Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Waterstones for Dummies?

Posts

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#27

My 2 cents on diamond sharpening

Steve Elliott

>Bill has covered this topic so well I feel no compelling need to add more than very small change.

Most of my sharpening is done through precise grinding. I happen to use a Tormek but find it somewhat slow when grinding highly abrasion-resistant alloys. I've bought a coarse Norton 3X grinding wheel and have a new grinder setup under construction. It will include a better tool rest than I've seen available on the market.

My recently acquired gray cast iron lapping plates work significantly better than the ductile iron plate I've been using for the last five years or so. On the old one I used 3 micron diamond on one side and 1 micron or finer on the other side. Usually some quick honing with 1 micron was all that was necessary after grinding, and the edge produced was plenty good enough for all practical purposes and some impractical ones.

On my Japanese chisels (my absolute favorite chisels even though they're not the really expensive ones) I grind right to the edge and then spend about 20 seconds on a fine waterstone. I still like the combination of white steel and a waterstone.

I do have one slight disagreement regarding whether the lapping plate wears. After an extreme amount of use I noticed that the ductile iron plate had become slightly concave. I lapped it flat again using waterstones. For a while afterwards the edges it produced weren't quite as sharp as before but the sharpness level increased again before long. This happened while I was making obsessively precise measurements of edge sharpness, otherwise I might not have noticed.

While I appreciate that sharpening itself can be an interesting pastime, what I'm looking for is a quick way of producing edges to use at my job in a custom furniture shop. Learning to grind well has been the key to that.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#28

Would Ductile Iron Work?

Tom Colligan

>A local machine shop had a 6" square piece of ribbed ductile iron for me. But he was skeptical that ductile would be what I needed.

Would anyone know if this would work the same way normal cast iron would? Tia, Tom.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#29

Ductile is not as good

Steve Elliott

>I've been using a ductile iron lapping plate for a number of years, not knowing how it would compare to gray cast iron. A few months ago I started using the cast iron and it's much better. The diamond seems to embed more and the cutting action is more effective. With the cost involved in having the plate ground and the low cost of cast iron, I'd pass on the ductile iron.

Re: Waterstones for Dummies?

#30

poor choice

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>There is a reason that for the past several hundred years cast iron has been the material of choice. The structure of the cast iron is essential to embed the diamonds.