Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

Posts

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#26

Re: surface grinding

Tony Z.

>Alan,

Established machine shops would have more than sufficent fixtures and vises to do the job. What I would be fearful of is the warrior "who's knows a short-cut" or the guy who thinks he doesn't need to support the fore and aft of the plane sole with a machinist's jack (besides the use of the vise). All planes I had done had the frog out and it really didn't make any difference.

As far as the guy actually doing the work, well, my take on it is that he/she is paid for whatever they're paid to do and it makes no matter if it is a plane sole or a tooling punch. My guys like having a break from the normal routine.

Surface grinding is a viable sole flattening option, but only if you do your homework to determine the shop's capability (maybe I should say the machinist who is doing it).

I know nothing about scrapers, but since I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express once, so I bought a couple from MSC and played around with a no-name smoother. It's very easy to remove material and I found I could do a significant amount of damage before I would even know it.

Given that the majority percentage of our work is automotive, if things get any worse, we may have to change directions and go into hand tool making and refurbishments! Problem is for the time we would put into a old #4, when accounting for all costs, the old #4 work almost equals a new LN!

Have a good one!

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#27

Most folks would be better off buying a new LN...

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

I also figure you could get a bottom out of wack in quick time, due to the softness of the cast iron used on the old planes.

I have a horizontal mill which I could adapt a grinding wheel to if I wanted, but this is also another exercise in another time sink. I never let that stop me before though! :-)

Recently I ventured off to turn my own split-nuts out of bronze, slot bronze for the back, to make a tool I felt was superior quality than is available today. The time I have into the saw can not be justified, but I have a saw that is unique, and that was derived through my education of working metal. I'm sure that any modern saw maker would shun the idea of doing so without seeing some immediate profit, but for me it was not driven by profit, I have the luxury of making tools as a hobby.

In fact, it is the hobbyist toolmakers that impress me most.

When a professional toolmaker posts a pic of a beautiful tool, I expect that from them. While I admire any quality tool, it is more impressive to me to see a tool from a non-professional in the field of toolmaking. What exactly inspires people to do these things can't be justified by the professionals, but the satisfaction that comes with DIY is something that some of us have within us. :-)

I was pretty darn proud when I finished my hand saw made with bronze parts...I don't believe anyone else has such a hand saw, not that it matters to anyone else, it does to me. A professional saw maker could make one much easier, and most likely one that is more refined and much more professional looking.

I didn't let that stop me from doing it myself though. *wink*

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#28

Re: Most folks would be better off buying a new LN

Tony Zaffuto

>Alan,

I fully agree with what you are saying! I would not go to an independent machine shop to have a sole flattened, but only did it because I own the equipment!

This past summer I purchased a small lathe (9" X 20") and bench top mill for my home shop. I can think of dozens of little fixtures, tools, etc., through the years that I could have made, and now I can! These are Grizzly machines and are definitely not for production settings. The lathe is far better than I thought it would be and is a very accurate machine. The bench top mill is a disappointment. As a small, highly accurate drill press, it is fine and for milling brass and aluminum, it is OK.

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#29

Actually, some of those machines aren't bad...

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

If I had my own machine shop with machinists working in it, I would probably have every one of my planes flattened! :-) Not that they need it, I feel that it's a better investment to ensure the blade is sharpened squarely/sharply, as long as the sole of the plane sits on the wood without rocking.

Some of the Grizzly machines aren't too bad, with some time invested in cleaning the cosmoline off, setting them up, and calibrating them, you can have a decent machine that can do adequate work, as you point out.

I know some folks that do fabulous work on the 7x12 mini-lathe, and there are even toolmakers that use the 8689 style mini-mill with great success. I have one of the 8689 mills, and after a bit of cleanup, setup, calibration, it's not too bad...but I had to replace the plastic gear with an after market belt drive, and swap out the torsion arm with an air shock, both at an additional cost. Finally after that it is good for some light work, since the mill is just not rigid at all, chatters easily, and is difficult to operate due to the limited functionality of the hand wheels and table screw. Still, it is more accurate than my drill press, although limited to the work it can hold in comparison. It is a good value for simple toolmaking, and for brass and aluminum it is ok, as you say about your bench top. I suspect you have a better and/or slightly more rigid mill than the 8689, which is Grizzly's bottom of the line mill. As a friend often tells me..."they are what they are...".:-)

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#30

Re: Actually, some of those machines aren't bad...

Tony Zaffuto

>Alan,

I have the 8689 also. I damn near bought the 0619, but in a fit of stinginess I didn't go for the extra money. I've got to get rid of the plastic gears also (one of these days) and I agree with your assessment of the machine. Most of our sales go into the automotive market and if times ever get better, that little mill will be replaced. The lathe I have is the 4000 and it was worth every penny and more of what I paid for it. I originally was only going to get the mill, then it was the mill and the mini-lathe, then it was the bigger lathe. The major determining factor is weight of the machines. We have a 120 year old home and although there is outside access into the basement (where my shop is), the steps are very steep. I have plenty of equipment to load and unload equipment, but managing those stairs is always a treat.

Problem with doing things at my plant is that my guys' time is better spent making money than taking care of my stuff. I swear it costs me more because of the BS'ing I do with whoever is working on my stuff! Then I got to take the guys up to my home shop and you know the drill.

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#31

Ah, that explains...

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

That explains why the bench top mill was a disappointment! *lol*

But that belt drive option will help quite a bit, consider it, I think it was about $130 and well worth it. Really quieted up the machine quite a bit, less chatter, and I can do some very light milling of bronze on it now. But don't expect it to eliminate chatter, as my good friend tells me, "they are what they are". *g*

But I did use a carbide end mill to clean up the end of a piece of bronze stock, which I used for my handsaw back. I did it on very high speed, with a very light cut. Took about 3 or 4 very light cuts to accomplish the task. I don't know about slotting on the mini-mill with bronze, might be able to be done with many passes. I just looked up the 4000, that looks like quite a bit better than the mini-lathe, which also has plastic gears, but I don't believe the 4000 has plastic gears. It reminds me of the Unimat 10, which is a decent little lathe.

The combination of the mini-mill and 4000 lathe is not a bad little setup for toolmaking, IMO. I have a South Bend 9A from the 40s. I'm very happy with it, need to spend more time on it though...I picked up a vertical head for my Nichols mill, and need to turn a ring adapter to attach it. My Nichols didn't have the ring adapter, it's an older mill from the 40s. I like that old '40s machinery...:-)

I think the Nichols is more suitable for doing infill planes also, like cutting the dovetails. Much better than a vertical mill.

I've been wanting to forge up some pattern welded steel to make a small plane and/or chisels out of. Saw this one that Wayne Anderson did recently...very nice!


With the chisels I was thinking of a mortise chisel, that had a piece of A2 laminated on the bottom for the edge, that would be an awesome chisel, IMO. :-) I have some 1080 that I was thinking about laminating up with a friend, that might work well for a chisel with some other steel in between, and a thin slice of A2 laminated for the edge, similar to this but with more pattern:


Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#32

Re: Ah, that explains...

Tony Zaffuto

>No plastic in the 4000. Very decent for the price and after I get a few more months with it (just got it in June), to make sure the motor doesn't catch fire or something similar happens, I would recommend it.

Now that mini-mill is something that I would not recommend. I was intriquedby the ad copy and at the Muncy Grizzly store, I was "snowed" by this older guy (older than my 56 years)who claimed to be a retired tool maker from the areospace industry and who at least talked a good story. He pointed to the dovetail column of the mini-mill and said that added plenty of rigidity to do mild steel. With the size quill and #3 MT, I thought the little guy would do what I wanted--alum., some brass and a bit of light steel. Funny thing was I was more concerned that the lathe wouldn't do what I wanted, and it is far better! I got a catalog from "Little Machine Shop" that has the belt drive conversion, but I still may hold off until next year and go for a larger mill. Maybe I ought to just convince my Wife to build or buy a new place, with better basement access. Then I can move in some of the vintage iron I have in storage out at my plant: nice Bridgeport with 36" table just perfect for a home shop, little surface grinder (can't remember the name, oldie, but American made goodie) plus tons of other stuff I've taken out of service but haven't gotten around to disposing of--dollars you would get don't warrant the effort.

T.Z.

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#33

1/2 Bu apples and some brownies

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>

Re: Alum Ox or Silcon Carb for sharpening?

#34

Re: Ah, that explains...

Alan DuBoff

>Tony,

Like my good friend tells me..."they are what they are". :-)

You should think about the belt drive kit, I got mine from the Little Machine Shop, it does help...just that it will not make the little machine any more rigid...there are professional toolmakers that do fabulous work with those, one that makes some much more beautiful saws that I do...

But personally, speaking for myself, I find using inferior machines to be an unpleasing experience. That's where the Nichols came in...it is a real mill by all counts...

Regards,

Alan (just back from a beautiful weekend, even nab'd some 1000 year old redwood that a friend chainsaw'd off for me...)