Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Posts

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#26

Re: very hard to do

Paul M.

>"I see this in luthiery on a relatively common basis...someone working on their first guitar wants to pipe bend a $400 set of difficult-at-best-of-times-to-bend wood, and is heartbroken when he or she slams head-on into the steep part of the learning curve."

This is timely. I'm starting on my first guitar through a class at a local community college. I have some awesome old-growth curly redwood pieces that I want use on a future guitar for a soundboard. But my first guitar will be basic mahogany and spruce. This first one is not about the product but is instead about the process. And so far, I'm enjoying the ride.

"On cleanup of PVA for a reglue...it is pure misery. I just spent close to 4 hours removing PVA for a reglue on four loose back braces. I had to wedge open the joint, insert sandpaper, remove the wedge to apply some pressure for sanding, floss the brace to remove Titebond, then repeat for the mating surface on the back. With a hide glued instrument, I would have blown out any debris with an air hose and reglued with fresh hide without any further cleanup."

Again, very timely info. My instructor uses Titebond I as it is reversable with heat. He did mention that it requires more scraping for a repair. But your analysis helps me with the decision process. Since this first guitar will be mostly a process thing, I may go the easy route and use Titebond. But when this becomes more serious, I'll keep your comments in mind. It's great to hear from someone who has actually done some significant repair work exactly what is involved.

Back on subject... All of the larger veneer work I've done has been with Titebond and using Vacuum bagging. I did a small piece once with Titebond and clamping cauls, and that was an ugly lesson in glue creep. Not fun. I've had zero experience with hide glue but I think that will change soon.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#27

Wow. From what I can see...

Victor Parisian

>looks really nice. Can you post a larger pic?

Thanks,

Victor in Hot and Humid Houston

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#28

Seconding Victor's request! And also,

Wiley Horne-- So. Calif.

>are those sawn veneers or the thin sliced veneers at 1/28" or 1/40", whatever it is now?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#29

Re: Get a really long bag.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hmmm, thanks, interesting. Think my little wine bottle evacuator would handle a 4'X24' bag? :)

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#30

Re: Get a really long bag.

Dan Donaldson

>If there are no leaks, the glue has a long enough open time, and it will pull a good vacuum, then it probably will ;-) It is noisy and not too energy efficient, but you could build a venturi and run it off your air compressor. If done right, they will pull a fair vacuum.

You can probably keep and eye on ebay or the local Craigs list or similar and find an inexpensive vacuum pump. You can make bags from the sheet vinyl from a fabric store if necessary and, while not as rugged as some of the commercial bags, are cheap and work fine for a hobbiest that doesn't want to invest too much in something that they will use only infrequently.

I built the extension table for my tablesaw with a bag and it came out nice and flat and has lasted for 5 or 6 years now with no problems. It is two layers of birch ply with a piece of mdf in the center and laminated with formica. I did the whole thing, including the formica, at one shot and used liquid hide glue for everything.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#31

Veneering by Professionals (long and boring)

Steve Elliott

>I've been doing veneer work at my current job for almost two years now, mostly hot press veneering using urea formaldehyde glue. I'm also learning vacuum bag veneering, which we reserve for curved parts.

The trickiest thing to learn has been getting good adhesion without having too much glue ooze through the pores. It takes the right consistency of glue, quick and even application, and sometimes a few minutes of waiting before the piece goes into the press.

For vacuum bag work we use PVA glues, Titebond Extend for larger or more complicated pieces because of its increased open time and Titebond I for smaller pieces. If there are bubbles they can be fixed by injecting glue and ironing down the veneer.

I can't speak to the use of hide glue because in 30 years of work in cabinet and furniture shops I've never used it, nor do I remember a shop that had any on hand. I imagine that furniture repair shops might be more likely to use it.

That said, I hope to try hide glue when I retire and finally have more time to learn the skills discussed on this forum, such as hand cutting dovetails. The level of craft displayed in most of the projects posted here vastly exceeds what I do at work every day in terms of using wood well with respect to its nature. Traditional joinery and design developed to allow furniture to last through many changes of humidity and temperature, to be strong yet light, and to be repairable. I'm now making pieces that sell for jaw-dropping prices in nationally known galleries, but they're pretty much just shapes drawn with some designer's CAD program and wallpapered with veneer. The exact shade of the wood and metal finishes has to meet the designer's approval and the workmanship has to be good cosmetically, but underneath it's pretty basic. I regularly make tables that have such heavy metal bases that I'm not sure the screws holding the tabletop to the base will hold if the table is ever picked up by its top to move it. Not that you'd want to, because moving them is best done with a forklift.

As for being product-oriented, professional shops are that way by nature. Skill acquisition comes mostly by hard knocks, making lots of mistakes in the early years and gradually developing some technical expertise and coping skills. I believe the better shops are ones that develop their processes and invest some time in training their workers. It's pretty rare.

My own hobby time is spent mostly on tools. What I�m after is the enjoyment of understanding and tinkering with them, and after I�m gone I hope some future owner will appreciate how well the tool works. I consider tools that end up in collections to have died, or at least their working lives have ended. I�d rather see them used until they�re worn out. I just love it that my best tools are older than my parents and yet are still in their prime.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#32

Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#33

Re: Wow. From what I can see...

Adam Cherubini

>I got this veneer from Constantine's. I think it's sliced and it's about .100" IIRC


img

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#34

Re: Wow. From what I can see...

Paul Kierstead

>From the difference in reflectance, I see you book matched the border :)

Very very nice work, Adam.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#35

Re: Hey is that...

Bjenk Ellefsen

>Hey is that the book by Lisa Jardine I see on your standing desk?

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#36

;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I think that you might have a bit of problem getting enough vacuum unless, of course, you get one of those super duper ones from the door to door salesperson. ;-)

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#37

Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

Tom Colligan

>bag arrangement? Thanks and this has been a great post for me. Tom.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#38

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

ThomD

>There is a problem, they don't develop enough presure for many glues. They work really well with epoxies. A person who didn't want to invest in a system for just one job, might decide to use a shop vac and epoxies. In our world though, one would have to be sure the materials being pressed were smooth enough to flatten out under the lower pressures of a vac. A vac will do about 2 pounds a square inch while pumps will do 7-14.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#39

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

Paul Kierstead

>I tend to expect the vac to burn out (or up) as well, depending on how long you run it. You might get away with it for small panels with quick setting glue. For larger ones, you tend to want longer set with the attendant longer cure.

Not sure I could stand the racket, even if I wasn't there....

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#40

Re: Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

MikeW

>Hi Tom--I would not think this is possible. HHG sets way too fast.

I have used a vacuum press with liguid hide glue, though. Works as well as PRG and epoxy with the advantage of fixing the thing down the road.

Most of my bag veneering of larger or curved stuff is done with PRG or epoxy. Smaller flat panels I bag are done with LHG. Smaller platen stuff is done with LHG. I have no real reason for the different glues used for a given application except on the larger work. Those were generally drinks cabinets and serving credenzas where the chance of heat and or alcohol were used.

I've only used HHG a dozen times or so. I don't like the smell but will use it when it is something that isn't worth bagging.

Take care, Mike

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#41

Re: Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Yes it can if the glue room is at 90 degrees, that will give you over 10 minutes open time with hot hide glue. The substrate, veneer and bag all need to be that warm to avoid shocking the hot hide glue.

Stephen

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#42

Re: Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

Paul Kierstead

>As stephen said, everything will have to be quite warm to get sufficient open time. One of the problems with water based glues (particularly liquid or hot hide glue and PVA) and veneering is the water tends to cause problems in swelling veneer. The most obvious manifestation is curling of the veneer, potentially making handling difficult (hammer veneering avoids this by having glue on both sides of the veneer). It can cause various other problems as well as the swollen veneer dries out; adhesion, seams opening, etc. Now this is not to say it *can't* be done; quite clearly it can (and I have done it as well), but it does introduce new problems. As always, the size and materials can matter a *lot*, and it isn't always exotic ones; for example, maple can be a lot more bother then oak to use as a veneer. One of the great upsides of hide glue is zero creep, reducing spring-back on curved items and helping keep seams closed up etc. on flat work.

But the catalytic glues do offer quite a few advantages over water based ones, but I'll admit most aren't very friendly in a variety of dimensions.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#43

Re: Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

MikeW

>Well, as I tend to avoid 90 degree weather as much as possible, refuse to heat the stuff, the wood and the bag, I'll let another try it .

I would think this idea of using HHG in a vacuum bag (with the evidently necessary additional steps) falls into the "yes it can, but why" category. Seems to me that hot hide glue is basically a "self-clamping" solution that by adding a bag to the process is unnecessary complication.

PRG and epoxy don't mind heat during application, it's the cold they don't overly like. So as long as I am comfortable, they are.

Take care, Mike

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#44

Re: Can HHG be used with a vacuum . . .

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>Well, one of the differences between central Utah and coastal Oregon is the frequency of incidence of 90*+ days...

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#45

I said it Could be one...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>not that is should be done. But in the old days glue rooms were hot sweaty places where all the glue ups were done.

Stephen

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#46

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Thanks, Thom and Paul; but it seems to me that once a bag is compressed it should stay that way for a relatively long time, depending on how well the vacuum/pump is detached and the bag sealed at the attachment point. Of course, I don't know anything much, but this does appear to be a handy step down of an essentially industrial process.

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#47

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

Dan Donaldson

>The vacuum presses are great. Especially for curved surfaces. I don't know, but I imagine that you are right and this is a step down from some industrial process.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#48

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

ThomD

>I thought the vac would burn out too, but the guy who showed me said he had the cheapest Shop Vac and it had lasted hundreds of 8 hour cycles. I was scared leaving the vac running would start a fire and burn the shop down. I should mention that to use a regular vac you need some breather holes, 4 x 1/4" or presumably some similar area. These do not affect the pressure much, one of the advantages to vac cleaner is it's higher volume of air movement effectively means one can suck down a leaky bag. That isn't an objective but it can be an occurance. In the end I never had a problem, and eventually burned out the motor on a drywall job, which is a whole other story.

Another thing I do is check to be sure the vac is relatively clean so it won't be sucking air through clogged filters. if nothing else one doesn't get a cloud of particles every time one turns it on.

I wish I had had my current small vac when I did all the bagging. It is a QSP, which is the quiet model. My old version was a banshee. I don't think SV still makes the model I currently have it had reasonable suction and didn't make much noise at all.

Unfortunately Pam, it takes a comparatively complex system to suck and hold air. I marvel at the ads they have for systems that suck down clothing for long term storage. It takes a dense bag, perfect seals, a one way valve, a pressure switch, a storage tank, and so forth. Compared to the simplicity of what I propose that is hundreds of dollars of gear.

I'm guessing the small vacs are in the 5 amp range, and cost about 80 cents to run for a cycle. I always wanted to live near a fast river or have a windmill that would provide free suction, then I would really use vac for everything from replacing post-it notes to squeezing orange juice.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#49

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

ThomD

>"The vacuum presses are great. Especially for curved surfaces. I don't know, but I imagine that you are right and this is a step down from some industrial process."

Depends what one means by a step down. It's less gear and uses mostly gear we have. It does have various advantages. It's a bit like clamps, every time one glues something up, one doesn't necesarilly want to put a tommy-bar on the clamp and crank for all one is worth. But having the big guns at times, is good too.

Vac bagging was a reasonably improvised thing for decades. Then I remember, all of a sudden ads showed up in FWW etc... for expensive finished looking systems. Nothing wrong with that but one is paying something for the hand holding, and for adopting only one concept of the process.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#50

Re: Is there a problem using vacuum cleaners?

Paul Kierstead

>I dunno. I just heard my press run in the basement for a few seconds to keep the pressure at a ways over 20 HG. It ran just a bit and stopped. I can go to bed now and know it will reliably hold the pressure without incident or fuss till tomorrow morning when I pull out the panels (Urea takes a bit to cure...). Handholding? Dunno, but it sure is reliable and predictable.