Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?
ThomD
>It's a nice way to look at it Wiley, but the end result for a lot of the tools really isn't all that great. I got given one of their mortice marking gages, 350, or soemthing, and I like it to look at, but it isn't an improvement over the existing designs that could be many in almost any shop in the country. I'm not talking here of some essoteric personal preferences, it just doesn't work as well as a number of designs that consist of a sharp blade in a few sticks of wood.
They made their innitial name on the squares that were/are a nice tool, but absolutely aren't any more accurate than the wooden one I made 30 years ago as a slip joint project, or the 9 dollar 6" machinist square I have had over the same time. I have nothing against the pretty ones, and could have ended up with one when LV was selling them, I just didn't as it turned out. The basic difference is the fancy presentation. These are basically machinists type tools, and with all those tools they share the flaw of not sitting still on the work all the time. That was solved on the Japanese metal square, and to some lessor extent on plain wooden ones.
I agree this new tool is in a separate catagory since it seems practical, though that may be an illusion. Training wheels are very practical also, though only up to a point. We have lots of jig machines out there like the woodrat. We shall see whether this one hits a home run and gets more than a small piece of the maket or not. I suppose it is possible the market does want a machine that is both slow to set up and to use. In the meantime, the fact they have a subscriber list for the tools they produce does show both the esteme directed towards them, and the reflexive mindset of some purchasers.
"If this machine did not work well, and repeatedly, and did not have an expected pool of buyers, then BC would just lose money. They are not in business to go out of business"
No, though I think they have been down part, or all, of that path.