Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Hand Saw Set?

Posts

Hand Saw Set?

#1

Hand Saw Set?

Sawman

>I am wanting to buy a tool for setting the teeth on hand saws.I notice there are different brands on ebay. Is there one that stands out among the rest?

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#2

Re: Hand Saw Set? *LINK*

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>Stanley 42x. The one I bought had never been used and the box only said 42. When you look at the saw set it says 42x on the handle. I'm doing this from memory. This sawset is the only one I've used and it seems to be a model that is liked by many. I believe I bought one originally because Pete Taran had recommended it. Check out his site for his take on it.


http://www.vintagesaws.com/cgi-bin/frameset.cgi?left=sawcare&right=/sets/sets.html

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#3

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Sawman,

The Stanley 42X has become the most popular saw set available, mainly on eBay. The price for them on eBay is continuously increasing. I see them selling in the neighborhood of 70 to 85 dollars now. Often times you can get them for less though.

I use two of them. One for regular handsaws and a second for backsaws. The second one I have reduced the width of the plunger for the smaller teeth, 12PPI and smaller.

I never recommend any other saw set. I have tried lots of others and find that the 42X is simply the best, IMO.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#4

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Andrew Lunn

>I also like the 42x. IMO, it's the best all around set. They seem to turn up on ebay a lot. Look for one that is nice but not so nice that a collector will want it! Good luck.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#5

Hold on a minute...

Patrick Gibbons, Somewhere in Texas

>I got my saw set off of the 'bay about five or six years ago. At the time, no one seemed to want the darned things and I think I paid less than 20 semolians for the thing. It would be nice to hear what people think about the new foreign-made ones that are available from many sources. They seem to be reasonably priced.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#6

Moses Yoder

Re: Hold on a minute...

Moses Yoder

>I have not looked at the new foreign ones yet becaue I have found so many 42X's at garage sales for a buck ;) Is that what you call a stealth gloat? Better lay low for a while....

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#7

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>The Stanley 42X's are ok, but I can't see any reason to pay much more than $5 for a saw set. After all, you are just trying to bend over the end of a tooth a consistant amount.

Eclipse 77's have all of the same features that a 42X does and they are made of bronze, they work well. There are many other manufacturers of saw sets, Morril, Sayre, Apex, Monarch by Disston, Taintor and others that would all serve the purpose if you take your time, adjust the saw set to the proper set, and pay attention to what you are doing.

Jim

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#8

Re: Hold on a minute...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Moses,

I'll pay you 5 dollars for every 42X you find that is in good working condition. Email me.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#9

Re: Hand Saw Set?

paul womack

>Eclipse 77's have all of the same features that a 42X does and they are made of bronze, they work well.

And are remarkably common on the s/h market in the UK.

1.00 GPB is the going rate at a car boot sale.

BugBear

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#10

Re: Hold on a minute...

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Patrick,

The only foreign saw set I'm aware of is the SOMAX. It is similar in design as the 42X but has a cheap aluminum diecast mainframe. Over time the sharp teeth of newly sharpened saws will wear the surface of the tool that helps determine the setting of the teeth.

The fact that it has a plunger clamping feature, same as the 42X, makes it attractive. However, my experience with it was, the part that bends the tooth tends to slide upward on the tooth. The 42X stays put.

Even though it is advertised as being available in two sizes, there is only one size being manufactured as far as I know. I bought one for the purpose of setting the smaller teeth on backsaws. The instructions say to set it at it's lowest setting for the smaller teeth, on 12, and it will set any size tooth that is smaller. NOT!!! At it's lowest setting, it will put waaaaaaaay too much set in the teeth and has a tendency to break teeth.

Someone who is new at sharpening saws might blame other reasons for getting a rotten saw cut and not realize it's due to a rotten saw set.

You can buy a Somax between 15 and 25 dollars, new, but I wouldn't pay 50 cents for one, "AGAIN". I'm sure others will claim it's the best saw set ever made, but I'll stick by my trusty 42X and find no reason to use anything else. Having said that, I sure wouldn't pay Pete Taran's prices between $100 and $150.

It's important for the beginner to know that the setting of the teeth is equally important as the actual sharpening of the teeth. When I was learning I ended up with a pile of various saw sets before I found the 42X. All the others are in a pile gathering dust.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#11

OT...Backsaws??

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Andrew,

Are you the guy who makes some beautiful saws for sale, including backsaws? Did I see one of your saws in the latest tool contest?

If you are the guy, your craftsmanship is outstanding!

Do you have a website?

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#12

Yes, we need to see!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#13

Re: Yes, we need to see! *LINK*

MikeW

>Andrew's web site of wonderful work is...at the linky

But make sure to go to the home page and check out the carvings shown there...

Take care, Mike


Andrew Lunn's Web Site

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#14

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>While they are not too common in the US, I found one at a garage sale a few years ago for a couple of bucks after reading a reference to them by Bugbear.

After looking at and using mine this morning, I'd have to say they are made of brass, not bronze as I said earlier.

Jim

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#15

Question about the steel

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

>Maybe I could ask this, while all you sawmakers are gathered round....When do you do the steel hardening? Do you do the shaping and tapering and basic toothing while annealed, then harden, then tension (flatten), then do the jointing, setting, and sharpening? Or what?

Do you use O1? Is W1 even made anymore?

Wiley

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#16

Fashions in tools? Naaaah *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>About a decade ago, one of the saw sharpening gurus recommended Taintor* sets, so I diligently picked up two at garage sales. Of course, they're generally so cheap, it's hard to get just one, so I've also found several other brands and models.

Since I have yet actually to sharpen a saw**, I can't speak for which is better or worse - but I find it interesting that this brand, which was once The One to Get, merits just one reference (two, now) on this thread.

*Also, I understand, the Official Saw Set of the Mangani (link below for those not familiar with classic literature).

**It appears that I am now finally re-entering retirement, although I'm still working a couple of days per week this summer, so this may be the year I get to try them out.


Then look up "Tantor"

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#17

Re: Question about the steel

MikeW

>Hi Wiley,

Speaking for only myself, the steel is the harder of the couple 1095 steels available. At the harder end of the range given the thicker it is.

So it is already hardened when we shape it, taper grind if appropriate for the saw, tooth it, fit it, drill it, etc.

Take care, Mike

back to some Ebony handles...

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#18

Re: Hand Saw Set?

John Pappas

>Marv, I have a MillersFall 214 that I picked up at an estate sale. Any comments about this particular sawset?

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#19

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi John,

I've tried a lot of different saw sets, but not the MF's one. I see them on eBay quite often though. I saw a saw set collection once that consisted of, I'd guess at least a hundred different makes and models. I couldn't believe so many existed. I'm a Millers Falls fan. They made some good stuff. I've been tempted from time to time to bid on one on eBay but since I found the Stanley 42X, I just figure there's no need to spend money on anything else.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#20

Re: Yes, we need to see!

Andrew Lunn

>Shoot guys, Marv, Mike, Wiley, thank you very much for the kind words. That is indeed me, and those indeed are my saws. :) Mike, thank you for posting my link.

Sometime soon I'll be adding a blog to the site, and I'll get around to answering questions about tool making and carving and whatever else comes up that seems worth talking about.

Saw making is surely one of those things you do mainly because you love it, and it bit me really hard. Mike, you were one of the first people to answer any of my most basic questions--thank you. I had no idea what I was in for--I started thinking about it all and couldn't stop! :)

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#21

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Jim,

I've had decent results from the Apex 95. I haven't used the others you mentioned. Once I tried the 42x I just didn't bother messing with others too much. It's amazing to me how little of the available range on these tools is actually necessary to set practically any saw. The original poster, who seems to be learning to sharpen and set, should be especially careful when applying set. Add it a little at a time.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#22

Re: Question about the steel

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Wiley,

Same here, I use 1095 that comes hardened and already tempered. You just have to be careful then not to ruin its temper when grinding it and such. No big deal.

I've thought it would be interesting to experiment with my own heat treatment of a saw, but that would be mostly for my own edification and curiosity. I've also thought it would be fun sometime to smith a whole saw out like they used to have to do before the steel was rolled. Interesting stuff.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#23

Re: Hold on a minute...

Andrew Lunn

>Hey Patrick,

With respect to those foreign ones, I expect you are referring to the Somax sets. I have to admit, I don't care for them. I found the same problem with them that Marv mentioned--they wanted to creep. I also thought they tended to distort the blade overly much, even at very low settings. Just my humble opinion. Probably some others have had a different experience.

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#24

Re: Hand Saw Set?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>As Andrew said, for those of you new to sharpening saws, be carefull adding set....

You can have a well sharpened saw and then easily screw it up by over setting the teeth.

You can easily check the amount of set by sighting down from the top of the saw with the saw tilted just right in the light. On a dovetail or tenon saw, that is set for cutting hardwoods, you only want to see enough of the tooth just barely sticking out that indicates that the teeth have been bent. Tilt the saw the other way and you need to see the same amount sticking out the other side. Of course the accurate way to do it is to use a micrometer.

As Andrew said, do it a little at a time. It doesn't take much set to prevent the blade from binding in the kerf. That's really all you want to accomplish. To get the smoothest cut, lightly joint the sides of the teeth after setting by sliding a slip stone over both sides of the teeth.

Marv

Re: Hand Saw Set?

#25

Andrew...Nice website! Thanks Mike....

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Hi Andrew,

Will be keeping an eye on your website and looking forward to some blogging and other additions.

I like your etchings. Also the nice carving you do on your handles.

For Googling searches, it might be a good idea to add some saw related words with your Company name. By doing that, it will cause your website to pop up more readily when people are looking for the type of saws you make.

Perhaps others have some better advice.

I googled the words Tenon Saw and didn't see your name show up but Wentzloff is all over the place.

How old is your website, Andrew? Maybe it's a longivity thing?

Marv