Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Strad violin makers planes

Posts

Strad violin makers planes

#1

Strad violin makers planes

Dean Lapinel

>Here is a photo of some of Strad's violin making planes. I'm trying to get additional photos for an attempt to replicate them as closely as possible. I'll probably cast in Silicon bronze though so many of us luthiers can share the resulting work.

These are likely late 17th cent iron planes with a curved sole, fairly wide mouth. I was hoping for input from those of you that may have seen these or similar period planes.

That metal tab on one of those planes doesn't appear to be attached or part of the main body. Function?

Any guess if these used to be stuffed in front or open like many older planes.

If you have photos of similarly styled planes of that period it would be helpful.

Thanks,

Dean


img

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#2

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Joel

>Diderot has drawings. While certainly of a period and a style I doubt they work better than the Preston violin planes of the late 19th century.THese look fairly beat up

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#3

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Dean Lapinel

>Diderot has drawings of these?

Fun and a form of connection with the Master violin maker is a large part but I haven't found a finger plane that suits me yet so I want to try these. The sole curvature is a little more radical and that would allow for rocking to better adapt to certain areas of the violin.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#4

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Why not make some wooden planes to suit your needs exactly? They'd be very easy to trim and shape on the fly. Small size blades are available from Japanese smiths, such as Mosaku, and there are a set of Japanese fingers that Mifuqwai has occasionally. And then there are the Bill Carter versions.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#5

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Alan DuBoff

>Great pics, me and my wife were at the Strad Museum in Cremona about 3 years ago but they wouldn't let us take any pics inside. There was some phony place in the San Marco square which had some old violins, but some of the other makers told me those are phoneys and are not actually real to how they claim they are. They certainly were old violins...

Some of the other tools in the Strad museum were really cool, I remember some old dividers and calipers which were hand made that were really interesting. Really put a perspective on what it must have been like to build violins during the 17th century.

People still trying to figure out why his violins were so special, why they sound so good, others don't seem to be as good...I've heard all types of theories, but none hold water, except the one where the logs sat in the water in Venice for a long time and maybe that had something to do with it. LOL!

Where did you get those pics?

FWIW, Heifetz's Guarneri is in the art museum in San Francisco. Guarneri was a student of Stradivarius, possibly why his violins also sounded good...but heck, most everyone went to Cremona to learn how to build violins not only back in those days, but still to this day.

If those are from the late 17th century, they're from the later part of Strad's career, or what was considered the best era. That era started just about 1700 and went for about 20-30 years. The best ones are to be about 1710-1715 if I remember correctly. Strad died about 1740 or so...

It is amazing that he made just over 1000 instruments, at least by calculation, and about 65 percent of those instruments are still intact today. Now that's what I call an old tool...;-) Fascinating man, fascinating instruments, a lot to be learned from him still...

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#6

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The Tabs at the back are the ends of the irons. They could have been rolled over at the ends so they didn't cut into a finger. Generally 17th century violins had more curvature in the belly than 19th century. This could have been reflected in some of the planes. I think planes without enough curvature could be modified somewhat by the user.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#7

Why not make them from iron like the originals?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Warren is right the tab is the end of the blade.

The violins sounded different because they were made from trees that were growing during the Maunder minimum (little ice age) and had very tightly packed rings. And then there is the varnish theory (my favorite).

Stephen

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#8

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Joel

>I'll check tonight but the first violin planes illustrations are in either diderot or roubo (same timer period I just am not positive which.)

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#9

I like the one about the insecticides...

Alan DuBoff

>There was another theory that whatever was put on the timber after it was harvested, or whatever Strad put on the wood when he got it in his shop, could have effected it also. Anything that changes the state of the wood is likely to have caused some effect on the wood, but insecticides is what I've heard.

It is fascinating, because the violins are about 300 years old, so it's not so easy to replicate one in a similar fashion, but age has most certainly been removed from the equation, since not all sounded good. Sure, the majority of Strads sounded good, but even some of them were notably better than others.

Also to note that Strads were made to use gut strings, and the more modern steel string required some modification to the violin, taking out the square nails which held the neck on, and properly gluing it back on. Some were able to withstand the stress of the steel strings, but most all required to have the necks reworked, as I recall.

Have you ever had the pleasure to see a Strad up close? There's all types of various sizes and types, bunches a lute type instruments and such that he made. Very fascinating aspect of woodworking, IMO, the mystery continues...

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#10

This all Reminds Me . .

Mike Fitterling

>. . of a book I read recently--The Violin Maker by John Marchese. Anyone interested in the art form might find that story interesting.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#11

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Dean Lapinel

>There a different goal though than just using a nicer finger plane.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#12

Re: Why not make them from iron like the originals

Dean Lapinel

>Good question and one I expected to read from you. Other than milling (more time consuming) I don't know how to make thes type planes. Were they cast in steel? I have seen somethat look like they were rolled then welded since part iof the wall has a ridge but I don't think these do. Your thoughts would be vastly appreciated by me...this is your ball park :)

Dean

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#13

Re: I like the one about the insecticides...

Paul Kierstead

>AFAIK, almost all violins from the era have been reworked in a few areas . A while back I listened to a documentry on it; they had one in "original" condition and it sounds quite different, and inferior, to a modified one.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#14

pics courtesy Geerten (Netherlands)

Dean Lapinel

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#15

Violin Lore

A. Sender

>FWIW, to correct or counter some violin lore that has come up in this thread. There is a great deal of misinformation in print in the violin world.

-Guarneri (Giuseppe or 'Joseph', aka �Del Gesu�) was not a �student of Stradivari�. He came from a family of violin makers, his grandfather was trained by Nicolo Amati.

-None of the theories which have gotten publicity regarding the �secret� to Stradivari�s success have broad credibility among violin experts. (i.e. the Maunder minimum theory, the borax one (insecticide), etc.)

-Heiftetz� Guarneri is indeed owned by the Palace of the Legion of Honor, but it has been loaned to the concertmaster of the SF Symphony and I believe it is no longer to be found on display in the museum.

-Early violins were modified into the modern configuration at a time when strings were still made from gut�the early 19th century. As late as the middle 20th century many players still used pure gut 2nd and 3rd strings. Recent research indicates that during the 18th century and earlier string tension was in fact in the same range as with modern strings.

-That an unmodified early violin doesn�t sound good may result from any number of factors, including: that you are used to the modern sound concept; that the instrument was never converted because it didn�t sound good to begin with; that the luthier who set up the instrument or the player who played it are not best qualified to make the most of the situation. :-)

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#16

Re: Violin Lore

Paul Kierstead

>For this documentary, they had (IIRC) taken a violin that sounded good and "downgraded" it. Certainly the "poor" sound may very well be due to ones expectations about how a violin should sound, but clearly we are not alone considering the modifications (IIRC particularly around the sound post) are apparently close to universal.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#17

Re: I like the one about the insecticides...

Patriciu Radulescu

>The reason for the reworking was the transition (in the late 1750s) from the Baroque to the Classic. As the later needed a higher amplitude of the sound, the logical step was to put a longer neck. High quality gut strings (and expensive also) are still used today on the same instruments.

Compare also the sound of a harpsichord to the volume of a piano, even they are completely different instruments.

Regards,

Patriciu

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#18

Got to see movie: The Red Violin

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#19

Re: Why not make them from iron like the originals

Todd Hughes

>I can't see these planes to well but other Europeon metal planes from this time period that I have seen had forged upper bodies that were forge brazed to thier soles. The bodies were just U shaped iron that was attached to the soles. Did not look like they would be complicated or difficult to make. I don't think they were milled out and if iron I do not think they were cast. Brass ones would have been though I am sure.....todd

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#20

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Dean, I thought my statement went well beyond "just using a nicer finger plane." I stated much more about making such planes and what some benefits would be. Just because I don't need a 3,000 word tome to so state doesn't mean I'm not saying anything.

Pam

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#21

I don't think the Japanese made violins

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#22

Re: Why not make them from iron like the originals

John Aniano - in NJ...

>Todd and Dean,

I would agree to the idea of making your little planes out of iron and braze them to steel soles. I've seen bow making planes from the mid-19th century and they are made like this. Not that I use any like this! Eventually I really do want to make some bow making planes from steel. Some day...

Also, a gaping mouth is not as horrible as one might think. A wide mouth allows you to SEE the shaving as it is made. I have several bow making planes that have gaping mouths, but high cutting angles and I can tip them slightly to plane either side of a facet. The huge mouth allows me to see what I'm taking off.

The wide mouth planes I mentioned and use for bow making are small cast brass violin making planes that I've filed the bottoms flat and fitted with thicker blades made from old Grobet files and added wood wedges to hold them. When properly set, they can take a whisper of a shaving - just the thing for truing up an octagonal bow stick.

The planes pictured are (back row) Bill Salchow-style scraping planes ~90 degree cutting angle - I made the two plain aluminum ones - you adjust the blade using setscrews; (front row - left to right) modified violin makers planes, pair of cast brass planes I got from Woodcraft ~30 years ago, with new blades [from files] and a little used St. James Bay "French" bowmaking plane. The latter 3 planes I tightened up the mouths for other reasons - like planing up to to the end of a stick - a wide mouth tends to gouge when doing that. I soft soldered small pieces of steel to the brass bodies. Was a pain to do, but they serve their purpose.

Over and out,

John


img

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#23

Re: Strad violin makers planes

A. Sender

>Pam, Dean meant no disrespect to your post I am sure.

I think what he meant is that there is an intrinsic interest in using the same tool as a master maker of a bygone era. There are elements of mind set and technique which may be revealed through using such a tool which might be missed in using another tool, no matter how ideal in every respect the other tool is.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#24

Re: Strad violin makers planes

Dean Lapinel

>Exactly as Andres stated. For me there will also be the thrill of having some form of connection with a man of legendary talent.

Realistic?

Useful?

Better?

No... more as in trying to understand the master through his tools.

Re: Strad violin makers planes

#25

Re: Violin Lore

Paul Kierstead

>As a matter of interest, are you the A. Sender who makes bows? I'd love to hear about that as well as the specific changes to violin construction.