Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Wow! *LINK*

Posts

Wow! *LINK*

#1

Corey Megal

Wow! *LINK*

Corey Megal

>This is so cool. The 3 minute dovetail. Let's see a router jig do that.


http://popularwoodworking.com/klausz

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#2

Just beat me to it :-)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#3

Imagine what he'll do with a bit of practise!!!

Brent in Montreal

>

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#4

Re: Hey I tried...

ThomD

>One year, maybe around 10 years ago, I wrote a bunch of major manufacturers, including Lee Valley, my home province heroes, and tried to get them interested in the idea of making dovetail blades for bowsaws in the japanese patterns (later happened with overly agressive blades that don't work that well), and the turning blades used to do this kind of cut so you can saw out the waste in dovetails. Some said they would think about the L-shaped baldes, none have done it. Based on the sales of bowsaws in general, who can blame them, but part of the problem is that for joinery the blades sold are not reasuring. This technique has been covered in FWW going back probably over 20 years, Frank said tey used to make crates for their furniture using this techniques. It just looks like so mucj fun I figured everyone would buy one, maybe the time has finally come. When I wrote some of the catalog stores didn't even sell dovetail saws of any pattern that actually worked.

Frank's basic no layout method is real easy to learn and I tried to sell it to students as a way so fast, that anyone could do, that frees you up to practice, and quickly master dovetails. It seems generally to stun people who assume only a master can do it and go back to some stilted method that involves lots of stress and slow layout. It's like basketball, you have to actually practice shooting the baskets, if you come up with some kind of method that involves building a giant marble run jig to control the ball going in, you won't learn how to do it freehand.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#5

Re: Wow!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Great link!

Maybe that's how they managed those 4-drawer bureaus in 36 hours back in the old days.

The no-chisel method of dovetails. Also, for the first time, I can see how pins first can actually work. Nother thing I liked: about a 3:1 rake on the pins/tails. He broke all the rules, not just some of them.

Thanks Corey,

Wiley

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#6

Re: Wow!

Kevin French, Antrim, NH------WebKitFormBoundary3x

>Not to mention Wiley that if you have to beat them together like that your begg'n for it to split.

I like the method and I think if you're not trying to set a speed record you'd be fine doing it this way.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#7

Re: Wow!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Kevin,

Watching Frank do those brings many thoughts to mind. Not that I ever see myself doing it his way, or even close. The reality is, I never apprenticed and never will do them all day long, so I will continue to do them slowly, though i think pretty well.

But 'slow' is a big concession. I've spent enough time around craft workers to know that the appellation 'he's slow' is about as devastating a cut as you will hear. The person who does fine work very slowly is an object of derision among professional craftsmen, in my experience.

Anyway, it sure is fun to watch someone work who is very, very good at what they do. Which implies fast. Heard similar comments about Imai's recent blacksmithing demo at kezurou-kai--it was all so fast and fluid that folks couldn't quite remember what had just happened.

Wiley

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#8

Re: Wow!

Hank Knight

>Have you seen Klaus's "Dovetail a Drawer" video? He's just about as fast using a chisel and a saw. His saw cuts are dead-on and FAST, and he clears out the waste with about three mallet blows per tail/pin. No paring, just a nice tight fit off the saw. It's discouraging to watch, especially for someone struggling to learn dovetails. I think it should be rated "NFN" ("Not For Newbies").

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#9

Re: Wow!

groovyman44

>I have seen him do this and sliding dovetails live in person and it is unbeleivable. He doesn't even measure anything, he just cuts and that's it.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#10

Re: NFN

ThomD

>"I think it should be rated "NFN" ("Not For Newbies")."

I think you probably win on that one since I never really managed to convince anyone to do it his way when I demoed it. From what people say from seeing his tape, he has the same problem. I don't care about being fast since for the most part I don't have to be either, and if I do something comemrcial where there is a reason for my being slow I just cut the quote. Why I think his layout and sawing method is for newbies is becaus one gets in better connection with the work. I used to X-country ski a lot and I would occasionally find myself relying on the poles too much loosing the rythm. The simple answer is to not use poles. It immediately corrects the problem and one gets literally into the swing of the thing; In archery a major practice technique is to shoot from extreme close range into the bale with one's eyes closed; In golf (there are lots of tricks) one dangerous drill is to throw the club towards the target as part of the swing. Teaches the realease right away.

All of these are advanced seeming, or odd techniques, but they immediately get you to feel what you are doing. I wouldn't say FKs method is that powerful (it is afterall a method of doing work, not a drill), but I think it is what newbies should do. It isn't appropriate for all qualities of work.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#11

Re: Wow!

john j

>I saw that, and just now went out and hacked out a dovetail joint just for fun. Didn't turn out too bad considering I was sipping a Pale Moon and watching my boys play in the driveway. Just kicking one out for grins...

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#12

Re: NFN

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I don't know why so few try freehand cutting for dovetails, although I find a bow saw a bit unwieldy for the task. 27 years ago I cut my first dovetails at the direction of a very good teacher in Boston; but the minute I saw that half the elements were marked from the other half that I'd just cut (doesn't matter, pins first or tails first), it became obvious that careful layout was not required, that the only mark that had to be measured was the base line. At that point I began free handing them, and it only gets easier.

Pam

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#13

I think you're right Thom

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>If I had had instruction, that's the kind of instruction and practice that would have been the most fulfilling. And for all the reasons you say: It gets you past the Oh-my-God-I-made-a-mistake barrier. Get that out of your system, and real learning can happen.

This is a philosophical point, but one thing I have come to learn that applies so many times is this. Don't build a game plan--for a game, for life, for a relationship, for sawing joinery--around not making a mistake. Perfection is the enemy of the good. Go for the money shot, make the mistake, and redo it. I don't know that surgeons can follow this advice, or carrier pilots. But it works pretty good in many situations I've been in. That's my takeaway from the FK video, and I think Thom is right.

Wiley

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#14

Re: I think you're right Thom

Hank Knight

>You guys may be right. But for those of us who didn't have the benefit of a talented teacher and who learned dovetails from published literature where the emphasis is on layout and careful, precise toolwork, watching Klaus pound out near perfect dovetails almost "from the hip" is breathtaking and more than a little intimidating. To me, his dovetail video is a parlor trick. I can produce respectable dovetails, but it takes a while. If I tried to emulate Klaus's style, I'd have to start over from scratch.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#15

Re: I think you're right Thom

wilbur

>Actually, surgeons do follow that advice often. The key is that if going for it results in a less than desired result, there's a routine called the "M&M conference", which stands for "Morbidity and Mortality", where the patient's case, the surgery, the outcome, and management is reviewed and analyzed to see where the process could be improved. Medicine not being a perfect science, often the answer is, "Not much could have been changed." Many other areas of medicine, including mine, have a similar routine, and my mindset is often to go for it when dealing with a patient.

I actually remember reading once that military pilots have a similar exercise.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#16

Re: I think you're right Thom

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Hank, you really should simply try it on some scrap, you'll be surprised. It wasn't my teacher who pointed the way to free handing, he pointed me to precise dovetailing. I was the one who reasoned it not necessary. People are great at bisecting space, and it doesn't matter what "mistakes" you may make on the first board because the second board will be laid out based on the first.

Pam

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#17

Re: I think you're right Thom

Hank Knight

>Pam,

I'll do it. I need the practice. I mark my second board (pins) from the tail board, so I've got that part. What I lack is facility with the saw and Klaus's bravado with the chisel. Practice would help me with both of those sills. I've been using dividers to lay out the spacing without measuring and that certainly speeds things up. But you're right, practice is the key. Klaus and other pros, especially those who came up in the apprentice system, have cut thousands of dovetails, so it's a well-honed skill for them. They can do it blindfolded. Hobby guys like me will never approach their speed, but the more one does it, the better one gets. Practice is the key.

Hank

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#18

Re: I think you're right Thom

Dean J in MN

> I've been using dividers to lay out the spacing without measuring and that certainly speeds things up.

Want more speed? Toss the dividers for spacing. Don't misunderstand, I love my dividers, but not for dovetail layout. Your eye will do just as well.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#19

Great, Hank

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Be sure and let us know how it goes. The main goal is to speed up your process, not necessarily match Klaus. A secondary goal is to enhance your confidence, so dovetails are no longer considered some sort of holy grail but a normal strong joint.

Pam

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#20

Dovetail saw involved

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi

I posted this video here over in the German Forum. Wolfgang Jordan whom you may know, pointed us to the special bow saw Frank Klausz uses to cut the spaces between pins and tails.

Now my question. Is this saw blade spread in the US? Is it common? In German it is called a dovetail or better translated a pin saw or an angle saw. It seems that this type of blade isn't produced here anymore.

Marc


img

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#21

Re: Dovetail saw involved

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Hello Marc,

I am curious about the 'special blade' that Wolfgang showed. Does the blade have an unusual shape, or is it simply a thin blade that is used with a twist.

On your question, that is called a 'keyhole saw' over here. Even Stanley still makes one--it can be bought with a metal handle, or blade only:

http://www.hechinger.com/hardware/tools/56777-stanley-tools-keyhole-saw-7in-15-275.html

The blades on these are too thick to work down a saw kerf, so for dovetails one would have to make two cuts, starting from the center of the waste. I do not believe these saws would be suitable for making the entire dovetail cut (sidewall + waste cuts) as shown in your drawing--the saw would wander because it is toothed for turning rather than for a straight cut.

In addition, there are Japanese keyhole saws (hikimawashi). Most of these cut on the pull stroke, but you find Japanese keyhole saws which cut on the push stroke--the only Japanese saws which do this. The pull-type Japanese saw might have a thin enough blade to work down a western saw kerf--I'm not sure, but it can be found out.

Wiley

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#22

Re: Dovetail saw involved

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi Wiley,

The photo only shows the blade, not the rest of the bow saw. So the part of the blade in the foreground is oriented horizontally and the far end of the blade behind the workpiece is oriented vertically. This special blade is named a pin blade or an angle blade and fits in a conventional bow saw. I guess the blade is bent in order to make this unusual shape. Once it was commonly spread in continental Europe. It always was used by dovetails that didn't show and where a tight fit was more important than the looks.

Marc

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#23

Re: Wow!

Sgian Dubh

>It puts me to shame. I can only do a similar size and layout in five minutes, usually four tails; I use a soft easy to cut wood such as poplar or a pine, and keep the thickness down to 10- 12 mm. I do it every now and then sort of on the spur of the moment in amongst a bunch of my learners. I get set up and I ask the nearest couple of learners to keep an eye on what I'm doing and, "time me cutting a set of dovetails".

I mark the shoulder lines with a cutting gauge and then just go for it with a saw and eyeballing the spacing. Apart from the saw I have a couple of chisels, a mallet, a block of wood and a hammer all to hand. Within about two minutes I've got an audience of five or six learners, and by the end just about every learner in the workshop is usually watching. I've finished with about as many as twenty watching as I hammer the joint together.

It's a wee bit of fun and I like to do it because it does show the learners the joint can be cut fast and accurately without a lot of setting up and marking. I wouldn't want to do it for long or do too many. It gets boring, tedious and repetitive, and oddly enough that is when the errors start creeping in. But I've never managed quicker than just a few seconds under five minutes. Slainte.

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#24

Re: Dovetail saw involved--My bad

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Thanks Marc. I'm afraid I created some confusion.

Now I see what is going on in the photo. There is an L-shaped section at the blade center, and that is where the transition is made from vertical to horizontal cutting.

Wiley

Re: Wow! *LINK*

#25

Here is mine

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have made a number of these blades and sold them, here is one I have set up in my bowsaw. I am building another frame for a regular blade as I use this one all the time.

It is a fun saw to demonstrate to people because of the square cut.

Stephen


img