Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

PW honing guides review

Posts

Re: PW honing guides review

#26

Re: Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>I am not familiar with the 'ruler trick'. I presume you mean a thin modern metal ruler as all of my rulers are made of wood and a minimum of 1/4" thick.

Elevating the blade when sharpening the flat side was always discouraged as it will eventually make it not flat.

It sounds like that method is a faster way to sharpen your blade and ruin them in the long run.

Stephen

Re: PW honing guides review

#27

a solution to your problem

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Buried in the post about sharpening at Bennet School and talking to your boards is a simple statement of how free hand is easily accomplished (at Bennet). I went through all the tribulations you list before I "rediscovered" this secret.

1. If the iron is sufficiently HOLLOW ground, honing takes 10 strokes on the stone not 100. It is vastly easier to accomplish 10 accurate strokes on the stone than 100, especially if you get bored easily.

2. Skew the blade some to the direction of stone stroking so that more of the bevel is supported on the stone. I suspect I am about 30 degrees from the iron being perpendicular to the stone length. I only pull. The process is (1)establish secure bevel contact at far end of stone, (2) pull iron toward you at a deliberate speed, (3) lift and repeat. I should emphasize that with a hollow it is trivial to feel that the bevel is properly seated on the stone because of the two points of contact created by the hollow.

3. Not previously covered is proper lubricating. The iron should glide across the abrasive smoothly.

Re: PW honing guides review

#28

Re: a solution to your problem

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Bill

I agree, hollow grinding makes freehand honing a cinch. Since this thread was started with Harrelson Stanley's Sharp Skate in mind, let me therefore add that when adds the technique of side sharpening to the mix, freehand honing becomes yet easier still. Harrelson's DVD is well worth viewing.

Earlier I argued that freehand honing and honing guides can and do coexist. To be specific, I hollow grind and freehand all my bevel down plane blades and chisels (with the exception of those with laminated blades, which are flat ground). For the high angles of attack I require on bevel up planes, these all have a primary bevel that is flat ground at 25 degrees, and then a secondary microbevel is added with a honing guide.

Whether hollow or flat grinding, there is a big advantage in doing so right to the edge of the blade. The subsequent microbevel can be really "micro", which means that very little honing is actually required. As you say "10 strokes". I might even argue that it could be less.

Grinding to the edge has its risks (of overheating), and this is where I see an advantage in grinders such as the Tormek (for hollows) and belt sanders (for flat bevels), as both run cool. Of course, these are not the only options.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#29

Re: freehand honing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>A perfectly flat surface is nice to think about in Geometry class, along with a line that has no width. But in the real world flatness is relative. Perhaps Adam was hinting at this above.

Whether you use a guide or you hollow grind or you sharpen on bench stones only, as I do, there will be some rounding. In free hand work especially, a beginner will round much more than an experienced sharpener. This rounding diminishes gradually over time. It takes a while for the investment in free hand sharpening to pay off. For an older person, or someone with poor hand skills, or someone who sharpens infrequently, a honing guide may be the better investment. Having watched you work, Moses, I am confident that learning to freehand would not be terribly hard.

Re: PW honing guides review

#30

Re: Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

David Charlesworth

>Stephen,

Since you have not tried or understood my method, (for all blades except bench chisels) I find your comments ill-judged, misleading and innacurate. Various other rude words have been deleted in the interests of harmony and calm!

The ruler trick does not ruin plane blades at all and massively increases the probability of correctly polishing away a wire edge.

I would also like reinforce the comments made by Larry, the problems I see in sharpening are almost entirely due to a variety of failures in flat side prep and polishing.

Bevel work, for straight or cambered edges is trivial in comparison.

David Charlesworth

Re: PW honing guides review

#31

Re: Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>David,

You wrote:

'Stephen,

Since you have not tried or understood my method, (for all blades except bench chisels) I find your comments ill-judged, misleading and innacurate. Various other rude words have been deleted in the interests of harmony and calm!'

Also in the interest of harmony and calm (although I am use to rude words) while I have not tried your method I do believe I understand the principle.

Correct me if I am wrong, and I may completely misunderstand the technique but the method means placing a flat metal ruler on the stone elevating the blade slightly in order for the end of the flat part of the blade to macro bevel the flat side?

I do understand the importance of the absolute flatness of the flat (non bevel side) of the plane iron.

Elevating the blade even slightly will eventually make the flat side not flat.

I may be wrong, but I don't think so.

Stephen

Re: PW honing guides review

#32

Re: Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>If I may chime in...

A plane iron back does not need to be absolutely flat. In order to have a sharp edge the bevel side needs to meet the back side in one straight continuous line (if doing a non cambered grind). The back does not need to be perfectly flat, just flat enough.

The principle is the same as putting a back bevel on a BD plane, except that the ruler trick involves a very small angle. Assuming a 3" wide stone (such as the Norton waterstones), a 1/2" wide by 1/32" thick rule laid on the right side of the stone, and that the back bevel is done on the 1/4" next to the left side of the stone, that will give you roughly a 0.8 degree back bevel. It takes only a few strokes to establish, and is a major time saver compared to polishing the last 1/2" or so of the iron, with no detrimental effect on sharpness. I don't know where "ruining the blade" comes from...

Of course, this can't be done on bench chisels. But for plane irons this is a great method.

Hope I'm not missing something, or misinterpreting what you said...

DC

Re: PW honing guides review

#33

Re: Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>There are two sides to the story (no, this is not a pun :) ).

I consider David's "Ruler Trick" to be an extremely clever and useful technique. It is the most helpful strategy for making a pitted blade useable (without grinding out pits), and - under certain conditions - ensuring that the back of the blade is flat and as polished as the front.

The "conditions"? Well, in my opinion, it is limited to those who use a honing guide and/or do not strop blades between re-honings.

I like to maintain an edge as long as possible by frequently stropping it as I work. I strop both the front and the back of the blade (on hard - no give - Horse Butt leather. Joel has the only one's I know of and they are excellent). A blade with a microbevel is very difficult to strop freehand (well, I find this so), and this includes a micro backbevel (ala Ruler Trick). The Ruler Trick does not damage a blade nor leave it unusable. It just makes it more difficult to strop freehand.

So there is likely to be a polarising between those who freehand and those who use honing guides when it comes to the Ruler Trick.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#34

This is a 'new' thing, right?

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>Because after looking over several old sources I have not found any reference other than 'keep the blade absolutely flat..." and "it is important to keep the blade flat against the stone...".

So if this is a 'new' method to sharpen faster then I understand and I still will to continue to say that that is not a good practice.

So what I said is not 'ill advised' or 'inaccurate' or 'misleading' as there is a considerable amount of documentation to the contrary.

Stephen

Re: PW honing guides review

#35

Re: Honing Guides

Harrelson

>Here is a direct link to the man I mentioned at the end of my earlier posting. Please notice that almost all of Nakadai's work was unfinished with any kind of oil of lacquer. I once visited him in his home in Tokyo when he was still with us. I held his pieces with white gloves so as not to stain them with the oil from mt hands. It was very difficult to find any tool marks and there was no grain tear at all. This man was one of the greatest sharpeners to have ever lived.

http://www.nihon-kogeikai.com/KOKUHO-E/NAKADAI-ZUISHIN-E/NAKADAI-ZUISHIN-SAKUHIN-E.html

peace and good woodworking

Harrelson

Re: PW honing guides review

#36

Re: This is a 'new' thing, right?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Because after looking over several old sources I have not found any reference other than 'keep the blade absolutely flat..." and "it is important to keep the blade flat against the stone...".

Well, "new" does not necessarily equal "bad"... While there are quite a few new tools and techniques that are of dubious value, I strongly believe that the ruler trick is a very valuable technique. Derek's comment about making pitted blades useable is a good application of it.

I don't know if the ruler trick originated with David (I think not, but am not sure), but he did help popularize it greatly. In fact I'm amazed that the old craftsmen didn't use the technique. Maybe it is because the "abrasives" they were using were of poor quality compared to what we have now, and they were stropping a lot more than we do, out of necessity.

In the end the, proof of the pudding... Show me that 1. the edge will not last as long, 2. the edge won't be as sharp, 3. the wood will respond differently to the presence of a tiny back bevel (less than one degree), 4. the iron will be worn out prematurely and/or will be irremediably destroyed in the process, and I will reconsider my position.

Chisels, I agree with you. There's no way out of a flat and polished back. But plane irons, that's a different ball game.

DC

Re: PW honing guides review

#37

Re: Honing Guides

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Hap

Thank you for the link. The Paulownia speaks volumes to me. I have worked a bit with this balsa-substitute (!) and it is extremely difficult to plane (the neighbours learned a few choice phrases on some of those days), never mind obtain the burnished finish in the photos.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#38

Newish, i.e. about fifteen years

David Charlesworth

>Denis,

I am quite certain that I did invent this technique, in its particular form, shortly after moving to Japanese Waterstones (Richard Vaughan in Australia also questioned this but has kindly recanted).

It is applicable to almost all cutting edges except bench chisels, and not just pitted blades.

It is 'new' in that it is a slight variation or extension of traditional technique, but there are many advantages and no disadvantages whatsoever, as far as I know.

First published in about 1997 though I had been teaching it for a number of years before that.

Advantages;

1. Less time spent preparing new blades. Flattening can be done on 800g stones only.

2. Less sticktion on the polishing stone.

3. A smaller area of high polish, therefore much quicker. Why polish large areas of blade which will not form the cutting edge for years or generations?

4. A much higher probability of polishing off the wire edge, first time and every time with total consistency.

6. No need to strop. Once disassembeled why strop a plane blade when re-sharpening is almost as quick?

7. In fact it makes the polishing of the flat side as easy and quick as putting a microbevel on the bevel side.

Disadvantages;

1. Having to think about something subtle, new and rather radical.....

2. None that I know. The change of effective pitch is about 2/3rds of one degree which has negligable impact on bevel up or down planes, and does not even interfere with chipbreaker fit, provide one has one to two degrees of clearance angle under C/B front edge.

There must be hundreds if not thousands of woodworkers who have tried the method, and have enjoyed the benefits. People are welcome to choose not to use it, but damage to blades is not part of the deal. A constant stream of woodworkers who attend my courses are blown away by the improvement in sharpening which they achieve in two days, and I have the letters to prove it.

best wishes,

David

Re: PW honing guides review

#39

Denis, I use scary sharp on a granite

Parisian, VL

>plate, so I'm not limited to the width of a stone, I'm using 2000 grit wet dry paper glued to the granite plate so my back bevel angle is very slight at about 5+/- inches from the blade edge to the cheap metal ruler. I haven't yet mic'd the ruler for thickness but it is thin.

My post was referring to plane irons only, forgot for a second that Stephen was likely talking about chisels and plane irons. For Stephen's use of period tools, he could accomplish the same with a couple of fine shavings under the blade to elevate it ever so slightly for the same fast results.

Victor - Houston

Re: PW honing guides review

#40

Better Sharpness

Steve Elliott

>A few years ago I did some work testing the sharpness of a number of blades achieved using different sharpening media. This included examining the edges under a 200x microscope and testing the edges by measuring the force needed to cut through a loop of thread.

After comparing the sharpness of edges produced using a small back bevel versus edges with a flat back, I became a convert to back bevels. Even with the most careful lapping of the blade back and repeated alternate honing of the bevel and back I was unable to achieve an edge that tested as sharp as those with a tiny back bevel.

So in my experience, the ruler trick not only speeds up sharpening, it also produces a sharper edge.

The results of my tests can be seen at Initial Sharpness.

Re: PW honing guides review

#41

Re: PW honing guides review

lignator

>Gordon,

What a great thread you've started here. Sharpening technique appears to be a very personal thing, on the order of religion and politics. Maybe it is the Zen like state one must get into to ensure ones blade angle has not gone astray. Be the blade. When you become the blade, changing course or technique is like being violated in your own home. But I digress.

I'd like to comment on your comment that, "I place the Mk1 and mk11 from veritas a distant second and third. I can only speculate the reason for this is that the latter employ a front to back motion and consequently the debris produced gets between the steel and stone."

Why push your edge back over the debris at all. With the mk11 it is easy just to lift the blade at the end of the stroke and roll it back to the other end of the stone/paper/plate or what-have-you. This technique works very fast and leaves the wire edge intact for removal via a backside lap or two.

But, that said, I'm still so curious about your results that I will likely plunk down some money this afternoon and buy one of those new fangled SS contraptions. My irons are already getting excited at the thought of being violated by a new sharpening stud.

Re: PW honing guides review

#42

Re: Better Sharpness

David Charlesworth

>Steve,

That is what I believe, and practise.

Thank you,

David Charlesworth

Re: PW honing guides review

#43

Re: rounding the back

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I generally practice woodworking by reading and employing common sense. Common sense would indicate that the back of the iron gradually would become rounded more each time you hone the slight back bevel with a ruler on the stone. My final grit stone is an 8000 water stone which I'm sure does not remove a lot of steel but still removes some. I would be interested in knowing your experience with using this technique on a plane iron over a period of say 3 or 5 years. I have never really had a big problem flattening the backs of new Hock irons, so have not used the ruler trick on any of them and they work just fine for me without it. I have had good success using the ruler with irons that I don't care much about and will probably continue to use it on them.

Re: PW honing guides review

#44

Re: rounding the back

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Remember that by honing the main bevel you are reducing the back bevel at the same time. It's basically self-regulating.

DC

Re: PW honing guides review

#45

Re: rounding the back

David Charlesworth

>Moses,

As Denis says, we are shortening the length with each sharpening and removing some, but very little metal with ruler trick on 8,ooog stone.

I have plane blades which get frequent sharpening and the polished band does not get much wider than 1/16".

best wishes,

David

Re: PW honing guides review

#46

Re: rounding the back

paul womack

>I have never really had a big problem flattening the backs of new Hock irons, so have not used the ruler trick on any of them and they work just fine for me without it.

Some older blades don't start in as good a place as a Hock... ;-)

BugBear

Re: PW honing guides review

#47

Re: PW honing guides review

Harrelson

>I will be glad to support you in any way I can to make sure my Sharp Skate� performs as it should.