Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?
Greg B�tit Crown Point NY
>The Windsor Institute's process has evolved over the years. I am concerned that what is taught there comes across as being a bit too dogmatic. There are different approaches to about every aspect of chair making used by contemporary chair makers with as much experience as Mike Dunbar's.
I don't believe any of them actually knows how it was done back in the day. I'm thinking that there may have been as many methods of work as there were master chair makers 200 years ago. They found what worked for them and set to the business of making a living at making chairs. And I'm pretty sure no one back then could make a living producing 2 chairs a week, which seems to be the target for today's professional Windsor chair makers. As I struggle with the small amount of knowledge and skill I have acquired about this trade over the years, I am constantly puzzling about how they did it. It makes me feel mighty humble.
As for tools- coming from one who owns one of about every make and model spoke shave- it's not as much as the tool as it is the user. Really.
Sharp is sine qua non. Then setting and technique. Keep adjusting until it works. Not just adjusting the setting of the iron, but adjust the way you hold the tool, the direction (push, pull, straight, skew, etc.), the amount of downward pressure, the relationship to the work piece, etc... Having someone show you may be very helpful, but don't be satisfied that his is the best, or only way.
Kuntz spoke shaves are probably recognized as the worst on the market today, but I have one Kuntz #55 knock off that works every bit as good as the Stanley #55 I also own. I changed the bevel angle of the iron, and poof, it worked. It wasn't the tool, it needed someone to make it work. OK, buying one of Dave Wisnicki's shaves that comes ready to work without adjustment is a better way to go. But in the long run it's more the user than it is the tool. Some day you're going to have to sharpen and re-adjust Dave's shave.
Think of how much use some of those way used wooden spoke shaves you see out there had. It took thousands of hours of work to get them worn like that, and the user had learned to keep on using it right up until the day it arrived at its present condition. Did he stop using it because it was used up, or did he make it perform right up until the day he quit using a spoke shave for good? In any case, a very experience spoke shave user was still working with that tool in it's present condition.
greg