Hey, Adam
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>The Woodresource interviewer pronounced the first syllable of your name "ker." Is this correct, or should it be "cher" as in cherry?
Pam
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hey, Adam
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>The Woodresource interviewer pronounced the first syllable of your name "ker." Is this correct, or should it be "cher" as in cherry?
Pam
Re: Hey, Adam
Adam Cherubini
>Kay roo bee nee
Che is KAY in Italian. I may be the only member of my family that pronounces our name this way. But then I speak Italian and not everyone else does.
Adam
What did you think?
Adam Cherubini
>What did you think of the interviews? I couldn't hear Craig super well. Schwarz is really good at interviews, so his was great. But I liked John Economaki's a lot.
These interviews are neat, I think. Kinda like a chat where you don't have to type. And though mine was very long, it was nice to discuss stuff in depth. It was also cool to be interviewed by someone who is a woodworker and very informed. So I didn't feel as though I had to be brief or dumb down what I wanted to say. I assumed he would edit out the drivel, but I think it's kinda cool that he left it in.
And anytime you can poke fun at Schwarz is good.
Adam
Re: Hey, Adam or Pam
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>Or someone. Please repost the link. Now that I have an hour, I can't find it to click on it. Thanks very much!
Wiley
Re: Hey, Adam or Pam *LINK*
Adam Cherubini
>
woodworkers resource link
Most enjoyable!
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>One of the things I like best about Adam's interview is that he doesn't offer short answers to the questions. His answers, almost without exception, are discussions of context and connections between things.
I especially enjoyed his remarks about (what else!) 18th century matters. In answer to a question about differences in tool availability then versus now, Adam thought one of the biggest differences was the relative scarcity of sharpening abrasives in the old days (he particularly mentioned the scarcity of coarse abrasives). I thought that was fascinating--one could imagine for example that dulling a plane because the sawcut was offline would have been thought ill of. If sharpening is an issue, then getting it right with the first tool would have been important--well, that's my take anyway.
Wiley
Re: What did you think?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>I thought it was an hour well spent. I loved your comments on our FOUNDING FATHERS (I, too, think they were, as we are, self-serving hypocrites), wages in Philadelphia, your common sense examination of documentation (good point about light duration in Philly), and your analog of 18th century Philly to current day India.
The only thing that tasted a bit sour was your claim that you didn't want to make tools, but were doing so merely to prod manufacturers. I believe that you think you don't want to make tools.
Pam
Re: What did you think?
Adam Cherubini
>I don't think I called our founding fathers "self serving hypocrites". But it's important to see them for who they really were. Call it spin, but you could say their efforts were all the more noble because the world they lived in was so unfair and hierarchal. If we were half what they were, our world would be a better place.
I'd just like to enlighten you to one institution that one of our founding father came up with that we have somehow let die. It was developed in the early 18th c by Benjamin Franklin. It was called "The Every Night Club". How it worked was important discussions like this one were discussed at length in a pub, get this now... every night. I think we should reform it Pam. You and I can be the first members. Maybe you can talk to your friends at Google and work on using paypal to download beer. I'll bet if we work really hard, (okay not so hard) we can get The Schwarz to join us.
Adam
Re: What did you think?
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>No, "self serving hypocrites" was my summation of what you said, and was the content as I heard it. I also appreciate what they did, amazing; but I'm real tired of all the worship lately, perhaps because we're so lacking in current day heroes? Perhaps because the things they missed/glossed over have rent our society? Perhaps because there are just too many people (btw, white westerners are actually depopulating)?
I used to go to pubs most every night after work in DC to have such discussions, had/made great friends, some great conversation. Only problem is that if all one does is talk.... :)
I suspect that there are serious online political groups; but if you want to start one (some sort of politics in woodworking?), I'll join in happily.
Pam
Re: What did you think?
Ace Karner
>Any chance a Moderator could put a stop to this Hate America speech and get us back to talking about woodworking.
No
Adam Cherubini
>Pam doesn't hate America. Don't put that out there. Listen to the interview and you'll understand what we're talking about. It really is topical.
I think folks have glossed over 18th c furniture the same way we've glossed over our founding fathers. This is especially poignant because in this instance, the furniture evokes the period which evokes the founders. Some folks seem to want both to be something they weren't (and I think for the same reason).
I'm just reviewing a new batch of pictures from the museum. Just shocking to see the care they took for some things, and how little care for others. I don't see this sort of thing in the (for lack of a better term) "mainstream press". You see all this stuff glossed over or skipped. I think there's an editorial effort there.
I don't want it to be my crusade to convince people that Thomas Jefferson really did father children with a slave he owned. It's a sociological quagmire. Reproduction furniture makers often don't like the images of furniture I have in iPhoto. When I share them, they reject them, say it's atypical, or misattributed. Very similar issues. If you aren't steeped in period furniture making, the political half of this discussion can be really helpful in understanding what I'm talking about.
I'm just trying to look at stuff for what it is. I look at my wife and kids with my heart, but I try to use my eyes for everything else. It's surprisingly difficult.
Listen to the interview then decide if what is written here is inappropriate.
Adam
Re: No
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Thanks, Adam, you've stated my position, too, very well. I love what I think America can become; but as one who's only been able to peep over the wall, I have a very different opinion of what America is. I want what America is for so many, no hate involved.
As to furniture and how it was made, I find your investigations and analyses intriguing and valuable.
The characterization of my attitude voiced by Ace is what I've long called intentionally ignorant, a knee jerk reaction. No one here wants to hear my knee jerk reaction. In fact, everyone should stop and try to think before knee jerking in public.
Pam
Re: No
Ace Karner
>I understand what you had to say that relates to the 18th Century workers and live styles as it pertained to the furniture being made at the time. This I find relevant to a woodworking forum.
Talk about our current politics and world over population have no place here and I stand by that.
Re: No
Ace Karner
>If the shoe fits
Ah, geesh, it's hopeless
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Are we now going to hear "love it or leave it?"
Pam
This conversation could degenerate quickly
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>While I agree that Pam did bring in some current political issues, I think to characterize what she said as "hate America" is wrong, and attack language. Our individual attitudes toward our countries (plural because this is an international forum) are not simple either/or attitudes. Best to take this conversation off line or let it go, I think.
Moderation lite--please continue
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>Dear Forum Folks,
Adam has hit exactly the right note. If you listen to the interview, I think most will agree that the points Adam made are eminently worth discussing. For those who haven't listened to the interview yet, Adam did touch on the sociology of early America. That subject evokes many deeply felt sentiments among us, relating to what America means to us. So then we have the feelings posted by Pam, and then Ace.
The forum needs to have a way to discuss early Americana and the sociology of work and tools --because that _was_ the heyday of handtools--and not lapse into hate talk. We need to be able to have and express a variety of opinions, and disagree while preserving dignity. Here's how we do that....We don't do name-calling. When Ace said that Pam hates America, that's name calling. When Pam said that Ace is doing knee-jerk, that's name calling. Please don't do that. It causes outrage, including among the readers, and diverts us from a good discussion.
Please continue.
Wiley
Re: This conversation could degenerate quickly
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>It's done, Bill, I'll never read another of "Ace's" postings, he can say whatever he wants with none of my interference.
Pam
Re: Moderation lite--please continue
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>OK, Wiley, so I'm in the middle of a discussion with Adam and someone accuses me of hating america. What precisely do you propose I do? Ignore it? Silence is implied consent.
Pam
Re: Moderation lite--please continue
Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX
>Oh, that's right, I'm a woman, I'm not supposed to be here or doing woodworking, that's why no one accused Adam of hating america. Right, Ace?
Pam
Hope this helps
Wiley Horne--So. Calif
>Pam, I think I can explain. Here was your initial response to Ace's 'Pam hates America' statement:
"Thanks, Adam, you've stated my position, too, very well. I love what I think America can become; but as one who's only been able to peep over the wall, I have a very different opinion of what America is. I want what America is for so many, no hate involved.
As to furniture and how it was made, I find your investigations and analyses intriguing and valuable.
The characterization of my attitude voiced by Ace is what I've long called intentionally ignorant, a knee jerk reaction. No one here wants to hear my knee jerk reaction. In fact, everyone should stop and try to think before knee jerking in public. "
Now. Your first paragraph deserves a standing O. Your second paragraph is of course fine. But then the third paragraph is a straightforward name-calling attack on Ace. So you're asking me what you should have done, and the answer is that you had already done it in paragraph 1 and it could not have been done with greater dignity by anyone.
Wiley
Re: Moderation lite--please continue
Ace Karner
>Can't see a reason to reply Pam since you won't be reading it anyway.
What I'm talking about
Adam Cherubini
>This chair has got to be one of the finest that existed in the third quarter of the 18th c in ANY colony. It's a masterpiece. But somehow the maker felt these hammer marks were okay. Obviously the mortise was tight and the maker decided (wisely) to hit the back of the chair instead of the front. This chair probably retailed for close to 2 weeks wages, likely one of the most expensive chairs in the colonies. But this hammer mark was fine.
How are we to understand this? Would you deliver a chair like this to a customer? I certainly wouldn't. The answer suggests a significant difference of opinion to what makes something great. I think there are more than a few Americans who are ashamed of Jefferson's alleged relationship with Sally Hemmings. But was he ashamed? I don't think he was. This was just the world he lived in. And that tells me just how little we really understand about our own ancestors' values.
Adam
Re: What I'm talking about
Joel
>Adam,
I don't actually disagreed with some of your conclusions but in this case how do you know the dents are original? The hammer marks aren't on the exposed tenon but the tenon also seems to not fit correctly. Also why would a metal hammer been used in the first place. While You can give me an argument that the hammer marks are original, I think a pretty persuasive argument can be made that the hammer marks are the result of an old repair. - something that isn't too unusual in old furniture.
This can turn your interpretation on end because one could suggest that if one feels that colonial work wasn't as prefectionist as it could be then these hammer marks reenforce that theory. If on the other hand one feels that master craftsmen wouldn't ship dented furniture in the first place then this is obviously a repair.
Actually, now that I finished this post and have given it a few more seconds thought - my question is that a dent like this is trivial to remove with a wet rag and a hot poker - a very old technique, - so if it was original and done under the finish is would have been removed. so I'm betting (considering the tenon repair also) it's not original.
Re: What I'm talking about
Adam Cherubini
>Tenon has never been out. This chair has no evidence of repairs. As you will soon find out in my column, the tenons were wedged here 98% of the time when new. Saw cuts were made the full length of the tenon about 1/4" from top and bottom, and wedges, maybe 3/16" at the back end, were driven in. The wedges go about half the length of the tenon. This is all by design. See my Dec column when it comes out.
The tenon's not been touched which is how we know it's original. This isn't my "expert" opinion. It's the real experts' opinion. I'm just the messenger. Looks like this guy really did hit this chair.
Adam