen