Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

Posts

Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#1

Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

Dominic in Buck's County PA

>Which Sandpaper is better for sharpening, and for flattening soles of planes, and chisels? Alum Oxide or Silicon Carbide?

I was using the Aluminum Oxide but was wearing the 80 grit out pretty fast. I was wondering if I would get better performance from Silicon Carbide.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#2

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

Neal in San Jose

>Silicon Carbide is a sharp abrasive, but breaks down way too quickly for use as a sharpening agent. It is very good as sanding paint, etc, but since steel is a little harder than paint.... Stick with the aluminum oxide.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Sanding belts

Jim in Burlington On

>Those Zirconia coated belts usually blue or purple really last a long time. Cut fast also. I have some with the Norton 3x written on them. Don't confuse that with norton 3x norton sandpaper.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#4

cutting action

paul womack

>Which Sandpaper is better for sharpening, and for flattening soles of planes, and chisels?

Chisels are hardened tool steel; planes are (commonly) cast iron.

The best abrasives for each may be different.

Further, I do not consider "sheet abrasive" the best way to flatten plane soles.

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#5

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>In my experience sheet abrasive turned out to be a good way to make a plane sole convex.

Abrasive selection is covered in detail in my article in the Articles on sharpening with abrasive sheets in the Articles section. .

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#6

Re: agreed

Tony Zaffuto

>Bill & BB,

Can you expand a bit about sheet paper possibly causing a plane sole to go convex?

I've used sheet paper on plane soles without adverse effect, but I have to add that the paper was affixed to a granite plate with spray adhesive. I've also done the same task with loose Sc particles and have had soles surface ground (a particularly bad 5-1/2 and a Gage that I had brazed).

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#7

don't know

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I "flattened" a sole with 80 grit affixed to a jointer bed and it came out convex. It was corrected by surfacing grinder. Same thing happened to a friend. Probably faulty technique.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#8

Dom, I have to agree with BugBear

Parisian, VL

>If you aren't a believer yet, read some of the comments posted on his link. If you are going to try scrapping, read everything at least twice, to save yourself some false starts and frustration.

Victor in Houston

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#9

convexity

paul womack

>Can you expand a bit about sheet paper possibly causing a plane sole to go convex?

From my website (see previous post for link)

Non uniform abrasive wear and the build up of swarf tends to result in slower cutting in the middle of the abrasive. This results in convexity of the workpiece.

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#10

Re: convexity

Tony Z.

>Thanks Paul & BB. I have noted on plane blades swarf building ahead of the blade and it is for that reason that I abandoned Scary Sharp. I think this is more a matter of using the abrasive a bit longer than one should! I'm also wondering if since most sheets are 11" long and a lot of plane soles exceed that length, that you run the risk of dragging loosened particles or swarf back under the plane if you run off the sheet.

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#11

research

paul womack

>If you read the S&S procedure they use a VERY large area, and replace the sandpaper frequently, addressing the issues I mention, and getting good results.

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#12

steve knight

paul womack

>STeve Knight

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#13

Re: research

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>BB

I believe that you make a strong argument for scraping. I have recognised this for some years now. Nevertheless I have had good results from sandpaper. I put this down to the technique and equipment I use.

My lapping surface is a 10mm thick sheet of glass 1m long and 400mm wide. It is glued to three sheets of 3/4" thick MDF, and all this rests on a flat surface (my bench or a tablesaw top).

I use spray contact adhesive for flattness when attaching sandpaper, and I always start with a too coarse grit so that as little lapping per grit is necessary. I change out paper as soon as it starts to wear. I also run the sandpaper over the whole length and width, and try and lap evenly over this area. (I have a memory of Steve Knight's lapping table, which was about 1m x 1m).

This is used for both metal and wooden planes.

I mark the plane sole and watch the wear pattern.

When pushing a plane on the lapping plate, 80% is downforce and 20% is forward and back. It is vital that the plane is held flat on the plate. I never use the tote or knob, since this might encourage a planing action, but push directly downwards on the frog area.

For small planes I have also had success using a stationary belt sander. Again, I only use fresh belts, spread the work over the surface and change the belts as soon as they wear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#14

Re: agreed

ThomD

>I can remember in the 80s doing the paper thing, and improving a plane. At that time, some of the better factory planes had gross erors in the sole. Nowadays I see a lot less of that kind of thing. So part of the issue is what kind of improvement is being undertaken. If one is trying to move from good to great, then sandpaper is not an accurage method, anymore than hand sanding a surface is an accurate method. But from poor to good it might be OK.

In the bigger picture, if you need to remove gross faults then it would be a lot easier to send it out for surface grinding, and if the objective were to perfect the surface, surface grinding would also be indicated. Scraping works well but is really designed to produce better surfaces than we generally need, and require a fair amount of gear to do properly.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#15

Re: steve knight

Tony Z.

>Thanks for the link and it supports the feelings I have (too large of a plane for too small of a piece of paper!). Anyhow, I'm not returning to using sandpaper as a sole-flattening medium, as I've felt right along that it can be problematic, especially since I have a surface grinder large enough and machinists skilled enough to flatten any plane I have!

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#16

NOT scraping

paul womack

>I believe that you make a strong argument for scraping.

My argument is not for scraping. My argument (or "position") is that lapping is less reliable than is often stated, and that separating the "reference" process from the "metal cutting" process is a good thing.

My pages (I hoped :-( ) make it clear that scraping is (in practice) too slow a metal cutting process for the errors commonly found on plane soles.

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#17

surface grinder

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I took a plane that I had screwed up by sheet abrasive "flattening" (what seems to be a common novice endeavor) to a machine shop and in 30 min they had it surface ground to +/- 0.001". After this experience I no longer attempted to flatten anything but chisel backs. For those with something better to do then rub metal on abrasive the surface grinder is money well spent.

Tony, they grabbed the plane body in a huge vise fastened to the bed of the surface grinder ( vice like used on a milling machine). They put a tiny screw jack under each end of the plane sole and then they ground away. The set-up took as long as grinding.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#18

Re: surface grinder

Joel

>Nothing wrong with surface grinding but in my youth a machine shop screwed up 1/2 dozen planes because they clamped them in the surface grinder wrong and ground them unevenly.

So be careful out there.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#19

Re: surface grinder

Tony Z.

>Bill & Joel,

I employ several machinists and one would be qualified as a toolmaker(I have a machine & tool maintenance shop as support for my powder metal part mfg. business).

Anyhow, I would not recommend that just anyone who has or can start up a surface grinder can grind a plane sole. The one's I have had done were done similar to how Bill described it: clamped in a vise and jack screws at each loose end. The actual grinding is much quicker than the set-up and the wheel has to be the proper type for the cast.

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#20

Happened to me

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The machine shop that I brought my Stanley #8 to did not support the plane properly, resulting in a concave sole. I brought it back, showed them the concavity, and they re-did it, being careful to better support the middle of the plane. It came out just a hair convex (didn't measure it exactly), which I think is perfect.

DC

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#21

surface grinding

paul womack

> to a machine shop and in 30 min they had it surface ground to +/- 0.001". ... For those with something better to do then rub metal on abrasive the surface grinder is money well spent.

What was the cost?

BugBear

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#22

Re: Happened to me

ThomD

>I have always wanted a plane with longitudinal convexity. That would be ideal for flatening. transvers wouldn't thrill me though.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#23

Re: research

ThomD

>I've had pretty good luck flatening wooden planes with sandpaper. They tend to be faily stiff anyway. Good enough to get shavings int he 4 10s arena anyway. With wood there is so little sanding required.

One of the things about not scraping surfaces is that a lot of people not doing so probably don't have the gear, therefore they don't have the means of determining how close to some ideal their plane soles actually are. Practically this is not going to be a problem, but as far as researching various techniques it could be.

A couple of things about scraping to keep in mind are that they make power scrapers if the process isn't fast enough by hand. It's also possible whether for sanding, or scraping to relieve the sole with a die grinder so that the process takes less time and the contact points that really mater are taking the wear. I think Robert Meadows wrote an article on this in FWW in the early days.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#24

Re: surface grinding

Tony Z.

>The time it took my machinist to do a 5-1/2 was a bit longer than 30 minutes, probably closer to 60! The second plane was a 4-1/2 and it took maybe 45. I calculate shop rates for machining at a cost of roughly $45/hour.

I put a modern Ray Isles blade (O1 I beleive and definitely not D2) in the 5-1/2 (post WWII era plane) and it is every bit as good as a modern LN. The plane was bought from a well known used tool dealer and cost (IIRC) $125.00, and the condition is excellent. Total cost was worth it to me. The 4-1/2 is a Type 11 with the original blade. Sharpened up it performs great.

Would I recommend surface grinding? Probably not unless you have total confidence in the guy running the grinder knows what he says he know!

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#25

Re: surface grinding

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

I know you have a machine shop, so wanted to ask you...can a plane be held in most common jigs/fixtures/vises which would be present in a typical shop, or would it require some special setup?

Also, it seems that an old scraper would work for this most likely. I have a couple friends with older Atlas scrapers, those are certainly much easier than hand scraping. I do know some folks that have hand scraped ways on old lathes, and it is not a quick process. However, since hand planes are cast iron I imagine that would be easier to accomplish. I would love to have an old bench top scraper, but alas have no place to put one...I am literally out of space for old iron in the garage...both a surface grinder or scraper...:-/

This seems like one of those jobs that you are best off having done correctly, and ponying up to the bar to pay for it, or be prepared for what is needed. Typically trying to get friends to help you with something like this only works if they do surface grinding all the time, and have the equipment at hand.

Would be fun to do by hand, even if it took several hours, but only because this is a hobby for me. I somehow suspect a machinist wouldn't think it to be fun...;-)