Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Waterstones for Dummies?

Posts

Waterstones for Dummies?

#1

Waterstones for Dummies?

Virgil Johnson

>I searched the archives to no avail trying to find a tutorial on buying a set of waterstones. Anyone have advice as to what to look for and the basics to get started. I'm currently using a DMT diamond plate, a medium India, followed by a hard Arkansas stone. This works well for me but I want to try something new. TIA.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#2

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

Tony - Memphis

>I bought the Norton set after using them in a class. They doa great job for me. The set came with a 200(I think), 1000,4000, and 8000. I rarely use the 200. I've been very pleased with these.

Tony

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#3

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

Hank Knight

>Virgil,

Tony's Norton set is pretty standard. I have and use the same ones and they have worked well for me. My only advice would be to skip the 220 coarse stone and use your diamond plate for the heavy grinding. The Norton coarse 220 stone cuts well but it wears extremely fast. I used mine up and never replaced it. I use a large DMT coarse/medium diamond plate to flatten my Nortons and have been happy with it. There are so many sharpening options out there and so many opinions that one can go totally nuts chasing after the "perfect" sharpening system. I've been through several myself and I keep coming back to the Nortons. They're messy, but they do a fine job. I think Kings and other water stones work equally well, but I haven't used them so I really can't comment. All systems have their idiosyncrasies and take a little getting used to, and I believe all of them are capable of producing a good edge. My advice is to pick one system and stick with it until you feel you are proficient with it. Otherwise you'll spend lots of money and end up terribly frustrated.

Hank

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

Ellis Walentine

>Virgil, I don't consider myself an authority on this stuff, since there have been some significant developments in just the past couple years. That said, I have been using King waterstones since the late '70s when they first appeared in the US. For years, I sharpened with a 1200, followed by another brand in the 3000 - 4000 range, followed by a King Gold stone. (Their G series stones are finer and sharpen faster than their S series.)

About 8 or 10 years ago, I was introduced to Shaptons by Harrelson Stanley of Japanesetools.com. These are synthetic ceramic (?) waterstones that really cut aggressively and are available up to grits that I could never imagine needing. I currently use a 2000, 5000 and 8000 and am quite happy with them. I also got one of their cast iron bases to set the stones on when using them.

Most recently, I picked up a very fine (8000, 10,000?) grit stone mounted on glass. I'm sorry I don't even recall the maker, but it is a very sweet finishing stone, plenty fine for producing a mirror polish in a hurry.

I regret that I am late to the diamond finishing regime, but many people swear by it. All you need is a collection of grits and an MDF block to embed them in.

The upshot is, if you can afford to spring for Shaptons, you will be happy. Otherwise, compared to the old India/Arkansas routine you're used to, two or three standard waterstones will do the trick.

The rest of the story is that there are quite a lot of other stones out there, from Woodcraft, the Japan Woodworker, etc. that are also excellent, and good alternatives to the King equivalents.

Good topic, and overdue.

Ellis

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#5

Shaptons

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Ellis, I more or less agree with your praise of the Shaptons if you're using Japanese tools with big hollows; but I've found incredible stiction when sharpening western tools on them, to the point of not being able to move the western tool at all (except, of course, prying them up off the stone). There are a couple of things that can be done to ameliorate this, but I have real problems with scratching out grooves on such an expensive item.

Pam

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#6

Re: Shaptons

Dean J in MN

>I'll echo Pam's warning of sticktion. I've given up on the Shaptons for my tools (western). Gone back to good old oil stones and am happy.

-Dean

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#7

Surface conditioning

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Dean,

Something I think might really help the oil stone bubbas who are thinking about converting--or even if they aren't--is surface conditioning. With water stones, including natural water stones, it is very helpful to condition and flatten the surface with diamond stones. Atoma is a brand that a number of water stone folks use.

I have seen Larry Williams' recommendation to regularly condition oil stones with a diamond stone, to deglaze them, flatten them, and generally restore their bite. Do you do this or similar, and if so, with what?

Wiley

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#8

Re: Surface conditioning

David W. Dougherty

>I have always used oil stones for my carving tools; but recently I switched back to oil stones for sharpening my "flat" tools as well. I just find them easier to use, easier to maintain, and, yes, less messy as well. Plus, the Norton oil I use is really nice on my hands after a day in my workshop.

I bought new stones (soft, hard select, and black hard) from Dan's Whetstone company--gorgeous stones they are too--and a few of the DMT solid plate diamond stones (an extra coarse, a course, and a fine). I use the diamond stones to resurface the oil stones. Naturally, the coarser stones need flattening more often than my black hard stone, but still far and away less than my now unused Norton water stones.

Hope this helps.

David W. Dougherty, Violinmaker

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#9

Prepare one piece of cast iron

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Charge it with 1 micron diamond paste. That is all the additional stuff you need. Spend money saved by not buying a suite of water stones on ......whatever. Spend time saved sharping on woodworking. Use machining skills to sell cast iron already prepared and retire early from profits. Your local machine industrial supply can supply blanks that will only require surface grinding.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#10

Blanchard Grinding Cast Iron

Steve Elliott

>I recently had a couple of pieces of cast iron Blanchard ground to see if the surface produced by this less expensive grinding method would be good enough for sharpening plane blades. My initial impression is that the surface is plenty good enough. It has some visible circular scratches but both 3 micron and 1 micron diamond seem to cut very well using this less-than-perfect surface.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#11

But Bill....

John in NM

>I think the success of the various sharpening products manufacturers has more to do with the desire to try something new than how effectively any particular system works! Same reason I keep changing sights on pistols, just too much fun to try the next different thing.

From an efficiency point of view, I tend to agree with you though.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#12

Re: Surface conditioning

Kevin Adams

>I also took the advice from Larry Williams and condition my oil stones regularly with an extra extra coarse (120 grit) DMT that is guaranteed (and actually is!) flat. I tried it with oil first, but find that using water for this process works better. I then put some mineral oil back on the stones and get to work. I find it makes a huge difference and it sure is nice working with flat stones. Larry also advises leaving the slurry on the stones and you'll be amazed at how quicker they work.

I'd suggest you try this first before you spend the money on a different sharpening system. BTW, I use a Lilly White washita (while Joel still had them), along with a hard and surgical black from Hall's Pro-edge. I've heard that Dan's is also very good, but Hall's are significantly less expensive and are first-rate natural stones.

Kevin

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#13

Re: Shaptons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Pam

There are two very easy fixes for stiction on the Shaptons, neither of which is as invasive as scratching the surface of the stones.

I was also struggling a little until I watched a DVD by Harrelson. In this he used as much water to wash the stones as I had with my Kings before the Shaptons. One of the reasons I moved to the Shaptons was the promise of less water - but this was not altogether so (at that stage). As soon as I used more water, the stiction ended.

Several months ago Mike Wenzloff suggested I add a little liquid soap to the water. This made a difference again, and I could reduce the amount of water in use.

I have Pro Shaptons 1000, 5000, 8000, 15000. They cut faster than the Kings and remain flatter longer. Still, it is advisable to flatten frequently.

I have been using a 10" DMT Extra Coarse diamond stone to flatten them until recently, when I was fortunate to pick up a Shapton Diamond Lapping Plate from a deceased estate (these are very expensive). The Shapton plate is faster to cut and produces a flatter surface (the DMT is flat enough). Both are rated at about 275, so 240 sandpaper (use beltsander belts glued to glass) would also work well.

The other observation I may offer is that the Shaptons do not dry flat. That is, if I flatten them before packing them away, when ready to use next time, they are very slightly out of flat. So I no longer flatten them after use, and instead do this before they are used the next time.

I have since epoxied my stones to 5mm glass plate (ala the glass stones), and (the lack of) movement is much better.

Feedback from the hard Shaptons is quite different from that from soft Kings. I prefer their directness.

The packaging of Shaptons (and Nortons) is excellent. They come in plastic cases, which protect them when stored, and may also be used as a holder in a pinch. A small but desirable feature.

I have owned Kings, used Nortons and also have a few natural stones. The Shaptons are excellent manmade stones. N atural stones are another story ..

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#14

Re: Shaptons

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I tried flooding the Shaptons, but to little effect. The soap sounds good, except I'd think it would diminish the sharpening effect in a small way, maybe not. Backing them with glass sounds like a good thing, but I'm in the process of trying natural water stones instead. Also, I don't seem to do all that well around glass, keeps breaking and cracking without provocation. :)

Pam

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#15

Blanchard Grinding works for us too

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>We have successfully used this cheap process for preparing cast iron plates for some time. The savings are substantial over surface grinding if a large batch of plates are prepared.

When I think how cheap plates could be fabricated I am astonished that no one offers them commercially. Someone in the club looked into domestic sources of blanks and even this route led to cheap, relative to alternative abrasives, plates.

Now days I only use one plate, charged with 1 micron. No water, no flattening maintenance, only one grit needed. I can understand why someone that had already made the investment in their stone suite would be ambivalent to changing, but for someone without this investment the diamond on cast iron alternative seems compelling.......especially for a machinist!

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#16

your diamond info is outdated

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>MFD is an especially poor substrate for using diamond abrasives. Most of the abrasive gets buried into the soft substrate where it remains unavailable. For many, a 5 g tube of paste will last a lifetime on a cast iron plate because it takes only a few milligrams of diamond to refresh the plate. Second, if the edge is hollow ground all one needs is 1 grit size. Given the issue of grit carry-over, it is compelling to only use one grit size for loose diamond sharpening.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#17

Re: Surface conditioning

Dean J in MN

>I have seen Larry Williams' recommendation to regularly condition oil stones with a diamond stone, to deglaze them, flatten them, and generally restore their bite. Do you do this or similar, and if so, with what

I too read what Larry had to say -- and it happened that I had a diamond stone from my waterstone days, so yes I do follow Larry's suggestion. Unlike what I have read Larry write, I don't do it every time I sharpen. I'm more likely to get the diamond stone out when I feel my stones are too glazed. I use lamp oil on my oil stones, seems to help keep them cutting longer than thicker oils.

The sharpening quest is interesting, I too am guilty of trying far too many methods. They all work, and all have trade-offs of some sort. After going in a big circle I'm back at oil stones. For brute force work I still have a piece of glass and sandpaper, but my day-in day-out sharpening is on a India followed by a translucent arkansas.

-Dean

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#18

question based in ignorance

Howard Pollack

>Hi- I'm totally ignorant of machining technique so I have a couple of questions. Are you saying that one could go to a machine shop, purchase a piece of cast iron and have it either Blanchard or surface ground, charge it with 1 micron (that grit in particular?) diamond paste (oil based?) and use it for all sharpening? That is both rough and fine work? If so, how does that work? Do you need to recharge the cast iron each time it is used? Does it ever get out of flat? (I'm tired of flattening waterstones) Thanks, in advance for your reply. -Howard

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#19

answer based on real world experiance

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>There is another option in all this what-stone-and how-to-flatten hype. Just don't flatten your water stones. I have a pair of water slip stones I bought from LV over 10 years ago that I use for the majority of my sharpening needs. In the entire time I have owned them I have flattened them once. Rather than rely on what someone wrote or said in a video I looked at how flattening the stones affected my sharpening and decided I didn't need to do it again. If you think I am out in left field on this why is Norton making and selling a crowned laping plate to hollow out water stones for sharpening plane irons.

Sorry to sound flipant but sharpening just dosen't need to be difficult and it isn't a zen thing. It is a way to maintain the edge on my tools and get me back to working. The little 4" long slip stones fit nicely in a tuperware sandwitch container in the top of my tool box so they are always wet and ready to use. I have always done side sharpening even before someone made a video of it, probably because my stones are 2" wide and that is the only way to put an edge on a 2" plane iron. One thing about only having small stones is that you tend to use the entire surface so it actualy stays flatter. It is also too small to use a blade holding fixture so you save some money there and once you develop the skill to freehand sharpen you save a whole bunch of time by not having to fiddle with a fixture.

Robin

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#20

answers

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Your questions have been covered in detail in previous posts on this topic. Search diamond on this Forum to find this information. To summarize a lot of discussion.....

Are you saying that one could go to a machine shop, purchase a piece of cast iron and have it either Blanchard or surface ground, charge it with 1 micron (that grit in particular?) diamond paste (oil based)( I use oil based with WD added?)) and use it for all sharpening? Yes, except go to the junk yard to purchase the cast iron.

If so, how does that work?

Why it works: The diamond particle embeds into the cast iron and renders it immobile. The tool moves across this immobile diamond particle. Diamond is the hardest stuff know to man and it is off scale tough. So it cuts aggressively and lasts a long time. This embedding is critical to performance and that is why cast iron is best. The embedding is optimum with cast iron. Also, tool steel slides nice on cast iron making hand held honing easier than some alternatives.

There are many variations in how to implement diamond paste sharpening. I hope Steve will join this discussion to tell what he may do different. I grind the tool edge with a 7" wheel. Depending, I may, or may not, then take a few strokes on a fine fixed diamond plate. Then I hone on the cast iron plate using 1 micron diamond. To renew the edge I may just do the 1 micron if the bevel is still small, or I may regrind if more metal needs to be removed than can be done quickly with 1 micron. My rule of thumb is that if the step taeks more than a minute I should have started with a coarser step. With experience you have a good idea where to start.

To give you an idea of how aggressive diamond is for grinding, with extended honing the 1 micron will grind away enough metal to remove the hollow grind.

Do you need to recharge the cast iron each time it is used? No

Does it ever get out of flat? Never. This technique is used to polish diamond stones and the cast iron laps last forever.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#21

Re: Surface conditioning

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I do not "condition" my Arkansas stones. When you abrade one of these stones, it temporarily cuts like a coarser stone. New stones also cut like coarser stones because of the scratches on them. I think that if you are going to jump from a fine India to a translucent stone or black stone it makes sense to abrade the stone so that it will more quickly smooth the scratches left by the India. You could get the same effect by using a soft Arkansas or other intermediate stone.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#22

confessing to training wheels

Bill Houghton, sunny in Sebastopol, CA

>I splurged some months back on the LV Mark II honing guide, and I must admit, I think my sharpening has improved on consistency as a result.

Does diamond sharpening affect the wheel on honing guides more than other methods?

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#23

Re: Pick-up truck, or Formula One?

ThomD

>Pick-up truck, or Formula One? Most of this discussion applies to sharpening for sharpenings sake. I have dozens of stones, and tried every new thing that came out, until I lost interest a few years back. A good starting point is looking at is how keen an edge one need. Sharper is always better, and shaving sharp is arguably necessary, beyond that it's a sub-hobby. The King 8000 will easily get you to a 3/10,000" shaving. That, by the way, is in the range of the surface grinder or 125K toolroom lathe. So I'm not too excited about the last 30 years of stone development. I hear a lot of stuff about hyper sharpening, but when people get off on hyper tool use it tends not to be the norm, so why bother. Does one need an 8000 stone to sharpen a chisel one will pry with.

Much faster sharpening would be a great thing. Sandpaper offers that, and Bill Tindall is in hot pursuit of faster diamond sharpening.

I have had bad results with DMT stones and stone flattening. At least to the extent I hoped the stones wouldn't wear out in a flash. I gave up on this part of any personal testing after burning up 3 stones. I haven't tried the more recent product on stones, though I use them for flattening. Diamonds are hard, but the bonding agent is only a few points harder that steel let alone stone swarf. Worth checking into anyway. Last time I looked they were R70ish.

One does need flat stones for hyper sharpening, but not so much for a more reasonable standard. Krenov mentioned, he had never flattened his stones at all. Old stones often show that pattern. I flatten stones, but if one is flattening with every use, or removing a lot of material, there is probably a technical fix that would obviate that need, or reduce it. With precious natural stones they are too expensive to waste in that fashion, A craftsman shouldn't dish out a stone radically anymore than they would distort a surface when planing it or sanding it. Consider that the objective is flattening the stone, not the tool, and the techniques required are obvious.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#24

using honing guides on cast iron

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Before I weaned myself of sharpening jigs, we were using multiple diamond grits. Carry-over on the guide wheel would have been a fatal issue. So, inspired by Steve, I extended the axle of the guide and put wheels on that extended past the width of the plate. I called it the "chariot guide". I used it for a while. Then I found that (1) it only takes a few strokes to complete honing and (2) the blade sucked down on the plate providing a secure tactile feel that all was in proper alignment. Honing on lubed cast iron is so different than on an India stone or some such. The edge sucks down on the plate and stays there in alignment.

To answer your question, I don't see any adverse issue with a jig so long as you use but one grit size of loose diamond. But I also predict that you will soon abandon the jig as something that becomes a nuisance rather than a helper.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#25

Yo Bill.

Virgil

>Give us the dimensions of what you think would be the ideal size cast iron block and the link to the diamond paste and I'll machine one out in the next week or so and report the results with the start up costs.

Thanks.