Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Posts

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#51

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

ThomD

>Sure that's a better system than what you can buy for 50 bucks. See the difference? On the other hand how is yours at doing a 50 foot panel? Some of the smaller pumps don't have the volume to even extract the bag.

Another thing is that ir depends on a perfect seal within an all enclosing bag. That means the molds have to be able to bear up to full weight of the atmosphere which is pretty wasteful.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#52

Thanks, all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Very valuable information that I'll save for whenever I try it. It will be interesting to see how the little wine bottle thing works for small work with small bags. I hadn't anticipated having to babysit the process and pump it in multiple events.

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#53

Re: Thanks, all.

Paul Kierstead

>If you use a relatively quick setting glue like PVA, the pump bag will work. I've done a few panels with it and it worked well. I check it after a bit just to make sure (and have re-pumped it when my sealing was less then perfect), but with something like PVA you can get away with only an hour or two in the bag anyway. It is a neat kit and works well.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#54

Re: Thanks, all.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Why do you say that a PVA glue allows only an hour or two in the bag?

In my experience with rubbed joints, hide glue clamps fast. Under what conditions do you need to bag them for more than an hour or two?

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#55

Re: Thanks, all.

Paul Kierstead

>In my experience with rubbed joints, hide glue clamps fast.

Hot hide glue sets too quickly to get your work in the bag, sealed and then pumped. You could, of course, press it down, but then you would be hammer veneering (nothing wrong with it, works well). Even if you can get liquid hide glue to grab, it still needs 12 hours clamp or so, especially in an environment that does not allow much in the way of evaporation. Just some grab is not enough, especially with a glue that makes the veneer want to curl away from the wood.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#56

I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#57

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Paul Kierstead

>Without heat (i.e. room temp), Urea Formaldehyde has a very long clamp time, one the order of something like 6 or 7 hours recommended min. I usually leave it overnight. The open time is awesome; yesterday I did up 2 panels (both sides of each) 16"x25" at once which, start to finish, would almost certainly exceed PVA's open time (not to mention the other problems) and could easily have added a couple more, but cold pressed it still takes forever to cure. Well, ok, not forever :) In a very warm room, it could be significantly reduced, though open time would also be reduced.

PVA does work well in the pump bag. Something like gorilla glue might work too; not sure about the clamp time, but it has the advantage of not being water based (it is catalytic).

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#58

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

ThomD

>If you want to use hide glue hammer veneering is oodles of fun. Urea is not a great benefit to the glue so I never use it. There can be quire significant localized pressure with veneers. I do a lot of boring veneers for structural purposes, but fancy veneers, like Birdseye have a nastily uneven micro surface that can require a lot of pressure to flatten out. Not a good thing for you basic vac cleaner. I wouldn't use gorilla, because it foams, and often with veneer there are those little areas that are not solid, and you can guess what might come percolating up. It is also highly carcinogenic if in contact with wet skin, so wear gloves.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#59

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I've tried hammer vaneering on a small practice piece, very guey [sic] process, not even sure where in my shop I'd do this without massive accretions. :)

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#60

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Paul Kierstead

>Ah, I misunderstood Urea :) Thom caught it nicely.

Hammer veneering is relatively easy to get the hang of for small pieces (I've done a few). It certainly is messy, but gets less messy with practice. Bigger pieces are trickier, especially large pieces of veneer. (see my post way below in this thread for a link to my own learning experience on that...)

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#61

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

ThomD

>I didn't find hammer vennering that hard on the coffee table and smaller bits I tried, but with hide glue the actual glue you use is often critical, can't even remember what I used but I must have gotten lucky. Folks that do a lot of gluing buy a lifetime supply from the factory so they can learn a batch once and for all.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#62

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I tried some of Patrick Edwards' hide glue, guess it's liquid, I refrigerate it. It worked fine, but again, this was a small piece, maybe 6" X 12". Makes sense that after you decide what you need and what works that you'd settle on that solution.

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#63

Re: I see, bummer. And urea doesn't help enough?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>My exposure to hhg and hammer veneering on larger pieces is via videos, and the way they seemed to handle this is to reheat and rehammer.

Pam