Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>When it comes to veneering I am a beginner. Beginners needing to do something (veneer door panels in this case) have two criteria for "best" that professionals don't necessarily have. How hard is an approach to learn and what are the chances for success of one approach vs another? These tales will help other beginners to decide among two approaches for applying veneer to a panel.
I have had only 4 first hand experiences with veneering, all recently. I will describe them chronologically.
Case 1. I needed to veneer some book matched quartered ash I had made to the back of a Krenov style cabinet. A friend had recently bought a vacuum bag and he said I could use it. Confident beyond what my experience justified I slathered thinned (5%)yellow glue only the veneer, taped the edges and stuck it in the bag. An hour later I went home with a successfully veneered panel.
Case 2 A friend needed to veneer two door panels for the desk Lonnie Byrd described in FWW magazine. He had little experience in veneering. Influenced by other period woodworkers he decided that hammer veneering was the way to accomplish the task. He realized that learning to hammer veneer might not be trivial so he hired a professional to teach him how in a two day personally arranged one-on-one class. First though, the crotch veneer had to be flattened as it was major wrinkly. This in itself involved choosing from among various recipes practiced in the art. To make a long story short, they failed to get good adhesion in the difficult parts of the crotch veneer, ultimately ruining the veneer sheets as well as the panel substrates.
Case 3. At SAPFM meeting Alf Sharp, 2008 Cartousch winner, demonstrated hammer veneering on a bow front drawer. He spent some time getting the glue just right. He then had some difficulty getting the last corner of the veneer stuck properly. He said he normally vacuum bags these kinds of projects now days.
Case 4 I obtained the remaining crotch from Case 2 for some door panels for a Federal style cabinet I would be making in a "Woodworking Workshops of the Shenandoah Valley" class held in the Mack Headley Sr. and Sons shop in Winchester, VA. With the experience of Cases 2 and 3 before me I was concerned(understatement) about the success this endeavor. Jeff Headley and Steve Hamilton, mentors for the class, examined my veneer and pronounced that it was flat enough to proceed. It had lumps at least 1 1/4" high and my concerns only heightened. Jeff slathered white glue on the panel substrate and veneer with a paint brush. He commented that this crotch would have been difficult with hide glue as there was a lot of end grain which absorbed glue. The veneer was taped to the panel substrate with blue masking tape and the assembly put in the vacuum press. It looked so easy that I did the following veneer application, and for variety we clamped this assembly. I sawed the a panel to size last night and I could not find any area where the veneer was not tenaciously held to the backing panel. Good adhesion resulted in no splintering of the veneer while sawing. The resulting panels are shown in the PIC attached.
The ease and assurance of veneering with modern glue and a vacuum bag has convinced many, if not most, professionals and amateurs to take this route. Had the advocates of hide glue not prevailed in case 2, this story would have been successful instead of a very costly disaster.
This post will not convince proponents of hide glue to change, nor is it intended to. You have invested a lot of time to develop the skill necessary to use this product and I admire this talent and skill. Rather, this post is intended to provide some additional data to those less talented, and beginners, deciding how to veneer their next project.




