Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

best plane for dovetails?

Posts

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#26

Re: best plane for dovetails?

David

>It's just the pins. The drawer is sized correctly. When I have needed to trim down a pin it's only a small bit. The article I read suggested that pins should be made long and trimmed after glue up (rather than trying to get the length exact?).

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#27

Respectfully, what in the world ...

GregB

>are we talking about here??? This is all backwards. I don't take FWW anymore, but this sounds like bad advice.

I can't imagine attempting to properly fit a drawer after marking and cutting halflap dovetails in a drawer front and leaving the pins proud. So why would we discuss planes, chisels and spelching? It should go the other way around.

The drawer front is fitted to the carcass opening. Then the marking is done. It is actually best to use two marking gauges, one for the length of the tails/depth they extend into the drawer front. The other for the thickness of the drawer sides, which is also the depth of the sockets cut into the drawer front. This setting should be a tiny bit smaller than the drawer side thickness.

This is precisely to avoid a situation where the pins are proud of the sides. With the sides a little "thick", the drawer front remains correctly fitted to the opening. You can also tap the sides home during glue-up and not have to worry about fashioning a special jig to allow solid tapping and miss the protruding pins. You then gently plane the sides, front to back, until the plane iron just meets the pins.

There should be no worry of spelching this way. You stop planing when the drawer sides (the tails) are planed just to this thickness. The drawers, as a whole, should still be fitted properly to their respective openings. The drawer front will not have changed dimensions or shape (not always a perfect rectangle) the birds sing and all is still right with the world.

If I have missed the point here, I truly apologize. Does this make sense?

cheers,

Greg

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#28

Re: Respectfully, what in the world ...

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Greg,

As you know, it's virtually impossible to cut the depth of the tail sockets to match the thickness of the drawer side stock.

We're not talking a very huge difference, just what's needed to flatten things out.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#29

Re: Wrong responses

ThomD

>"And the problem is....? :@) "

No problem, just trying to reasure the patient that all was not lost in the provision of alternatives, it can be a "both and".

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#30

Other way around - shorter pins and tails

David Cockey

>Greg's method is what Ian Kirby recommends. It takes into account that it's about impossible to cut the sockets and pins so they match the thickness of the boards exactly. But it makes a different assumption about measuring.

The basic assumption of this method are

1)The outside dimensions are more critical than the inside dimensions. The precise thickness of the sides doesn't matter if the outside dimensions are correct.

2)It's simplier and more accurate and trim to cut boards to exact lengths than to try to control the depth of dovetails exactly.

After cutting the dovetails slightly shallow to ensure the faces are proud of the ends, the faces are planed even with the ends. The result is a drawer/box/etc with outside dimensions of the length of the boards.

The disadvantage is the end grain is not planed so any damage to it is not cleaned up.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#31

Re: a rasp?

ThomD

>That's the technique I use on hardwoods, some of the time. It fills quite remarkable erors, not that I have any problems you know... It giveth and it taketh. I watch the direction I am working because incorrectly applied is will keep a gap in play.

I don't think the thing I use is a rasp, it's a course file. The actual one I have used over the years was real cheap so it's intended purpose could only be guessed at not looked up. It might be a mill file. The mill bastard is finer, and occasionally takes off at an angle and leaves some lines. I use the masking tape trick one has to keep an eye on it, because one wants minimal tape, but eventually the teeth can poke through.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#32

Re: Respectfully, what in the world ...

GregB

>Hi Andrew,

I do understand we must not be talking about pins much too proud. My question has to do less with matching thicknesses, but more with fitting a drawer to an opening. After all that planing and shooting to mate each front to its own opening, I cringe at the idea of removing any further shavings from its length.

Also, I'd just never heard of this method, so it sounded strange to my preset thinking.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#33

Re: Other way around - shorter pins and tails

GregB

>Hi David,

I never read Kirby on this subject, but did assume it to be the traditional method. (Now watch that remark draw some fire!) I'm sure Alan Peters, OBE (Edward Barnsley Workshop) does it this way, so probably Rob Cosman would too. I can't remember if it's demonstrated in his video. David Charlesworth also teaches this fitting/constructing method. I believe it's in his second book. I'm not near my library. I think his is the best single written explanation, with photos and illustrations, I've ever read.

Actually, the endgrain of the pins is cleaned up. A minute whisper of a shaving is taken just at the last pass. At that point the fitting job should be just right.

As for inside dimensions, I don't cut the bottom until the rest of the drawer is fitted and done. I never do it to a measurement, but rather to fit the space, always a little over and then a few shavings to fit. So you're right; this isn't a problem.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#34

It's common, Greg. *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Greg,

You typically have to remove a few shavings off the side of a drawer to get it to run properly.

I linked below to a discussion on 'traditional drawer' fitting.

The method advocated here is what is being referenced.

A drawer needs to finish up with a scant 1mm clearance all around the face, yet it is initially cut to fit so that it is a 'plug' in the opening, not even fitting correctly.

It needs some work.

Apologies for a brief reply. I'm in the middle of writing a text and am suffering a combination of writer's block and burnout at the moment. The links will tell you everything about the technique that I was going to, anyway.

In your initial description, you forgot the part about leaving the drawer to dry in it's opening, so that the shape of the drawer and any non-perpendicular angles are set to dry correctly.

Cheers,

Andrew

Cheers,


traditional drawer links

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#35

Re: It's common, Greg.

GregB

>Thanks, Andrew.

I get it. And yes, the starting point for drawer front fitting is to have it only just enter the opening, leaving the outside, or show side of the drawer, slightly too large to enter. This makes it sort of like a "stopper" in shape. I just checked my Charlesworth, vol. 2 and there is a diagram of this. I hadn't heard of leaving the front in the opening to acclimate. Now that would require patience!

I didn't mention all phases of fitting in my initial post, which only concerned leaving pins proud. The chapters in vol. 2 are excellent and do the topic justice. I couldn't.

Thank you for the links. I must admit to it being too late and me being too tired to look just yet. So, touche'! I "feel you".

Thanks again,

Greg

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#36

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I've heard both arguments,pins long to trim and pins short and plane sides.Personally I prefer shooting for exact fit.It's not that hard to achieve and less work.However,I don't try for piston fit drawers either.---Jack

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#37

Re: It's common, Greg.

Dean J in MN

>Let's throw a wrench in the practice of planing from front to back to do the final fitting...

Lipped drawers.

-Dean

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#38

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>The thing to bear in mind is that you will have to define--on the drawer front--a reference line that will not move and not be trimmed. The drawer front has to carry the reference for fit against the enclosure.

Soooo. You can make the outer drawer edges--the pin ends--the reference, and in that case you achieve fit by not overcutting the sockets on the drawer front that the drawer sides will bed against. This leads to Ian Kirby's thought of making the pin ends exact and the drawer sides proud, and trimming the sides to fit. Or. You can decide to make the aforementioned scribe line and socket base on the pins board the reference--this is what the sides will bed against. And cut exactly to that line. If you do that, the pins can be as long as you want, but the side thickness needs to at least cover the pin ends.

It's just a case of deciding what to use as your reference, and then letting the details of trimming be guided by that choice. I like Kirby's method myself, because you can then cut the drawer front to get an exact fit to the enclosure opening, plus use it for testing the runners/sidewalls for fit in depth.

Wiley

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#39

false fronts

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#40

Re: It's common, Greg.

GregB

>Thanks, Andrew.

Just got a chance to check the links you supplied. Too late for me last night as well. Couldn't get the Alan Peters article to work. If it's the same one which appeared in FWW some years ago, I still have it somewhere.

Cheers,

Greg