Re: Gorman's site
MikeW
>Hi Pam,
I think it is important to note that Jeff is describing marking knife use in relation to marking faces/edges in regards to say lap joints and tenons. Not DTs.
You wrote:
"Contrary to what Dunbar says in PopWW, you place the bevel against the straight edge, not the flat. This provides a cut a bit closer to the straight edge, but mainly tracks the edge better. According to Jeff Gorman."
He does advocate the use of the bevel against the ruler, but not for the line to be closer to the ruler per se, but rather the tracking issue. "Closer" being the by-product of not straying. I have never had a problem with a knife straying from a ruler due to the flat side of a knife being against the ruler. He evidently has and obviously has less of an issue with the bevel against the ruler.
I also think there is a difference in which knife I use when striking lap and or tenon lines versus pins or tails. I use a skinnier knife for DTs or thin box joints and a heavier, broader knife for laps/tenons or other surface marking.
As regards my Japanese knives, I don't think Jeff would like them for general marking out. The tips are long and skinny and one *cannot* use them like the broad-tipped knives he shows. No bevel against the ruler for them.
Personally I think that Jeff's main point within the series of mini articles was that the bruising of the knife line should go into the waste side of the joint. Something I thought was a universal understanding regarding knifing a line.
Take care, Mike







