Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

Posts

Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#1

Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Virgil is going to investigate diamond sharpening and I penned him a letter about what we know and don't with the hope that our experience would help him. I thought it might be of interest to others so I am posting it here. Also, Steve Elliot has been using this technique and I would like his (an others) thoughts and comparisons to what we are doing.

Background: When I asked abrasive experts, such as tech staff at 3M and elsewhere , how to grind tool steel they universally said to use diamond. The question then became....how? Industry has available all sorts of diamond products impractical for home woodworking use. While researching diamond products I blundered into the lapidary applications and I wish I could find who I talked to that sold lapping plates for specialized grinding applications. Anyway, they pointed me in the direction of using a charged cast iron plate for our flat bevels.

The expertise in doing what we are trying to do lies in the lapidary community where gems have been "cut" (think honed) for centuries. What we haven't done is refine the charging process nor optimized the surface of the cast iron. I have never seen a lapidary plate. I think it has grooves to slush off the gunge generated. I just float it off the edges with the WD 40 I add. What we do works, and works well, but it is likely what we do can be improved.

Initially we had as set of plates charged from 30 micron down to 1 micron. Oh wow did the 30 micron cut steel. So the edge renewal routine involved grinding a flat bevel on the 30 micron plate, then various smaller grits, and ending at 1 micron. Soon we discovered fresh 30 micron scratches from the 1 micron plate. Examination of the tool under magnification revealed diamond particles embedded in the scratches. We call this problem "carry- over". I later found it described in a machinist handbook from the 1950's. (What we are doing is not novel nor "invented" by us. ) We never found an effective way to remove loose diamond particles carrying from coarse pates to finer plates.

Then some fortuitous discoveries came together. The bottom line was that even 1 micron diamond is sufficient to refine a hollow ground tool edge in one step, no matter how coarse the wheel was to generate the hollow grind. However, 1 micron was not adequate to refine a crooked edge if the wheel grinding was not near perfect. So, a crutch was inserted in the sharpening regime. After wheel grinding, a few strokes were made on a fixed fine diamond plate. The purpose of this step is to reveal and correct any crookedness from wheel grinding. Because it is a fixed diamond, there is no carry-over that we have observed. We lube the fixed plate with water soluble machine shop cutting fluid, diluted. It makes the tool slide nicely. I'll bet Windex would work well.

To summarize the steps and their purpose/objective:

A. hollow grind up to the tool edge- this is the major metal removal step, as needed. A light touch is essential on this step. Use a crowned wheel.

B. fine fixed diamond plate- this step is a moderate metal removal step. It is used to straighten the edge from step 1, as needed. As you get better it is needed less. If the edge is crooked the bevel made in this step will reveal where the edge is crooked and it makes going back to the grinder for straightening easy. In reading this part don't overlook the importance of this feature. Most people will make use of this feature when learning to hollow grind on the grinder.

C. 1 micron on cast iron- This step requires little skill or experience. If the edge is straight off the grinder, 5 pull strokes on the plate is all that is required to remove the grinder scratches and refine the edge to 1 micron scratches. A hollow ground edge sucks down on the flat plate making registration of the edge secure. Skewing the blade 30 degrees or so makes registration even more secure.

Notes:

1. If a jig is used, step B might be eliminated with the expense of spending more time on step C. A jig would enable vigorous back and forth honing in step C which will remove metal at an astonishing rate considering 1 micron abrasive is being used. I don't use the jig.

2. The surface will appear dull compared to other sharpening. I think the dullness is due to carbon from the cast iron embedded in the scratches.

3. I don't know if 1 micron is the best grit to use. It works for my practical applications.

4. I occasionally squirt a 1/4" worm of paste on the plate and rub it in with the tool. I am sure there is a better way to charge a plate.

5. The skill lies in step A. A nice flat tool rest helps here. I learned this step at low grinder speed, but now I use 3600 rpm and a very soft wheel. I started out with 120 grit wheel but found that step C removed 80 grit scratches almost as quickly. I almost always do a stroke or two on the fixed diamond plate just to be sure the edge is straight so it matters none what grit wheel I use. 80 grit cuts faster and cooler, but requires more skill because metal goes away quicker.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#2

Thanks

Howard Pollack

>Thanks Bill, I look forward to further additions to this thread. It promises to be very useful. -Howard

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#3

Thanks Bill, a question

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If I wanted to use 1/4 micron paste, would the cast iron still do, or should I look for some other substrate? Would you change the steps prior to getting to the cast iron plate?

I'm really interested in the technique, but I'd like to push it to a still keener edge...

Thnx,

DC

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#4

A few more details

Steve Elliott

>Bill�s procedure covers all the important issues so there�s not much for me to add. I believe the important issues are:

1. Use grinding to do the major metal removal

2. Use an effective substrate (cast iron is much better than MDF, hard maple, or acrylic)

3. Keep the number of grits used to a minimum

I�ve tried a number of different types of diamond paste and hope also to try loose diamonds. The very fine grits (less than 1 micron) do produce a keener edge but the difference is gone after just a few strokes of the plane. For my purposes the speed of 1 micron outweighs this small difference in sharpness. On the other hand, 3 micron is even faster but just doesn�t refine the edge enough. It would be fine for mortise chisels but not for my super smoother.

I recently bought some polycrystalline 3 micron diamond with the idea that the diamond particles might fracture during use and gradually become finer as I honed. I found that it cut very fast, at least as fast as the 3 micron monocrystalline diamond, but didn�t seem to become finer.

For fluid to wash off the blade and lapping plate I keep a small can of odorless mineral spirits handy. It has a nozzle that allows me to put just a couple of drops on the plate at a time. I wipe off the slurry with small pieces of paper towel. Honing isn�t very messy, better than waterstones or oilstones in my experience.

The only real difference between Bill�s method and mine is use of a jig. I don�t recommend a jig for most woodworkers because freehand honing is really pretty easy, but for very precise control of the edge geometry I�ve developed my own jig that gives me speed and control over both the main bevel and a tiny backbevel. I�ve found that the edge produced using the backbevel is sharper than I can get when I keep the back of the blade flat. David Charlesworth�s ruler trick is the best-known technique for producing this type of backbevel.

My goal in developing the jig was to be able to use the entire surface of the lapping plate or waterstone, to be able to hone the main bevel and backbevel alternately to remove any wire edge, and to have independent control over the angles of both the main and back bevels. The result is quite a contraption that I consider a prototype to be refined, but it works pretty well.

My recent acquisition of Blanchard ground gray cast iron to use for the lapping surface is a major improvement. Right now I have two plates the size of a typical waterstone and a couple of larger pieces that I will cut to size eventually when I know what size I want. I bought the cast iron from an industrial supply company in bandsawn slices about 3/8� thick. The surface had deep ridges from the bandsaw and I found it much too difficult to flatten even one small plate myself. The Blanchard grinding was pretty cheap on a per-plate basis and it�s not hard to further refine the surface of a small plate if I think it�s necessary. So far I�m satisfied with the Blanchard-ground surface.

Over the years I�ve tried many fine waterstones and some oilstones too, and they all produce good edges once you�ve learned to work with them. The same is true of diamond sharpening. There are differences in the feel of the stone or plate, the need for flattening or not, and the type of mess involved. What I like about diamonds is their speed and the small amount of equipment needed. One plate with two useable surfaces should be enough and a lifetime supply of diamonds doesn�t cost much. Again, grinding skill is the key and it�s no harder to learn than honing.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#5

Re: Thanks Bill, a question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The cast iron works best with the small grits. Acrylic (Plexiglas) works best for coarse grits as they embed better.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#6

our experience matches everything Steve said

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When two groups pursuing a goal independently come to essentially identical conclusions it is a good indication that the approach being investigated is robust. Others will have a high probability of finding the same result, for better or worse. So if you like what you see you will likely be successful doing what we do. And if you don't like what you see, then look for something different.

I think the main attribute of diamonds is cheap and quick, not better, unless high abrasion resistant steels are being honed (M2,M4, 3V etc.) . Cheap is irrelevant if you already have bought something else that is successful.

There was one tidbit of new to me data in Steve's post, the frailty of ultra sharp edges. It has been an ongoing discussion whether ever increased edge refinement would lead to longer edge life, or whether the additional refinement would simply wear away in a few strokes leaving one in the same state as the case where the edge was not as refined. Or to say it different, in practical situations are we always planing with a "dull" blade? It sounds like ultra edge refinement is useful for planing contests and not significant for on-the-job planing.

Steve should be more famous for the work he has done. If I was a magazine editor I would be beating down his door to publish his findings.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#7

Steel types

Alex Grigoriev

>"I think the main attribute of diamonds is cheap and quick, not better, unless high abrasion resistant steels are being honed (M2,M4, 3V etc.)"

Does 1 micron diamond lapping work well for A2 steel?

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#8

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

ThomD

>"Background: When I asked abrasive experts, such as tech staff at 3M and elsewhere , how to grind tool steel they universally said to use diamond."

That probably needs elaboration. What tool steel, a lot of cases techs recomend against diamond with tool steel, that is what the average machinists hears from them. It also isn't what they tell knifemakers when they are selling belts. I'm not saying diamonds are the wrong track, you have certainly convinced me it is worth investigating, and now tha LV is selling the paste I have a local supply. Bill, have you checked the threads on the turning side? They are talking about diamond wheels for grinding HSS turning tools, which is one of those things, that "can't" be done. Diamonds aren't one thing only. I have used them for shapening for decades (new to the paste), there are lots of interesting interactions.

"produce a keener edge but the difference is gone after just a few strokes of the plane."

That worries me, while we all reach the point of deminishing returns. Normally the hyper sharp blade lasts surprisingly long, It just isn't worth it either for the the quality of work required or the time put into the sharpening.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#9

A Caveat

Steve Elliott

>My statement about ultrasharp edges losing their advantage after a few strokes of the plane is based on ordinary experience, not the controlled testing I've done on other issues. I hope someday to do a controlled test of this, but right now I have this job thingie I have to spend most of my time on. With the recent developments in the economy I may end up with lots more time for testing.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#10

A2 abrades readily and quickly

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In the abrasion resistance scale A2 is somewhere between carbon steel and the highly abrasion resistant steels like M2, 3V, and M4. Diamond cuts them all readily.

Based on some combination of my experience grinding stuff and literature data abrasion resistance is in the order: Stanley plane irons< Hock and similar carbon steel< M2 and 3V

If practical diamond sharpening became widely available one would see these tool steels become widely used in hand tools, just as they are in turning. Without diamond sharpening it is difficult if not impossible to sharpen these tool steels, which I think generated the myth that the tool steels would not take an edge as keen as carbon steel.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#11

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

Alex Grigoriev

>In his excellent book about sharpening, Mr. Leonard Lee says that the edge will hold, as long as the angle is high enough for the particular material and job. Though I think that's mostly for chisels that are pushed pretty much parallel to one side of the edge. For a plane, with its relief angle, abrasion may be causing the most dulling.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#12

Is it diamond or the set up?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

To date I have only experimented with the oil based diamond paste. I have used this on scraps of hardwood (mainly Jarrah) since I did not have an iron plate. The Jarrah seemed to hold the diamond pretty well. The grits I have are 40, 10, 1 and .5

I have not bothered with diamond paste for several months now. Firstly, it is very messy. Even a tiny amount tends to smear itself over everything. It is harder to wipe off one's hands than the residue from a waterstone. I have a greater concern about staining the wood I work with diamond paste than with waterstone residue.

I have not tried water-based diamond paste, and I wonder if this is different in this regard?

The second reason I stopped using diamond paste is that, since it is as messy (for me) as anything else, I preferred the ease of using Shaptons. Frankly, with good preparation, just about anything will sharpen fast and easily!

As you mentioned, the key to preparation is a hollow grind to the edge of the bevel. I use either a Tormek or a 46 grit Norton 3X wheel on a 8" half-speed grinder (that's 1400 rpm in Oz). It depends on the steel. I have been using more A2 because of its greater abrasion resistance on the silica-rich Jarrah.

The thing is that just about any media hones really fast when the amount of steel to remove is minimal - as it is when you hollow grind to the very edge of the bevel. It takes a few strokes on a 1000 grit Shapton to straighten a ground edge, and then I conceivably could go stratight to a 8000 or even 15000 Shapton. As the microbevel widens I use a 5000 before moving to a finishing stone.

I am still interested in diamond, but mainly for flattening backs of blades. Diamond definitely does a great job, and your (and Steve's) writings enthuse me to try once more. However, for creating an edge, with the ideal set up, I really wonder whether you are measuring the speed of diamond cutting, or the speed of the set up?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#13

Charging Question

Al Goldstein

>Bill and Steve,

I like the idea of using diamonds for sharpening. Thaks for sharing your expertise with us.

When I upgraded from an old 8 inch Rockwell tilting top table saw I kept the top for just this purpose.

I intend to cut up the top into several sharpening stations. I could also use the bottoms from several old damaged metal planes. My question is how does one charge the top with diamonds? Not being a machinist I don't know anything about Blanchard grinding. Can I just spread the diamond paste (Lee Valley) on the cast iron top or must I treat the top in some way first?

Al

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#14

No special technique is needed

Steve Elliott

>For a lapping plate the size of a waterstone I put a couple of very small dots on using the syringe dispenser the diamond paste comes it, then just rub it into the plate with my finger. If it will just barely spread over the surface that's the right amount, and it doesn't take much. Then I add abut two drops of mineral spirits and start honing.

The resulting slurry is almost black. I wipe it up with torn-up bits of paper towel and discard them in a metal tin that has a tight-fitting lid. (That's just a precaution I take with all solvents, and it helps isolate the mess.)

When I'm done I put a couple more drops of mineral spirits on the blade and wipe it clean, then do the same with the lapping plate. I like the fact that I don't need to be near a sink or drain and don't end up with oil on my hands, as with traditional honing methods.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#15

Corrosion?

Alexander Grigoriev

>Does cast iron rust with water-based lube? Should I use mineral spirits?

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#16

All of this discussion started from...

Virgil

>My friend at work asking me to borrow a plane to plane the edge of a sticking door. I did not want to loan him a dull tool so I got out the stones and proceeded to sharpen it. After I finished I got inspired and sharpened all the planes I own. A whopping 4 piece collection. During this I thought about how I had wanted try water stones which lead me to post the stone question. So now I'm off looking for a chunk of cast iron to map a lapping plate from.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#17

You'd want to test for flatness

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>but if your local dump has a recycle area, you might have no trouble finding a defunct table saw with a cast iron top and wind up with more sharpening surface than you'll likely ever need.

This, at least, is what I'm telling myself with the two table saw tops in my shed, waiting for round tuits.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#18

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

Miles

>The usual cautions about diamonds and steel are for high speed machining. In this case, the contact point between the workpiece and the tool gets extremely hot - under these conditions the diamond 'dissolves' (reacts with) the iron, forming iron carbides. Thus the diamond does not mechanically abrade, but chemically, and hence it does not last as long as it should. This is only true for materials that can react with the diamond - iron, titanium, etc. Concrete, on the other hand, does not, which is why diamond wheels for grinding it work so amazingly well.

This problem is what led to the use of CBN (cubic boron nitride) for machining steel at high speeds - it is not quite as hard, but it lasts much longer for this application.

At low speeds, like Bill's lapping plate, this reaction is not an issue - but it might well be for grinding the HSS turning tools. I wonder if CBN wheels would not be better for that application...

Bill and Steve have done a great job explaining what is surely one of the best options for 'lifetime sharpening' - it has a great pedigree and allows us to use all those interesting steels that 'don't get as sharp as carbon steel' on oilstones. If only someone would get to it with supplying good plates and paste (Rob Lee, here's looking at you!), we could wave goodbye to all those endless discussions about which colour waterstone matches the soul of a particular blade and just get on with it... :-)

I wonder what grit Rob uses on those lapping machines that he puts his plane blades through?

cheers to all

Miles

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#19

on-line source?

Howard Pollack

>Does anyone know if there is an on-line source for appropriate cast-iron plates? If someone has some to sell, please pm me. Thanks. -Howard

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#20

Here you go

Dan Donaldson

>Dusking and running ;-)


img

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#22

Re: Corrosion?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I don't know the answer to your question. Probably yes if you left it wet.

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#23

talk about slipery slopes!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#24

I have never found any source

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Dear Virgil and Steve (about diamonds)

#25

both

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you are grinding Stanley plane irons I doubt one would notice a difference in speed between refining a hollow grind edge on a water stone or cast iron plate with diamonds. The main advantage of diamond is cheap (presuming you obtain a cast iron plate cheap) and it may be the only route to getting a good edge on the more abrasion resistant steels. Diamond could be quicker if you need more than one water stone to get an equivalent edge, or if maintaining the water stone is counted.

The mess issue you raised has not been a problem for me. When I was working the mahogany for the Federal piece my hands stayed black from the mahogany. That and farm dirt and grease; whatever additional from the cast iron is not noticed. It is one of the least significant of my shop mess sources, well behind stains and glue.