Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

18th century tool chests

Posts

18th century tool chests

#1

18th century tool chests

Jerome B.

>And I am confused about tool chests. Neither the hay cabinet shop or the picture of the Dominy shop seem to make use of a tool chest. Is this accurate?

I always thought that each cabinetmaker had his own tool chest, sort of like a modern car mechanic who works in a car repair shop. He would use his tools and at the end of the day he would put the bulk of his tools away.

Although I don't have a tool chest, that is what I try to do. Otherwise the chaos drives me crazy.

If cabinetmakers at the time didn't use their tool chest very often, then did many have them? And if they did how did they use them?

Thanks,

Jerome

Re: 18th century tool chests

#2

Re: 18th century tool chests

Roderick Drumgoole

>Jerome,

I wresteled with the same question a few years back when I constructed my tool chest. The conclusions I came to were that I didn't want to house everything in the tool chest (in my case, it would be rather large), particularly those "most used" tools. For me, since I work primarily with only hand tools...that would mean, everything is hung on the wall. In the end, I compromised and hung the larger tools (saws, braces, straight edges, hammers, etc.) on the wall; the smaller tools - specifically those tools prone to rusting easily (chisels, layout tools, a few metal planes) went into the tool box. All of the bench planes (mostly wooden) went under the bench while the remaining molding planes went onto a shelf.

I believe that there have been a few posts posted in the past on the subject, which I drew some of my conclusions a few years back. Certainly, my response isn't the only answer while many others are more qualified to answer the response on the historical accuracy of how it was done in the 18th century.

Roderick

Re: 18th century tool chests

#3

Re: 18th century tool chests

joel

>They did. The Seaton Chest and the Duncan Phyfe chest survive from this period. I assume others did too.

On of the primary reasons tool boxes don't survive in the workshop is that the tools belong to the craftsman and when they leave the workshop, the tool box goes with them.

I know of at least one case (a machine shop) where the shop survived and 100 years later the tool box that was in the shop was found separately and reunited for an exhibit.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#4

Re: 18th century tool chests

James Watriss

>I've seen pictures of old shops where everything was simply hung on the wall, to the point where the entire wall was covered. I imagine there are still some tools that are kept in the tool chest, particularly when security is an issue.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#5

period tool storage

Adam Cherubini

>Both the (modern) Hay shop and the Dominy shop have tool chests. Master craftsmen, working by themselves or with an apprentice, and on their own property, had little need for tool chests. They would have done as many of us do today, store tools on walls, open shelves, or wherever convenient. This was the situation in the Dominy shop.

The folks who needed toolchests were journeymen, who worked in their masters' shops, possibly with other journeymen. They needed a way to transport and store their tools. They also needed to safeguard their tools from strangers and shop mates alike. And I see this as exactly like modern automotive repair shop that I am familiar with. The owner's tools hang over his bench or are stored hastily in chests and boxes. His collection is now far too extensive to fit in the toolchest he used in his younger days.

18th c tool chests weren't not designed for easy transportation. They were very heavy and surely required a helping hand to lift or move. Journey men probably didn't get their name from their "journeys". They were day laborers, and probably got their name from that status. Journey probably came from the French "journee" meaning day or daily. My guess is that this provides a clue about the origins of "Strike block". The English were great adopters and corrupters of foreign words. My guess would be that "strike" was not an English word or at least wasn't the English word "strike".

English Carpenters and joiners alike seemed to transport tools to jobsites in woven grass or "bass" bags. These can be seen in some of the period paintings of 19th c joineries in Jay Gaynor's books. Bass bags were used by joiners and carpenters well into the 20th century.

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#6

why would 18th century be different than today?

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Other than the addition of some power tools I can't see why a modern shop doing reproduction work for profit would be any different than a shop in 1750(unless OSHA was hounding them!). The tools are going to be where they can be accessed readily, and that's not in a box. I just spent a week in the Headley shop and things like gauges, chisels and planes were within easy reach of the bench, DUH! Jigs were hung about the walls. Chisels and rasps in a rack beside the bench. Marking gauges and the like in the bench drawer. Other stuff on shelves. But all of it nearby and within reach. I find that in today's professional shops that no time is spent doing stuff that doesn't make money and I suspect it was not different then. A tool box built is a piece of furniture not made, today or then.

A person working remote on jobs would be a different case. I would suppose that the people that did work on buildings would need some container for their tools just as is the case today. .

Re: 18th century tool chests

#7

Re: period tool storage

Jerome B.

>Okay, I was with you until you went to the strike block concept. Can you clear that up a bit?

Thanks,

Jerome

"18th c tool chests weren't not designed for easy transportation. They were very heavy and surely required a helping hand to lift or move. Journey men probably didn't get their name from their "journeys". They were day laborers, and probably got their name from that status. Journey probably came from the French "journee" meaning day or daily. My guess is that this provides a clue about the origins of "Strike block". The English were great adopters and corrupters of foreign words. My guess would be that "strike" was not an English word or at least wasn't the English word "strike". "

Re: 18th century tool chests

#8

Re: period tool storage

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I have to agree about the strike block. The fact that period terms straight block and strike block were used contemporaneously suggests that the terms had no literal meaning to the users at that time. Like the "english horn" (not English, not a horn), they could have been substituting English words that sounded like a foreign name for this tool.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#9

Re: why would 18th century be different than today

joel

>Actually a box is super convinent - far more so than having the tools in the bench or on a wall. The reason is in a good tool box with sliding tills EVERY tool is accessible right at the foot of your bench with only one hand. So you can easily pick out or put back more than one tool with one hand using the other hand to carry and hold. No need to loose the space for holdfasts under the bench or have drawers blocked by work, and no need to walk across the room to a cabinet or have to move something so that you can open the cabinet doors. Not to mention a chest keeps the dust on the tools down.

Also in a real 19th or 19th cnetury shop the workbench would be in front of a window so there would not be convineint wall space for wall cabinet.

Not to mention it's a handy seat for lunch and other sitting activities.

that all being said I think but am not sure that a box is an English / UK tradition but on the continent wall cabinets were used.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#10

You got that right...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>'Also in a real 19th or 19th cnetury shop the workbench would be in front of a window so there would not be convineint wall space for wall cabinet. '

Except you misspelled century and convenient, sorry, but the placement of the bench directly in front of the window was an absolute necessity for available light. No switches to flip on a convenient light. But a mirror and a whitewashed interior would help with illumination.

Stephen

Re: 18th century tool chests

#11

Re: period tool storage

Adam Cherubini

>There are a great number of words- well "journeyman" is probably one. It's spelled like an English word and pronounced that way. But it is actually corruption of a French word and has nothing to do with our word "journey". "Popinjay" is an old English language word. Folks used to call someone "showy" a popinjay. It's a corruption of the French word for parrot. "Firmer" chisel is probably another example, but I'm not 100% sure of it's derivation. I think there are many many others.

Scrutore (esctritoire) is certainly a common early 18th c word. A lot of this has to do with never having seen the word written correctly. Guys just spelled stuff the way they heard it. And if the word was a foreign word, it got butchered.

My experience with my English friends and family is that they butcher foreign words on purpose. I think despite what we were taught, France is the economic and culturally dominant force is Western Europe, or at least it was for the last 500 years, I suspect the British defend themselves culturally by refusing to say foreign words correctly. In fact, I had a similar experience with my name in Texas! They called me "chair BOONEY". Hey! You wanna them there EYE Talians ain't ya!

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#12

Re: 18th century tool chests

Dave Anderson NH

>You have already received a number of good answers, all true, and all showing that there were a variety of situations. The Hay shop did have tool chests. Cabinetmakers upon completion of an apprenticeship did have tool boxes which they used as they became jorneymen and often traveled looking for a job. These chests are heavy when loaded and not easily portable. They were most often used as secure storage to prevent damage and/or theft. The wall hanging of tools in small shops of 1-4 people was not usually a risk, but in the large shops like that of Thomas Chippendale with about 20 employees everything was secured at the end of the workday. Remember that many apprenticeship contracts specified that the master was responsible for providing a full set of tools and a good suit of clothes upon reaching journeyman status. This almost certainly included allowing and or helping the apprentice build a tool chest.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#13

Re: 18th century tool chests

Dean J in MN

>I built a chest a few years ago to answer your very question. I wasn't sure I'd like working out of a chest, but, after some time I have grown to like it.

My saws hang on pegs on the shop wall, and my chest is within arms reach of my bench. My chest has three sliding drawers and plenty of room for my bench and molding/joint planes.

I find my work progresses in stages so I have only the tools needed for that portion of the work out and about. Stock prep I have my fore/try on the bench, dovetail work sees the needed chisels out, but the planes are nesting in the bottom of their little home. Gauges tend to live on my bench for the course of a workday, but end up back home each night. My chest "self organized" to have the most common tools at my fingertips, the least used are in harder to get to areas.

Of course, I have no idea how my work habits relate to the 18th C workers. But I have to guess in some ways we still solve problems the same way (same brain, same problem, same solution hypothesis).

-Dean

Re: 18th century tool chests

#14

Tool accessibility

Adam Cherubini

>Never saw a great method for saw storage. The Seaton chest's saw till looks it it wants to be unpacked and repacked as infrequently as possible. Indeed, I think these chests didn't provide great accessibility for the larger "bench tools" such as saw, larger planes, squares etc. I agree that they excel at storing smaller tools and less oft used molding and fitting planes.

There are several chests, not terribly different from the Seaton chest or Duncan Pyfe chest on display at the Mercer Museum. Though the Seaton chest was made in the 18th c, I think it exhibits very typical 19th c features with it's "chest of drawers" till. True 18th c chests were probably lower, longer and with a single till. I think my chest is a bit too nicely organized to be typical of the 18th c. I would expect to find fewer matching sets of tools in an 18th c chest.

I think I read long ago that period chests were inconvenient to work out of. I'd like to add my voice to those here with actual experience working out of these chests. They are NOT inconvenient to work out of. But I suspect some tools were brought out each morning or remained out to improve accessibility. It's also interesting to note that in the 2 period images of joiner's shops, the chests are depicted closed. I've found this to be a smart move. My tools certainly stay cleaner, and I think rust less when stored in my box with the lid closed.

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#15

Re: Tool accessibility *LINK*

Joel

>You are probably right about the saws. Phyfe's chest only has accessible space for smaller joinery saws. and while most chests I have seen have fairly common till design and plane storage saw till design seems all over the map - suggesting there is no obvious best way.

On my tool box I have space for the two main saws and two more saws but I really need to figure out how to squeeze 2 carcase saws and a dovetail saw on the lid.


My Tool Box part 1

Re: 18th century tool chests

#16

Re: period tool storage

ThomD

>"My experience with my English friends and family is that they butcher foreign words on purpose. I think despite what we were taught, France is the economic and culturally dominant force is Western Europe, or at least it was for the last 500 years, I suspect the British defend themselves culturally by refusing to say foreign words correctly."

They were a little late at that task given the invasion. It was only normal that certain words would undergo a change and become localized. Certainly it was normal to not use foreign pronunciations for words in England when I was a kid. We have Paris, not Pahree. I think the English versions are more in line with the abilities of the English mouth, and I don't feel any need to present a fluency in French that I have as a bilingual person, when I am not engaged in speaking the second language. One could as well say there is confidence in that as the lack of it. I see people in white shoes, on jets, with phrasebooks when I hear foreign words attempted throughout normal speech.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#17

Re: 18th century tool chests

Bob Demers

>The tool box book by Jim Toplin has a good write up on the history and evolution of tool storage.

As needs changed, so did the toolbox.

The various tool storage strategies are explored and discussed along with a variety of build ideas, although no complete plans per se, there is enough information in order to be able to built yourself a decent tool storage apparatus.

It is akind to CS book on the workbench. History and form are discussed along with plenty of examples. Although more than eye candy, it contains serious drooling illustrations :-)

Bob, who has been struggling with tools storage for years, so many tools and so little time....

Re: 18th century tool chests

#18

Re: why would 18th century be different than today

Charles

>Agree. Working serially and logically through a project going to the box is not inconvenient at all.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#19

Who owns the hand tools?

John in NM

>At the Headley's shop? The couple shops I worked for, the hand tools hanging around your bench, such as they were, belonged to the shop, just like the power tools. We could provide our own tools if we wanted, but why? On the rare occaision that I did bring my own tools, I made sure to bring ones that I didn't mind loosing, or to take them home at the end of the day - just prudence, I didn't really expect one of the other guys to steal things, but they wouldn't be above borrowing and running your favorite plane accross a brad nail by mistake. One place in particular, the owner would litterally scowl a bit if he came in and saw a hand plane on your bench. Absolutely insisted that anything powered was faster and better than anything sharp and pushed by hand.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#20

Re: Who owns the hand tools?

joel

>In the 18th century shop all the hand tools were owned by the craftsman who were paid in piecework. Apprentices either would have to own some tools or more likely be allowed to borrow tools from the master. There is plenty of documentation on the cost of wear and tear on tools and deep in the achives of the Old Bailey tons of sad but fascinating reports of tool theft by apprentices and journeyman, sometimes because the apprentice took a tool and the master or other journeyman said they never gave permission.

Even as late as the early 20th century in England at least in the chairmaking industry, the Master billed his journeymen for rent on a bench, apprentice help, and electricity. paying the journeyman piecework.

At least one Victorian apprentice in the 1840's who hated being an apprentice said in his shop the master was never there and that if you wanted any of the journeyman to show you how to do a job you had to pay them something go get them to help. (beer tobacco etc)

When stationary power tools came in they were set up in a Machine room separately and used by speciallists. Even as late as the 1930's there is documentation of a small cabinet shop in london who took their wood to a lumber year for planing and power cutting because they did not have any power tools in their shop.

It should be noted that before the day of the small electric motor setting up any machines required a fairly large investment in belts, pulleys, machine setup and possible a steam engine ans someone to tend it. This would be out of the resources of a small shop.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#21

Come again?

Adam Cherubini

>"Other than the addition of some power tools I can't see why a modern shop doing reproduction work for profit would be any different than a shop in 1750. The tools are going to be where they can be accessed readily, and that's not in a box."

I think there's a huge difference there! 18th c shops didn't supply the basic tools required to do the job. Hand tools in modern shops are few and much less consequential than hand tools were in the 18th c. If you are going to make the analogy, make it right. How would you like it if someone borrowed your table saw, or jointer? You really don't want someone borrowing your table saw.

A better analogy is a modern automotive repair shop and an 18th c cabinetshop. The shop provides only a work space, a bench, and a lift. The mechanic supplies 99% of the tools he needs. They are expensive, maybe 1/2 to 1 years pay. He stores them in a chest that locks. Borrowing is discouraged.

The chest is something you must have if you work in someone else's shop. It's not hard or inconvenient to work out of a well made, well fitted chest. If you are working in your home shop, there may be no need to have a toolchest. I like having one, though.

Adam

Re: 18th century tool chests

#22

On a similar vein

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Our word soldier comes from the fact that professional fighting men were paid a solidus a day for their services. They were therfor a solidiere or soldier.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#23

Re: period tool storage

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Adam, it's not just English either. All Romance languages once were Latin. Languages are a living thing and keep changing. Simplification is generally the rule. Thus haut bois becomes oboe.

Strike block, I assume, was a corruption of something from a foreign language. It was further complicated by the change in use of the tool. When no written records exist of something, a name will sometimes give us clues as to use, origin, etc. Maybe 200 years from now someone will be wondering why the thing that turns on the watering, cuts the grass, locks the house at night, shuts off unused energy, charges the car and fixes the kids breakfast for in the morning is called a beesee (with emphasis on the first syllable). In the 1980's we called its beginning form a PC. Fiction? Yes. Farfetched? No.

Re: 18th century tool chests

#24

Were independent saw tills used ?

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I agree that saws are more convenient in a free-standing till. Mine don't close, they just offer a safe place with easy access. If an 18th C. cabinetmaker remained in one place did he use an independent saw till?

Re: 18th century tool chests

#25

Re: Were independent saw tills used ?

Adam Cherubini

>I've never seen one and can't imagine one. If you are working in your home shop, I would think you would store your saws on pegs. And this is what we see in period images.

Adam