Mr. Lee, you're our the only hope
Alexander Grigoriev
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Mr. Lee, you're our the only hope
Alexander Grigoriev
>
Thanks, Dan
Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA
>but I think I need to put that one in my savings account for the moment. Yesterday, I redid the before-it-rains-and-before-my-surgery list. I'd seriously reduced a list that took up a full half-sheet of paper (that is, folded over), but, somehow, the new list took up the whole half-page again - and that without the window replacement we've been discussing (because, by the time we ordered a window and it arrived, we'd be so deep into December it could be raining/too cold to have the house open for a day).
On a way off-topic personal note, LOML and I went to see Joan Baez last night. It turns out she's celebrating her 50th anniversary of public singing this year, and she's still got that voice and soul. We were struck by how unpretentious she is: she showed up in a white blouse and jeans, and her between-songs talking mostly made fun of herself. Two non-stop hours of great music and a lovely way to celebrate our own 39th anniversary of being together.
"Oh help us O B 1. You are our only hope."
Parisian, VL
>
I'm doubtful LV will ever be a source
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>There is no doubt that LV has looked into the potential of this product and rejected the idea for some reason. Strange to me that something to grind plane bottoms was developed for what I would think a micro market but an alternative to water stones was not viable. The really strange thing is that the cast iron plate would enable anyone to sharpen the more abrasion resistant A2 alloy, or anything else. A plane iron maker could sell a premium steel blade and the means to sharpen it as a package.
I would be more hopeful that some entrepreneur would crank up production. Back when we had the lumber business I would have done it myself, but not now.
Plates would be vastly easier to manufacture than plane irons, marking knives, bow saws, chisels or the multitude of other stuff people are successfully marketing from micro businesses. A machinist in our club was going to produce a trial batch of 50 plates but he got scared off by the possibility of LV making them. If any large company makes them they would be cast and ground in a low labor cost country for next to nothing and wipe out anyone making them domestically. Look what Grizzley can sell cast iron blanchard ground machines for, or Harbor Freight. This may be reason LV has chosen to not try to develop the plate market. Nothing more commodity than a chunk of Blanchard ground cast iron.
Re: No special technique is needed
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Are you saying the charge is only temporary? That you go through those steps for every edge you sharpen?
Pam
routine maintenance
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I don't recharge every time I hone....not needed. But I do add a drop of lube before honing. (I use WD 40 as I became convinced it is more slippery than mineral spirits, but maybe not) . Before I put the plate away in its bag ( I need to get around to making it a box) I wipe it, and of course I wipe the blade.
Wife fixed me a paper towel holder by the bench so these wipes are close at hand.
Currently I am using powder and I find it more inconvenient than a tube of paste. I am trying to figure out a way to suspend this powder in grease and put it in a tube for dispensing.
For the powder a recharge of the plate is at most 5 milligrams of dry powder. A grain of rice sized mound would be too much.
Charging the plate is quick
Steve Elliott
>I start my honing procedure by charging the plate and sometimes add a fresh dab of paste if I'm doing several blades or am renewing a significantly worn edge. It's not a lot of steps, just quickly rubbing on a tiny bit of paste. Overall I find it less bothersome than soaking a waterstone.
Re: on-line source? *LINK*
Paul Kierstead
>See URL for 2 quite large ones for $149.
Semi-cheap cast-iron plates
Re: I'm doubtful LV will ever be a source
Rob Lee
>Hi Bill -
This isn't as straight forward a problem as it seems.... "cast iron" is a pretty generic term, and covers a lot of territory. Finding the correct material isn't as easy as one would suspect.
If we were to support a diamond lapping system based on a cast iron plate - we'd have have to do a ton of work to ensure we were doing the right thing, for the right reasons... and we're just not at that point.
Not that we won't get there sometime....
Cheers -
Rob
Re: Charging the plate is quick
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>OK, Bill and Steve, what I want to do is get things set up and then work all day with minimal mess and fuss. I don't typically soak waterstones (just spritz on some water from time to time), although that would be easier than what the cast iron/diamond set up sounds like. When I need to sharpen something, I want to walk over to the sharpening station and do it, really don't want to clean up after each event. What am I missing from what you're saying.
Bill, first thing I installed in the shop after cabinets and bench was a paper towel holder. :)
Pam
Re: I'm doubtful LV will ever be a source
Miles
>Rob, I know a cast-iron specialist metallurgist (in Poland, but hey, they can't be that common) who could perhaps answer some of those technical questions for you.
He cast me a couple of plates - I'm waiting to grind them. He normally makes ultra-wear-resistant parts for shotblasting machines. Apparently cast iron of certain grades is just the thing. Might mean that my ones are going to surprise a machine shop somwhere.
PM me any questions that you think might have useful answers, if the list is not the place.
cheers
Miles
LOLZ!
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA
>
customized directions
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>1. If you have already invested in some successful sharpening system and you are not going to used a high abrasion resistant steel then this technique has little advantage.
2. To operate the way you want I would mount the plate in some sort of holder which could be a simple block of wood. I would then provide a cover of some sort to keep contamination off the plate. When it came time to use the plate, uncover it and add a drop or two of lube if the plate appeared dry. Olive oil can be used and it will then remain wet. I use WD 40 and it dries out after some hours. Every now and then I might wipe the plate off with a towel as gunge accumulates. More rarely I would recharge it.
A significant disadvantage of plates over water stones is that contamination on a plate is forever. A contaminated water stone can be reground with shop tools and equipment. Removing a contaminated layer from a plate is territory I have not explored, save a trip to the surface grinder.
3. What is needed is some gem stone cutter to tell us how to best maintain plates. They have had 300 years to figure it all out
plate metal selection
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>The purpose of this note is to be sure individuals wanting to try this approach are not dissuaded by metal selection. Cast iron plates charged with diamond have been used to grind gem stones since about the start of the iron age so the cast iron attributes required are not unknown. The effort to select the right metal is not the obstacle to commercializing this approach. "Gray Cast Iron"- available anywhere cast iron is manufactured (or junked)- will make a successful plate. I have made them from virgin gray cast iron ingots, sawed them from cast iron objects like angle plates, and recovered them from junk yard scrap.
A local business has a pallet of 3' x 3" x 1/2" Blanchard ground plates sitting in storage. (they gave me one and that is how I got started) Should they ever go out of business I hope I am at the auction. They got them for somewhere. Find where and you can be in the plate business for the price of a hack saw to reduce them to 12" lengths.
Re: on-line source?
Victor Parisian
>A couple/few years back there was a discussion on cast iron plates. Someone suggested that replacement parts (the wings) for Sears cast iron topped table saws were reasonably priced. I never looked into it, but I imagine that somewhere there is a warehouse with a pallet of those parts sitting gathering rust and dust. And the price is still relatively cheap.
Victor - gotta get back to work again
Re: on-line source?
Paul Kierstead
>Yup. And I expect if you watch your local craigs list or troll the garage sales, you can probably get something too. Or even just put out a WTB in the local classifieds; some guy will probably happily give up his dead TS in the basement for $20
Re: customized directions
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Understood, many thanks, that contaminated forever bit is key.
As to gem cutters, maybe David Barnett will show up with his encyclopedic knowledge.
Pam