Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Hand Saw Set?

Posts

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#26

Re: Andrew...Nice website! Thanks Mike....

MikeW

>Hey Marv--howzit?

Alternatively:

"andrew lunn" hand saw

brings Eccentric Toolworks to the top in Google. Just Andrew's name will get ya there, but it is down a bit, so adding something about a tenon saw, hand saw, etc., will narrow the search.

Take care--all the best this 4th!

Mike

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#27

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>Ditto what Andrew and Marv said about too much set, a little goes a long way, especially in dry hardwoods which is mostly what I use. Most saws that I acquire have too much set and they can be sharpened a couple of times without setting, just stoning to make sure the set is even.

Jim

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#28

Re: Andrew...Nice website! Thanks Mike....

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Marv, thank you for the kind words and suggestions--doing things to maximize my search engine exposure isn't something that tends to naturally occur to me, so suggestions like yours are very helpful.

The site should begin to grow a lot in the near future, with fairly regular entries about different topics. So check it out then and let me know what you think!

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#29

Thanks Mike. Happy 4th!

Andrew Lunn

>

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#30

I prefer a saw wrest

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Saw Wrests are less distructive on the teeth and insure that just the tip gets bent, not the entire tooth down to the root.

I also think that plyer type sets can crush the teeth and deform them. I think the pressure at the beginning is greater than after you have set over 150 teeth.

Stephen

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#31

Re: Hold on a minute...

ThomD

>I had that experience oodles of years ago. I gave up on the mechanical set I got from LV in it's infancy, and i went to the hammer and anvil method. I actually like the saw set and had good results as far as consistance and ease of use are concerned. One thing that I didn't like was the little wheel that gave more set to large teeth on the assumtion they would be used in wet logs rather than just thicker cuts. That would be a pretty easy thing to fix. Just turn a wheel to fit at a lower angle.

From pictures on the bay it seems the 42 has a constant angle, like the anvils. What is the ideal angle?

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#32

Re: Hold on a minute...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Thom,

You asked.....

From pictures on the bay it seems the 42 has a constant angle, like the anvils. What is the ideal angle?

I measured the angles on the 42X and the Somax. The 42X has a 15 degree angle compared to the Somax with 22 degrees. No wonder the Somax puts too much set in the teeth. The hammer has the same angle to match the anvil. This is probably the reason the Somax tends to slip upward on the tooth.

I think your idea of machining or turning a replacement anvil for the Somax is a viable consideration. I'm going to try that. The angle of the hammer will have to be made to match the anvil. When this is done, there will be more movement forward that will effect the handle movement. There will be issues in this area.

To answer your question.....because the 42X does not overset the teeth, and does not tend to slip upward on the tooth, I'm going to say that the ideal angle is 15 degrees.

The one drawback I find with the 42X is that the larger mechanism up front prevents setting of teeth below the handle on certain saws when not removing the handle, where as the Somax is much smaller in that area of the tool.

The Somax appears to have varying angles, but it's the same angle, only deeper on one side than on the other.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#33

Re: I prefer a saw wrest

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I believe that careful application of the plier type saw set could eliminate the damage you fear. Skill is acquired not inborn.

JR

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#34

Re: Hold on a minute...

ThomD

>Replacement anvils - Patent pending!

Just kidding. Thanks for the useful report Marv. The real colateral win here is I can put replacement anvils on the list of things I need to make that will justify owning all these metal working tools. Stuff like this where one gets a big payoff for a fiddling little project are gravy. This could pretty easily be done without the metal tools. Drill press and a grinder would help.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#35

Setting a progressive pitch saw?

James Watriss

>This may be an entirely different question. To be honest, I haven't had to sharpen my saws yet, but a recent addition to the tool chest is a L-N progressive pitch DT saw.

Given the length and breadth of this thread so far, I figured I'd throw this into the fray... what kinds of things need to be considered with a progressive pitch? Do you have to change the setting on a saw set for each tooth? Or just wing it?

Or is that an esoteric question best answered by the really seasoned saw guys?

I have to say, I've seen a lot of saw tuning stuff pop up lately in here, and I'm getting more and more interested in trying my hand at tuning up an old saw.

(Great... just what I need... one more hobby...)

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#36

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

Joel

>The saw teeth all need the same set or the saw will jam in the cut.

If you are hand filing the saw it gets sharpened like anything else only the teeth change in size as you do it which might be confusing.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#37

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi James,

Progressive teeth show up on a lot of the old big tooth rip saws. Progressive might not be the right word for it. Some of them will just drop down a tooth size for about the last 4 or 5 inches of the blade at the toe end. Others might drop a half tooth size in two steps or more. It appears to be "progressive", but progressive to me would mean the teeth would graudually get smaller and smaller with each tooth.

Ok, here's the deal from my experiences when setting those bigger teeth. It's the same with the smaller teeth. It's all about the kerf width. With your saw you don't want but very little set. You want just enough to prevent the saw from binding in whatever kind of wood you are sawing. Regardless of the number of teeth per inch, you still want the same kerf width to be cut for the full length of the blade. This means you want each tooth to protrude out from the blade the same amount from start to finish. The difference in the size of the teeth is very little, so it only makes sense to set all the teeth the same.

From a manufacturing standpoint, it would be terribly time consuming for someone to set each tooth with a different setting of the saw set.

The smaller teeth are merely for making it a little easier to start the cut and then progressively saw faster as you push through.

I think of it more as a marketing thing, not something that offers any great advantage. If you want to saw faster, just put a little more muscle behind each stroke and more strokes per minute.

If I'm full of lunchmeat here, I'm sure it will be expressed following this post as we venture outside the relm of common sense and enter the technical world of confusion. *grin*

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#38

Sawman, you still here? Are you confused yet?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#39

Re: Sawman, you still here? Are you confused yet?

Sawman

>Still here and taking it all in!

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#40

Another question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Does anyone _not_ stone the teeth of their saws after setting and sharpening? Seems like stoning reduces the clearance of the teeth.

Wiley

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#41

Re: Another question

Dean J in MN

>I try not to stone my saws if I don't need to. I file the face of the tooth toward the saw plate to attempt to push any burr inside the tooth line. I think stoning a rip saw changes the intersection of the face and side of the tooth, so I avoid it. That said, if I find my saw drifting I will lightly stone the sides. I just don't make it a habit to stone after each filing.

I know others stone lightly every time, I'm not sure there is gospel truth either way.

-Dean

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#42

Re: Another question

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Wiley,

I always "stone" whet, joint, the sides of the teeth after setting. If the teeth don't need setting, often times they don't, I will still joint the teeth using a slip stone. It only takes a couple of light swipes to remove burrs and to get all the points even. It's not absolutely necessary, but it will enhance the initial smoothness of the cut surface. With use, the teeth will usually even up anyway when the filing and setting are done properly.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#43

Re: Another question

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Wiley,

I take a light swipe with a slipstone like Marv does, just enough to knock off the burr that is out where it would engage the wood and to bring any protruding point back in line with the rest of the points. I think of it as just a subtle final touch and like the small difference it makes.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#44

Re: Hand Saw Set?

paul womack

>While they are not too common in the US, I found one at a garage sale a few years ago for a couple of bucks after reading a reference to them by Bugbear.

After looking at and using mine this morning, I'd have to say they are made of brass, not bronze as I said earlier.

Examples also exist in cast iron.

Be careful - they were made for a long time and (SHOCK!!!) the earlier ones are a little nicer.

BugBear

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#45

Re: Hand Saw Set?

paul womack

>One thing that I didn't like was the little wheel that gave more set to large teeth on the assumtion they would be used in wet logs rather than just thicker cuts. That would be a pretty easy thing to fix. Just turn a wheel to fit at a lower angle.

From pictures on the bay it seems the 42 has a constant angle, like the anvils. What is the ideal angle?

The angle thing is interesting.

In any design that has an anvil and "punch", the angle of the punch must match the anvil. Since I cannot conceive of a way to make a varying angle punch, the anvil must also be fixed angle (which is a shame, since the rototating anvil of the Eclipse #77 could easily vary both angle *AND* depth).

Given a constant angle amount of set must be proportional to the depth setting, which is in turn conventionally propertional to tooth size.

I have once reworked a #77 anvil to have a smaller angle, and (when I realised...) also reworked the punch to have the same small angle.

This modification worked as intended. Note that a normal #77 is only rated to 12 TPI (although in any case saw set numbers are notoriously dubious at the best of times)

One of the issues is accuracy of depth setting; if one is trying to set a 15 TPI saw half way down the tooth (as recommended), one is aiming for 1/30" of an inch below the tooth tip, which ain't a lot of room for error.

BugBear

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#46

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

James Watriss

>Yeah, I figured that multiple settings would pose a real hassle in manufacturing. But as the tooth count gets smaller towards the back of the plate, the length of the tooth gets longer, too, so I didn't know if that would affect the way the saw set worked.

Then again, without having a set in front of me, the whole question was just me talking out of the wrong end of my digestive tract...

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#47

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi James,

Hmmmmm...that sounds a bit strange....When you refer to the "back" of the plate, are you referring to the handle end? The teeth are more per inch and are longer?

And when you refer to the teeth getting longer, would that be a measurement from the tip of the tooth down to the bottom of the gullet?

Bottom line is, each tooth needs to protrude the same amount out from the plate.

Thanks,

Marv

PS...I wasn't aware there is a right and wrong end of our digestive tract, figuratively speaking, that is...LOL

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#48

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

James Watriss

>Fewer teeth per inch... teeth get bigger, gullets between them get bigger, too, hence longer teeth.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#49

Re: Setting a progressive pitch saw?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>James,

The reason it sounded strange to me was because you said the teeth get smaller at the back of the plate.

As you just now described the teeth, it sounds right if the larger teeth are back near the handle.

Same conclusion regarding the set....all should be the same. One setting on the saw set but where the bend takes place on each tooth will vary a little. Keep in mind, the amount of bend is merely a few thousands on a DT saw. Your focus will be on how much the tooth protrudes out from the plate, not so much as to where the bend takes place. There is so little bending taking place, that you don't need to be concerned about where on the tooth the bend is.

Now if you were to use a "saw wrest", you would have to be careful about that. A saw wrest is just a flat piece of metal with slots in it that requires the user to be in complete control of each tooth separately. Get yourself a Stanley 42X and there will be no worry. The tool does most of the work.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#50

More than a flat piece of metal

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Marv,

While I do have a wrest that is just a flat piece of metal with slots, there are others out there that make using them much easier to use and get consistant results.

This one has an adjustable and reversable stop to insure the bend on the tip of the tooth is uniform.

Stephen


img