Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Overdue Review...

Posts

Re: Overdue Review...

#26

Re: Gorman's site

MikeW

>Hi Pam,

I think it is important to note that Jeff is describing marking knife use in relation to marking faces/edges in regards to say lap joints and tenons. Not DTs.

You wrote:

"Contrary to what Dunbar says in PopWW, you place the bevel against the straight edge, not the flat. This provides a cut a bit closer to the straight edge, but mainly tracks the edge better. According to Jeff Gorman."

He does advocate the use of the bevel against the ruler, but not for the line to be closer to the ruler per se, but rather the tracking issue. "Closer" being the by-product of not straying. I have never had a problem with a knife straying from a ruler due to the flat side of a knife being against the ruler. He evidently has and obviously has less of an issue with the bevel against the ruler.

I also think there is a difference in which knife I use when striking lap and or tenon lines versus pins or tails. I use a skinnier knife for DTs or thin box joints and a heavier, broader knife for laps/tenons or other surface marking.

As regards my Japanese knives, I don't think Jeff would like them for general marking out. The tips are long and skinny and one *cannot* use them like the broad-tipped knives he shows. No bevel against the ruler for them.

Personally I think that Jeff's main point within the series of mini articles was that the bruising of the knife line should go into the waste side of the joint. Something I thought was a universal understanding regarding knifing a line.

Take care, Mike

Re: Overdue Review...

#27

Re: Gorman's site

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Dunbar's article got me thinking about this, then Rob & Derek started this thread, which prompted me to go back to Gorman. All I can say is that I honestly value your experience; but my experience is that placing the bevel next to the straight edge, of any sort for any joint, seems to give me a cleaner cut. But there are a lot of variables in this process, so maybe it's not only due to how I hold the knife.

On the Japanese knives, I haven't actually used any, bought several when they hit ebay for $5 per, but they're still sitting in their plastic.

Pam

Re: Overdue Review...

#28

Re: Gorman's site

MikeW

>And I your experience.

I think you nailed it when you wrote: "my experience is that placing the bevel next to the straight edge, of any sort for any joint, seems to give me a cleaner cut." As in so many things, consistent personal victory in a wodworking task trumps "common" knowledge.

And I am going to give it a renewed effort. I look at it like using a Japanese saw or a push saw of the so-called gent's saw variety. For years I would twist my hand using any type of "straight" handled saws. A few years ago I tried again and any problems I had were gone. It was night and day difference. So much so that I wondered if I had really a problem using a straight-handled saw years back.

I don't think the Japanese knives I own with the long, thin point are well suited to using the bevel against the straight edge. So I'll give it a whirl with one of the broader ones I own.

Take care, Mike

Re: Overdue Review...

#29

laying out *LINK*

joel

>The way to use any marking knife is to put the knife at the mark and slide the rule into it. That way as long as the knife leans against the rule somehow you are consistent and all will be well. with a bevel towards the rule it's more comfortable to ensure that the knife is bearing against the rule vertically or leaning over the rule. you don't want the knife to be only touching the rule at the wood surface because it's easy to cut into the rule and you have no bearing edge at all to guide the knife and you can easily undercut the intended line.

With a flat side at the rule the entire knife has the lean over the rule which is less ergonomic than having it the other way around and it's very easy to tilt the knife the wrong way and only have contact at the bottom.

The only exception I can think of to this practice is with extremely thin pins where there is no clearance to tip the knife over. but that's a special case that calls for a different making tool than is usually used.

You might also want to look at my current blog entry on the advantage of a slightly dull marker.

ps - I am not sure if this most makes any sense without diagrams - or better writing


blog

Re: Overdue Review...

#30

Re: laying out --fixed blog linky *LINK*

MikeW

>Try this link...yours had a '/' where a '.' belonged...


Joel's blog entry

Re: Overdue Review...

#31

Re: laying out --fixed blog linky *LINK*

MikeW

>Argh...

missing a 'p' in there too...


Maybe this time...

Re: Overdue Review...

#32

Re: laying out --fixed blog linky

MikeW

>I really wish we could edit our own dang posts instead of adding another...

Mike

Re: Overdue Review...

#33

Re: Gorman's site

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Those knives with the long, thin points may not be marking knives at all, maybe they're trimming/carving knives.

For some reason I took to straight handled saws (one LN as well as the Japanese) like a duck to water, probably something simple about them.

I'd love to have another conversation about this after you've had a chance to try things out again.

Pam

Re: Overdue Review...

#34

Re: laying out

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Pretty cool blog entry, Joel. I've always wondered why I never need to sharpen awls. :)

Pam

Re: Overdue Review...

#35

Re: What I understand ...

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Sorry to have killed the fun. I admit I shouldn't have said "right way." I was trying to join in on the fun and cheer up Todd (I know, he wasn't serious). I do think that the bevel to straight edge is a better way for me.

Pam

Re: Overdue Review...

#36

Re: Gorman's site

MikeW

>Will do Pam.

I got to mulling this over down at the bench and was pleased to see your message. Joel's blog about the awl combined with wanting to give a proper go with the bevel against the ruler made me remember something.

It came to me that I use a birdcage awl for marking lines a lot of times when I am also marking hole locations. One tool to do both sort of thing. Due to the square tapered tip, it is akin to a bevel against a ruler (as is a round-tipped awl is as well). And I do use round-tipped awls for long-grain marking (actually it is a striking knife with an awl at one end and a wider knife blade on the other).

The Japanese knives. Yes, they really are not marking knives which is why I now try to avoid combining those two words directly together as in "marking knife." I try to write that I simply use them to mark with.

Take care, Mike

back to packing...

Re: Overdue Review...

#37

Re: cutting action

Alan DuBoff

>Paul,

You know, for me it's not rocket science in getting the perfect kerf from my marking knife. I use the same utility knife to cut leather when needed, and the tip has been rounded to give a clean cut in wood.

As I have said, I have used a good 'ol No. 2 pencil, it works.

Maybe one day I'll get a better marking knife, like a fancy Japanese knife that sells for several hundred dollars...*g* better yet do as Derek has done and make my own...

Nothing like using a tool one has made for themselves. :-)

Re: Overdue Review...

#38

Re: What I understand ...

Alan DuBoff

>Derek said:

"Anyway, I do not believe that there is such a thing as the the right side of a marking knife"

I agree with you on that. It is not that important that I have such accuracy when working with wood, my utility knife works most of the time. I have several awls, a small Japanese one I bought at Hardwicks when I was in Seattle, I think it cost about $4, it is also used for some marking.

Like you, I enjoy making my own tools, when I can. And understanding the online dilemma where people talk about woodworking more than they do it, I try to get myself into the shop and do some work whenever possible. Even if that means using my trusty utility knife...I've seen Rob Cosman using an even older Stanley utility knife, and he does some fine work with it. There is no right or wrong way...and as I have said, a No. 2 pencil will work just dandy, and has for me in the past. Certainly nothing wrong with having a nice marking knife, don't get me wrong. It's just not a priority unless I make one for myself. :-)

Nice looking set of marking tools, that bevel does look nice, and I like how it has the thumb screw on the bottom like the old Stanley No. 18 I use. What other types of tools does Vesper make? I'll have to Google, maybe he has a web site.

Re: Overdue Review...

#39

cutting action

paul womack

>You know, for me it's not rocket science in getting the perfect kerf from my marking knife.

Sorry - are you using a marking knife or a Stanley knife?

BugBear

Re: Overdue Review...

#40

Re: cutting action

Alan DuBoff

>Paul wrote:

"Sorry - are you using a marking knife or a Stanley knife?"

Both plus awls. I have several blades with a flat back, double bevel, which Johnny Kleso made, one has a handle I made.

I have about 3 awls.

I have a lot of No. 2 pencils.

I have my trusty Stanley 10-049 that I use most of the time as it works the best for the majority of my needs, including shaping m&t pins, cutting leather, and other uses. The tip has been rounded, and I sharpen it on a stone. My apologies if I confused you with my reference to marking knife in regards to the utility knife, but that is one of the ways I use it. Let me post a pic, so you know exactly what I use, it is probably best to call it a Stanley 10-049, rather than anything else. :-)

(this blade mics out to about .040" thick, and about 1 3/4" long)


You can buy them in the U.S. for about $12, and the blades are about $3 sold separately. I have ground the top to a round end profile so it slices wood grain nicely (and leather;-)


I have about 4 of these with a flat back, but don't like them as they are too thick and too pointy.


I could certainly get a nice marking knife from Dave Jeske or similar, but the Stanley 10-049 serves my purpose just fine.:-)

Also, of all the awls I have (maybe 4 or 5), this one works the best, but I got mine from Hardwicks up in Seattle.

(I only have the small mini-size)


HTH clear things up, but ultimately it doesn't matter what is the right tool, or what could work better. Of all my tools the Stanley 10-049 is the one I reach for most of the time. :-)

Re: Overdue Review...

#41

cutting action

paul womack

>I have my trusty Stanley 10-049 that I use most of the time as it works the best for the majority of my needs,

How do you address the (small) symmetric 'V' cut issues I described?

BugBear

Re: Overdue Review...

#42

Re: cutting action

Alan DuBoff

>Paul wrote:

"How do you address the (small) symmetric 'V' cut issues I described?"

I don't. I'm a worse craftsman for it, but I don't let it stop me doing doing work. For the most part it is a problem that does not exist for me, since I don't pay any attention to it.

Re: Overdue Review...

#43

Re: cutting action

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Paul,

If you use only the point of the blade, the angles don't come into play.

Marv

Re: Overdue Review...

#44

Thanks Pam, I'd lost that link. Great reading

Parisian, VL

>