Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Yard sale hand saw

Posts

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#26

Close

Kevin French

>Very close Neal, your on the right track there.

It's so collectors can see at a distance of 15-20' that someone is about to make a VERY big mistake by dropping one into the metal dumpster at the Transfer Station.

Now THAT's what I call 'Forethought'.

28" #9 circa 1880's, w/a partial label

Can a fell'a get some extra butter on that popcorn and I have a couple spare beers, (don't tell SWMBO)

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#27

Re: The nib is used to start a kerf

BobStrawn

>Looking up the meaning of NIB, and ignoring the acronym references to Black Sabbath and National Industries for the Blind, you come up with some fairly old meanings.

A Bill, Beak, Pen tip, sharp point or protrusion. So probably, from the meaning of nib, but not definitely, it was intended as a way of scribing the first cut. When you add to that, many satisfied customers for the starting a cut with a nib, you combine some convenience with nomenclature and this increases the odds of it being right.

Since a lot of folk carry the wisdom of not pulling a push saw to superstitious extremes, I can easily see where a pull stroke marker on the back of a saw might allow those with curmudgeon's for employers to avoid ever pulling a push saw.

Most of us have seen curmudgeons use good wisdom as all encompassing law to the detriment of function. While I personally don't want to sharpen a point on the back edge of my saws, I do like to use a Ryoba so I can see a certain conflict in my own opinions.

So, Steve, if it makes you happy to continue using an actual ancient method(that much is pretty much true), that may or may not have been an official method, that is so obscure that the great saw manufacturers of old had no opinion on it, I think that we can give you permission to do so.

Even if you can historically prove that that is what the nib is for, I will not be changing my methods of work.

If however the angels come down from on high and declare for me that that is what I should use a nib for, and that I should never ever push a saw blade the wrong way, since it makes angels cry, I will change my methods of work.

After that, every time I use the silly nib to start a cut, I will, however, wonder how Steve managed to get the angels to play along with him.

Bob

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#28

Re: The nib is used to start a kerf

Dean J in MN

>I'll second the request for the date on that book.

I just can't square in my mind what is wrong with starting a cut using that row of perfectly good (and sharp) teeth on the correct side of the saw? Further, holding any of my saws upside down isn't the most comfortable thing. As well, why don't we see these on backsaws -- aren't backsaws used for "accurate" cutting after all? As for decoration and "not being very decorative" I ask -- what is the birds beak on the handle for? What is the bead and beak for?

I'm looking at the saw in Moxon -- it has a pretty little deal on the toe. Yet no mention of it even being called a nib. Using the definition of nib == sharp point is begging the question, as nib also can mean a projecting part.

But boy, is it a fun topic!

-Dean

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#29

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Ray Binnicker

>Thanks guys !!!!! You did not disappoint me !!! You are the greatest !!!!! I only wish we were ALL sitting in my shop right now coming up with all these answers.

Now, what can I come up with to stir the pot???

Ray

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#30

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Ray,

Leave the stirring to us, we are good at it. This thread could continue on for days....*grin*

So tell us, will you be using your nib to start a kerf? How big is your nib? Is it a skinny one or is it wider at that bottom so it won't break off while using it for what it wasn't intended to be used for? Do you like the looks of your nib and do you consider it decorative and perhaps even a thing of beauty? Has your wife seen it, and if so, what does she think of it? Ok, you don't have to answer that last question. *smirk*

Does your saw have an etch or other markings on the blade that might include the maker's name? Lots of saw makers used the Warranted Superior medallion, even Disston used that type medallion on some of their cheaper saws but never on a saw with a nib. Disston made that type medallion and sold them to other saw makers.

Marv

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#31

Re: Yard sale hand saw

MikeW

>Hey Ray...start a thread--any thread--with "What's best to ... " as the thread title.

Like, what's the best way to sharpen. Please leave the title and post with specific information as to what you actually want to sharpen. Then you'll get page-long response of the shotgun approach. And some will get in a huff and perhaps come down on you for lacking critical information. Then some will step in to defend you, and then ... well, you get the picture.

Dovetails: pins/tails first. This one has gotten a bit too much play, but it too is worth a shot.

Glue strength and or clamping pressure.

Oh, fixing up vintage planes, carving saw handles, cleaning vintage woodies and or metal planes to look like new. The list can get long.

All of them can gain legs at various times.

Have fun! Mike

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#32

Looks to me like...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>He (or she) is just using the saw as straight edge.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#33

A few more.....

Dave Anderson NH

>Some other pot stirrers:

Buy new vs refurbishing old for the beginner

Lee Valley vs Lie-Nielsen planes

The proper way to restore a tool (including ethics)

We could take topics like these and save them for Fridays and have a special weekly event callled the Foolish Fanatic Fridays. The only requirement would be that tongue in cheek responses must be italiciized or otherwise identified since some of this crew can get fairly subtle.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#34

Pot-stirring digression

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>(with a nod to my neighbor Marv)

So, then: what's the functional/spiritual/cultural meaning of the blade of wheat carving found on later saw handles? Why not, say, oak leaves, pine branches, or other wood references? How many carpenters in the heyday of handsaws were building their houses from wheat?

And why only on the left side, where it's visible when you hold the saw in your right hand, but out of sight then you hold it in your left? Was this an ergonomic addition, to remind carpenters which hand was their right hand - since the big "R" and "L" painted on the toes of their boots could get covered with sawdust - or is it yet another indication of the systematic discrimination against those of us who use the proper (left) hand for sawing?

And why is it more common on hand saws than on backsaws?

Is it, perhaps, an indication that the manufacturers of Wheaties won the endorsement contest over the makers of cornflakes?

Bill, not a popcorn guy. Anyone got any chips?

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#35

Re: A few more.....

MikeW

>"We could take topics like these and save them for Fridays and have a special weekly event callled the Foolish Fanatic Fridays. The only requirement would be that tongue in cheek responses must be italiciized or otherwise identified since some of this crew can get fairly subtle."

Hi Dave--and or cannot take a joke if it was all trussed up with ribbons that had "Joke" printed on them...

Seeing how this is your idea (which I think would be fun for a while), we could always do it on SMC...*

Take care, Mike

*that was a joke. Sort of ...

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#36

Thats my que "how to carve a saw handle"

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Thank you Mike...thought you'd never ask...

Speaking of carved saw handles....

Hey, if'n ya kain't gloat, why do it? In this case, a "tote-gloat".

The picture is of a custom Disston #12 tote. Sorta, with some subtle and not so subtle modifications in shape and design. The wood is Cherry. I made it about two years ago. Been waiting for a good blade to mount it on. One of my early attempts at wheat carving.

Marv


img

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#37

Re: Pot-stirring digression

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Bill,

And a nod backatcha... You git'n any smoke down your way? We can't even see the mountain across the lake.

All very good questions. Many of which have crossed my mind from time to time. The answers are as elusive and varied as with the nib.

My theory regarding the wheat carving on only the left side of the tote. Saws were displayed in stores with the handle to the right. But that might have been because the carving was on the left side of the tote.

Why not on both sides? Too time consuming and added cost. The Panther Head saw is the only saw I've ever seen with carving on both sides.

Wheat was used for decoration because it was easier to do.

Wheat carving was done on the very first Disston #12,s. The wheats were very small and was spread all over the left side, much more than on later handles.

I have no theory on the spiritual aspects of it.

Below is a #12 with the original smaller wheats that came to me with a broken handle. One of my favorite saws. The medallion dates it to around the 1880,s. And yes, it has a nib. The nib is not original, sadly, someone used it to start a kerf and broke it off. Too bad, it greatly reduces the value. Thought I should mention the nib so as to stay within the spirit of this thread.

Marv


img

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#38

But wait, there's more...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Why stop there Bill, We can do Panthers and other animals as well. Who was it that posted the Beagle handle on Badger Pond?

Chips are coming your way!

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#39

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Marv,

Things are going well, thanks.

And yep, I am also interested in blacksmithing--been at for a year or so, a year ago in the spring I guess. Started out interested only in making tools and have gotten sucked into ornamental work. Slippery slope in its own right, that's for sure.

Anyway, that saw nib question .... hmmm. Maybe you could use it as a toothpick on your front teeth after eating all of this popcorn.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#40

Hey!

Hank Knight

>"How big is your nib?"

Let's not get too personal here.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#41

Re: Thats my que "how to carve a saw handle"

Ray Binnicker

>Hey Marv,

That is a beautiful handle ! When you can do work like that it ain't gloating !

OK, back to the nibs.

Ray

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#42

It's a holder

Wayne Carson "TX"

>when your finised sawing you turn it over and stab it into the stud or what ever wood is near by to hold the saw saves, on the teeth.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#43

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Andrew,

Well, if one is inclined to use the nib for which it was not intended, even though we are not sure what the intention for it was, why not use it to pick yer teeth? Just one more way to break a perfectly good nib though.

Lets imagine a news reporter sitting with the guy who was thought to have come up with the original idea and posing the obvious question...."Sir, what purpose does this little pointy thing serve?" And the guy answers.."damned if'n I know". It just came to me in a dream as I was coming out of a drunk'n stupor. But Ole Hank, my boss over there said it's really nothing new because he remembers seeing them used on saws when he was in England and he doesn't have any idea what it's for either". The reporter then asks..."so what do you call it?" "We don't have a name for it. Hank my boss over there says to let history determine what to call it. He said he has enough concerns trying to perfect his new smeltering process so he can make his own spring steel and doesn't have time for such nonsense".

Marv

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#44

Re: Yard sale hand saw

Ace Karner

>Mike, can't believe you left out Bevel up v. Bevel down. LOL

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#45

Re: The nib is used to start a kerf

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>The book is new published in 1990, however the engraving is probably late nineteenth century, no credit in the book was given.

And it is using the reflection and the straight back of the saw to draw a square line. But the saw is not a sway back, so it is earlier.

Stephen

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#46

THANKS Marv I GOT IT!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The nib was placed there so Jimi Hendrix, Jimmy page, the guy from Whitesnake and others could slide them up and down guitar strings!

Jimmy Page must have broke his off and used a violin bow instead!

Then the rest followed. Do I get the golden DT saw for finally figuring it out?

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#47

Well that's what it looks like to me...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>'nuthing more than a ruler.

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#48

Ahhh Man...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Just when I ready for a that's what your wife said comment...

Scott going back to the peanut gallery..

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#49

Moses Yoder

Re: bevel up versus down

Moses Yoder

>The bevel up versus bevel down threads were left out because those are not funny. That is a very serious and real issue, and not to be laughed at.

(debating whether I really have to admit this is a tongue in cheek response, but I suppose I better. It is too easy to find out where people live nowadays.)

Re: Yard sale hand saw

#50

Re: Well that's what it looks like to me...

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I believe the word is 'nothing'.

And it is still a saw, right?.

Stephen