Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Yard sale hand saw

Posts

Yard sale hand saw

#1

Yard sale hand saw

Ray Binnicker

>Bought an old hand saw this past week end; the only name on is on the large handle nut; "Warranted Superior". It has the nice old scroll handle, minor nicks and staining, all the teeth seem pretty much in tact; not a great find but for $3.00..... The real story comes today when a friend stops by the shop and sees the saw and says, "What is this little tip sticking up on the end of the blade"? I said, "well, I don't really know, but I know a dozen or so guys I'm willing to bet will give us a dozen or so different answers.

So, What is the nib on the old saws for?

Ray Binnicker

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#2

Well, my dad would have said it's to

Parisian, VL

>make little boys ask questions. But now that we are all grown and dad is long ago passed on, I haven't a clue.

Victor - in hot and humid Houston

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#3

Re: Yard sale hand saw

wilbur

>Hang on a second. I need to make a fresh batch of popcorn.

*pulls up a chair and relaxes*

:@)

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#4

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Ray,

It serves no particular purpose other than decoration..

Marv

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#5

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>pass the popcorn, this could be a very long thread....

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#6

Re: Yard sale hand saw

MikeW

>Nah, Marv answered the question.

Now, where's ... that popcorn.

Take care, Mike

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#7

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Ray,

To save a little time here...BTW...it's commonly referred to as a Nib.

These are the various reason for it according to various opinions.

1- It's a sight for lining up a cut.

2- It's for holding a tooth guard on with the use a a string or cord.

3- It was done to break up the straight line of the top of the blade.

4- It's used to start a saw cut.

5- It's to let the user know when to stop the back stroke.

6- It's for decoration. The other 5 reasons are not logical, so I choose this one.

Marv

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#8

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Wait a sec, I want to grab another beer before the show starts...

Ok, on with the show:)

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#9

No, No, No, it's for....

Neal in San Jose

>They knew that these saws would eventually become collector's items, and they put the nib on so that collectors would have something to get excited about when the nib survived for 100 years or more.

I also know where socks go when they disappear out of the dryer.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#10

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Andrew Lunn

>Here's another one Marv.

7. It was used to test the hardness of the blades. This is why some nibs are missing, because they were snapped off at the factory to test the blade. I think it might have been on the Old Tools list where I saw this one referenced recently.

I also think it was for decoration.

Now for the beer and popcorn. No really. I'm going to go have some beer and popcorn.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#11

Ah, Ray -- your poor devil

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>This question comes up with some regularity, so those members of this group who spend WAY too much time here are giving you a hard time...

Marv's last response is the most comprehensive, although he left out that, if you put the top of the handle against your cheekbone, point the sawblade at Polaris, and sight along the blade, the nib will help you find true north.

It seems most likely to have been a decorative feature, like the wheat carving you find on some later saw handles; and, indeed, it is kind of a nice little fillip on the end of the blade.

For modern practical purposes, it does help you spot good saws in the saw pile at garage sales.

By the way, "Warranted Superior" seems to have been, like "cast steel," a marketing message that meant, "This is a good saw." Doesn't represent any particular company. I once asked whether the presence of this medallion indicated that there are saws out there that are "warranted mediocre" - not to my surprise, I've never found any with such medallions.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#12

I'm with Bob...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>'nother cold one and pass the popcorn. Anybody have some Peanuts?

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#13

The nib is used to start a kerf

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>As for decoration, it is not very decorative. Here is an illustration from Rural Carpenter's World by Wayne Franklin, an interesting read, this illustration is facinating.

Using the reflection in a bright saw, it can be used to scribe a straight line across a board, the reflections line up. After scribing, the saw is drawn back with the thumb as a reference to make a nick in the edge of the board to start the cut.

A nicker nib, pass the popcorn and peanuts, I have my own beer.

Stephen


img

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#14

Hold on, I just checked with Alf and

Parisian, VL

>someone posted comment to her blog that it was used to scratch one's A**e. True. :>)

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#15

Somebody want to try these macadamian?

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#16

Re: The nib is used to start a kerf

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Stephen, what's the date on the book? While this seems like a very good use for a nib, it doesn't mean that's why the nib was originally found on saws, it only means that someone found a good use for it. I wonder what the oldest saw or illustration or reference to one is for the nib? Now, if I only could find out why there are teets on a bull.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#17

Sure! Love em!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#18

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Wiley Horne--So. Calif

>Well, lessee.....If you knew you were going to notch the back of a saw plate down near the end, then you'd realize that stress cracks could form and propagate from the interior corner of the notch. So then you might say, 'we'll just put a little fillet in there to cover that inside corner and spread the stress so as to avoid stress cracks'. Course that doesn't explain why the desire to notch the back of the saw. Unless it's like Henry Disston said, for decoration.

No, no...I have it now. The nib is where the sawsmith would mic the saw plate after it came out of the grinding machine, to check that the double taper is within spec.

Wiley

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#19

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Bob Demers

>Oh Oh here we go again...

You had to ask didnt you? :-)

Bob, ducking and running for cover

PS check out this latest pot stirring results on this very subject on the old tool list

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#20

Warran and Ted Superior *LINK*

Bob Demers

>Tongue in cheek

But if you check out the Disstonian site, under the 'Medallions' entry, at the bottom of the page there is a very good explanation of the use of Warranted Superior medallions found on numerous saws

Bob, slowly dragging his b... to work


Saws medallions and Warranted superior

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#21

This one is as much fun as

Dan Donaldson

>Pins or tails first ;-)

To Ray, this one is controversial and no one really knows for sure.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#22

Re: Well, my dad would have said it's to

Rob Lee

>Hi Victor -

Had to laugh at that ....

Dad has a brass letter "Q" on the door leading to the stairs down to his shop...

If you ask - he'll tell you it's there to make people ask questions....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#23

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Dean J in MN

>Ray -

The nib did it's job. It was intended purpose was to have shop visitors ask "What is this little thing on the end of the saw for?"

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#24

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Andrew,

How are those beautiful saws you make coming along? Rumor has it that you are becoming a Blacksmith and are the proud owner of a brand new Rathole anvil.

Ok, here's the real purpose for the nib...

On Disston saws for example, it was for the purpose of quickly identifying their high end saws. They only included it on their #7,#8,#9,#12 & #99 and maybe a couple others. It is only found on straight back saws, never on a skew back. The #8 in this list is identical to the #7 except it has an applewood handle instead of Beech as all #7,s have. This #8 is not to be confused with the D8.

During the early 1930,s when Disston was attempting to lower manufacturing costs, they discontinued the nib on all their saws. During those years, they weren't actually making any high end saws. All their saws became cheaper and more junky looking as time went by, right up to the time when H.K. Porter bought them out in 1955. Porter knew nothing about making handsaws and managed to somehow make even worse saws.

Marv

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#25

Cuts drag / friction . . .

steve mackay

>much the same as a Stanley "C" plane. Sadly, these great leaps in our understanding of the physical universe have been lost in the mists of passing time. One day these principles will be re-discovered and the understanding of the handsaw nib and corrugated hand plane soles will enable us to reach the stars !