We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'll wait until your column comes out. Of course you got me curious because the quality of American furniture - like product quality everywhere depends on the wealth and priorities of the customer base. So I am looking forward to finding out more about the specific piece.
Incidently I highly recommend Ben Franklin's autobiography to anyone who is interested in the period. He's a real interesting guy, his sense of civic responsibility is impressive, and his descriptions of his life very interesting.
>"This was just the world he lived in. And that tells me just how little we really understand about our own ancestors' values."
Also, now that I am 49, I stand in memory of people born, say, in 1895, that I knew as a child, my parents born in the 1925s and still living. And I know they looked at things very differently than people born since them, in some cases, can even conceive of. So going back 230 years or whatever, not even a hope.
Also someone mentioned heros. In the life of a nation one can only have heros of the birth of a nation once. To state the obvious. I suppose on could say that if one didn't have them they would need to be invented, though in the American case that may truly not have been necesarry. In any case, people do heroic things all the time, it's like miracles they are all around us. I would imagine most people do something heroic in their lifetimes.
>Even if those hammer marks were left by the original maker, you're making a huge assumption. I don't see how you can say the maker didn't care. I doubt anyone knows what happened there but are there hammer marks on the other side? You know, there have been a couple times I decided to make a last minute fix or adjustment to minor flaw on a project only to make things worse. I remember one instance where I didn't have a choice after a flubbed minor fix and delivered the project as it was. I was heart sick about it but I didn't have an option.
It reminds me of the patched dovetail you once showed on your blog and used it as an example of how the maker didn't care. If the maker hadn't cared, he wouldn't have tried to repair the damn thing.
> I think there are more than a few Americans who are ashamed of Jefferson's alleged relationship with Sally Hemmings. But was he ashamed? I don't think he was. This was just the world he lived in. And that tells me just how little we really understand about our own ancestors' values.
The world we live in allows all sorts of rape, pillage, honor killings, slavery, and other vicious manifestations. Make of that what you will.
He almost certainly considered Sally a guilty treat, otherwise we'd have heard of their relationship in his journals, letters, etc.
England outlawed slavery in 1807, which was Jefferson's second to last year in office. It must have been a topic of conversation for years before.
And yet, he had a beautiful house, founded an excellent university (although I wasn't allowed to attend even though my parents paid taxes to support it), did a fine turn as president, and I still admire most of what he did.
>If Jefferson's relationship to Sally Hemmings was kind of accepted by him and it wasn't worth a story on "la une" of journals, then maybe because one made a clear distinction between one man's profession and its personal life... Take a look over the pond now. France's Sarkozy divorced and married to a model shortly after having been elected. It has come to no doubt in his political abilities therefore. In Europe there is more acceptance of what a statesman is sensed to do. Or should I say tolerance?
Now coming to the two hammer blows on that chair. After having applied a finish on the chair, a repair by the craftsman could have turned out to worsen the spot. Maybe or maybe not. That's not the point. Those blows can't pull down his skills. He put all these efforts, all this knowledge and all this craftsmanship into that piece. And you can see that looking at each side. I'm sure there is no scar of his on the front. Those blows will definitely not affect his expertise. I understand him and the damage wouldn't worship me.
So, looking from here and considering our common roots, traditions and habits, the question is: Where do you go?
Adam, would it be possible to you to show us the whole chair?
Marc
p.s. going downstairs and looking for dings in my self made furniture :-)
>It would be hard to give an opinion on the hammer marks without the chair in hand. But I must agree with Adam's premise that 18th century workers cared about very different things than workers today. Many of today's workers and owners, more concerned with a flawless presentation than a stylish one, think that their reproductions are equal or better than the originals. Sadly their stuff often misses the mark.
If I were evaluating someone's efforts at a reproduction chair, hammer marks on the back would be the least of my worries.
What we know for certain is that the marks are there now and we think they were left by the original builder.
What I know is that if I did this sort of work at the College of the Redwoods, or North Bennet Street School, I probably wouldn't get many slaps on the back. Garret Hack protects his workbench top from glue drips with brown craft paper that he keeps neatly rolled up for the purpose. Would he look on admiringly as I whacked a chippendale chair with a metal hammer? You get mad at me when I leave a little tear out on a not so visible surface.
You're right this could have been an apprentice's worst mistake. He could have been busted up over this. For me this conversation is just about seeing the furniture for what is really is, not what we think it is or what we want it to be.
>If a student did something like that where I studied (or anywhere else I would guess) the teacher would use it as a chance to show how to get rid of dents.
It's also pretty common to make students work to a high standard so they don't start out sloppy.
But outside in the production work, where chairs like this would have been made by the thousands, to a price and deadline is a different type of environment.
In the production shops of NYC where work of all levels is being done even a top shop will occasionally let stuff slide by because a client wants is NOW or some such thing.
>No Adam, I get mad because you seem oblivious to the culture of craftsmanship that develops in any good working environment. Does your attitude come from your engineer's background where every effort is made to remove the human element in a product, maybe a lack of professional experience in any trade? Screw-ups happen Adam but they're not something to celebrate or sprinkle liberally through a project.
>I love the imagery of that. WRONG AGAIN WILLIAMS! I keep my failure in a spray bottle. HA!
Seriously, I think you have the right idea. It's not so much about removing the human element. It's about removing ME. To do work like someone else, you sorta have to think like that person (or culture).
I don't mean this to be disrespectful- please don't take this the wrong way: We're not talking about kitchen cabinets here. We're way beyond basic craft. We're talking about copying someone else's art work, reproducing their attitudes, using their tools and approaches.
You have the last word. I'm going on vacation!
BTW, nothing to do with Larry, anyone else noticing the push back from this picture? Anyone else feeling it in the pit of their stomach?
>What I don't particularly get is what those dents are there for. I've done some bad things in my time, but I don't recall making any dents that look like that at all. They don't look like the normal marks of assembly or repair. If that is a steel hammer, I might not even have it on the bench when doing that kind of work. When working on guitars it is all too easy to fatally scratch something, or for that mater when doing contract work in someone's prissy house. A lot of time goes into cleaning up and putitng down drop cloths of surfacing. If this is a comon pattern of dents that would be one thing.
In any case I suppose it maters what one means by not carring there is plenty of evidence they didn't spend time on all surfaces equally so that shouldn't be a surprise. The approach where all surfaces are equally finished I think of as modern, and uncomon, at that.
As a guy who has done production work at times in a variety of fields, I am not inclined to the idea that carelessness is productive. When I look at those marks I ask myself why that was easier for someone to do, and there may be reasons. If it was an accident I want to know what he was doing applying that kind of force in the region, and how slipping up like that made life so much easier. If it was regular production on every chair or possibly just one stuck one, then it is a different series of questions. But the saying is that the shortest distance between two points is a straight line, not a squiggly one with several dents and glue drips.
similar to what a literature prof. once told me...
John in NM
>He was paraphrasing a philosopher who I've forgotten, but the gist was that works of art have an inherent contradiction of having to be able to stand on their own merits while still reflecting the time and society in which they were created. In many cases I think the same goes for period furniture, its just not as obvious.
Without being able to see the rest of the chair, I can't tell if there are stretchers involved or not. But I can say that having glued up chairs like that, it can get a little hairy. The ones we did at school had stretchers involved, which means you really have a lot of things going on at once, and a lot to align. Stretchers, side pieces... if you're smart, the front assembly is already together... but everything HAS to go all the way together, before the wedges go into that tenon.
Maybe the tenons fit a little too tightly and swelled up a hair before assembly. Or maybe it was the end of the day, and the glue pot had been going, and the glue was a little thicker than it should have been. But one way or another, those tenons have to seat all the way, becuase once the wedges go in, it's all a done deal. No room for gaps between the shoulders, or everything will get weird. So... if the hammer marks weren't from someone who was really missing the wedges, then it may very well have been someone who was half-panicked, and trying to get that one stupid joint to seat properly in time to get the wedges in.
The hammer strike may not have actually been the first thing to go wrong. But it's the visible evidence that we have.
>It's not the picture, Adam. It's the absurd assumption you draw from it. You take an anomaly and make it the rule. Then you make another idiotic assumption, that the photo is the problem, and say; "I'm done with this conversation, I'm outa here." Is that just your way of admitting you can't defend your narcissistic pronouncements?
>if the hammer marks were done while the piece was mostly assembled they would show on the mortise. they don't.
it's why I am suspicious. It's a trivial dent to repair, it wouldn't even be typical using a metal hammer on wood. Whether or not it is original is interesting but certainly its uniqueness suggests drawing any conclusion from it difficult.
Adam certainly wants to draw the conclusion that 18th century work was done fast, sloppy, and with a different criteria on neatness than we have today. The problem is that there are tons of examples to the contrary, and even (just to my less than complete knowledge) recorded complaints by craftsman in the early 19th century of how high the standard was.
>I'm probably missing something, but, ignoring this specific piece for the moment, it seems to me that Adam is saying that we treat antique furniture with too much preciousness and accede a few pieces too much influence and that these attitudes encourage us in turn to spend too much time trying to make perfect furniture.
Pam, who, knowing how much abuse a piece of furniture takes during its life, thinks it's very, very hard to attribute a couple of metal hammer marks to the maker with anything approaching certainty. But then, I'm no expert.
>Eighteenth century standards are very different from old-fashioned twentieth century craftsmanship. Not so much higher or lower as different. I see stuff all the time and find myself thinking that would not have flown in the 18th century. Likewise I see on 18th century pieces things that were disparaged in the 20th century.
Nobody would have thought these scars were original if they had not been just one of many similar occurrences which together form a picture of attitudes of the time. I'm not sure if I agree with Adam in this particular case. But I find it curious that you think it absurd.
>I think you meant to say that they would show on the tenon... since they do show around the mortise. And you're right... they would show, IF it was all the way together. If it wasn't, and someone was trying to persuade a stuck joint to come together before the glue had fully cured, it's a different story. And that could have been during assembly, or re-assembly by a repair speecialist.
I'm not asserting anything, I'm guessing. I'm just trying to say that I've had a few joints get stuck during glue-ups. And when time is an issue, extreme measures can come to mind. My guess is that they would normally use a padding block or something, and it slipped... and this is all conjecture, so who really knows.
And maybe it was made by an apprentice. The tenon in question was a hard one to cut properly... the cant of the back legs, and the angle of the side pieces made for a compound cutting angle, and those can be a hassle to lay out and cut if you're still learning. At school, we had a very bizarre jig to cut them on the table saw. I think the instructor figured it would be easier to refine a machine method for student use than to rely on student handwork to accurately cut a very critical, and visible joint. So if the joint in the picture was off by a hair or two and got stuck during assembly, it makes sense to me that someone would go out of their way to drive the joint all the way home while the glue is still in a forgiving mood. (No stretchers on this chair though, so some of my original statements go out the window.)
I'm not trying to make any claims about who's right, or what the proper assumption should be about when the dents were created. I've seen pictures of furniture where the back of the piece, which was assumed to rest against the wall, looked like someone had gotten bored while chainsawing... and left that way. And if it was something that wouldn't be seen, then in many cases it would be left that way. I've heard stories about chippendale chairs that still had rasp marks (or tool marks, there was some debate about the use of rasps) in upper nooks and crannies, since they wouldn't have been seen. This is a different story, though, since the dents are clearly visible.
You're right, or course, about the steaming method. Maybe whoever it was didn't want to call attention to the fact that he'd been making "elephant tracks." Or, maybe someone doing repairs had been watching antiques roadshow, and they were happier leaving hammer marks than messing with the original finish. No idea.
>Adam sez" This chair has got to be one of the finest that existed in the third quarter of the 18th c in ANY colony. It's a masterpiece. But somehow the maker felt these hammer marks were okay. Obviously the mortise was tight and the maker decided (wisely) to hit the back of the chair instead of the front. This chair probably retailed for close to 2 weeks wages, likely one of the most expensive chairs in the colonies. But this hammer mark was fine.
How are we to understand this? Would you deliver a chair like this to a customer? I certainly wouldn't. The answer suggests a significant difference of opinion to what makes something great. I think there are more than a few Americans who are ashamed of Jefferson's alleged relationship with Sally Hemmings. But was he ashamed? I don't think he was. This was just the world he lived in. And that tells me just how little we really understand about our own ancestors' values.
Adam "
If I understand this right The chair makers disregard for the dents and Jefferson's relationship with Sally Hemmings when taken as a whole show how we don't understand our ancestors values.
Since neither Adam or I really know how those dents got there I suggest that perhaps those dents occurred when the craftsman was finishing the glue up just as he heard someone on the street break the news about Jefferson's relationship and that he wasn't ashamed of it. At this time our craftsman who had the most unassailable values, became so upset that he banged on the chair in disgust with ole TJ.
Makes just a much sense to me as Adams thesis.
Hope I didn't offend anyones sensibilities with this reply.
>I don't think Adam is arguing that sloppy work was encouraged, or even necessarily condoned universally. His point is that mistakes happen, a glue up goes wrong, and there is not necessarily time to fix it and meet a production schedule. The owner of the shop may not even have known that mistakes were "fixed" in a way he might not approve of. What we frequently seem to forget is that modern furniture of this sort is an expensive, luxury item, and the standards for perfection are very high - because in our culture there are many alternatives in our market, each with its own level of quality and corresponding price. Most antique furniture was produced in a much tighter market, and though still producing luxury items, I think Adam is saying that the period shop was more like a modern cabinet or furniture factory than a contemporary "studio" shop.
I spent a couple years working in one such shop, one with a very good local reputation. In some areas it was deserved, in some it was not. The worst case I saw personally was staining over some exposed plywood where a $5/hour sanding employee had gone through some veneer. Two problems - it was going to be very, very difficult to replace the plywood, and second, the client was a huge pain and one of these guys who wants it now, or better yet, yesterday. So out it went. A huge gamble, that never came back to haunt the shop.
In the case of the chair pictured, I personally doubt that the provenance of the hammer marks is provable. But I could see the piece going out if they were original, and I could also see it being fixed, depends on the situation. And that's what's so interesting about it. Eighteenth century shops were perhaps not ivory towers populated by masters who only sent out the very best in furniture. They were running a business, just like many today. Making that business successful probably involved the ability to compromise just like today.
The implications of those marks are more interesting if they are original, and if so don't cut down the monument of antique furniture. Perhaps if they are original, it just means that the builder knew his client a lot better than any of us do, and he chose to gamble.
I don't think its Adam's intent to cut down or belittle historical furniture makers. I think he gets excited about some of these errors and fixes because it establishes a connection with a long dead craftsman. This guy was human too, he made the same sort of mistakes I've made - probably didn't make it more than two or three times before learning to avoid that particular one. I've never made a piece without something I'd have preferred to do better.
>At this time our craftsman who had the most unassailable values, became so upset that he banged on the chair in disgust with ole TJ.
Certainly as plausible as any other explanation I guess eh Ace. ;~)
My opinions are that the dents where made while trying assemble a too tight fitting joint.
Perhaps it was the last chair of a 12 piece set, it was late in the night of the promised delivery day, which, just by chance, was also the craftmans last day of work before retiring, the craftsman hadn't eaten all day, and the customer walked in and said "Are you done yet", and that was just as our hero was getting ready to pull the joint apart and do some more paring. Hammer is handy, and rather then throwing it at the PITA customer he took his frustrations out on the joint.
What we see today as a nice antique chair the craftsman saw as just another chair--at that particular moment anyhow.
I do think the dents are original, but would not be the norm to be let out of the shop on a visible surface.