Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

best plane for dovetails?

Posts

best plane for dovetails?

#1

best plane for dovetails?

David

>I've always tried to cut dovetails so that they needed minimal attention after everything was glued up. If the pins were too long, I'd (bite my tongue) hit 'em with a sander. I was reading Fine Woodworking the other day and saw the statement that you should run your pins long and flush them with a plane afterward.

So my question, what's the best plane to use for this? Low angle block?

Always in the mood to buy a new tool...

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#2

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Joel

>I use a Bedrock 604. I don't think the plane matters as long as it is sharp.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#3

any plane for dovetails

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi David,

Any plane is fine for dovetails.

Another tip -> when making your drawer sides, one of the overriding factors aside from quartersawn stock is to make sure that you align the drawer sides so that you plane from front to back, to avoid spelching out the drawer front.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#4

Great Advice

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.

>Great advice, took me a few times to get that one right,

I like to use a low angle plane to shave the sides, it's end graina nd long grain, I want a light clean cut.

Take care,

Jim

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Wrong responses

Jack Guzman from Maine

>You guys missed the point. David wants to buy a new tool.

David,get a 4 1/2. It's what works best for me.A block plane will work but it's a little small for the job. Now,a low angle bevel up jack plane...---Jack

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#6

Darrell in Oakville

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Darrell in Oakville

>One question to ask is: are your drawers purposely made too wide to start with so that you need to plane them, or is it just the pins that need trimming?

I usually use a paring chisel to trim any protruding pins. Then, if the drawer is too wide it gets planed with whichever plane is sharpest at the time. Sharp matters more than cutting angle, in my experience.

So I guess my advice would be to forego a new plane, and get ahold of a really nice paring chisel. I have a Howarth chisel 1 1/2" wide, with a VERY thin profile. Works great on this kind of job.

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#7

Re: Wrong responses

Don in Vancouver,WA,USA

>If you really wont to buy a new tool then an alternative to the sander or hand plane is a float. Go to LN buy a couple of his floats and his recommended file, sharpen the floats and grind/plane down the pins. And if you have an old horse you can use the floats to knock of the sharp edges of his teeth. Vets float an old horse's teeth but I wonder if the term float originated by Vets or woodworkers? Personally I use the sander to remove long pins but I do use floats to finish the shoulders of dovetails.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#8

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Dean J in MN

>Case dovetails or drawer dovetails?

I asked the guys at Williamsburg what they use for case dovetails. You'd never guess the response.

A toothing plane.

So, there, you have a new tool to hunt down!

-Dean

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#9

Float

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Apparently the woodworking tool was up first, the OED lists it as 1750 and the vet reference is 1886.

Stephen

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#10

Re: Float

Don in Vancouver,WA,USA

>I had a Vet float my horse's teeth in the 1970's and bought LN's floats a couple of years ago. One day that light bulb in my head went off connecting the two! I find that after I got the floats I find them very useful...replacing rasps, files, and planes. They leave a nice burnished finish compared to a rasp or file.You do have to keep them sharp just like a plane.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#11

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Jim in VA

>More info, please. Is that because the toothing plane marks are then covered by molding? Or do they remove the tooth marks with a regular plane? If the later, why not do drawers the same way?

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#12

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Toothing plane is like a flat rasp and doesn't tend to chip out problem or end grain and is easily smoothed with a scraper. The change in grain direction from flat to end isn't a problem with a toothing plane.

Stephen

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#13

Thanks Jim, reword

Andrew F in Australia

>Try this as a clearer reword

Another tip -> when making your drawer sides, one of the overriding factors aside from using quartersawn stock is to make sure that you orient the grain in the drawer sides when setting out/cutting the drawer dovetails so that, when you plane down the protruding pins, you plane from the front towards the back of the drawer, to avoid spelching out the drawer front.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#14

Spelching

wilbur

>"to avoid spelching out the drawer front."

Spelching. What a great word. I am going to use that word in conversation sometime tomorrow, even though I have no idea what it means.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#15

Spelch forth, Wilbur

Andrew F in Australia

>

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#16

Re: Spelch forth, Wilbur  *LINK*

Andrew F in Australia

>


linky thing -> definition

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#17

Re: Spelching

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Spelch does pretty much ruin a piece of woodworking. There are two ways typically used to avoid the condition: 1) you can't spelch if your plane/chisel is working from wood edge toward the body or 2) if you brace a wood edge with a sacrificial piece of wood so it can't split when you plane/chisel.

Pam

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#18

Re: best plane for dovetails?

David

>I was referring to dovetails on drawers since I've never done any casework with dovetails, but trying isn't too far off in the future.

Plane versus chisel is interesting, never thought about using a chisel to do this. I'll have to play as I keep my eye out for a #4 1/2. And thanks for the advice on planing direction. Thought I understood from the first post, better after clarification.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#19

Re: best plane for dovetails?

Dean J in MN

>I didn't ask if they smoothed the marks left behind when flushing pins. I rather doubt it as they would all be covered anyway, or on the top and bottom of the case as these usually have the pins in case pieces.

Dean

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#20

One other thing

Wiley Horne -- So. Calif.

>If you skew the plane a little before it hits the pins, this will ease the entry, plus lower the attack angle a bit. Sharp is most important however, as others have said.

Wiley

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#21

Re: Wrong responses

ThomD

>Most of the "you can just use" posts are actually recomendations for even more tools!

I mean floats? Good suggestion, but they cost more than most planes. Toothing planes?, finishing planes , of course. A guy could fill a shop off this question alone.

I use files sometimes. Files without looking as though they are doing it, actually deform enough wood to make joints look like they were melted together at the ends. A plane cuts a little faster, but if one is in any doubt as to the fit...

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#22

I pulled it off

wilbur

>We were having our weekly meeting today where we talk about hard to treat cases, and today we were talking about a teenage girl with a very weird thyroid tumor, and how aggressive we should get with chemotherapy in the absence of any real data to show the efficacy of chemotherapy in this particular situation.

I said, "Well, we should keep in mind that we don't want to spelch the girl with therapy that may not even be indicated."

Interestingly, no one knew what the word meant, but everyone knew exactly what my point was.

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#23

Re: Wrong responses

wilbur

>"Most of the "you can just use" posts are actually recomendations for even more tools!"

And the problem is....? :@)

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#24

check the dictionary of urban slang

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Wilbur,

Before you use it widely, you may want to check the dictionary of urban slang (google will give you the link.)

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: best plane for dovetails?

#25

Moses Yoder

Re: a rasp?

Moses Yoder

>James Krenov recommends wrapping some tape aroudn the end fo a rasp so it won't mar the drawer sides and rasping the tails flush with the sides then finishing with a plane. I noted taht David Charlesworth recommended leaving the drawer sides proud of the ends so the end grain on the tails would not need to be trimmed; the side would just be planed flush to the tails. This seems like it would work but would require more accuracy in the joints so you don't need to remove too much amterial on the sides. I am thinking my next batch of tails will be left about 1/32" stong of the drawer sides and made flush with a rasp then the drawer side planed. My favorite smoother is a 604-1/2. The best plane I have for end grain is the LN 60-1/2R. I plan on buying the LV low angle block plane with a few of the attachments with profits from one of my next few projects. The only trick to planing end grain is to have a good hard iron and make it sharp. I like a sharp chisel for trimming also.