Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

Posts

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#26

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>Hi Marc,

Caveat: This is idle speculation on my part, which experience teaches me is often incorrect. I offer apologies in advance to anyone for whom this is a serious matter.

I can envision a perfectionist sort of amateur woodworker, maybe one who uses mostly fine power tools, and who wants to have sharp-looking drawers in what he/she makes. This person is very interested in having showpiece drawers, with very fine pin entries and gradation in the pin spacing. Like you see in some period furniture. Router jigs won't cut those. But this person I am thinking about also does not want to spend the time becoming expert at hand-cutting such drawers; it is only the result that is important. So they buy this machine as a practical solution.

I do think your lawnmower example is more interesting however!

Wiley......wondering how much those front-throw reel mowers cost

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#27

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Should take that $20 saw, use the table top for diamond sharpening, use the undercarriage and add a couple of fences on top for a home made jointmaker, leave any cart attached to the undercarriage for height and portability. :)

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#28

Thank you, Marv. It is pretty cool cutting.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#29

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>John, I normally need a long bench for edge and face jointing, and other planing on long boards. I don't see this device obviating these needs.

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#30

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

John Hoffman

>Right I am with you, but I am thinking small size stuff, limited space etc.

Regards

JH

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#31

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

David Cockey

>Why not motorize it if all the user does when actually making the cut is provide power for the blade?

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#32

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Marv....... Northern California Lake Co.

>Yeah, lets motorize it.....it's not expensive enough now, lets get the price up to around $3500.00. Hey, lets computerize it too, then just stick a piece of wood in and stand back...$20,000 anyone?

Kinda defeating the original purpose don'tcha think?

Marv

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#33

Good point, if you never do big.

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#34

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>In the video the cuts look real clean, square in the right places, small kerf, etc. You don't normally get that performance from a table saw, which takes big gasping cuts that are often a bit crooked.

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#35

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro?

ThomD

>It's a nice way to look at it Wiley, but the end result for a lot of the tools really isn't all that great. I got given one of their mortice marking gages, 350, or soemthing, and I like it to look at, but it isn't an improvement over the existing designs that could be many in almost any shop in the country. I'm not talking here of some essoteric personal preferences, it just doesn't work as well as a number of designs that consist of a sharp blade in a few sticks of wood.

They made their innitial name on the squares that were/are a nice tool, but absolutely aren't any more accurate than the wooden one I made 30 years ago as a slip joint project, or the 9 dollar 6" machinist square I have had over the same time. I have nothing against the pretty ones, and could have ended up with one when LV was selling them, I just didn't as it turned out. The basic difference is the fancy presentation. These are basically machinists type tools, and with all those tools they share the flaw of not sitting still on the work all the time. That was solved on the Japanese metal square, and to some lessor extent on plain wooden ones.

I agree this new tool is in a separate catagory since it seems practical, though that may be an illusion. Training wheels are very practical also, though only up to a point. We have lots of jig machines out there like the woodrat. We shall see whether this one hits a home run and gets more than a small piece of the maket or not. I suppose it is possible the market does want a machine that is both slow to set up and to use. In the meantime, the fact they have a subscriber list for the tools they produce does show both the esteme directed towards them, and the reflexive mindset of some purchasers.

"If this machine did not work well, and repeatedly, and did not have an expected pool of buyers, then BC would just lose money. They are not in business to go out of business"

No, though I think they have been down part, or all, of that path.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#36

I want one!

David Barnett - SW Florida

>If nothing else, for latenight insomniac sittin'-on-the bed sawfests. Safe, soporific, and the inevitable drool won't rust the aluminum.

I'd actually use one for smallish and repetitive work I tend to take on. It'd reduce reliance on big noisy things -- I use those Grrrippers for some small stuff on the TS -- but it's still scary.

I'd more aggressively rationalize buying if JE/BC offered a blade for non-ferrous metals. That'd tilt things from 'nice' to 'must have' in a heartbeat.

Kinda pricey, though. But then again, so are fingers and nerves. Not so messy, either, as prepping my bandsaw blade with tallow before sawing 6061 aluminum.

My WC hat's off to BC for exploring jigged handtools. You don't always want or need WofR, especially when product or safety trumps process; i.e. when repeatability and minimal wood waste have the edge over skills.

While it's not an 'oldtool', it's nevertheless a well-designed and well-made handtool, affording all the sensibilities of such, and I find it somehow reverberant of old tools.

Essential? Probably not. It's good to have options, though.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#37

No skill required, just power *LINK*

David Cockey

>From the website: "All you do is provide the easy back-and-forth motion. Between each stroke, you adjust the blade height for the next cut (if necessary)."

The need for skill is over with the Jointmaker Pro once the cut is set up whether muscle or electric power is used. To me this is not hand tool woodworking, rather it is muscle powered machine woodworking. Making a cut on a bandsaw (without a fence) requires at least as much skill.

So a simple setup with a small, fractional horsepower motor (like a sewing machine motor) with a crank providing the back and forth motion and a simple trip mechanism for the blade height adjustment could be used instead of muscle power. Somewhat like the mechanism used on a saw filing machine but considerably smaller.

Perhaps another way to look at this is similar to the difference between foot treadle powered and electric sewing machines - the significant difference is how much work the leg muscles do, not skill.


Jointmaker Pro Website

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#38

Not a circular saw.

David Cockey

>I wasn't suggesting a table saw, just substituting electric power for muscle power in the Jointmaker Pro. Since the JP guides the blade all the JP operator is doing is providing muscle power. Same cut quality should result either way.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#39

Own the "best"

David Cockey

>My perception (guess really) is the majority of Bridge City tool owners are folks with reasonable (or greater) financial means who want to own the "best". For the them the "best" means expensive compared to alternatives with visual and perhaps functional elements to justify the price and provide uniqueness. The whole Bridge City sales pitch seems to be set up with these customers in mind.

Some may use the tools to build fine furniture, others for more modest projects like a doll house for the grandaughter (the Jointmaker Pro would be great for cutting doll house size trim), and a lot of the tools may just sit. I doubt many Bridge City tools are purchased by folks who's primary source of income is woodworking.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#40

Re: Own the "best"

Pam Niedermayer, Austin, TX

>Certainly that's true; but I contend that BC doesn't offer the "best," merely unique and reasonably well engineered.

Pam

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#41

Re: Own the "best"

Thomas S Stockton

>Right on Pam but you forgot pretty

Tom

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#42

Yea!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>If'in a can't get a uni for that much, I could loose a finger for more cost!

Sweet dude!

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#43

There is a difference between desing and true...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>function. Being trained as a designer it's a true "over the top" design. A bit too much IMHO, but most BS tools are to me. That said you could get away with a home grown version that would do more and cost a lot less.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#44

Yea Dom! The designen engerres speak!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I'm in completely agree!

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#45

I completly agree with your first satement..

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>But wat they consider the best if often misconscrewed 8^)

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#46

WOW, I'll leared to spell one day..

Scott in BL Ca

>

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#47

Don't know Marv...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Looks like those fences could become clamps...

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#48

Non Judgmental?

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Sure sounds like we just heard your judgment on it.

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#49

Response to who?

David Cockey

>Who was your response directed to?

Re: Thoughts on Bridge City's Jointmaker Pro? *LINK*

#50

Ignore message above

David Cockey

>Ignore the message above, the "cherrys" or whatever they are mislead me.