Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

Posts

Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#1

Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

Charles R. Smith

>I have spent time looking at the video and other information on the Jointmaker Pro, from Bridge City's John Economaki (if I've spelled his name correctly). I am curious of the thoughts of others, and would covet knowing your views.

I personally find it a fascinating concept, though the $1,000 price tag seems high.

From John's blog (http://www.bridgecitytools.com/blog/), which boasts some fascinating photos of the Jointmaker Pro's capabilities, it would appear that the device has Chris Schwarz's blessing. Being in the middle of building the French workbench from Chris' book, I take his word to be a high recommendation.

Charles (who wonders if he should buy another expensive toy from Bridge City)


Link to Jointmaker Pro

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#2

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?  *LINK*

paul womack

>


thread on oldtools

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#3

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Thomas S Stockton

>Charles,

I'll bite with some observations that will probably contradict them selves

1- Looks like a real slick and well designed tool

2- Holy cow $1,200 thats a lot of good quality japanese saws

3- I'm personally on the war path against all the gizmo that are out there when all you need sometimes is a simple saw and a few tools not some real expensive glorified jig to cut dovetails and other joints, your still going to have to get the other half of the dovetail to fit.

4- I'm curious how it will work on thicker and harder stock.

5- I have power tools that can do a bunch of that stuff.

Tom

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#4

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Looks to me like the undercarriage of a table saw with fences on top.

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#5

Fantastic!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Totally disregarding whether the price and what one might consider as an alternative in the power tool department, I must draw attention to the thought and creativity that went into this design. Fantastic!

If I did small, precision production work, I might be in the market for one. Obviously I am not the target audience, but that does not stop me appreciating the design.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#6

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

hooligan

>Really slick, not sure about using it on thick bubinga though-

I will wait for the 99 dollar Harbor Freight version.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#7

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pat Riley

>I have to agree with Derek. The design if very interesting, but it really only lends itself to a production environment - lots to do with little time, and most likely helpers that aren't highly skilled yet.

Years back I would have been more interested, then I realized that it isn't all that hard to get pretty good results by hand with a good saw and a bit of practice.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#8

strikes me as an expensive dumb idea

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Disclaimer- I have found that I am the world's worst marketing manager. People make purchases that astound me. But even with that disclaimer I can't fathom anyone buying that thing. Had it been posted April 1 by Mr. Lee I would have immediately recognized that it was an April Fools.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#9

Great idea! Lousy Price!!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I watched the video on this amazing tool and was astounded at it's accuracy and speed! It is a great idea and perfect for someone dedicated to a "electron" free shop. The fence and slide system look exceptionally well thought out and well made. I especially liked when the user was cutting the outlines for the dovetail pins and tails. If I was into Marquetry or segmented bowl work, I would probably have to think seriously about it.

But I nearly had a coronary when I saw the price tag! YIKES! Then I remembered that Bridge City's tools are numbered amoung the "Cadillacs" (maybe I should say "Rolls Royce" now) of the tool world, and with prices to match. I guess the old saying about getting what you paid for applies here.

Still, if I did the kind of work that required this kind of tool, I'd be more likely to consider it if the price was a bit more resonable (ie: around $300-ish).

Later,

Dominic

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#10

Re: Great idea! Lousy Price!!

Michael Brady

>I saw this tool demonstrated by the inventor, at the L-N road show in Chicago. He made extremely fine, consistant dovetail sawcuts with it. I say he made the cuts, because only he was allowed to use the tool while I was there. This tool is a bit of a gizmo to my narrow-minded way of thinking. The BC tools are aimed at a market that I am not part of, apparently. I view most of them more as expensive curiosities rather than something to lust after. The comments that went before about using this saw for limited, fine production are relevant, I think. That audience would be pretty small.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#11

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Brent in Montreal

>To me, and no insult to JE intended, this seems like the product of someone who sold a company for a tidy sum and now has too much time on his hands. Aside from the fact that it takes away from the tranquility of using a handsaw it doesn't seem overly user friendly. I didn't notice any positive stops on the bevel apparatus and the same with the fences. This will lead to quite a bit of setup time.

I imagine it will have it's uses, but at $1100 I think I'll just practise my sawing.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#12

Video? Where?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Dom,

Where did you see a video? I would like to see a saw in action.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#13

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

John Hoffman

>Guys, I have seen this item and seen it in use. It does perform as advertised.

Secondly, the thing that can be accomplished with this saw, is the work of the silent woodworker. Meaning, anyone in an apartment, or without a shop who wants to do exact work. This device does it. It is totally self contained so a person doesn't need a bench with a vise to hold work. It allows a person to work without noise and without the need for a lot of space. If I were in that type of situation this is something I would buy. I need to woodwork or I go crazy. With this saw I would be able to accurately make joints for boxes and small scale work without noise and with complete precision. If you have a full shop then this device may not be for you. The rise of hand tools sales and interest indicate that there may be people out there that would like to do work without the investment that we all have made.

My 2 cents...

John

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#14

bottom of the page

Wayne Carson

>

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#15

Not on the bottom of the linked page.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#16

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>But you need a bench and vise(s) for other work, regardless of how your joinery is done.

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#17

Thanks guys, you too Pam!

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>It would be nice to have the word VIDEO somewhere on the page. So for those of you who are as dumb as I am, click on the "HOW TO" tab to view the video located near the bottom of the page.

Marv

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#18

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Pam,

You are right, it's not a Do-all machine. However....it is for sure a very ingenious invention. Like a lot of new creations such as this, the price will probably come down. Bridge City is no doubt part of the pricing problem. I don't think they will sell anything unless it is more costly than everything else, but I guess someone has to be selling things at the highest prices.

Like someone said in an earlier post, I too will wait until a copy shows up at Harbor Freight for $49.95.

As long as the saw blade is really sharp, it will do a great job on small pieces that are normally difficult to cut as safely as this machine does it. One could still get a nasty cut on it if not careful. I would like to see a "hold-down" devise for when the saw begins to get dull.

Marv

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#19

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

John Hoffman

>Right you do, however not a 8' long 300lb bench. Something different that would allow you to fold it up and out of the way.

John

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#20

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

ThomD

>That's the part I like about it, if not for people like me or you. A lot of people use table saws precisely because they take the skill out of a number of cuts. At least where the accurate cutting of wood is concerned. There is a fair amount of skill relative to not cutting fingers off, kick back, and so forth. A really practical device designed to get the accuracy monkey off peoples' backs, without the danger dust and space hogginess of a tablesaw, would be good for a lot of people.

Price is a problem because I just bought a nice little table saw for 20 bucks. I'm looking at an old heavy cast one for 120, I don't have the space for it but they often sell for as much as 800, so it's a flip. There are any number of very accurate ones made to the highest old world standards for 200 bucks.

The problem, as others have said, with jigs is that they just put off the day when a person develops real skills that will take them further. There is both a mindset impediment and a skillset impedement to relying on jigs.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#21

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>"The problem, as others have said, with jigs is that they just put off the day when a person develops real skills that will take them further. There is both a mindset impediment and a skillset impedement to relying on jigs. "

Amen...

Norman

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#22

Re: Great idea! Lousy Price!!

ThomD

>"The BC tools are aimed at a market that I am not part of, apparently. I view most of them more as expensive curiosities rather than something to lust after."

That is true, some of them are really good tools. The thing they learned early on was that you couldn't make as much money making woodwork for real woodwork users, as you could making real woodworking tools for mostly non-woodworkers. It's just one of those things. Same deal as the idea that the highest monetary return for a good Noris may come from a collector, not a real woodworker.

"The comments that went before about using this saw for limited, fine production are relevant, I think. That audience would be pretty small."

I agree, but in the real world that is mostly another market you can't make money in, and where just about any jig you might want is makeable out of birch plywood. Not to mention what first generation CNC is selling for.

One of the real jokes about complex single purpose jigs is that for what that thing costs, you could buy 1-2 bridgeport mills.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#23

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi All,

Little different take on Bridge City's new offering. Let me first say that I don't own a BC tool.

But I'm still a cheering section for BC. I have deep admiration for the audacity--plain guts--of folks who will spend real money and real time and sweat to bring these long shot mechanical marvels to market, with the ambition to sell them for a profit. This doesn't happen by pushing a special ebony and brass button--it takes huge amounts of product design and prototyping and production planning and check writing, to make this happen. And the company is still there doing it every year! Bottom line: US manufacturing gives me a warm furry feeling. These folks are swimming against the current, and I like them.

Second thing. I believe this machine was invented for, and will be bought by, people who intend to use it. Why do I think that? Well, if you have money and want to indulge a woodworking hobby plus have some bragging rights in the bargain, I don't think you buy this product. Which is a sliding table built around a machine-made thin little Japanese saw blade. You buy a big high-end table saw or some other collection of big iron, so it looks like you've really got something. And you _do_ really have something. Or else you buy actual high-end Japanese saws, one of which would cost the same as this tool. There's pretty thin bragging rights about this particular tool, because think of it--this is going to draw more snickering from the machine tool side (the majority culture) than it does from the handtool folks. Your friends come over and say 'Huh?'. And if you cut a micron-thickness tissue sample of wood with it and hand it to them, they will still say 'Huh?'. And then, 'Uhhh, where's the motor?'

No, the people who buy this thing are buying it to use. For appearances you buy something different. I think it's for folks who have a machine-tool sensibility--they want very precise results and are not interested in feedback from the tool or developing hand/eye skills. Their pleasure will be in the results. From that standpoint, the alternatives are other types of jointmaking gear--like 3-axis contraptions that you mount electric routers on. Plus this tool can make dovetails that look handmade, rather than machine cut, and no 90-dB dust control system.

Wiley ... being non-judgmental

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#24

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Marc in Luxembourg

>Wiley,

Do you think that people buying the BC Jointmaker have already a reel mower with grass catcher in their gardening tool bag - a new one for sure? Otherwise formulated are those people targeted? Sharpening of the blades are required, an eye for the good day for mowing too. The lawn should not be too high. Gas mowers make too much noise, scythes doesn't produce the perfect "edge" on the lawn.

Not wanting to sidetrack, just wondering, if there is a new costumship on the monitor,

Marc

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#25

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I totally agree Wiley. I think that you have captured the essence of the issues very well.

If this machine did not work well, and repeatedly, and did not have an expected pool of buyers, then BC would just lose money. They are not in business to go out of business. So clearly they identify that there are enough of those to make the venture worth their while.

So whom does the target buyers represent?

Earlier I suggested those with interests in making limited precision runs. Box makers, model makers, amongst other small scale work. That is my (probably short-sighted) perception.

But there will be individuals who want one as well, partly because it is BC (that is status in itself among BC collectors), and partly because it can provide such superb results. There are those who want to brag about their constructional skills now, rather than then taking the time to acquire them in the traditional manner, or those that lack the physical skills to do certain handtool tasks (owing to injury or illness).

While I admire the quality of the result produced, I love more the effort taken to achieve quality. In other words, I prefer my woodworking without machines. In fact I go further to prefer certain handtools over others in the quest for increased tool feedback. Light, hands-on tools, such as chisels, spokeshaves, rasps, and block planes are a great deal more pleasurable than that BC contraption will ever be for me. In the past I have raptured on about light wooden planes over heavy metal planes, and I still feel this way when using them - just not when looking at their results. On our hard Aussie timbers it is often a wiser choice to stick to the heavier, higher-angled version.

So this saw machine from BC will have its supporters and detractors. I admire the tool for its design and I admire the manufactuers for their willingness to put their money where their mouth is. It is still not for me ...but I am quite happy to be its reviewer! My address for delivery is on the other side of this letter :)

Regards from Perth

Derek