Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Strad violin makers planes

Posts

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#51

Re: Here is a neat article on Violin making *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>St. Roy did a violin making survey show with Joe Thrift, a fiddler and maker, in 2007, available on the web.

Pam


St. Roy's 2007 shows

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#52

Ah, gotcha...

Alan DuBoff

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#53

Re: Strad violin makers planes

ThomD

>"That an unmodified early violin doesn�t sound good may result from any number of factors, including: that you are used to the modern sound concept; that the instrument was never converted because it didn�t sound good to begin with; that the luthier who set up the instrument or the player who played it are not best qualified to make the most of the situation. :-)"

One problem might be hearing it at all! It's not just rock musicians who kept playing larger venues with ever louder instruments. I seem to recall a critical factor is the new bow. The Baroque bow looks like a longbow, or a U bent stick.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There are elements of mind set and technique which may be revealed through using such a tool which might be missed in using another tool, no matter how ideal in every respect the other tool is."

You are doubtless right, though there is something suspiciously tool-centered about our approach. Most older craftspeople I know, even pre-70s or non-US/Can/Eng etc... are nowhere near as tool centered as we are. There was a wandering guitar maker from Israel a few years back who made a fairly complex Baroque guitar, with nothing more than a Jackknife.

It is also possible that while Strad was a master instrument maker he was not a master planer, not hard to believe at all. What he knows about planes could be as little as we care about a power planer that just gets the job done. It might be interesting to talk to the guy who made them.

Those planes, as little as I could tell, seemed to be folded metal. The most critical parts would be the sole contour, blade contour, and mouth, none of which was completely in evidence.

Another thing that seems to get lost in the recreation of this stuff is that there are much larger Strads than the violins alone, and they had to bust out some serious wood to get those done. I want to see his guttering adze, and jackplane sized contour planes.

And yet another is that you don't generally need narrow mouths to plane downhill, in very fine quality riven wood.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#54

Re: Tomato alert!!

ThomD

>I rented that and early on there is some scene where a maker gets upset, has a tantrum and smashes the piece he was working on. Might have been when I was making guitars. Anyway, I just turned the movie off and that was that. So completely unbelieveable I figured the rest was a waste of time.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#55

Re: Chris Farley me another one

ThomD

>If the world works here the way it works elsewhere, Strad is rolling in his grave wondering why they only seem to like the ones he made as school instruments.

Everyone agrees that Strads are the best... Yet there not only isn't any agree upon reason why that is the case, but there isn't any repeatable test to prove it. Yet there is an elite of instrument collectors, musicians, and others who re-enforce the impression, keep the careers and instruments circulating. Nobody wants to admit it isn't true because there wouldn't be anything to be gained by doing so, so long as the instruments remain cridible and in the hands of the very best musicians.

If you think the musicians are credible sources on all this you should follow the interplay between Segovia and his makers. Segovia at least had the smarts to tell people (in every city) they were the future of the guitar. Which is pretty clever really: Either it's true and everyone is happy, or it isn't true and nobody notices.

Recently a fairly top violinist Chris Farleyed his irreplaceable violin, now there are some matchsticks for analysis. Or will the insurance company, restorer, musician and owner sort the whole thing out carefully between themselves. Who wants to: Pay out the claim; admit they can't fix it; have their picture appear in the wiki section set aside for Gerald Ford; loose their entry to society. "you know that violin is even better since the accident!"

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#56

Oh, too bad, you missed a good movie

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#57

Re: Royal Palace on my list of places to visit!

Hank Knight

>Alan,

I was close. Here's what Wikipedia has to say about the Madrid collection:

The world's two largest publicly accessible collections of Stradivari instruments belong to the Agency of National Estates of Spain, consisting of two violins, two cellos, and a viola, exhibited in the Music Museum at the Palacio Real de Madrid (Royal Palace), and the U.S. Library of Congress' collection of three violins, a viola, and a cello.

I recommend Madrid and the Stradivarius collection is a good reason to go.

Hank

Hank

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#58

The Violin Maker

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks for the recommendation, Mike, a very good read, very informative, realistically inconclusive.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#59

Re: The Violin Maker

Mike Fitterling

>Glad you enjoyed it, Pam. I thought it might have more in it about the woodworking involved, but I was not disappointed with the intriguing discussion of the philosophy, tradition, mysticism, and legends of that craft.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#60

Re: The Violin Maker

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, read it knowing that Marchese's craft is writing, not woodworking or finishing or playing an instrument at a top level (although he does play trumpet at a semi-pro level, so probably has a good ear). For the actual building there must be 100 good books, some of which he recommends. I got a very short book from the library called Violin making : a guide for the amateur by Bruce Ossman, which provides form designs, cheap clamps and other jigs he shows you how to make, and templates. I wanted a quick review and got it.

The finish Sam Zygmuntowicz applies is interesting. Apparently he uses a heat lamp to apply a preliminary "sealer/penetrator" before any varnish or oil. Anybody know what this might be?

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#61

Re: The Violin Maker

ThomD

>The cournall book is good for pictures and processes, and the Lee Valley book has some interesting stuff in it.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#62

Re: The Violin Maker

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thom, "cournall" returns no results in an Amazon search and the LV Books section shows no books on violin making. A little more help, please. :)

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#63

Re: The Violin Maker *LINK*

David W. Dougherty

>The book is "The Art of Violin Making" by Chris Johnson and Roy Courtnall--I highly recommend it if you're interested in making a violin. Howard Core sells it (link below).

The "Lee Valley book" mentioned above is really a re-print of a very old text written by Edward Heron-Allen titled "Violin Making As It Was and Is". LV might have discontinued selling it, as I can no longer find it on their web site. I bought my copy from them about four years ago.

You might also have a look at the books written by Henry Strobel (www.henrystrobel.com). They're not quite up to the standard of J&C (above) in terms of polish and completeness of presentation, but they are excellent references. Mine are just about worn out (as it my copy of J&C).

Good luck Pam!

David


Howard Core Company LLC

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#64

Re: The Violin Maker

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, David, got me right on track. Unfortunately the Johnson/Courtnall book appears to be out of print already, and the cheapest available copy is $120+. Sure hope there's a paperback in the making.

I'm in the study stage on this, may get up the nerve to try to tune a couple of Jack's old violins in the next few months.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#65

Re: The Violin Maker *LINK*

David W. Dougherty

>FWIW, I didn't pay much less than that when I bought my copy years ago. It has never been a cheap book. There really isn't such a thing as a cheap violin making/repair book. I've spent thousands on my very small library.

If you're interested in repairing or fixing up violins, there is no better text than "Violin Restoration: A Manual for Violin Makers" by Hans Weisshaar and Margaret Shipman; another expensive tome.

David


http://www.weisshaarrepairbook.com/

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#66

Re: The Violin Maker

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Ouch. I'm not really contesting the value of these books, but I am contesting my ability to even understand them at this point. I've put them all in my wish list, but think the Ossman book for amateurs is more appropriate for me. Besides, it's at the library. :)

Thanks, David.

Pam