Re: research
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>BB
I believe that you make a strong argument for scraping. I have recognised this for some years now. Nevertheless I have had good results from sandpaper. I put this down to the technique and equipment I use.
My lapping surface is a 10mm thick sheet of glass 1m long and 400mm wide. It is glued to three sheets of 3/4" thick MDF, and all this rests on a flat surface (my bench or a tablesaw top).
I use spray contact adhesive for flattness when attaching sandpaper, and I always start with a too coarse grit so that as little lapping per grit is necessary. I change out paper as soon as it starts to wear. I also run the sandpaper over the whole length and width, and try and lap evenly over this area. (I have a memory of Steve Knight's lapping table, which was about 1m x 1m).
This is used for both metal and wooden planes.
I mark the plane sole and watch the wear pattern.
When pushing a plane on the lapping plate, 80% is downforce and 20% is forward and back. It is vital that the plane is held flat on the plate. I never use the tote or knob, since this might encourage a planing action, but push directly downwards on the frog area.
For small planes I have also had success using a stationary belt sander. Again, I only use fresh belts, spread the work over the surface and change the belts as soon as they wear.
Regards from Perth
Derek