Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

18th century tool chests

Posts

Re: 18th century tool chests

#26

Re: Who owns the hand tools?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

>The last time I worked in a patternshop other than my own was in the late 90's. It was in our union contract that the shop was to provide all power tools including powered hand held power tools and we were to provide all hand tools. The shop was responsible for insuring our tools. It was not required that we have any particular type of tool box but tradition is a powerful thing. In some ways your toolbox was your resume. It as well as the contents is what made a first impression on others and it was common for the owner or lead guy to come over and inspect your tools when you first started at a new shop.

Robin

Re: 18th century tool chests

#27

Re: Were independent saw tills used ?

joel

>When you bought lumber for furniture in the last centuries you would buy it dimensioned but not planed - the sawyers would saw out stock for drawer sides, legs, etc. And since it was hand sawn the quality of the surface was descent if not finished. They also bought stable stock so when it was dry all it needed was mostly a quick planing. The idea that you would have to mill lots of wood to thickness or cut to width tons of material to start of project just didn't happen.

One man shops could buy pre-dimensioned wood from a lumberyard.

Anyway what that means is that your average cabinetmaker didn't need those big hands saws much. (the Phyfe chest has no large saws or planes in the chest - although the rest of his shop probably had them.) The Seaton chest does but if the theory that Season was planning to set up a new shop elsewhere he would have needed one of everything - even if the larger saws wouldn't get used as much once the shop was set up. Also a country cabinetmaker would be more of a generalist than a city cabinetmaker.

Joiners on the other hand - and carpenters framing houses - they needed big saws all the time but the latter worked on job-sites, the former pre-work in the shop then on job sites.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#28

I was going to let this pass, but

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have been in a bunch of shops that make furniture for a living-reproduction, modern, etc. These are family or one person shops where defending one's tools is not an issue and the workers "own" their bench space.. These shops use planes and chisels and marking gauges and band saws too. I have never seen anyone working out of a box. Again, I don't see what about these modern shops would result in a different tool storage arrangement from a similar staffed shop long ago. If indeed a one person, or family, shop typically worked out of a box in 1750 why did this method fall out of fashion? I scanned the records of the cabinet shops of Chester County, PA 1682 to 1850 and saw no mention of tool chests in the shop inventories( I could have missed an occasional entry so I can't claim there were none). Most of these inventories are detailed. And most of these shops were at most a family staffed shop most comparable to the modern boxless shops I visit.

I do see the motivation to box one's tools in a factory shop, but it is not efficiency. It is lack of real estate you own and can easily defend outside the box.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#29

Re: I was going to let this pass, but

Larry Williams

>Just one reference that comes to mind. From the April 5th, 1755 issue of Gentleman's Magazine:

"A fire broke out at the Workshop of Mr. Chippendale, a cabinet maker near St. Martin's Lane, which consumed the same, wherein were the chests of 22 workmen."

Re: 18th century tool chests

#30

I agree

Adam Cherubini

>You use a chest because you need to have your stuff stored away. If it's your own shop, a shelf might do just as well. I certainly do this in my shop. I do like the chest for storing smaller items. When i built my chest one of the issues was preventing my toddlers from trying to play Daddy with a draw knife. So in my case, safeguarding my tools in my own home was indeed a concern. I don't think this was common in the 18th c.

But I don't agree that they are inferior in any way as a means of storage. I recall reading (was it Tolpin?) traditional toolchests were difficult to work out of and that things needed to be removed to access other things. That makes logical sense and when one looks at the chests stuffed to the gills at the Mercer Museum, that notion is reinforced. But it's not been my experience actually using a chest however.

One does see these things in period images. I find it remarkable how similar the 19th c chests are too.

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#31

Too many tools

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>When I look through Fine Woodworking mags from the 1980s I'm always a bit surprised how tools, albeit power tools, seem to be priced less now for the most part without accounting for inflation. We live in a consumer society and I believe many are like me. I have too many tools, I've bought stuff I never use and never will, I have many duplicates of varying quality. It seems to me that up until the second half of the 20th century craftsmen did not suffer from this excess of tools. Am I right? Those of you that have reviewed tool inventories, do you see unnecessary tools such as I would be guilty of? If your tool selection is more thoughtful and useful I would doubt that a tool chest would be as difficult to use as it would be for me. I have a feeling that building a tool chest would cause me to do more serious thinking on what I own and the lot would be rationalized considerably.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#32

Re: Too many tools

Adam Cherubini

>Inventories I've looked are are usually not specific enough to answer your question. You might see 3 long saws. Are they all 5 ppi rip saws? A listing of 12 chisels could be 6, 1/2" chisels, 4, 3/4" chisels, and 2, 1" chisels. So it's possible they had redundancies. Possible, but I doubt it.

Now they may have had tools they used infrequently- specialty planes for example. I don't find my side rabbets very helpful. And thought they work well, I've haven't had much use for my snipe bills. My 7/8" dado sees little action. But these tools don't take up much space.

Personally, I have way too many tools. I've got more saws and more augers of differing types than any 15 woodworkers should have. I have several hundred Sheffield brace bits. I believe they have started a colony and are multiplying. Any day now I expect to receive their terms for my unconditional surrender.

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#33

Re: Too many tools

Bob Demers

>Quote I have a feeling that building a tool chest would cause me to do more serious thinking on what I own and the lot would be rationalized considerably. Unquote

To me it has the opposite effect. Everytime I sit down to draw up my ideal tool storage brain schemes, I end up thimking that Oh yeah, need to leave room for that one and this one that I dont have yet, and then Rob keep adding fuel to my fire and and....Its a loosing battle. I have long ago surrendered to the umpteen tool colonies which unbeknown to me have been breeding around all the dark recess of my shop.

Results: today I have tool scattered all over the places, somewhat organized by function, which tend to gravitate in small piles near wherever I last worked, and then unable to find where I last seen the one I need now, or cant remembered if I own one, I go out and buy a duplicate/triplicate/quadruplate...

Im doomed!!! Oh the humanity of it all.....`-)

Bob, somewhat tongue in cheek

Re: 18th century tool chests

#34

Re: I was going to let this pass, but

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Bill I don't think a shop inventory would include any journeyman owned tools or chests.

JR

Re: 18th century tool chests

#35

Re: Too many tools

Joel

>My toolbox only contains tools I actually use on a regular basis. I just don't want to constantly have to pick through tools that aren't used much. And I don't both sharpening stuff I don't use. For secondary tools that use occasionally like a moving fillester plane I keep them off to the side in a big closet so they don't get in my way but are accessible when I need it.