Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>Virgil is going to investigate diamond sharpening and I penned him a letter about what we know and don't with the hope that our experience would help him. I thought it might be of interest to others so I am posting it here. Also, Steve Elliot has been using this technique and I would like his (an others) thoughts and comparisons to what we are doing.
Background: When I asked abrasive experts, such as tech staff at 3M and elsewhere , how to grind tool steel they universally said to use diamond. The question then became....how? Industry has available all sorts of diamond products impractical for home woodworking use. While researching diamond products I blundered into the lapidary applications and I wish I could find who I talked to that sold lapping plates for specialized grinding applications. Anyway, they pointed me in the direction of using a charged cast iron plate for our flat bevels.
The expertise in doing what we are trying to do lies in the lapidary community where gems have been "cut" (think honed) for centuries. What we haven't done is refine the charging process nor optimized the surface of the cast iron. I have never seen a lapidary plate. I think it has grooves to slush off the gunge generated. I just float it off the edges with the WD 40 I add. What we do works, and works well, but it is likely what we do can be improved.
Initially we had as set of plates charged from 30 micron down to 1 micron. Oh wow did the 30 micron cut steel. So the edge renewal routine involved grinding a flat bevel on the 30 micron plate, then various smaller grits, and ending at 1 micron. Soon we discovered fresh 30 micron scratches from the 1 micron plate. Examination of the tool under magnification revealed diamond particles embedded in the scratches. We call this problem "carry- over". I later found it described in a machinist handbook from the 1950's. (What we are doing is not novel nor "invented" by us. ) We never found an effective way to remove loose diamond particles carrying from coarse pates to finer plates.
Then some fortuitous discoveries came together. The bottom line was that even 1 micron diamond is sufficient to refine a hollow ground tool edge in one step, no matter how coarse the wheel was to generate the hollow grind. However, 1 micron was not adequate to refine a crooked edge if the wheel grinding was not near perfect. So, a crutch was inserted in the sharpening regime. After wheel grinding, a few strokes were made on a fixed fine diamond plate. The purpose of this step is to reveal and correct any crookedness from wheel grinding. Because it is a fixed diamond, there is no carry-over that we have observed. We lube the fixed plate with water soluble machine shop cutting fluid, diluted. It makes the tool slide nicely. I'll bet Windex would work well.
To summarize the steps and their purpose/objective:
A. hollow grind up to the tool edge- this is the major metal removal step, as needed. A light touch is essential on this step. Use a crowned wheel.
B. fine fixed diamond plate- this step is a moderate metal removal step. It is used to straighten the edge from step 1, as needed. As you get better it is needed less. If the edge is crooked the bevel made in this step will reveal where the edge is crooked and it makes going back to the grinder for straightening easy. In reading this part don't overlook the importance of this feature. Most people will make use of this feature when learning to hollow grind on the grinder.
C. 1 micron on cast iron- This step requires little skill or experience. If the edge is straight off the grinder, 5 pull strokes on the plate is all that is required to remove the grinder scratches and refine the edge to 1 micron scratches. A hollow ground edge sucks down on the flat plate making registration of the edge secure. Skewing the blade 30 degrees or so makes registration even more secure.
Notes:
1. If a jig is used, step B might be eliminated with the expense of spending more time on step C. A jig would enable vigorous back and forth honing in step C which will remove metal at an astonishing rate considering 1 micron abrasive is being used. I don't use the jig.
2. The surface will appear dull compared to other sharpening. I think the dullness is due to carbon from the cast iron embedded in the scratches.
3. I don't know if 1 micron is the best grit to use. It works for my practical applications.
4. I occasionally squirt a 1/4" worm of paste on the plate and rub it in with the tool. I am sure there is a better way to charge a plate.
5. The skill lies in step A. A nice flat tool rest helps here. I learned this step at low grinder speed, but now I use 3600 rpm and a very soft wheel. I started out with 120 grit wheel but found that step C removed 80 grit scratches almost as quickly. I almost always do a stroke or two on the fixed diamond plate just to be sure the edge is straight so it matters none what grit wheel I use. 80 grit cuts faster and cooler, but requires more skill because metal goes away quicker.




