Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Posts

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#26

Re: power tool thinking *LINK*

Peter Evans

>The Tools chapter of Denning can be read online at:


Denning Cabinet-maker

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#27

Three moldings

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>The visual impact of those moldings were strikingly different and would have a dramatically different effect on any given piece.

Larry, I can intuit that the moldings have very different effects on a given piece of furniture, particularly the one with dentils (for a mantle?); but I couldn't begin to qualify this. Can you and/or Don specify on which types of pieces you'd use these moldings and why?

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#28

Re: Good question

Gary Roberts

>Joel and Larry

Thanks for getting into Neve. I never knew of the additional material in the later edition. I have the Kelley reprint of the second, 1726 edition. Nothing on Planes and on Saws... only on Sawyers, timber and producing lumber. I'll dig into my library connections to see if I can come up with copies from a microfilm. Same for Felibien. There are a handful of libraries who will produce photocopies of microfilm for a fee. Mostly in Australia, so I'll see if I have any luck. Unless of course I stumble across a library that has plans to digitize both books at some point.

Gary

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#29

Neve and the lengths of planes

wilbur

>Thanks for posting this, Larry!

I hope I'm not going to complicate this thread too much by adding in another point of discussion, but the mention of the lengths of the planes used caught my eye. If I am understanding this right, to dimension a board, the planes recommended by Neve would be:

Fore-Plane, 18" long

Long Plane, 24" long

Smoothing plane, 6-7" long

For those who would rather use metal Bailey-type planes (I know, I know), a very common recommendation would be to use:

A #5, 14" long

A #7, 22" long

A #4, 9 1/2" long

Now, it could be that the shorter lengths was a result of the weight of the cast iron used in these planes, but it doesn't really explain why the Bailey smoothing plane is a #4, instead of a #2 (7-1/2") or a #1 (5-1/2"), which are closer in length to the wooden smoothing plane.

To add another twist to this, Japanese woodworkers would have had a set of three Japanese planes to do tasks similar to Neve's fore-plane, long plane, and smoothing plane, but the Japanese planes would have been about the same length: 11" or so. The main differences in this set of planes would have been the camber of the blade, the tightness of the mouth, and the width of the blade (Japanese "fore-plane" is narrower than the Japanese "long plane", which is narrower than the Japanese smoother).

Maybe there are just different paths to the same end. But the lengths must have been important to Neve, otherwise why mention it?

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#30

Re: Neve and the lengths of planes

Joel

>THe point of the smoother is just to take a final clean shaving ready for finishing - not to add accuracy. Therefore the shorter the smoothing plane the better because it makes it possible for the plane to follow smaller imperfections in the strightness of the planing.

The typical Wooden smoother is about 6-7" long and the typcial Infill smooth is about the same. Stanley just couldn't figure out how to make a smaller mechanism that was comfortable. BUT remember that by the time Stanley's were invented most wood in the US would have been initially machine planed (especially on a construction site) and even if you follow up with a plane the machined surface would be pretty accurate so a longer plane is fine.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#31

Japanese plane length

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know about that, Wilbur. For example, jointers are about 15" long (as in Mosaku).

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#32

Re: Neve on saws

Don McConnell

>As Larry already indicated, I don't find Neve's section on saws to be particularly helpful. With the possible minor exception of the Tenon saw entry. In any event, here it is, for everyone's perusal.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#33

Re: Neve on saws

Ray Gardiner

>Hi Don,

Thanks for posting that, the tenon saw reference is interesting. That is at least much less ambiguous than Moxon.

His comments on whip saws are curious, and I wonder why he took the time to say that, quote: "that it were mispending time to say more about them"

Maybe he was in a hurry to go somewhere? Publishing deadline?

Regards

Ray

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#34

Re: Not sold on Snipe Bills

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>History aside, I think Don's use (see Chapter 11 of his Traditional Molding Techniques dvd) is wonderful (as I think you said). He also makes a good case for paired snipe bills (left and right). I think the reason for the boxing is that you're dealing with a very small portion of the sole, which would require a very hard and stable wood to maintain it. His example of an 18th century version with depth stop is also enlightening.

So why not go with it? I don't know whether C&W is selling these (they're not in the web page catalog), but they seem an excellent tool for spiffing up moldings.

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#35

The first moulding

Larry Williams

>Pam,

I'm going to have to post this in two different posts. The forum software, it appears, won't let me post more than one photo at a time but I can use the forum's hosting to squeeze two photos in the second post.

The first moulding is from Thomas Sheraton's book. It's appropriate for a somewhat delicate neoclassical piece.


Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#36

Re: Strike Block Plane?

Don McConnell

>John et al,

Based on the descriptions of the uses of the strike block plane in Neve and Moxon, I would characterize it, functionally, as roughly analogous to the miter plane. They could be used to shoot miters, end-grain, etc., as well as long grain edges, in smaller work, in preparation for glue-ups. Moxon additionally describes a method of holding the strike block plane in one hand and a mitered work-piece in the other and shooting the miter without aid of any appliance.

There has been a lot of speculation about the origin of the term, strike block plane, including a recent discussion here on WoodCentral. The discussion is far from over, I suspect, but my conjecture is that one or another (or possibly all, collectively) of the "shooting" appliances in use with these planes was known as a "strike block" at some point in time. Again, note that I characterize this as conjecture - but, it makes more sense, to me, than any of the other conjectures put forth so far.

Sometime during the eighteenth century, analogous planes, in terms of function and features, came to be called straight block planes. So far, I've not found both terms in the same source, so my conjecture is that the primary change was in the nomenclature. Though straight block planes seem to have been somewhat shorter (at 12 inches, compared with Neve's mention of 14 inches), as well.

As best we can determine, strike block planes had no totes and they had bedding angles of about 40 degrees. In keeping with this, they were bevel down planes. Forty degrees is about the lowest practical angle for any bevel down plane due to the need for maintaining an adequate clearance angle. Lower bedding angles would necessitate more acute bevel angles for the iron, which would begin compromising the integrity of the cutting edge during use.

Hope this helps.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#37

The second and third

Larry Williams

>The second moulding is taken from EJ Warne's Furniture Mouldings. It's most of the cornice from a 1695 pine architectural built-in cupboard.


The third moulding is the cornice moulding on a walnut vernacular country cupboard from around the Civil War. This piece is in a local antique store.

Don wanted three different cornices of the same size using the same basic components to illustrate the different visual effects.

I'm not the person to explain manipulating designs with mouldings. As I said earlier, I'm trying to learn this because it's important. The best source of information I know of is C. Howard Walker's 1926 Theory of Mouldings which has been reprinted by W.W. Norton.


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#38

Re: Strike Block Plane?

Larry Williams

>I've attached a photo of what we think strike block planes looked like.


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#39

Many thanks, Larry, I just ordered the book.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#40

Less than 40�

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>So how come Japanese planes with bedding angles routinely less than 40�, say 35� - 39�, work so well with a single bevel of 25-35�? Think it has something to do with the tapered irons (from front to back, not side to side), the iron thickness, the sole shape, or what? I don't think this is an apples and oranges question, given that the clearance angle appears to be the issue.

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#41

Re: Less than 40�

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>If a "western" plane is bedded at 40 degrees and the iron has 2 degrees of taper (for example), then the actual cutting angle is 38 degrees. If a Japanese plane has the opposite taper, then an iron bedded at 36 degrees will have a cutting angle of 38 degrees. Tapers vary, but at least some of the difference you mention can be accounted for in this way.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#42

Google Books has... *LINK*

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>a preview up of the TOC and the Foreword.

Fascinating stuff....


Google Books Theory of Mouldings

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#43

Re: Strike Block Plane?

MikeW

>Here's mine, one from Phil Edwards in England.


It is bedded at 38 degrees. He also makes them skewed, which is what I am ordering for my wife.

Take care, Mike

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#44

Freehand not freeform

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I understand your confusion, Larry. I've been forgetting to type my location. I live in New Jersey not California! I work freehand, not freeform. There's a big difference.

Working freehand is just a different way of achieving the same goal. It's not better or worse, but it can be faster. I'm not even sure it's less "certain", to borrow Pye's term.

So to the point: Don planes shoulders in his work to guide his planes. But HE could have very easily freehanded those planes and skipped SOME of the setting in. What he showed us is ONE way. It's a good way and may be the way it was done in the period. It absolutely makes sense for larger architectural moldings. For furniture, I'm just wondering out loud if a freehand approach that was quicker and a little less fussy would be attractive to furniture makers looking to incorporate simple molders into their work.

More: I spoke to Don face to face about this (which was a treat). he and I both freehand rabbets for carcass backs and the like. You really don't need a fence for this work. Anymore, I can free hand so close to my gauge line that I often don't have to clean up the fillet. I have nothing to base this on except my gut feeling, but I suspect 18th c craftsmen did a fair bit of this sort of thing. They may not have done it for architectural moldings. But I wouldn't be surprised to learn that they rarely used their moving fillesters (this is what Don said) and rarely bothered with fences or guides. I think Warren is right: These are things WE do because we lack their skill and desire a greater level of uniformity than they did.

This has been an unexpectedly thought provoking discussion. Thanks for it.

Adam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#45

Re: Strike Block Plane?

john jesseph

>Thanks for the replies- I wasn't sure about the nomenclature since I assumed it would be a plane used with a shooting board, and that strike block was another term for shooting board, or some other shooting fixture.

I have limited myself to essentially the planes listed in the referenced material (coincidentally), but I don't have one of these. I will make one...

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#46

Re: Less than 40�

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>True, assuming western blades taper from edge to top, getting narrower.

Pam

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#47

Re: Japanese plane length

wilbur

>Hi Pam,

I'm basing this supposition off of Toshio Odate's book, where he describes the various types of Japanese planes, from looking at a lot of used Japanese planes, and from Zaprudering workshop photos of people who use Japanese planes. There is the long 15-17" Japanese jointer plane, as you mention, but Odate describes it as being used for edge planing, much like Neve describes the jointer plane, and for real precision flattening. This type of plane also seems to me to be much less common compared to the ratio of the number of western jointer planes to jack planes and smoothers.

Odate also describes flattening and smoothing being done with just the "cutting-down" plane, the "roughing" plane, and the "intermediate smoothing" plane, which all seem to be about 11" long.

In any case, it seems to me that the Japanese bench plane pretty much comes in just two sizes, and that milling a board could have been and was done with Japanese planes of just one length, with blades and mouths set appropriately for the stage of work.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#48

Wandering OT: lapidary saws

Bill Houghton, sorta sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>Don,

At the very end of the scan you posted is the statement, "Saws are also used by lapidaries, made like a little whirligig."

When I look at online dictionaries, the only listing with an etymology for "whirl" refers back to middle English as "something that rotates," not much changed in modern English.

Could Neve have been describing a circular saw? If so, does that mean lapidaries developed the circular saw before 1736?

If so, it sure ruins the common story that the circular saw was developed by Shaker sister Tabitha Babbitt in the nineteenth century.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#49

Re: Less than 40�

Don McConnell

>Pam et al,

I guess when I said that 40 degrees was about the lowest practical bed angle for a bevel down plane, I had a number of things in mind. But, I didn't mean to indicate that lower bed angles simply wouldn't work at all.

Let me begin my explanation with an anecdote. When we developed our prototype strike block plane, I wanted to test how it worked shooting a miter on 7/8" cherry stock, using a miter shooting board. The plane worked, but it seemed a little skittery and I needed to press it into the material with more force than I felt should be necessary. In checking into this, I discovered that while the iron was sharp, its bevel had inadvertently been ground close to 30 degrees (we normally shoot for around 25 degrees) and honed at more than 30 degrees - leaving a clearance angle of less than ten degrees. I corrected the bevel to 25 degrees and honed at about 27-28 degrees, and the action of the plane smoothed right out.

Additionally, I noticed that the surface left by the plane after correcting the grinding and honing angles was more matte than before. At first, I thought I might not have gotten the iron quite sharp, but then realized that the prior shininess was due to burnishing because of an inadequate clearance angle. This burnishing of the surface isn't desirable, especially for surfaces destined for gluing up. And it may not be desirable for some finishing regimes. This "burnishing" has another ramification, which I'll get to in a moment.

I'm not aware of any universally recognized minimum clearance angle suitable for wood, and suspect it changes somewhat due to type/hardness of wood, the angle of attack, as well as the depth of cut. In general, though, we've come to believe that the 12 degree bed angle of low angle (bevel up) block planes may be taken as a good "practical" rule of thumb.

It is possible to obtain suitable clearance angles in bevel down planes with bed angles of less than 40 degrees, but trade-offs begin to creep in. For example, with a bed angle of 37 or 38 degrees, you may be able to maintain bevel angles of 27-28 degrees and be able to use the plane, as long as you wish to take only very light shavings. Or, you can have a bed angle of about 35 degrees, but this will, I think, tend to push you in the direction of maintaing a honing bevel angle of 25 degrees, or less. In this case, you will likely be limited to working in relatively soft woods, as my experience indicates that a 25 degree bevel angle will not maintain edge integrity for any period of time in timbers as hard as white oak, for example.

Another issue with inadequate, or barely adequate, clearance angles is that of wear to the iron - related to the burnishing already mentioned. This prematurely dulls plane irons and requires more frequent sharpening than would, otherwise, be necessary. Not to mention the additional effort required to use the plane under these conditions.

At the 40 degree bed angle, it is possible to maintain a honing angle approaching 30 degrees and still have a clearance angle which allows for use with woods of various hardness as well as a range of depths-of-cut, while avoiding premature dulling of the iron. I feel these considerations have a good deal of practical value, and are what I had in mind with my initial assertion.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#50

Re: Less than 40�

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>All very reasonable, reasoned, and empirical...for cherry. But how about for pine, mahogany, walnut, or ebony? Here's a very rough list of guidelines for Japanese planes:

33-37� kiri (paulownia)

35-37� sugi (Japanese cedar)-soft wood, western red cedar

38-39� hinoki (Japanese cypress), matsu*(pine)-common or ordinary wood

40-41� kuri (chestnut), tsuga (hemlock spruce, boxwood)

40� Birch soft, cypress, pine, medium soft woods

40-42� walnut

41� willow

41-42� maple soft

42-43� keyaki (zelcovia), sakura (cherry), elm

42-45� oak

43� beech, birch hard, maple hard, keyaki (zelcovia), sakura (cherry)-hard wood

43-45� chestnut

45� teak

52� ebony, rosewood kokutan (ebony), shitan (rosewood)-hardwood-kyubobai (steep slope)

This list is intended as a heuristic, not written in stone, but a very reasonable place to start. This is the reason I think it so important that those of us working with wooden planes be able to make the bodies. No one much agrees with me on this, primarily because they think a body/dai without blade misshapes itself. I made some blade place holders of iron wood, which seem to overcome this problem. Repeat, the guys on the Japanese forums say I'm stupid, below contempt, ad nauseum.

What do you think vis a vis western woodies?

Pam