Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I totally agree Wiley. I think that you have captured the essence of the issues very well.
If this machine did not work well, and repeatedly, and did not have an expected pool of buyers, then BC would just lose money. They are not in business to go out of business. So clearly they identify that there are enough of those to make the venture worth their while.
So whom does the target buyers represent?
Earlier I suggested those with interests in making limited precision runs. Box makers, model makers, amongst other small scale work. That is my (probably short-sighted) perception.
But there will be individuals who want one as well, partly because it is BC (that is status in itself among BC collectors), and partly because it can provide such superb results. There are those who want to brag about their constructional skills now, rather than then taking the time to acquire them in the traditional manner, or those that lack the physical skills to do certain handtool tasks (owing to injury or illness).
While I admire the quality of the result produced, I love more the effort taken to achieve quality. In other words, I prefer my woodworking without machines. In fact I go further to prefer certain handtools over others in the quest for increased tool feedback. Light, hands-on tools, such as chisels, spokeshaves, rasps, and block planes are a great deal more pleasurable than that BC contraption will ever be for me. In the past I have raptured on about light wooden planes over heavy metal planes, and I still feel this way when using them - just not when looking at their results. On our hard Aussie timbers it is often a wiser choice to stick to the heavier, higher-angled version.
So this saw machine from BC will have its supporters and detractors. I admire the tool for its design and I admire the manufactuers for their willingness to put their money where their mouth is. It is still not for me ...but I am quite happy to be its reviewer! My address for delivery is on the other side of this letter :)
Regards from Perth
Derek