Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Hey, Adam

Posts

Re: Hey, Adam

#51

My great aunt Zelda did it.

Larry Williams

>I recognize the marks, she was death on spiders with her high heels in the 40's. They say my great uncle just hated it when she'd slip of a shoe and pop a spider on the plaster walls. I'd show you exactly the same marks in the furniture and casing of their doors and windows in that old house but it was torn down in the 1960's. Still, I have as much proof this was the source of those marks as Adam does for his assertion.

Re: Hey, Adam

#52

Re: What I'm talking about

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Ah, it wasn't my grades, it was my gender. I literally was NOT allowed to apply. It would have been a lot cheaper to have attended a good school so close to home; but instead I went off to UWisconsin and spent a small fortune the first year.

Pam

Re: Hey, Adam

#53

I betcha...

John in New Mexico

>He just found out that the shop apprentice was dragging a handsaw backwards to start a cut instead of using the nib.

(sorry Stephen, couldn't resist!)

Re: Hey, Adam

#54

Re: What I'm talking about

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I didn't realize that UVA was all male until 1970. Still think grads are ...ummm...Well you know if you spend any time in Virginia.

JR

Re: Hey, Adam

#55

Re: re: that much force in that area...

ThomD

>The thing is it isn't even well struck. I have some wooden chisels I have been hitting with metal hammers for 30 years and they don't look like that. An moron with a framing hammer would have possibly left those marks on a weekend play house. A pro with a framing hammer would have left a more level mark every 100 or more nails. A bunch of them for no apparent reason around the piece - It doesn't add up. Frankly a woodworker should possibly know that, which means I'm an idiot if these are all over the place on 18th C furniture, or possibly it isn't me.

Re: Hey, Adam

#56

Re: re: that much force in that area...

ThomD

>"And maybe it was made by an apprentice. The tenon in question was a hard one to cut properly..."

It was harder to learn to walk than it was to run let' say. Today doing either one is no difference. These ideas are irrelevant to someone who is competant.

"the cant of the back legs, and the angle of the side pieces made for a compound cutting angle, and those can be a hassle to lay out and cut if you're still learning."

I know this isn't your contention, but I heard someone say this chair was a masterpiece which means it wasn't done by a hack, by definition. In reality I would accept that different hands of different abilities may have worked on it. In an open shop though hammering like a madman, doing a stupid fix on a piece that had consumed some carvers time would not be wise. If the joint doesn't fit there are better fixes particularly with hot glue.

"So if the joint in the picture was off by a hair or two and got stuck during assembly, it makes sense to me that someone would go out of their way to drive the joint all the way home while the glue is still in a forgiving mood."

I have done that, but then I don't like dry fitting, even on one-offs I have never made anything the like of before. Hardly the likely process at work here. I still contend that the dents themselves are the mark of a hack, You could hit that piece a heavy blow and leave hardly a mark. It takes a special lack of skill to leave those marks. However, the fact that something makes no sense does not mean it didn't happen. We only have the evidence we have, and little real ability to conclude any particular way.

Re: Hey, Adam

#57

Re: What I'm talking about

ThomD

>It is kinda funny the dents don't affect the tenon. There could be a number of reasons, one possible one is they were pre-existing and they were not sufficient reason to disgard the piece of wood. Another would be that the damage was trimmed away, though there are reasons to not believe that.

Re: Hey, Adam

#58

Re: Heros

ThomD

>Heard and interview tonight with a guy who is 104 or 105, and wants to deliver the first pitch at a Socks game. He is practicing every day, and trying to qualify. Not sure that is exactly heroic, but it's noteworthy.

Re: Hey, Adam

#59

Re: What I'm talking about

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have to agree with Joel, this is just too easy a problem to repair quickly, why wasn't that done? Most of the early hammers I have seen have octagonal faces, so the wood blossom would look different than these perfectly round marks.

If it is indeed a masterpiece then scientific analysis in a good conservation laboratory could determine if the chair had been repaired.

But I also know that this is not the 'money side' of the chair and the attention to detail is almost always on that side, not the sides that don't show.

Stephen

Re: Hey, Adam

#60

Re: What I'm talking about

Paul Kierstead

>On a dining chair, is not the back the money side? It isn't clear the intended use of the chair.

Re: Hey, Adam

#61

Re: A bit harsh I think...

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>I have a few thoughts. I would assume that the client ordered six or eight chairs, not one. Maybe he had a function he needed the chairs for and there was a hard deadline. Also, using heat to repair those hammer blows would have also affected the hide-glued-joint. Most of the chairs looked great, the cure might have been worse than the affliction and the commission was due to deliver now. Voila, one acceptable, though less than perfect chair.

Having studied history in grad school when I was younger, I can affirm without doubt that our forebears had different attitudes about almost everything. Making assumptions about the past based on our values and attitudes leads to false conclusions. If I were building a cathedral that started out in the Romanesque style, I certainly wouldn't have finished it in Gothic. But that's exactly how it was done in many places in Europe. Why? Because it took 150 years to finish the thing and the master mason at the end of the project knew how to build properly with flying buttresses. Didn't match? Why should that matter? But it would matter to a modern. Cherubini is asking correctly, "What mattered to the craftsman then?" Maybe he has come up with the wrong answer, but the question is correctly asked.

Re: Hey, Adam

#62

Re: What I'm talking about

Dean J in MN

>Paul asks: On a dining chair, is not the back the money side? It isn't clear the intended use of the chair.

Chairs, from what I've seen in Sheraton's (or was it Hepplewhite?) book, were pushed up against the walls of the room when not in use. So the backs are not seen as often as the fronts. Even the dining tables shown in those two books were well suited to be modular and pushed out of the way when not in use.

-Dean

Re: Hey, Adam

#63

Re: A bit harsh I think...

ThomD

>"Maybe he has come up with the wrong answer, but the question is correctly asked."

He has come up with the Adam like answer. We sorta knew what the answer would be based on the teacher in question, which is also something I remember well from university history.

Re: Hey, Adam

#64

Re: What I'm talking about

Paul Kierstead

>In most museum room restorations I have seen (where they present a room as it was x years ago) they have been typically pushed up against the wall as well. However, all of those places have been *extremely* swank, and the rooms always struck me like those interior living magazines; places that don't really exist, at least as presented.

I wonder, did they really push the dining room chairs up against the wall? One thing for sure, though, they did use individual chairs (dining room style we'll say) a lot more for general seating, against walls or mid room. I see that even in my grand parents generation.

Re: Hey, Adam

#65

Re: What I'm talking about

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Oh, yeah, those southern boys and I never saw eye to eye on anything beyond cordiality; although the few of them with whom I worked became my best friends until we moved so far away, and all in all, they are good people. :) I moved to DC as soon as possible.

Pam

Re: Hey, Adam

#66

Re: A bit harsh I think...

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

>Thom, I think you demonstrate a good lesson on objectivity in history. It lies in the whole, not the individual work.

Re: Hey, Adam

#67

Furniture at rest

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Again we have a different idea of what a dining room table should look like with the table set and all the chairs. Actually in earlier times the table was set and the chairs placed all around when they ate.

When they were not eating, a lot of the time, the furniture was put 'at rest' against the walls, so the money side showed with the chairs against the wall.

People also spent a lot less time in their houses, they cooked, ate and slept there, but most of there activity was not necessarily in the house. And a lot of houses were smaller so rooms were used for multiple purposes.

Stephen

Re: Hey, Adam

#68

Re: What I'm talking about

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I should have read your post first Dean, before I responded, but what you said.

Stephen

Re: Hey, Adam

#69

Re: What I'm talking about

John W

>I think it is short sighted to say the tenon has never been out. I say this because I know of several craftsmen today who could do such a repair in a manner that it is undetectable. And there were a lot more talented craftsman repairing these chairs 150 years ago. Here is a link to an article in the NYT about such workmanship today and how it has fooled experts. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/22/garden/22hobbs.html?_r=1&oref=slogin

I have seen and worked on many antiques and while one doesn't often see hammer marks these dents are really trivial. If they were done when the chair was new, they wouldn't show as much as they do now as they wouldn't have the "patina" in the recess. And as low on the leg as they are, I doubt if someone standing would have noticed them. Also, keep in mind the lighting of the time. And as Dean pointed out most of the time the chair would have been placed against a wall.

However, for a much more glaring example of a mistake being let out of the shop in the 18th C. I remembered an article in Home Furniture Spring 1995 where Allan Breed tells of making a reproduction of the John Goddard Newport Secretary that sold for $12.1 million in 1989. He examined, measured, and took photos of it before it sold. He states that the maker was human, and he made a few mistakes. One was that he planed a little too deeply on the upper door stiles and exposed the mortises for the rail tenons. The holes were filled with glue and sawdust. They were also 8 feet off the ground. This was the most expensive piece of furniture to be sold when it was auctioned in 1989. It was also most likely the most expensive piece of furniture available in RI when it was made.

This mistake however did not affect it's value either time it was sold.

I don't really understand Adam's quest to find "flaws" in old furniture. Even the very best cabinetmakers were human and could not turn out flawless work every time. Who would expect anything else? Their customers knew and accepted this. What we think today really doesn't matter and it is so many years past us that it is folly for us to try to judge it. For anyone who works with antique furniture and is also aware of today's reproduction furniture it is obvious that there are 2 standards for the 2 markets. The makers of the antique and today�s furniture produce what the customer will buy and pay for. Today's furniture has to be perfect and flawless inside and out in the customers eyes. They have been trained to demand it. Character to one person is a flaw to another.

Re: Hey, Adam

#70

Re: Absurdity

Larry Williams

>Warren,

What I find absurd is Adam's assertion that the photo is causing some kind of "push-back." It's not the photo, it's his interpretation of what is in the photo. There are so many questions about this that were never asked. How many chairs from the set exist? Who says it's the master piece Adam claims? When was it made? Where? By who? What kind of provenance does the chair have. What does the rest of the chair look like? The list goes on and on.

Re: Hey, Adam

#71

Harsh?

Larry Williams

>John,

You start by saying, "I don't think Adam is arguing that sloppy work was encouraged, or even necessarily condoned universally..."

I don't know about "encouraged" or "condoned" but, having read his articles and quite a number of his Internet posts, the underlying theme I find in his writing is that in the early 18th Century they wouldn't or couldn't do any better. There are so many examples I could cite but it wouldn't do any good--as is his usual behavior, he's tossed a bomb into a forum and walked away.

Re: Hey, Adam

#72

Question for Warren

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Warren,

As is typical of your posts, there is a lot said in a few words. Because of your long experience observing period furniture, I wonder if you would expand a bit. Two things in particular caught my attention:

"Nobody would have thought these scars were original if they had not been just one of many similar occurrences which together form a picture of attitudes of the time."

and

"I see stuff all the time and find myself thinking that would not have flown in the 18th century. Likewise I see on 18th century pieces things that were disparaged in the 20th century."

Question: What do you see in 18th century American work that illustrates some differences in values between then and more recent times? I'm asking about imperfections that passed muster in 18th century America (and wouldn't in the 20th), but also things that the 18th century folks put higher value on than 20th century folks did.

Your commentary would be much appreciated by all.

Wiley

Re: Hey, Adam

#73

Re: Question for Warren

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Eighteenth century craftsman were much less concerned with covering their tracks. There are tool marks, evidence of how it was done, everywhere. They were also much less ashamed of the occasional misstep. A single over run saw kerf illustrates that they did their work in a matter-of-fact attitude not as fussy as some today, and not ashamed of their mistakes. Not that the work was sloppy, just not obsessed with covering up. Today workers have a whole repertoire of cover up techniques.

Here is an example which I hope generates less controversy. In curved inlay work you can often see where the guy put his compass point. Right on the face of the showiest part of his work, still visible 250 years later. No shame, no effort to cover up. Today some suggest a temporary block for the point to avoid scarring. It would not surprise me to see a gadget marketed to use to avoid what seemed natural in the 18th century.

The things I am most critical of in today's reproductions are style and crispness. Pieces with much sanding lose their refinement and look doughy. Some of the biggest flaws I see are in curves. Just a slight alteration and the curve loses its emotional impact, its charm or its warmth or its loveliness or its exuberance or its vitality. I think that if you are not thinking in these terms you are missing something that was very dear to the 18th century craftsman.

Re: Hey, Adam

#74

Re: Question for Warren

Kevin Adams

>Very well said, Warren. Thanks for answering as you did and thanks to Wiley for asking. We appreciate the contributions you make to this and other handtool-oriented forums. I would sure like to figure out a way to visit your shop at some point.

Kevin

Re: Hey, Adam

#75

Re: Question for Warren

Dean J in MN

>Thank you Warren! Great insights there.

I'm not ashamed of my drawer dovetail kerfs running well into the rear face of the drawer front. Seems there are those workers today who go through various gyrations to avoid that issue. I appreciate the tool marks left behind, my very favorite piece in our local museum has a marking knife slip near the dovetail in the drawer divider. The very same slip I've made. I visit that piece and feel right at home with it.

-Dean