We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I remember reading the chairmaking book about 30 years ago. One thing gave me a chuckle. Dunbar said that in the 18th century it took seven years under a good master to learn to make windsor chairs. Yet here was Michael, writing a book about it after only five years and without the benefit of any master at all. Since I had a friend at the time who was making chairs completely by hand and for quite a bit longer, I thought it rather pompous that he acted like he was the only one who could figure this stuff out.
Not as much shop time as I would like. There's just so many distractions that I finally went away for another class back in October. Went up to Canada to spend a week with Dave Fleming to build a post-and-rung. I've been wanting to make one for years and I must say, it's a real favorite now. Very anti-Dunbar I know (keeping in step with this thread!), but I real nice chair none-the-less. I'd like to make a few more. BTW, Dave is a great guy and I also got hooked on his pole lathe, whcih is next on my list of things to make (as soon as I finish some carved figures that were due last Christmas).
Look forward to seeing your photos when you get around to posting them. In the meantime, hope we both get in more shop time one of these days.
>I've read Dunbar in magazines over the years, and while I didn't always agree with him he struck me as a knowledgeable, competent person, with lots of common sense.
Reading the blog changed my view of the man allright... People who need to praise themselves always make me uncomfortable and suspicious...
DC
BTW, in the FWW review of a couple years ago Dave's Whaves, while well regarded, didn't earn the Top Tool award (Woodjoy did)...
I don't think people really cotton to naked blades for some sorts of work, even if a drawknife is a more efficient and versatile tool. At school we learned to take a band-sawn cabriole leg blank and shape the majority of it with a 1" chisel. It's remarkable what can be done with a good sharp, naked edge. Drawknives are a similar experience, albeit a (very) little more involved to get properly tuned.
I've also seen Boggs go to town with a well tuned drawknife, and it's really something to witness firsthand. DVD does a decent job, but in person just seems so much more... I dunno, convincing, despite my efforts to be open minded in general. His ability to hog off inches, or peel off delicate curls, with the same knife, speaks volumes. Anyone who has ever seen the practiced and competent ease of a master at work will know what I'm talking about. And those who haven't... well, it's inspiring and humbling, and it's why I got into woodworking to begin with.
Another thing is that I think people are more used to baby steps in some directions. Hewing off massive chunks of wood seems somehow less refined. Even though it's a hell of a lot more efficient to use a drawknife or big chisel, for some reason, people love making curly shavings, and I think that some of them also feel more confident in the deceptive feeling of control with the spokeshave vs the drawknife.
I can relate, to a point. There's so much emphasis on this tool or that tool, and spokeshaves do get a lot of attention. For whatever reason, they seem a little sexier in the glossy pages than a drawknife does. They certainly seem to make for better copy, because they look more involved, and perhaps more evolved, than a drawknife. And they are. But what they've evolved into is more specialized and precise than is necessary for roughing work.
But then again, I also get the feeling that sometimes people get a bigger thrill from seeing their fancy new tool making shavings than they do from watching their new chunk of wood get ripped to pieces too quickly. Some quote about the journey and the destination comes to mind. But I think that, lacking adequate or appropriate instruction, some of those folks are ambling their merry way along that particular road. I'm not trying to cast aspersions here; I'm just trying to point out one of the shortcomings of going that road alone. Lacking someone to illustrate efficient work techniques, they're going the slow but steady route.
I think the drawknife is a great, efficient, no-nonsense tool for anyone who knows where they're going, and what they're trying to get done. And the spokeshave is a wonderful way to keep the joy of the work going for a while longer. It does take time, but I'm sure there are people who would rather see it as a slower way of romancing and evolving a shape, and unwinding after a long day's work.
For some, the joy of walking at all is thrill enough. And I can understand that, too. It's the difference between the hobbyist and the serious amateur or professional. There's no shame in being any of those. Do what you love, and keeps you happy.
>I think it depends on how you're using it. I think it's a different feel for sure, but I also think for roughing, having the arms higher helps tilt a bevel up shave forward, so it can dive down and into the work. Running the flat of the blade along the flat of the work won't cut. You need to tilt it forward, ever so slightly, to engage the wood and provide a relief angle. I think some of them look like the arms are a bit too high up, but in use I think they feel just fine. I've seen a lot of different shapes for the arms, too. Some curve downward, some sweep forward, or forward and down... it becomes a matter of personal preference. But I don't think that arms like that are really so unusable as all that.
Didn`t mean to imply that the arms in the pic were difficult,just that the lower approach made a noticeable difference.At least to me they do.
As far as roughing goes,watching a pro can be one of those turning points that kind of draw you in and won`t let you go till it`s you making the big chips.For me it was watching one of the old joiners wield an adze.I just knew that was a skill set I had to aquire.
With a wooden spokeshave, I find myself gripping the body with my fingertips and thumb just outside the blade rather than with my hands wrapped around the handles. As James was saying, it is much more of a finesse tool than a drawknife and I find that holding it for control rather than power works best.
I agree, the blog is "amazingly egocentric" and quite the markting tool for the Windsor Institute.
If enough people have bought into his message, your tools should do well on ebay.
I'd also be interested in the part of the process that he teaches doesn't work efficiently. I have never taken a class at the Windsor Institute, but would be interested in improving or changing the process I use if another way would work better.
I took a one-day spokeshave making class from Russ Filbeck. He makes his with the handles at the bottom and the front edge of the spokeshave. I like the control available with this setup, and if you want to lower the blade for some rough work it works like a drawknife to get the handles in-line with the blade.