Not sold on Snipe Bills *LINK*
Adam Cherubini
>I like Don's clever use of the snipe bill. But I'm not sold on it's use or it's history. Lot's of craftsmen had moving fillisters and plows, not all had snipe bills. There are lots of antique fillisters about, but very few snipe bills. The snipe bills I've seen are all in very good shape (ditto for side rabbets) suggesting to me that these planes saw little real use.
Their shape suggests a purpose for creating or improving quirks. I can see why Don would gravitate to this plane for making a shoulder, but is this really the best plane for the job? Why not design a plane to support this technique? It's a good technique. I like it. So how about a plane that's simply beveled? Maybe shaped more like a side rabbet? Having a super thin entry doesn't seem to be advantageous when all you really want is a line and maybe a bit of shoulder? So why bother with the boxed edge?
In terms of historical usage, I think guys used plows with 1/4" irons for a lot of the setting in. We certainly see enough of these to believe this was a common practice, regardless of what is written. In my neck of the woods, I see a fair bit of 18th c and early 19th c moldings. These are very typically built up, which eliminates some of the setting in task. They are also not particularly uniform, especially when big (like Mount Pleasant).
As far as moving fillisters go, I have one and use it, but don't find too many applications for it in cabinetry. The rabbet joints I see can be made easier free hand with a rabbet plane. In fact, I find making a single short run of molding freehand is really fun. I mentioned it to Don at WiA. I hope he makes a video of that. I think some guys get intimidated by hollows and rounds. Doing work freehand might encourage them to just dig in and do it. It's certainly not a plan for success when making multiple pieces. For that, one must do what Don showed in his video. But a cabinetmaker who may only need 6 or 8 feet of molding can certainly try freehanding molding as an alternative approach. In this case I use a small round plane and a sq. rabbet for setting in.
Adam
P.S. If you don't know what I'm talking about with all this "snipe bill" and "setting in" you probably haven't seen Don's excellent video "Traditional Molding Techniques" available from Lie-Nielsen. It's a lot of useful woodworking information for $25. I think everybody should buy it. If you are worried about paying $25 for something you'll only watch once or twice, buy it then donate it to your local woodworking group. Don't have one? Start one. This is a nice place to begin. A woodworking lending library of books and dvds is a great benefit to members.
Lie-Nielsen website