Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Strad violin makers planes

Posts

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#26

They do today, and have the tools to prove it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#27

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Then you'll need a lot better photos. To say nothing of some measurements.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#28

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Dean Lapinel

>Pam,

Please read the first post.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#29

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Geesh, I did Dean, was simply reiterating that you don't have enough information to build the planes to reexperience Stradivardi's process, a way to end my part of the conversation. Of course, I think that's more or less impossible and not very useful for building violins today, too many variables from steel composition to electric glue pots and coffee pots; but I'll cheer on all tilters, read your book, watch your dvd, etc. :)

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#30

You seem bitter...

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

You seem bitter about Stradivarius, I'm not sure why. He is the epitome of violin makers, if ever one was. If you look into the violins that the makers around the world are producing nowadays, you will find that there is one single maker who they have *copied* with the majority of instruments...yes, Stradivarius. Do you think that is coincidence? The Japanese, the Europeans, the Chinese, the Americans, the South Americans, etc...the world continues to copy the maker and the violins in hopes of achieving similar results.

So far, nobody has been able to produce such quality in their instruments. One would have to conclude that Stradivarius seemed to know what he was doing, close to 300 years ago. Seems to be the best gage to go by...To see the tools Stradivarius used tells one it certainly wasn't the tools, it was the maker. It for the same reason people like you are inspired by a maker of furniture, or other woodworking. There is nothing wrong with that, and I can understand where Dean is coming from.

Maybe it's just a rough day for you...I can understand. Please accept this virtual cold one I'm sliding down the virtual bar on the inet.

wwwwwwhhhhhooooooooooooooosssssssssssshhhhhhhhhh!

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#31

Re: Violin Lore

Alan DuBoff

>For some reason I thought Guarneris were rooted to Strad, my bad, I'm not a violin maker, just a bass player...:-/

I'm glad Heifetz's violin is being played, that beats sitting in a glass case any day of the week!

There was a gent who works at the Strad museum who's job it is to play the instruments. Maybe you don't subscribe to the theory that a played instrument sounds better, but I think I do.

Would you agree that Strad seemed to change the direction of the violin in the sense that his designs are still the most copied today, seems before that many of the violins were chunkier/fatter in comparison to the thinner design which Strad used. Many of the great Guarneris were of similar vintage to the Strads, which leads some makers to the conclusion of the theories such as insecticides. I suspect that the Guarneris and the Stradivarius familes were pretty friendly in those days and shared information freely with each other. Could be wrong about that though...

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#32

Re: You seem bitter...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Not at all, just a little tired of another go round with Dean, and wondering what I said to cause it, if I did. We seem to butt heads and talk past each other. Sure would like to break that cycle.

I know that Stradivari was great, no question, but none of us knows why; so I consider the pursuit of his experience a windmill, unattainable. Also, I'd bet there are a few contemporary makers whose violins are at least as good, but they don't get the press they deserve; so once again, marketing rules. (I may be a little bitter about that. :))

Also, this whole idea of calling one maker's violins "the best" is illogical, intellectually weak. Best for what? For producing the same old sound? How about some new sounds? How about violin planemakers making some new innovative planes? Whole thing smacks of the reproduction industry to me; but then I get hung up on originality and creativity, working from scratch to see what happens.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#33

Plenty of pretty scenery on various roads

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I recall a Fine Woodworking article some years back on 18th century furniture building that examined the work of several current builders, some of whom were intent on building exactly as the old makers did, with a goal of understanding intimately what their work experience was - clearly an impossible goal, as Pam points out, what with coffee pots and all (modern plumbing and hygiene, electric lights, the severe lack of 10-year-old apprentices sleeping under the workbench...the list just goes on and on). Others were examining the designs and rethinking some of the practices with a goal of making furniture that respected all the design decisions while improving on structural weaknesses that two centuries had exposed in 18th century practices.

Two parts of the article stick in my mind:

1. A discussion of corner blocks in the base, and the question of whether standard 18th-century practice led to cross-grain gluing (it does), the hazards thereof, and one maker's more complex construction of corner blocks that don't use cross-grain construction, and, related to this part,

2. Quoting Eugene Landon as being delighted when cross-grain construction on one of his pieces led to the panels cracking, because it was authentic.

Now me, if I were putting in the hours involved in building one of those pieces (and a similar project is on the fantasy list, WAY down there), I'd do my level best to build something that wouldn't be cracked when my so-far hypothetical grandchildren were arguing over who was going to get it. But I appreciate the dedication of those who are trying to understand how the makers got there with the tools they were using.

I think we fail in our conversation when we think that one's intrinsically better than the other. Depends on the goals.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#34

We seem to be in sync on this, Bill.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#35

Re: Violin Lore

A. Sender

>Alan, I think it�s fine that Heifetz� instrument is being played, although I don�t go to those concerts so I would have more fun going down and seeing the instrument in its case, which is always good for an hour or two.

Strad certainly did something special with violins, but you can�t characterize it in terms of gross differences in shape. One can find instruments from before Strad�s time which are superficially similar, the Amati brothers and indeed Nicolo Amati often used similar models. Even late in life Strad made some rather high-arched violins. Stradivari worked out some key shifts in things like the shape of the arching and the graduations of the back, and orchestrated those changes with other choices from the soup of what had come before, and he just did it in a way that proved particularly successful.

There is reason to think Guarneri Del Gesu was influenced by Stradivari (one sees it in the instruments themselves, especially some earlier ones), but whether there was actual exchange of information is as far as I know impossible to tell.

Paul�I am he. I am fascinated by early bows but it�s hard to find time for making them lately, I have 4 languishing on a shelf at the moment.

Andres

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#36

Re: You seem bitter...

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

Need to run to work (I hate that;-), but wanted to say that I do agree with your points. It is silly to hold a single maker to the top, and there are many fine violins, even modern makers that know how to craft wonderful instruments.

Why is it that all these people strive to be like Stradivarius? It is a mystery to musical instrument makers, not only for violins but other instruments as well. I think it is similar to woodworkers striving to be like Moxon, or similar. These are merely inspirations to some of us that may otherwise not experience the passion, some of those masters do help us to be able to learn from their work. Stradivarius was so unique, and such a humble and honest craftsman, if the letters in the museum are anything to go by, and I believe they are. Strad seemed like a guy who was more than willing to work with others, although he had some secrets that weren't shared.

People like Dean (and even me;-) are driven by passion of one man's work, and I too admire such a person as Stradivarius must have been. Some power to be gave that man the talent to be what people 300 years later are saying was "the best". Damn, that's a pretty honorable reference, IMO.

Overdone by some of us? Well, passion has a way of doing that...*wink*

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#37

Re: Violin Lore

Alan DuBoff

>Andres wrote:

"Alan, I think it�s fine that Heifetz� instrument is being played, although I don�t go to those concerts so I would have more fun going down and seeing the instrument in its case, which is always good for an hour or two."

Andres, I pretty much agree, but there is a chance I could hear it, since I live in the Bay area...I hate to admit I haven't been to hear the symphony in the "City", but I do go to the Youth Symphony in San Jose, which is closer to my heart as I have 2 kids, 12 year old daughter who plays piano and bass clarinet, and a 16 year old son that plays tenor sax now, but did play violin as a child for about 3-4 years.

I am a parent who tried to get his daughter to play violin when she was less than 2 years old, and while it took me and our teacher almost a full year to get her to play the first song in Suzuki (Twinkle-Twinkle), the thought can still bring a tear to my eye just thinking back...

There are many great violins to see, but I'm thrilled that such a great violin is being played, it will continue to bring joy to hundreds if not thousands of people, and the concert master is no better person to hold that, I hold those people with the utmost respect.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#38

Re: You seem bitter...

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I would agree that we would be much better off trying to make some progress instead of trying to recreate what we imagine the past was like. Although there is nothing wrong with recreating history. Maybe we can chew on that for a while. I'm just going though a stage now where I don't believe the past was nearly as good as we think it was.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#39

Some of those windmills were sawmills

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#40

And many of us are Tilters

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#41

Re: You seem bitter...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, and I'm just waiting for the day when it's revealed that Mrs. Stradivari was the one who suggested that he modify the design in several ways, including using that ultra cheap, thoroughly soaked, wood from the river. :)

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#42

I do like the water theory...

Alan DuBoff

>Pam,

I actually do like the water theory, in the sense that wood changes in water. Maybe the wood partially rotted in the water, and then he used the insecticides, a double theory...;-)

One would think that after 300 years somebody would figure it out thought, right? :-/

Modern violins are different to me, yet still excellent instruments. I can appreciate any quality instrument, new or old. Tools are the same to me. I did make a living for myself selling vintage guitars, but violins are in a different class. To be considered one of the all time best in such a high class says a lot for Stradivarius.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#43

Re: I do like the water theory...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'm actually amazed that we've figured out as much as we have. This is a typical determine-the-components-from-decomposition problem, similar to chemical combinations from which we try to analyze the components, which is often impossible because some chemicals make others when combined.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#44

Re: I like the one about the insecticides...

Hank Knight

>Alan DuBoff asked, "Have you ever had the pleasure to see a Strad up close? There's all types of various sizes and types, bunches a lute type instruments and such that he made. Very fascinating aspect of woodworking, IMO, the mystery continues... "

Fransisco Franco was enamored of beautiful musical instruments. If you get to Madrid, go to the Royal Palace. There is a small room off the main music room where a number of of certified Stradivari instrumnets are on display. I think there are seven, but it may be only five (it's been 12 years since I was there and my memory is not what it once was). There are several violins, a couple of violas and a cello or two. They are displayed in glass enclosures; and, while you can't touch, you can get very close to examine them. I felt like I was in some kind of temple - it was really impressive.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#45

Re: I do like the water theory...

wilbur

>I seem to recall reading about the practice of deliberately submerging trunks (don't remember which trees, but I think it was pine or some other softwood) in a body of water which would leach/dissolve the resins out of the wood, which made the wood better to work with.

Violin tops are made with spruce, so it might benefit from this treatment.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#46

Royal Palace on my list of places to visit!

Alan DuBoff

>Hank,

I will definitely try to get there if I get to Madrid. At the Stradivarius museum in Cremona, they have many various instruments, most of them in large glass cases, but all to see and observe. My favorite was a letter written by Stradivarius himself, and signed to one of the great violin players of the day...and it said something as such...

Sradivarius wrote: (paraphrased)

"it is my pleasure to be able to repair your violin. You are one of the greatest musicians and I am honored to work on it for you. I am only charging you a very small amount as I am so honored to work on an instrument for a person like you, please accept this as a token of my admiration."

I can't remember the exact text, and it was hand written so some was hard to read, but this was what it kinda said. Considering he was one of the greatest violin makers of all time, it was so nice to know that he was truly an honest and genuine person. This is a rare quality to find in someone that is so superior in their area of expertise. Not unique, but certainly rare.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#47

Here is a neat article on Violin making *LINK*

Sandor in Middletown, DE

>http://www.violins.demon.co.uk/making/index.htm

I've always wanted to make one. It's on the list for when I retire in 30 years. I started playing violin in 4th grade, but haven't really played since my band in college covered Camper Von Bethoven's version of Pictures of Matchstick Men. Grin. Usually I played Bass.

Sandor


Making a Violin the traditional way

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#48

Re: I do like the water theory...

Alan DuBoff

>Pam wrote:

"I'm actually amazed that we've figured out as much as we have. This is a typical determine-the-components-from-decomposition problem, similar to chemical combinations from which we try to analyze the components, which is often impossible because some chemicals make others when combined."

I think this is over-simplifying things a bit, in the sense that people are still grasping for straws to figure it out. Keep in mind that most violinists are the most scrutinizing and accomplished musicians, IMO, and the average person has a hard time discerning subtle differences between the sound which an accomplished violinist will notice. Violins are not just a work of art, they instrument art form in themselves.

To the unsuspecting, your comment above is spot-on. Many things are accomplished with the above scenario you've outlined, but in this one case it has not helped, yet! To compound this issue, the instruments have such high value that even the people that do own them are often reluctant to let anyone do any type of analysis where the wood could be changed.

The fact that people are willing to pay outrageous sums of money to possess one of these rare and superb instruments, shows there is unique qualities about them. If I ever had enough $$$s, I'd be more than happy to own one...but reality hasn't provided me the ability to do just that...it is good to dream though...

For lack of a better analogy..."..if I were a rich man..." ;-)

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#49

the water theory...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>As A. Sender mentioned in a Violin Lore post, explanations like this are largely discounted by the serious makers of today, who are probably the best in almost three centuries. Some people want to believe that there is some trick that made the old violins better, that the old makers couldn't possibly have had more skill or better feel.

We see this attitude on this forum all the time. Some people just are not interested in skills that take a long time to acquire. They are always looking for some trick so they can avoid the pain of discipline, practice and experience.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#50

Wait, please reread, I just said that...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>it was probably impossible to determine the reasons in this case because of irreducibility problems.

Pam