Re: very hard to do
Paul M.
>"I see this in luthiery on a relatively common basis...someone working on their first guitar wants to pipe bend a $400 set of difficult-at-best-of-times-to-bend wood, and is heartbroken when he or she slams head-on into the steep part of the learning curve."
This is timely. I'm starting on my first guitar through a class at a local community college. I have some awesome old-growth curly redwood pieces that I want use on a future guitar for a soundboard. But my first guitar will be basic mahogany and spruce. This first one is not about the product but is instead about the process. And so far, I'm enjoying the ride.
"On cleanup of PVA for a reglue...it is pure misery. I just spent close to 4 hours removing PVA for a reglue on four loose back braces. I had to wedge open the joint, insert sandpaper, remove the wedge to apply some pressure for sanding, floss the brace to remove Titebond, then repeat for the mating surface on the back. With a hide glued instrument, I would have blown out any debris with an air hose and reglued with fresh hide without any further cleanup."
Again, very timely info. My instructor uses Titebond I as it is reversable with heat. He did mention that it requires more scraping for a repair. But your analysis helps me with the decision process. Since this first guitar will be mostly a process thing, I may go the easy route and use Titebond. But when this becomes more serious, I'll keep your comments in mind. It's great to hear from someone who has actually done some significant repair work exactly what is involved.
Back on subject... All of the larger veneer work I've done has been with Titebond and using Vacuum bagging. I did a small piece once with Titebond and clamping cauls, and that was an ugly lesson in glue creep. Not fun. I've had zero experience with hide glue but I think that will change soon.




