Re: Honing Guides
Harrelson
>Hi everyone,
I have been reading this thread with great interest and I thought I might make a couple of comments.
As a little background, I have been very interested in sharpening since I was 11 years old. I used to sharpen my buck 110 on an old oil stone I found in the basement. I later went to the North Bennett St. school in Boston and learned their methods. (hollow grinding and free hand on an oil stone). towards the end of my two years there I started using water stones and thought I had discovered nirvana! I still didn't understand the need to flatten my stones though. From there I went to Japan and apprenticed for 8 years to a lacquerer and high end box maker. I ended up staying for 12 years and studying with some of the most amazing blacksmiths, lacquers, woodworkers and carpenters. In all that time I don't think I had a conversation with any of those folks where sharpening did not come up. I spent a lot of time sharpening many different tools. All free hand. I collected lots of stones too.
I spent most of my time with Niikura Mineo an amazing box maker and formally trained lacquerer. He graduated from Kyoto art university and then apprenticed under Kuroda Tatsuaki who was one of the most well known living national treasures.
My other teacher was Kuroda Kenkichi, the son of Tatsuaki. Tatsuaki died just before I went to Japan and his son Kenkichi died a month before I left Japan. I still visit Mineo as often as I can.
Kenkichi was a sharpening maniac! He could talk about sharpening for hours and loved to go out in search of the perfect stone. He believed that we should have a conversation with the wood while shaping it and that sharpening improved the conversation. He taught me that I needed to sharpen more than I actually worked the wood as I approached the end of a project.
Niikura-san taught me to get the first coat of lacquer into the wood before using any sand paper. He didn't want any sanding particles to be embedded in the pores of the wood. That means tear out has to be controlled with sharp tools.
A lot of our tools were carving tools. Sharpening carving tools is the most difficult challenge in sharpening. Wavy buffed edges will not suffice if the tools marks can't be erased with sandpaper. All the wood fibers have to be perfectly sheared to avoid tear. The importance of edge geometry becomes magnified. We solved a lot of our problems by shaping stones to fit our tools.
Towards the end of his life, Kuroda Kenkichi and I often talked about jigs for sharpening. Kuroda-san loved to make small mini planes called "bean" planes. He would cut up large blades and make tiny little blocks to hold the blades. He felt that certain blades required a tool holder to sharpen effectively. when i made trips back to America, he had me buy the smallest vise grip pliers I could find to experiment with. He was gripping the blades and pushing them front to back. We never considered side sharpening. I really wish he had lived to see my Sharp Skate�, I think he would really have loved it because it solves the problems we talked about.
Some tools can be sharpened perfectly by free hand method but some tools are just too narrow, too long, too short or too thin to sharpen free hand. Moreover, as I have been experimenting with the sharp skate for the past 3 years, I have come to realize that no mater how careful I am, the skate produces better geometry than my best freehand effort.
I feel that freehand sharpening is an essential woodworking skill. The control needed to pare very fine joinery can be learned from sharpening. Really fine tuned motor skills are rarely innate, rather they are ingrained from lots and lots of practice. I designed the Sharp Skate to have the feel of freehand sharpening. I wanted it to have very fine, precise control and it had to use all of the stone, especially the edges. The sharp skate is really different sharpening tool. In many ways it can't be compared to jigs that have come before it.
You can work the edge, get on it really hard or back off an go ever so light. You can actually sculpt the edge. For a beginner to achieve that kind of performance with only a few hours of practice has never been possible. Real one handed sharpening is really possible. Right now we only have a few users who have really put the skate through it paces but I think that a year from now the conversations on forums like these will not be so much about weather we need the Sharp Skate but but rather, we will see lots of discussion about the possibilities of the "Sharp Skating". Has anyone tried a drill bit in it yet?
If you are interested in amazing carving and wood joinery, go to www.nihon-kogeikai.com (Japan traditional craft society) and one of my favorites "Zuishin Nakadai" He was the incredible
Peace and good woodworking
Harrelson Stanley