Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Hand Saw Set?

Posts

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#51

Countless shapes and styles

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Stephen,

I'll try to not piss you off again with the following response. I don't mean to offend.

I've seen many different designs of the Saw Wrest, some with adjustable stops, but most without. But basically, they consist of a piece of flat metal with slots and rely on a practiced hand to conistantly bend saw teeth. For a first timer, the Stanley 42X is pretty much a no brainer.

Most people who ask questions about saw tuning are people with little or no experience. If they are experienced, they don't ask the questions, there's no need to. With that in mind, I try to offer information that a beginner can most easily relate to. When responding to the original question that started this thread, a saw wrest wasn't the first tool to come to mind for someone who hasn't ever set teeth on a saw.

I pretty much realize where you are coming from, only because I know that you rely almost entirely on the old style hand tools to do what you do. Not everyone knows that about you. I respect and admire you for what you do and how you teach and demonstrate how working with wood used to be done.

While it is interesting to know the history of an old tool such as a saw wrest, learning what it is and how to use it, might best be done after the beginner learns about the safer and easier present day methods that are available and more commonly relied on.

For James' graduated DT saw, no way would I suggest that he use a saw wrest to set the teeth. It might be ok, if he had you standing next to him, showing him exactly how to do it without messing up an expensive favorite saw.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#52

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Pedder

>"Eclipse 77's have all of the same features that a Stanley 42X does."

My 0,02 �

I own and use both: The anvil of the Stanley 42 x is straight, but the anvil of the eclipse looks like a snail. Because of this the eclipse will give a little difference in setting left and right teeth.

Not a big thing, just a little "whetting" (learned a new word) and it's done.

Cheers

Pedder

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#53

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>A straight anvil compared to a snail shaped anvil makes the two saw sets significantly different. Similar features, but much different. Anyone buying a saw set for the first time needs to know that.

It isn't the saw set that is setting the teeth on one side of the blade differently than the other side. It's probably due to the filing of the teeth and having "big tooth-little tooth" syndrome.

Respectfully,

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#54

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Seems to me that even the simplest saw wrest has some built in guides, in the form of the width of the opening. When the leading side of the slit touches the body of the saw you know to stop.

Pam

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#55

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Pam,

You are right, however, we are often times concerned about not putting too much set in the teeth. The saw wrest makes it more difficult to maintain consistancy than does the Stanley 42X, along with a few other plier type saw sets. It's all about repeatability from tooth to tooth without having to be careful how far each tooth is slipped into the slot of a saw wrest. It's not a matter of a saw wrest not doing the job, it's mainly a matter of ease, especially for a beginner. I'm sure with practice, one could become quite adept with the use of a saw wrest.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#56

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>I understand that, perhaps the hammer/anvil saw sets are a bit too much like power tools for me, kind of like jigs. I'd even prefer a regular anvil on which to lightly tap the saw teeth with a point or cross pien hammer. Then stone after to get the sets level. True, tough when starting, but one can ramp into expertise quickly.

Pam

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#57

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Pam,

When setting a tooth it is most important to not cause the bend to be down into the blade below the gullet. This can cause a crack that can migrate into the blade. You might not see the crack at first but with use, the crack can grow.

The plier type saw set will prevent the bending from taking place where it shouldn't be. It's best to bend the tooth about half way down from the tip. The smaller the tooth the more careful one must be.

If you were to use a drift punch for example with the plate laying on an anvil, it would be nearly impossible to bend each tooth at the same location, especially if we are setting, say, a 15PPI tenon saw.

However, if I had no other way to set the teeth, I might try clamping the plate to an anvil with a sheet of steel between the plate and the anvil with the edge of the sheet of steel set back from the tips of the teeth about half the length of the teeth. Then with a drift punch, lightly tap the teeth on the outer half, holding the punch at an angle that would determine the amount of set.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#58

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>If you were to use a drift punch for example with the plate laying on an anvil, it would be nearly impossible to bend each tooth at the same location, especially if we are setting, say, a 15PPI tenon saw.

I'm also not convinced that bending each tooth at precisely the same location is desirable, that perhaps better performance is introduced with some variability, the performance of risk.

Pam

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#59

Re: Countless shapes and styles

MikeW

>"I'm also not convinced that bending each tooth at precisely the same location is desirable, that perhaps better performance is introduced with some variability, the performance of risk."

Pam, the problem with setting at different heights is that the teeth where the bend is lower than others will also be set wider. There are ways around that, or more properly, fixes, but why bother with added work?

Variability may well be a good thing, but in the set of the teeth isn't where it should occur. Variable rake, fleam and or spacing are the areas that variablity would not affect the kerf width.

Take care, Mike

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#60

Re: Countless shapes and styles

paul womack

>I'm also not convinced that bending each tooth at precisely the same location is desirable, that perhaps better performance is introduced with some variability, the performance of risk.

Do you have any justification for this?

The benefits of *uniform* set (or tooth tips contributing to cutting the kerf) seem obvious.

The benefits of variable pitch and rake have, of course, are not controversial.

BugBear

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#61

Re: Countless shapes and styles

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>No, absolutely no justification; but I was assuming a light stoning after setting, which should bring the teeth in line pretty well, but not precisely.

Pam