Re: re: that much force in that area...
ThomD
>"And maybe it was made by an apprentice. The tenon in question was a hard one to cut properly..."
It was harder to learn to walk than it was to run let' say. Today doing either one is no difference. These ideas are irrelevant to someone who is competant.
"the cant of the back legs, and the angle of the side pieces made for a compound cutting angle, and those can be a hassle to lay out and cut if you're still learning."
I know this isn't your contention, but I heard someone say this chair was a masterpiece which means it wasn't done by a hack, by definition. In reality I would accept that different hands of different abilities may have worked on it. In an open shop though hammering like a madman, doing a stupid fix on a piece that had consumed some carvers time would not be wise. If the joint doesn't fit there are better fixes particularly with hot glue.
"So if the joint in the picture was off by a hair or two and got stuck during assembly, it makes sense to me that someone would go out of their way to drive the joint all the way home while the glue is still in a forgiving mood."
I have done that, but then I don't like dry fitting, even on one-offs I have never made anything the like of before. Hardly the likely process at work here. I still contend that the dents themselves are the mark of a hack, You could hit that piece a heavy blow and leave hardly a mark. It takes a special lack of skill to leave those marks. However, the fact that something makes no sense does not mean it didn't happen. We only have the evidence we have, and little real ability to conclude any particular way.