Re: surface grinding
Tony Z.
>Alan,
Established machine shops would have more than sufficent fixtures and vises to do the job. What I would be fearful of is the warrior "who's knows a short-cut" or the guy who thinks he doesn't need to support the fore and aft of the plane sole with a machinist's jack (besides the use of the vise). All planes I had done had the frog out and it really didn't make any difference.
As far as the guy actually doing the work, well, my take on it is that he/she is paid for whatever they're paid to do and it makes no matter if it is a plane sole or a tooling punch. My guys like having a break from the normal routine.
Surface grinding is a viable sole flattening option, but only if you do your homework to determine the shop's capability (maybe I should say the machinist who is doing it).
I know nothing about scrapers, but since I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express once, so I bought a couple from MSC and played around with a no-name smoother. It's very easy to remove material and I found I could do a significant amount of damage before I would even know it.
Given that the majority percentage of our work is automotive, if things get any worse, we may have to change directions and go into hand tool making and refurbishments! Problem is for the time we would put into a old #4, when accounting for all costs, the old #4 work almost equals a new LN!
Have a good one!
T.Z.





