Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Posts

Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#1

Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When it comes to veneering I am a beginner. Beginners needing to do something (veneer door panels in this case) have two criteria for "best" that professionals don't necessarily have. How hard is an approach to learn and what are the chances for success of one approach vs another? These tales will help other beginners to decide among two approaches for applying veneer to a panel.

I have had only 4 first hand experiences with veneering, all recently. I will describe them chronologically.

Case 1. I needed to veneer some book matched quartered ash I had made to the back of a Krenov style cabinet. A friend had recently bought a vacuum bag and he said I could use it. Confident beyond what my experience justified I slathered thinned (5%)yellow glue only the veneer, taped the edges and stuck it in the bag. An hour later I went home with a successfully veneered panel.

Case 2 A friend needed to veneer two door panels for the desk Lonnie Byrd described in FWW magazine. He had little experience in veneering. Influenced by other period woodworkers he decided that hammer veneering was the way to accomplish the task. He realized that learning to hammer veneer might not be trivial so he hired a professional to teach him how in a two day personally arranged one-on-one class. First though, the crotch veneer had to be flattened as it was major wrinkly. This in itself involved choosing from among various recipes practiced in the art. To make a long story short, they failed to get good adhesion in the difficult parts of the crotch veneer, ultimately ruining the veneer sheets as well as the panel substrates.

Case 3. At SAPFM meeting Alf Sharp, 2008 Cartousch winner, demonstrated hammer veneering on a bow front drawer. He spent some time getting the glue just right. He then had some difficulty getting the last corner of the veneer stuck properly. He said he normally vacuum bags these kinds of projects now days.

Case 4 I obtained the remaining crotch from Case 2 for some door panels for a Federal style cabinet I would be making in a "Woodworking Workshops of the Shenandoah Valley" class held in the Mack Headley Sr. and Sons shop in Winchester, VA. With the experience of Cases 2 and 3 before me I was concerned(understatement) about the success this endeavor. Jeff Headley and Steve Hamilton, mentors for the class, examined my veneer and pronounced that it was flat enough to proceed. It had lumps at least 1 1/4" high and my concerns only heightened. Jeff slathered white glue on the panel substrate and veneer with a paint brush. He commented that this crotch would have been difficult with hide glue as there was a lot of end grain which absorbed glue. The veneer was taped to the panel substrate with blue masking tape and the assembly put in the vacuum press. It looked so easy that I did the following veneer application, and for variety we clamped this assembly. I sawed the a panel to size last night and I could not find any area where the veneer was not tenaciously held to the backing panel. Good adhesion resulted in no splintering of the veneer while sawing. The resulting panels are shown in the PIC attached.

The ease and assurance of veneering with modern glue and a vacuum bag has convinced many, if not most, professionals and amateurs to take this route. Had the advocates of hide glue not prevailed in case 2, this story would have been successful instead of a very costly disaster.

This post will not convince proponents of hide glue to change, nor is it intended to. You have invested a lot of time to develop the skill necessary to use this product and I admire this talent and skill. Rather, this post is intended to provide some additional data to those less talented, and beginners, deciding how to veneer their next project.


img

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#2

PS

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The picture is of the panels just after they came out of the press. I am anxious to get them sanded and get some finish on them.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#3

Repairing veneer

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>If you cannot find somebody competent to lay veneer with hide glue, I am wondering how you will ever find somebody who is able to repair it. Veneered furniture is quite susceptible to damage and lots of Federal pieces have had restoration to the veneer. I cannot imagine that you have a repair strategy in place for your panels; nobody will want to work on veneer that is put on with white glue. When I see veneer laid on plywood with glues that are not easy to remove I am thinking throwaway furniture: easier to make new than to repair.

The same applies to mortise and tenon joints glued with yellow glue or white glue. Have you ever tried to take one of these apart? How do you repair a panel if you can't get the surrounding frame apart?

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#4

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

wilbur

>Just for argument's sake, couldn't your cases be explained as more a failure of hammering technique vs. vacuum bag, instead of a white glue vs. hide glue issue?

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#5

Re: PS

Tony - Memphis

>Can't wait to see those with some finish! When I was first trying out veneering, I learned a lot from Daryl Kleil at Vacupress via his videos and forum. One thing he cautioned me about using alphatic resin glue was the creep factor. His explanation is that the glue gives a little and will allow the veneer to move and open joints, etc. So, I used Unibond800. I've had good success with it. I tried poly glue once as I saw a project at Phil Lowe's shop and that's what they were using. Didn't like that too much, but it worked good. Also tried liquid hide glue. That worked fine, but then, some knucklehead (maybe the one typing) used a water based dye and the veneer wrinkled. Bummer. At least it was a test project anyway. I flattened it somewhat with an iron. for flattening, I did the water/alcohol/glue/glycerin thing and that worked well too. I did notice the other night that a table I did with crotch mahogany has very small cracks in it. Adds to the antique look!

Keep us posted on your project.

Tony

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#6

Re: Tales and now the truth.

ThomD

>I don't use veneer much, but over the long haul have done everything from hammer veneering crotch onto a friend's table (made the hammer also), to vac bagging panels 24 feet long.

As an occasional teacher I have noticed that just as there are people who can program a VCR, and others who can not, there are people who can do every project out of the box, while others can't. Then there are people who actually enjoy the stress of doing the projects out of the box...

All these methods work and normally they are fairly easy once you have blown a piece. It's a bit like shooting a rifle: you need some sighter shots, no mater how good you are at the shooting. The more variables a method has the more exploratory steps there may be even if the basic "technique" is not difficult (lots of muscles to train).

Basic issue is that the items outlined were mostly undertaken as projects. This is like a guy asking how his swing is coming along in golf, who has only tried to play full rounds at golf courses, no time at the practice tee. Basically while it is fun to do all these methods, they exist to achieve particular objectives. I'm not hammer veneering a 4'x24' compound curved panel that is going to be used in a marine environment. Vac was the only logical way to go. The big advantage to hammer veneering is the edge will crush down the bubble in a veneer that resists 24 inches of mercury, and of course one needs very little gear. Once you figure out why you need a particular technique, if you have any doubts, run some practice pieces. Determine when you are practicing and when you are executing and don't mix the two. Avoid project mentality. Of course if you like the chaos, go for it.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#7

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering *LINK*

Paul Kierstead

>I've done some hammer veneering, and done some vac bagging. I'm not gonna tell ya that hammer veneering is the be-all end-all; it certainly isn't, and I own a vacupress set-up that I love. But, your two cases of woe sound like people (the teacher and the pro, not your friend) who haven't done it recently or haven't done it much.

- Corners are always one of the hardest bits IME in hammer veneering. But, using an Iron after the fact makes it quite easy. If the demonstrator didn't know enough to apply an iron, I have to wonder how much he has done it in the last 15 years

- The teacher trying for a first crack to do a burl was very foolish. Even in vacuum pressing, burls can create a lot of problems with bleed through, adhesion, etc. (though clearly don't always cause a lot of problems). Trying it as your learning project for hammer veneering seems pretty much destined to failure. It is definitely a skill which needs to be built up.

All that said, I still use a bag particularly for large surfaces or repetitive work. Hammer veneering is great for quick stuff (no need to make up cauls, etc) and odd things which won't go in a bag well (like veneering the face of a drawer after it has been assembled....)

Now if you want a good disaster, read what happened when I bit off more then I could chew doing a hammer veneering.... (I've since both got better at hammer veneering and got a vacupress system)


A Veneering Disaster

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#8

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

roninkokomo

>I have done e few projects that included veneering. Hide glue only. No problem of any kind that could in anyway be attributed to the adhesive. ( there were a couple caused by the woodworker)

I would really be concerned about the repair issue. I pretty much use only hide glue for anything that I imagine someone might want to keep.

Are the modern glues probably superior in holding power? Probably, but I think it may be a distinction that does not really make a difference.

Ron

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#9

Just what I was thinking, Wilbur.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#10

How do you "bag" a 4'X24' piece?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#11

Get a really long bag.

Paul Kierstead

>Companies like vacupress can make custom bags.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#12

Re: Get a really long bag.

Paul Kierstead

>Actually, they have a 20" x 21' bag even in a standard size.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#13

very hard to do

roninkokomo

>For the recreational woodworker, it is very difficult to avoid the "project mentality" because that is the way that most of our time is spent

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#14

Re: very hard to do

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>I agree with Ron. There are almost no processes that I want to do just to own the skills. I want to do the processes to own the results.

There are times when owning the skills is the goal, but it takes a more dedicated hobbyist than I, most of those times. Six ways to Sunday, I usually don't need.

OP, thanks for the writeup. It explains a little of what I went through with a veneering attempt some years back, and offers a way to success, should I restart down that neglected path.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#15

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Adam Cherubini

>This is my first veneer job. I did it with hot hide glue, a hammer, and an antique sad iron. The center on both the desk and the flap is two pieces of veneer. They are surrounded by holly from my backyard. Out side of that are smaller pieces "on the bias". How does one do this with a vacuum bag? Is it really faster?

I guess my point is, that the approach recommended will work for somethings, but may not be faster for everything. So instead of actually saving yourself trouble, are you actually just putting off learning a skill you will need later? And has your choice limited what you can do?

I don't like the idea that guys have to do everything period correct as some sort of stunt, or to earn bragging rights. Some of the old techniques are really just great. And while they can sometimes be hard to learn, it can be worth it in the long haul. Everybody has to decide that for themselves.

Bill, you are very analytical, so I'm always interested in your choices. Thanks for sharing this with us. I think this has been helpful for many folks.

Adam


img

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#16

Re: Get a really long bag.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I wouldn't think this something that a home shop would have, much less a sufficiently strong vacuum; but it's cool that they're out there. Thanks.

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#17

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

Phil Smith

>The picture of Bill's panels don't do the panels justice. They really are something to see in person. I know because I took the picture.

There is another option for veneer that Bill did not mention and that is to use two ply veneer. It comes flat and is easy to apply with traditional clamps or vacuum press. If you only use veneer occasionally its another way to get a project completed sucessfully.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#18

thank you

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is encouraging to find a few like minded breathern on the Forum.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#19

Re: very hard to do

ThomD

>"I agree with Ron. There are almost no processes that I want to do just to own the skills."

I have several kids like that too. One of mine's first attempts at anything on ice skates was a tripple axel. That pretty much describes her whole outlook. That can be good, a talented person can jump over a lot of slowpoking around, or not.

"I want to do the processes to own the results."

You get the results you deserve. But without being a bully on the point, I'm the kind of guy who will glue up a big job without even a dry run. My patience is not inexaustible and I skip steps, not claiming any kind of perfection here. But there are two points. One is that remarkably small amounts of practice can make a big difference. Both in acquiring skills and refreshing them in warm-up mode. The amount of practice required to go from a good athlete to someone who wins a gold medal is enormous and possibly ridiculous. The amount of practice required simply to be competant is far more immediately rewarding.

The other point is that probably someone is willing to build their skills. For that person the trap can be simply a lack of perspective on what they are actually doing at the time. It may seem like an overly fine point but it can be really important. To be fully comited to the activity one is doing is part of what makes it come off well. It's a lot more important than what a tool is sharpened on. Testing, skills building, execution, should idealy be neatly segmented.

Also, some of the groundwork isn't skills related it's like testing finish materials for compatability. Stuff like veneering can be like baking a soufle. Even just scaling a process up can unearth unexpected traps.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#20

Re: How do you "bag" a 4'X24' piece?

ThomD

>The standard 6 mil plastic used as a vapor barrier is 9 feet wide, and will do both sides, or two pieces will do a 9 foot width. I have never purchased a special bag, though it would be a good thing for certain repetitive runs. I rarely do the same thing twice so I just make bags for situations as they come along. Bags can be welded shut, but there are interesting splines available at your local home center, and caulking works well too, so does tape, so does reuseable putty string sold for sealing heat leaks, etc... You should be able to put together a good system with a pump for one-offing just about anything for 50-100 bucks. And these bags can be reused, I often reuse larger ones for smaller jobs, but a bag can be made to be reused frequently also. In many applications pumps are run without shut-offs, and the plastic may not survive the bagging, since it is full of ouzzie glue. If you are doing one-off you can recoup the cost of the kind of systems they are selling the cabinet trade, with all the bells and whistles. good time to go looking for stuff as the home heaitng season rolls around.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#21

Re: How do you "bag" a 4'X24' piece?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>That's so cool. The directions for the tiny (skateboard size) one I got to play with talk a lot about sealing the bag, but with some tar like black goo.

Pam

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#22

Re: very hard to do

tstock

>I see this in luthiery on a relatively common basis...someone working on their first guitar wants to pipe bend a $400 set of difficult-at-best-of-times-to-bend wood, and is heartbroken when he or she slams head-on into the steep part of the learning curve. Time spent on developing some basic level of proficiency on scrap seems to me to be more than amply returned later by avoided repairs or trashed components & projects. In terms of hammer veneering, a scrap of waste ply and $2 worth of veneer would seem to be a pretty moderate investment. Vac bagging works (and I've seen 70+ foot boats bagged in one massive application of veneers, glue, plastic staples, and hoses...talk about a big baggie), but it's even more of an investment in time and money than setting up for hot hide and doing things with a hammer.

Re: hide versus PVA for veneer - PVA will heat activate with good results, but once cooked is much tougher to get to heat release. Hide's other big advantage besides easy reversal is that it can be rewarmed while still in gel form to work out a bubble or to push some glue into an area where you were not so generous with glue during initial application.

On cleanup of PVA for a reglue...it is pure misery. I just spent close to 4 hours removing PVA for a reglue on four loose back braces. I had to wedge open the joint, insert sandpaper, remove the wedge to apply some pressure for sanding, floss the brace to remove Titebond, then repeat for the mating surface on the back. With a hide glued instrument, I would have blown out any debris with an air hose and reglued with fresh hide without any further cleanup. At $75/hour shop rate, it added almost $300 to the $550 repair tab. Old hide combines with new hide for a strong joint, while old Titebond is best viewed as a contaminant in a joint to be reglued - a real PITA on veneer work.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#23

Re: Get a really long bag.

Dan Donaldson

>The size of the bag is really not too relevent as long as you have a decent pump and no leaks. Just takes longer to get down to the lowest level. It really doesn't take that much to pull a pretty good vacuum. The bigger pumps have more capacity (faster) and some bells and whistles like shutoffs at pressure, but for intermittent usage at home, it really is not too hard to set up something that will work.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#24

Re: the steep part of the learning curve

James Watriss

>I saw a lot of the over-enthusiasm from the other side of the counter, back when I was working at the woodworking stores. The magazines, and Norm, all make it look so easy. And they encourage this idea, that anyone can buy a gee whiz gadget, and make something masterful, at first pass. What the magazines and tool vendors are actually doing is selling something that just requires a different skill set... learning to set up some of the more involved jigs can take a long time. And it's possible to go through a large amount of scrap until you've gotten it figured out. But people jump right in, thinking it's just that easy. And they botch a project, ruin some beautiful wood, and drop the hobby. It always made me feel kinda guilty, working behind the counter, and taking people's money. I gave them as much advice as I was able, but some people don't hear. There's no mistaking the burning eyes of the zealous converted. They just know, they've see it on TV themselves... this finished project is right around the corner. And it'll be easy.

I've also seen some folks over-estimate the abilities of their tools... like the guy who bought $150 of wood for a jewelry box for his wife, but tried to cut the miters with a "contractor grade" circular saw. They've worked with pine before... wood is wood, how bad can rosewood or bubinga or padauk really be?

I guess it's just 2 different mentalities sometimes. Some people see this gorgeous thing in a magazine, and they want to be able to say that they made their own. And I think that's really cool, because (my view) being able to say that you made your own implies the desire to show off the skill set, and not just the object. But some people really just want the end product, and they think it will be cheaper to make it themselves. The Luthiery bit sounds very familiar, and it really does sound like people who see the finished product in their minds, but they let that vision obscure the things that they'll ave to do along the way. "It'll be so cool... it'll be so cool... it'll be so cool..." Everyone hears the line about how it only cost some company $10 to make something that sells for $100, and they take it to heart. How hard can it really be?

And I've had customers come back, who managed to get over that learning curve hump, but they walked away with a lot more humility, talking about the time they spent $400 on tools, $100 of fancy wood, and most of one weekend, to make what would basically be a $30 part for their project. But they learn, they go forward, and it's a great first step. And they're able to build whatever the next thing happens to be that they want.

Personally, I guess I'm more of an egotist sometimes. I just have too much fun figuring out how to build things, to the point where it gets in the way of profitability sometimes. I enjoy owning the skills, because I see them all as useful. Hard to maintain sometimes, but useful, because so many of them become complimentary. I want to see just how far I can go in this, how much I can learn, and just how capable I can become. I've played with making planes, gone through all kinds of sharpening methods, made a bunch of my own jigs from scratch, so many different shooting boards, etc, etc, and I learn something new every time I do something, and learn the proper skills. Inevitably, there's a eureka, and something that seemed so involved becomes clear. I live for those moments, but they are expensive to find.

At this point, I have to be careful... I'm so wound up with the woodwork, but I also want to learn some basic machining skills, to make new tools. And having used a vacuum press, I want to learn about carbon fiber and other composite materials. Working with metal, wood, composites... I was always good in school, but I want things to be practical and applicable. I want the skills to build anything. I want to know just how far I can take my own abilities. It's not about building... whatever it is. It's about building me. Like I said, egotist.

That said, everyone makes mistakes. And if one of the skills I have to learn is how to use a glue that will help me fix my own mistakes, so that I don't have to ruin or rebuild an entire part, then I think that's a useful skill, and one worth owning.

Re: Tales of hide vs white glue for veneering

#25

Again... who's here?

roninkokomo

>Veneering is a perfect example of what I am trying to say. If the average guys here makes 4 nice projects a year.. how many of them will involve veneer?? The original point is certainly valid that one, to get better, must devote time to skill acquisition... but for the folks who build 4 nice projects a year, it is likely to be very project oriented.

I really wonder if it is that much different in the pros? They are "on the clock".