Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Posts

Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#1

Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Larry Williams

>With all the plane choices today, it can be confusing as to what is really needed. In 1736 Richard Neve published the City and County Purchaser's and Builder's Dictionary. In it he listed the planes necessary to make about anything one might want. In more than 200 years, little has changed--the wood is the same and the work is the same. Anyone building a piece at a time would be well served by the planes on his list:


He includes almost every plane I would have on my must-have list except possibly a shoulder plane.

Here's the title page of his dictionary:


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#2

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Larry,

Thanks so much for publishing this! This book is scarce. For those who might not be aware, it is only Neve's 3rd Edition of 1736 (as Larry notes) which has this hand plane information. The earlier 2nd Edition--which can be had--does not.

A few points jump out:

1. Fore plane. As in Moxon, the fore plane remains the only roughing plane.

2. Long plane. Apparently this is what later came to be called the try plane (in Great Britain). Neve is going from the long (try) plane to the smoother when working faces, and from the long plane to the jointer for edges.

3. Strike block. Bevel-down miter plane.

A number of us are awaiting Don McConnell's next video on use of the snipes bill to make the entry cut for mouldings.

For purposes of historical comparison, does anyone have a translation of Felibien or the later Roubo? I'm curious as to whether the French practice used a similar line up of bench planes. I recall Bjenk Ellefsen was working on a Roubo translation.

Thanks again Larry.

Wiley

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#3

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Joel

>Larry,

I have the 1734 builders dictionary by Hawksmoor, JAmes & Gibbs which is 2 years earlier and includes the identical information (different text so it is not a direct copy) plus some additional info on grind angles. they list the snipe bill but not broken out like in the Neve edition. Do you know of any information on the relative popularity of the 2 books - if they were in competition, and if the 1734 edition information had any influence on the 1736 neve edition?

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#4

Good question

Larry Williams

>I don't have any idea, Joel. Can you post the information you have?

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#5

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Joel

>I just read the preface of my edition which says that this book borrowed heavily from Neve but is much larger (almost double the size) and was fairly well known in the colonies. but the question still remains about the details of the later Neve edition

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#6

Re: Good question

Joel

>what I have isn't scanned - I will try to scan the plane page - it's from a very limited edition facimilie from 20 years ago.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#7

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>This pretty much describes my toolkit and is similar to Nicholson in the 19th century. I do have a moving fillister- perhaps that is included under rabbet planes. I also have a router plane, not necessary for a joiner. I use mine for carving work only.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#8

Moving fillister

Larry Williams

>I would have considered a moving fillister a pretty important tool as well. However Don's recreation of Sheraton's use of the snipes bill planes has changed my mind. Now I see why they were missing from a lot of early inventories. While I see where they would be useful if one had a lot of the same sized rabbets to rough out, I don't know how important one would be to me. As a roughing plane I do see some usefulness.

I've come to agree with David Denning's opinion that appeared in his 1890's book The Art and Craft of Cabinet-Making. Denning described them as a carpenter's plane: "... For instance, our friend the joiner, working, as has been said, principally in pine, would find that the fillister is not so suitable as the rabbet-plane for making a rabbet in hard-wood furniture, a fact which the trained cabinet-maker is aware of, and so very probably does not even possess a fillister, the use of which would be somewhat inconvenient to him on that account even in 'deal' work. ... "

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#9

Re: Moving fillister

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Larry,

I am dense this evening, and can't quite follow Denning. Maybe you can connect the dots for me. Denning says that the trained cabinetmaker would prefer a rabbet plane for making rabbets in hardwood furniture, and would find the fillister "...somewhat inconvenient to him...even in 'deal' work".

'Deal' is pine, right? And our friend the joiner apparently uses a fillister to work in pine, since that is the comparison Denning has set up.

So why is the fillester inconvenient to the cabinetmaker, both in hardwood and in deal (pine)?

What is the contrast between the joiner and the cabinetmaker that Denning is making? Is he saying that the cabinetmaker will prefer the rabbet plane because he uses hardwood, or because he has a different accuracy/squareness requirement than the joiner?

Wiley

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#10

Re: Moving fillister

Larry Williams

>Wiley,

It's time consuming to set the moving fillister accurately or accurately enough for good joinery. Generally it's a lot easier to set the moving fillister to stay away from layout or gauge lines and finish up by working to the gauge lines. It takes a bit of time tinkering to get a moving fillister even close so why invest the time in the roughing stage?

You've got a couple other choices. You can start by working from the gauge line with a snipes bill, which requires no fiddling with a fence or depth stop, and finish up with the rabbet by working to the lower gauge line. The other option is to use your fingers as a fence for the rabbet, staying away from the gauge line during the rough in then finish to the gauge line. The second is significantly easier with a square rabbet rather than a skewed plane. Rabbet planes also offer bidirectional use and square rabbets are an advantage here as well. The ability to work both directions is especially important when working with hard woods and when the work will be more visible. Since working more with square rabbets I'm at a loss to explain the popularity of skewed rabbets.

Carpenters generally work to lower tolerances than cabinet makers and do a lot more repetitive work where taking the time to accurately set the fillister makes more sense. I certainly don't have anything against carpenters, I spent much of my life as one. I well remember making a lot of lineal feet of different things, a lot more than I ever did when making furniture.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#11

Earlier Editions

Ray Gardiner

>Larry, thanks for posting this,

I have added it to my library wish list..:-)

How does the earlier 1703 and 1726 editions compare?

Now, going slightly off topic,

... (fingers crossed) what information on handsaws is in there?

Regards

Ray

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#12

Not sold on Snipe Bills *LINK*

Adam Cherubini

>I like Don's clever use of the snipe bill. But I'm not sold on it's use or it's history. Lot's of craftsmen had moving fillisters and plows, not all had snipe bills. There are lots of antique fillisters about, but very few snipe bills. The snipe bills I've seen are all in very good shape (ditto for side rabbets) suggesting to me that these planes saw little real use.

Their shape suggests a purpose for creating or improving quirks. I can see why Don would gravitate to this plane for making a shoulder, but is this really the best plane for the job? Why not design a plane to support this technique? It's a good technique. I like it. So how about a plane that's simply beveled? Maybe shaped more like a side rabbet? Having a super thin entry doesn't seem to be advantageous when all you really want is a line and maybe a bit of shoulder? So why bother with the boxed edge?

In terms of historical usage, I think guys used plows with 1/4" irons for a lot of the setting in. We certainly see enough of these to believe this was a common practice, regardless of what is written. In my neck of the woods, I see a fair bit of 18th c and early 19th c moldings. These are very typically built up, which eliminates some of the setting in task. They are also not particularly uniform, especially when big (like Mount Pleasant).

As far as moving fillisters go, I have one and use it, but don't find too many applications for it in cabinetry. The rabbet joints I see can be made easier free hand with a rabbet plane. In fact, I find making a single short run of molding freehand is really fun. I mentioned it to Don at WiA. I hope he makes a video of that. I think some guys get intimidated by hollows and rounds. Doing work freehand might encourage them to just dig in and do it. It's certainly not a plan for success when making multiple pieces. For that, one must do what Don showed in his video. But a cabinetmaker who may only need 6 or 8 feet of molding can certainly try freehanding molding as an alternative approach. In this case I use a small round plane and a sq. rabbet for setting in.

Adam

P.S. If you don't know what I'm talking about with all this "snipe bill" and "setting in" you probably haven't seen Don's excellent video "Traditional Molding Techniques" available from Lie-Nielsen. It's a lot of useful woodworking information for $25. I think everybody should buy it. If you are worried about paying $25 for something you'll only watch once or twice, buy it then donate it to your local woodworking group. Don't have one? Start one. This is a nice place to begin. A woodworking lending library of books and dvds is a great benefit to members.


Lie-Nielsen website

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#13

Re: Earlier Editions

Larry Williams

>Ray,

I don't have the whole publication, only excerpts. Joel may be on to something about Neve's 3rd edition copying from Hawksmoor, James & Gibbs; Don McConnell tells me that Neve's information on handsaws leaves a lot to be desired.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#14

Re: Not sold on Snipe Bills

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I reread Peter Nicholson on these subjects this morning. Nicholson worked as a cabinetmaker in Edinburgh and London in the 18th century. He devotes three paragraphs to the snipesbill, entirely concerned with forming and cleaning quirks. He devotes three pages to the moving fillister, which he puts under the heading of rebate planes. Of the "rebate planes without fences", he says they are "not used for sinking a rebate, but rather for smoothing the bottom, after the moving fillister."

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#15

Re: Not sold on Snipe Bills

Larry Williams

>Adam,

I thought you were fond of Moxon. He very specifically mentions snipes bill planes in conjunction with hollows and rounds. So does Neve. Sheraton describes their use and a fenced plane simply wouldn't work where Sheraton describes the use of the snipes bill. Neither Moxon or Neve mention fillisters.

The snipes bill is actually a lot like a side rabbet. In fact the side snipe is essentially a side rabbet with a snipes bill shape to work in fine details.

What do you mean by freehand? What's freehand when using a fenced plane with a depth stop? By "freehand" do you mean winging it--just whacking away with no specific goal in mind. Mouldings are functional. They're the design tools used to manipulate forms to create a more appealing appearance. Used with deliberate intent they're quite effective, a vocabulary of design if you will. You don't get there by standing back throwing cr@p at a project to see what sticks. Like most things in woodworking, and life, the real key to success is to start out with a specific plan. It's pretty helpful to know where to stop--to know when your goal is achieved.

I don't know if you noticed the three cornice moldings displayed in our booth at WIA. All three were of about the same size and all used the same basic features. The visual impact of those moldings were strikingly different and would have a dramatically different effect on any given piece. Don made all three moldings from specific sources, two from books and one from a photo of a piece in a local antique store. He was able to reproduce them exactly because he started with a good plan followed by dependable technique. He might have been able to do the same thing by just whacking away but it would have taken a lot longer and probably would have involved a lot of wasted time and material.

Phil Edwards (Philly Planes) has a photo of the booth with the mouldings here. I wish I had a better picture available.

If moulding profiles are the vocabulary of furniture design their application is the grammar. I've got a lot to learn about the grammar and am certainly no expert at the visual impact of different profiles and how they're effectively used. I'm making an effort to learn it because I think it's incredibly important. I haven't experienced much real success by just whacking away with no plan.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#16

Re: Not sold on Snipe Bills

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have made custom moldings for furniture restorers for more than 20 years. I have made thousands of handmade moldings, mostly hardwoods, and often having to match up with an existing molding at a miter, such as when a return is missing. I think a moving fillister is handy for the precision required for this work. It is not hard to adjust this plane for careful work.

I don't think Joseph Moxon ever made a molding. I have not read the Andre Felibien text that he used for his plates, but I have wondered if he copied from the text as well.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#17

Re: Earlier Editions pt 1 

Joel

>


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#18

Re: Earlier Editions pt 2 

Joel

>


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#19

Re: Earlier Editions pt 3 (cover page) 

Joel

>


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#20

Re: Earlier Editions pt 3 (authors)

Joel

>Actually I think the names are made up.


img

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#21

didn't say it was "hard"

Larry Williams

>Warren,

I don't think I said it was hard. I said it was time consuming. I wouldn't try to set a moving fillister for accurate work without taking a test cut on a scrap piece of wood. I'd want to cut a complete rabbet to check for both width a depth. If I was off slightly I'd reset and test again. This is all unnecessary tinkering when working to gauge lines with a rabbet.

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#22

Strike Block Plane?

john jesseph

>I am guessing this is a shooting plane? ?

I really appreciate the scan, BTW... Thanks!!!

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#23

Dado planes?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>This discussion makes me curious about the history of dado planes. When did they come into being? And what was done before dado planes came into use?

Wiley

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#24

Re: Not sold on Snipe Bills

Paul Kierstead

> By "freehand" do you mean winging it--just whacking away with no specific goal in mind.

I'm not Adam, but that characterization sounds pretty severe. When people draw freehand, for example, they don't exactly just swoosh the pencil around and hope for the best. I should think that freehand is pretty far from "just whacking away".

Re: Richard Neve had it right in 1736

#25

power tool thinking

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>My goodness! Make a complete rabbet on a test piece? Reset and do another test before actually doing any work? This is a good example of old fashioned 20th century thinking. It takes long enough to make a rabbet without all this. Get it right the first time.