Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

jointer planes

Posts

jointer planes

#1

jointer planes

David

>Hi All,

I've been looking at jointer planes (Stanley 7 & 8) and was wondering what the difference is between corrugated and smooth bottoms (beyond one being corrugated and the other not). That is, different uses, is one more versatile, or will I just have to get both?

Thank you,

David

Re: jointer planes

#2

An evergreen question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>You might search on "corrugated" and look at past threads. This comes up from time to time. Some argue that the corrugations make sole flattening faster, if you're planning to tune up the plane, or that the corrugations hold a little wax for smoother planing. There are those who argue that the friction is reduced, countered by those who argue that it makes no difference, since equal weight is applied to the surface regardless.

I've got some corrugated long planes, and find that occasionally, when edge planing, the corrugations can cause the corner of the stock to "steer" the plane. This, of course, could be a matter of my technique or competence; I often slightly skew the plane in use, and the skew and the corrugations can fight each other.

Given the choice between a corrugated and a smooth plane at or near equal prices, I'd buy the smooth one, and would not pay extra for a corrugated plane just for the corrugations. But I'd buy a $10-15 corrugated No. 7 as fast as my hand could reach my wallet (price exaggerated for effect).

As to the wax, one minute with a waxy paper towel can renew the wax coat on a smooth-soled plane, and the coating lasts, at least for me, for quite a while.

Re: jointer planes

#3

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Sole flattening

Jim in Burlington On

>Since I haven't come across a flat Stanley yet it's alot easier to flatten a corrugated plane sole IMO.

Re: jointer planes

#4

Re: jointer planes

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I have read that the corrugated base is to reduce friction on pitchy woods.

Stephen

Re: jointer planes

#5

I agree...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond, CA

>They are easier to flatten. As Bill said, sometimes they "catch a edge" while edge jointing. They do cost more than the flat sole brothers, because their more collectible.

Re: jointer planes

#6

Re: jointer planes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>As far as friction is concerned, a corrugated sole will not make a difference in the world. The smaller surface area of a corrugated sole is compensated by the higher pressure on the smaller surface.

Where a corrugated sole can make a difference is when dealing with "resinous" woods like pine. The decreased surface area will make a corrugated sole easier to push.

In practice, waxing the sole will render that issue moot IMO, so a plain sole is the way to go as far as I'm concerned.

DC

Re: jointer planes

#7

Re: jointer planes

David

>Thanks for the responses and explanations. I had been incorrectly thinking that the difference was in how much wood was taken off or something like that. Your explanations make more sense.

Thanks again.

DGW

Re: jointer planes

#8

Re: jointer planes

Paul Kierstead

>The smaller surface area of a corrugated sole is compensated by the higher pressure on the smaller surface.

Possibly, but also possibly not. For example, friction could be related to the square of the area, so pressure may increase linearly but friction drop quadratically, meaning less area could indeed mean less friction despite the increase in friction. This is common in many physical systems, although I do not know it is true here.

Re: jointer planes

#9

Re: jointer planes

paul womack

>I have read that the corrugated base is to reduce friction on pitchy woods.

IIRC this is a "reported claim", even in the original catalogues.

I don't recall anyone EVER doing an experiment to confirm.

BugBear

Re: jointer planes

#10

Re: jointer planes

ThomD

>Pretty much all of the issues raised: friction; ease of flatening; stickiness to pitch; catching edges or otherwise damaging wood; are all better dealt with with a wooden plane anyway. And there are others to boot: Light weight (it's heavy work doing a lot of planing); warm in the hand; certain aspects of stabiliy are better with wood; Certain aspects of blade adjustment are better.

Re: jointer planes

#11

Re: jointer planes

Gary K

>I've never found the corrugations to have a noticable affect on planing. I use a little carnuba wax on the bottom of my planes, and I don't have a problem with them sliding.

Wood or transitional planes have a bit more warmth and 'feel,' but I've always had as good luck with the metallic jointers, and sometimes the extra mass is useful.

Other issues, like a sharp iron, often have more affect than corrugations.

Gary K

Re: jointer planes

#12

Re: jointer planes

David Wittner

>Guess you guys read my mind. I was also looking at the transitional or even all wood jointers and was worried/wondering if there are problems with the wood moving if one's shop is largely unheated. (I'm actually in the final stages of building my new workshop--36x34 post and beam barn. Hope to finish wiring it this week. For now I'm using a kerosene salamander for heat although I plan on putting in a woodstove in the spring). I would think that wooden planes should be stable but hey, until recently my idea of a hand tool was a circular saw (well, maybe I'm not quite that bad)...

Re: jointer planes

#13

Salamander...

Bob Hackett

>Those type of heaters will crank an incredible amount of moisture into the air.I would hope you`re running a dehumidifier along with that noise maker.

Mainely,Bob

Re: jointer planes

#14

Re: jointer planes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>Others, with more experience, will offer better advice on the issue of wood plane stability. My only experience with a wood jointer was one that appeared to be describing the motion of a plane just as it starts a severe dive-and-turn. The front end was in about a 15 degree different world than the back end.