Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

Posts

Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#1

Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I only have a few (3) metal spokeshaves, those tiny bronze ones, flat, convex and spoon bottom, very handy for small work.

All of my other spokeshaves are made of wood, with the exception of the blade. Some are old ones that work just fine and the rest and I have several, made of beech and dogwood are the ones I use all the time.

Low angle, bevel up, wow, leading edge technology. I prefer the wooden spokeshaves, especially in the winter when metal tools make my hands numb. I also like the feel of wooden spokeshaves, but that is just my personal opinion. If I drop the wooden spokeshave on my work it doesn't leave a dent.

What do you use and why?

Stephen

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#2

Metal

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA, sunny so far!

>My serious hand tool usage started, really, when I found out how many tools are available pretty cheap at garage sales. Out here on the CA north coast, wooden shaves aren't common, so I've picked up a selection of mostly Stanley bevel-down shaves (52, 54, etc.). I find they work pretty well for me, but I don't really have any comparison with the classic wooden shaves.

Thanks to a generous BadgerPond/Centralian, I also have the LV metal riff on the bevel-down shave, but, due to the constant call of our house in the last decade since we bought it, have had little opportunity to learn how to use it or compare it to the Stanley shaves. Soon, I keep telling myself.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#3

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

Dave Mount

>Hi Stephen--

I guess I already explained what shaves I use. I get most of my vintage tools off of Ebay and a wood shave always seemed a dicey purchase if you couldn't really examine it. Metal shaves seemed more likely to be either in working condition or able to be brought there. So many people like wooden shaves that I've been meaning to explore that. With the make-your-own kits available that's been on my to do list for a while, but I haven't done it yet.

Best,

Dave

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#4

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

ThomD

>Right at the moment I am using metal ones, mostly the new LV ones, and their older, nicer bronze one. I use the zero angle metal one they have. I have some Japanese ones that are higher angle and wood, I don't use them as much because the mouth is extremely thin and I don't want to alter them. When green woodworking I like a more open mouth. I also like all the extreme shapes one can get in metal ones. Metal with wooden handles is a good compromise.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#5

Preferences

David Miller form Iowa

>Like sharpening, this topic can be logged in under "whatever works". All there is is what we have available and what we've become good at.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Both

Jim in Burlington On

>I have and use both. The metal ones have round wooden handles and work easily in alot of positions. Easy to adjust metal ones. Wooden one's work well for hogging large amounds of wood off better than the metal ones.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#7

Re: Both

Dan Donaldson

>I use both also. I have the Lee Valley flat and convex shaves, a Boggs type from LN, a coupe of old metal stanleys and a few wood ones that I made myself using the Hock blades. Funny thing is that one of my favorites is one that I made, but never got around to shaping the handles. It is a square chunk of wood with a blade in the middle of it. Been that way for a couple of years and still used that way ;-)

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#8

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal *LINK*

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>Stephen,

I have a pretty good selection of spokeshaves, wood and metal, old and new, though I don't have any of the new versions of metal shaves. I find that I prefe rusing wooden shaves. Most of my spokeshave work is with green wood so I appreciate the hogging ability of the low angle, open mouthed shaves. After getting used to them, it becomes easy to adjust the cut for finer work. I also think the cut is "sweeter", shavings just seem to fly of a piece when using a wood spokeshave.

My normal use of metal spokeshaves is to achieve a finished surface. I think of it with an analogy to bench planes, the wooden ones are like jack or fore planes and the metal ones are like smoothing planes.

For an interesting take on modern spokeshave production, take a look at Michael Dunbar's blog entry for January 16th titled "Gresham's Law and Windsor Chairmaking, Part II.


Michael Dunbar's Blog

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#9

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

Robin Corell in Atascadero Ca

>I have 9 or 10 metal shaves, three of which are the same little white metal shave. As you might guess the little white metal shave is my favorite. it is just under 3" from handle tip to handle tip and has a blade that is probaly about 3/4" wide. I use my shaves only on dry wood so I almost always want a thin wispy curl. The reason I have three of the same shave is mostly due to the fact that they are dificult to adjust so I like to sharpen all three so as one dulls I can just grab another and keep working. I like these little shaves for delicate control they give me. Many people find these little shave useless and I think it is because they fail to tune them up as they would a larger shave or plane. another reasnon for these small planes poor perfomance can be due to razor thin blades that are often supplied with them. A 3/32 thick upgrade will make thes little gems perform like the big guys with jewel like acuracy

I have never used a low angle shave and would like to someday as I only work with solid wood and often end up working end grain. I have several shaves that I put a back bevel on to end up with a 55* angle of attack and have found this to work particularly well on figured wood.

I would also like to try a nice wood shave someday too.

Robin

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#10

Two different animals

James Watriss

>I started using the Lee Valley metal shaves, and made a wooden one with a Hock blade, using instructions in Charlesworth Volume I. I liked the wooden one because I was able to make it the size and shape that I wanted it to be, and it's pretty big. Great for roughing work, but I found at first the I was having a hard time with depth control, because it's low-angle, and it was diving in, because I hadn't tuned it properly.

I liked the LV well enough, but I ended up going with the Boggs shaves after a while. They have a more solid feel to my hands than the LV, and they're not as hard to adjust as I'd figured they would be. I was taking a class with M. Boggs, and having seen him in action, I was pretty well convinced. He actually manages to adjust them on the fly, and I was very impressed. They felt and handled better than the ones I already had, so I figured why not.

As for the wooden one, I'd had it for a while, and it worked well enough, but I still managed to learn a thing or two in that class. Boggs pointed out that a wooden spokeshave was a very versatile tool, but that instead of thinking of it as a plane, it helped to tune it up as if it were more like a drawknife with a wooden depth stop. (Brian was a virtuoso with a drawknife, so I took his word on it.) Turns out if you round off the flat of the blade just enough, it doesn't dive in as quickly, and I'm able to maintain more control over shaving thickness. And there's another trick I picked up. With a wooden shave, if you have a big enough blade, you can adjust the blade to take heavier shavings on one side, so you can rough out and take finer shavings with the same tool.

The metal shaves are great for finishing, but as many others have commented, they're better for finishing cuts than they are for roughing out work.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#11

Do you agree with Dunbar?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#12

Re: Two different animals

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>For those who haven't had the opportunity to spend time with Boggs, I highly recommend his dvd called Drawknives, Spokeshaves and Travishers--A Chairmaker's Tool Kit available from LN.

Pam

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#13

Roughing out question

Bob Hackett

>Why is it that those who have responded seem to favor a wood shave for the rough work?I thought that was what they made the smaller drawknives for.Maybe it`s just a case of regional technique again.

MB

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#14

Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi.

>Pam,

Absolutely not, I find it maddening and somewhat amusing that that he is taking credit for 300 years of windsor chairmaking and 3 millenium of tool evolution. I think his statements also do a disservice to a number of modern tool manufacturers. I thought this thread was interesting after reading Dunbar's statements a couple of days ago. A number of people on this forum are very satisfied with tools that are supposedly inferior.

Jim

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#15

What a relief ! :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#16

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

paul womack

>Low angle, bevel up, wow, leading edge technology. I prefer the wooden spokeshaves, especially in the winter when metal tools make my hands numb. I also like the feel of wooden spokeshaves, but that is just my personal opinion. If I drop the wooden spokeshave on my work it doesn't leave a dent.


What's your opinion of the Veritas spokeshaves, which embody the same low angle, bevel up cutting action, but in a robust, hard wearing metal body?

link

BugBear

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#17

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

ThomD

>I have one of those Paul, and it is an excellent tool. The way the blade is attached is conceivably the most brilliant tool design feature the LV crowd have come up with and would be great for stuff like a beam plane.

I don't really like the metal feel or look, but it works and is durable, The adjustible mouth aspect allows the same tool to do double duty as a flat and comvex shave though the support for the latter is a little abrupt. Nonetheless I occasionally reach for it to dig into corners my other shaves don't reach.

I find overall that the low blade is less useful for stuff I do because it doesn't break chips, but it is great for endgrain. That really isn't an aspect of this presentation anyway. I'd probably buy it again if I lost my current one.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#18

Re: Dunbar on Gresham's Law

ThomD

>Apart from the fact that Dunbar appears to have morphed from a scholarly writer of excellent books to rather weird cultist. I don't really see how his points on shaves can be criticized. There is the odd person around who didn't go through the 70s and the total lack of good tools that existed. We had to make out own, get antiques, or go Japanese. The process he describes happens all the time, though the overall level of tools appears to be rising, and I don't really believe we will be left with dreck.

In fact one could argue that what he observes has happened even in the LV shaves under discusion. I am very please with mine, but the newer ones are not the measure of the older ones LV made, they have the old handles that come undone, and the size is less than it was. They have wide market gizmos to adapt the mouth rather than just making them right in the first place, and they are not larger in a useful way, and the bronze was better. They used to sell/make the Boggs shave, but appear to have taken that design over which one can only assume they have reason for doing given the high integrity of the company, yet the tool has suffered, an itsy bit.

His point about the crap that exists in chairmaking is spot on. The guttering adze and spoon bits that have been distributed in the big US catalogs are pretty unuseable, and some of the modern versions are not 300 years old but fairly new in inspiration. One thinks of the Machine spoon bits and tapers, and the Weyers adze.

In fact one of the challenges of his earlier books was that the tools just didn't exist for people who lived away from the major antique tool barns in a pre-ebay world.

Dunbar didn't invent the Windsor chair but he may actually be responsible for inventing it as a stand alone hobbie like knitting or quilting, or turning.

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#19

Re: Dunbar on Gresham's Law

ThomD

>OK well after reading part one of his rant, I don't believe that what is happening is that the good is driving out the bad in accordance with Gresham's law. It's just cheapness in production. The good tools aren't being held out of circulation, in some cases they were being burned for fuel, blown up on the fourth of July, or otherwise savaged.

OK, som perhaps not so Scholarly...

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#20

Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?

John Jesseph

>Hey, it's funny to read this... I stumbled onto his blog after getting back from Williamsburg. (Good seeing you there, Jim)Amazingly egocentric blog. Quite an influential woodworker who has lost touch a bit...

I disagree with him on a lot of points, and have decided to dig out all my Dunbar approved tools to sell on eBay- all my spoon bits, Barr scorp and adze, and Crown travisher and compass plane. The whole process is wrong anyway, and I don't use that stuff anymore...

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#21

Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?

Kevin Adams

>Hi John--

You still making chairs? I seem to recall you had taken a class with Dave Sawyer a few years ago--if you are still making chairs, how did you like Dave's process vs. Dunbar's? BTW, did you ever get any of that old iron up and running?

Thanks.

Kevin

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#22

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

Bob Hackett

>Why is it that most everyone who offers these spokeshaves makes them with the arms above the blade?I thought is was common knowledge that they are much easier to control if the arms were lower,on plane with the cutting edge.

Guess common knowledge isn`t really all that common eh?

Mainely,Bob

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#23

Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?

Greg B�tit Crown Point NY

>The Windsor Institute's process has evolved over the years. I am concerned that what is taught there comes across as being a bit too dogmatic. There are different approaches to about every aspect of chair making used by contemporary chair makers with as much experience as Mike Dunbar's.

I don't believe any of them actually knows how it was done back in the day. I'm thinking that there may have been as many methods of work as there were master chair makers 200 years ago. They found what worked for them and set to the business of making a living at making chairs. And I'm pretty sure no one back then could make a living producing 2 chairs a week, which seems to be the target for today's professional Windsor chair makers. As I struggle with the small amount of knowledge and skill I have acquired about this trade over the years, I am constantly puzzling about how they did it. It makes me feel mighty humble.

As for tools- coming from one who owns one of about every make and model spoke shave- it's not as much as the tool as it is the user. Really.

Sharp is sine qua non. Then setting and technique. Keep adjusting until it works. Not just adjusting the setting of the iron, but adjust the way you hold the tool, the direction (push, pull, straight, skew, etc.), the amount of downward pressure, the relationship to the work piece, etc... Having someone show you may be very helpful, but don't be satisfied that his is the best, or only way.

Kuntz spoke shaves are probably recognized as the worst on the market today, but I have one Kuntz #55 knock off that works every bit as good as the Stanley #55 I also own. I changed the bevel angle of the iron, and poof, it worked. It wasn't the tool, it needed someone to make it work. OK, buying one of Dave Wisnicki's shaves that comes ready to work without adjustment is a better way to go. But in the long run it's more the user than it is the tool. Some day you're going to have to sharpen and re-adjust Dave's shave.

Think of how much use some of those way used wooden spoke shaves you see out there had. It took thousands of hours of work to get them worn like that, and the user had learned to keep on using it right up until the day it arrived at its present condition. Did he stop using it because it was used up, or did he make it perform right up until the day he quit using a spoke shave for good? In any case, a very experience spoke shave user was still working with that tool in it's present condition.

greg

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#24

Re: Do you agree with Dunbar?

john jesseph

>Hi Kevin;

I have been swamped with work and kids, and moved a year and a half ago- still unpacking the shop. I haven't made a (finished) chair since, but have a bunch of projects to post over the next several months. One or two will be Windsors... :) Maybe another joined chair or two, and a table or two or three.

I started typing out a long winded response, but decided to cut it all. Dave has some great ideas, and is a great guy. I don't remember much about what I learned from the WI. I think there is a lot to be learned about Windsor making still, and the old work can be improved on, despite what some people think.

Are you getting any shop time?

I better get out to the shop and try and find my trammels-

Re: Spokeshaves: Wooden v Metal

#25

Good Points

john jesseph

>hi Greg;

Good points. Processes irrevocably lost to history.

The young fellas worked fast in their time, but a lot of the work looked it. Hard to want to make a chair that looks as bad as most of the old ones did IMHO.

I still like the 53 or 54 stanley, and don't mind an old wooden shave.