Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

PW honing guides review

Posts

PW honing guides review

#1

PW honing guides review

Gordon Thomas

>I have just read through Chris Schwarz's review of four honing guides and would like to offer my comments as a user of three of them: Veritas Mk11, Eclipse and Sharp Skate (SS). The Veritas Mk1 which I also use was not included in the article in PW. I will state from the outset that I firmly belong in the category of hobbyist.

I have owned the first two guides for several years - the Eclipse belonged to my late Father. I had taken taken several courses in how to freehand sharpen but was never convinced that the methods described could be quickly learned by a novice. The matter came to head after I purchased several Japanese style Shinogi chisels from Kayoko at Misugi designs. It was apparent that the MK1 and Mk11 were not able to secure the chisel. I then read about the SS guide from Harrelson and decided that it offered a means to secure a Shinogi chisel and hopeully produce an acceptably sharp edge.

As an aside it appears to me that the central question with sharpening is "what is sharp?" A guide provides a benchmark which acts as a starting point for the novice. One always has the option to abandon the "training wheels" or, continue with the guide.

Having used four honing guides and now freehanding I believe that the sharp skate produces the best edge by far. I place the Mk1 and mk11 from veritas a distant second and third. I can only speculate the reason for this is that the latter employ a front to back motion and consequently the debris produced gets between the steel and stone. This is not so much an issue with the SS.

My criticisms of the SS are: a) the setup is fiddly (it does not come with instructions although, the inventor does have a video clip on his website); and b) the price.

If one is willing to take the time to become familiar with the SS then I feel that even a novice will experience for themselves what a pleasure it is to use a tool that is truly sharp.

cheers,

Gordon

Re: PW honing guides review

#2

Re: PW honing guides review *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Gordon

When was Christopher's review published? Is there a link? My copy of PW appears to have gone astray in the mail.

For reference, I have reviewed the Sharp Skate, and this was discussed on this forum. The article is at the link below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Side Sharpening and the SS honing guide

Re: PW honing guides review

#3

Re: PW honing guides review

Gordon Thomas

>Derek:

the article is in the latetst issue of PW.

chees,

Gordon

Re: PW honing guides review

#4

more specifically #167

Gordon Thomas

>Hi Derek:

I read your comments on the japanese forum and wanted to make some additional points with greater emphasis on certain aspects after using the four guides.

best,

Gordon

Re: PW honing guides review

#5

Re: more specifically #167

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi again Gordon

I hope we do not turn out to be the only one's chatting here!

I want to add, in the light of your previous comment, that I am not yet done with the Sharp Skate or Hap's (Harrelson's) techniques. We have maintained communication, and my plan is to complete my own investigation into the differences that result from front-and-back verses side-to-side honing. I now have my own microscope, so this will include photographic data. This is one part. The other includes evaluating objectively an edge strengthening technique of Hap's (completed while honing).

I am hoping to be free to begin this in about 6 weeks time.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#6

My copy of PW only arrived today. *LINK*

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)

>Yours shouldn't be far away Derek.

You can read the article on the honing guides by following the link below.


PW honing guide article.

Re: PW honing guides review

#7

Thanks Ian. Now where is Christopher?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Thanks for that link, Ian.

Looking specifically at the data on the Skate Sharp I note that Christopher rated it "OK" on bevel up plane blades. I wonder what bevel angle he was honing at? This was the one area that I considered the SS to be poor since it was really unable to hone a 50 degree bevel (for a 62 degree angle of attack) and, if you did manage a few degrees lower, you would still not have sufficient blade projection to be able to camber it.

Here is a picture of what I found:



Compare this to a 25 degree bevel ..



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#8

PW honing guides review some additonal comments

Gordon Thomas

>I have added some comments about my experiences of using the SS jig for more than 50 hours and hope they will be helpful to anyone interested.

Here is the link:

http://www.japanesetools.com/phpBB2/viewtopic.php?p=9582#9582

cheers,

Gordon

Re: PW honing guides review

#9

stepping in for Joel, here

Larry Williams

>I'm sorry but I disagree with your statement "It establishes a benchmark for what is "sharp"."

I have a couple issues with honing guides. The first is that, under the best circumstances, they may be able to help with the easiest sharpening tasks. If one learns to depend on them, they'll never be able to sharpen tools like gouges or molding planes.

My other problem with honing guides is that they create a mindset that the real work of sharpening happens on the bevel. That's less than half the picture because the quality of an edge is dependent on the preparation of both surfaces that make up the edge. From years of participating on Internet woodworking forums, I'm convinced at least 95% of the sharpening problems I've read about result from improper preparation of the flat back/face of edge tools. Honing guides are no help with this. I feel the surface that needs the most attention is the flat face of an edge and the bevel is incredibly easy by comparison. I just don't see how a crutch like a honing guide that encourages people to concentrate on the easy part of sharpening and ignore the more difficult can set a "benchmark" for anything.

Re: PW honing guides review

#10

Re: stepping in for Joel, here

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Larry

While I agree with your comment "I'm sorry but I disagree with your statement "It establishes a benchmark for what is "sharp"." (how can a jig set a benchmark for sharp - it is an illogical statement), I disagree that the use of a honing guide automatically creates a mind set that precludes a critical analysis of what is required to prepare a blade. Why should the use of a honing guide cause someone to suddenly forget the other side of the blade? I do not see this in training DVDs, such as those by David Charlesworth or Harrison Stanley.

It is possible, probably likely, that most novices will take a simplistic view of the sharpening process at the start. I prefer to believe that such an approach continues as a result of the personality of the woodworker, rather than blame the tool, per se.

I do agree that handskills are important, if not vital, for sharpening blades that cannot fit into a jig of some form. At the same time I imagine that there are woodworkers who lack the coordination to hone a blade without a jig, and the use of one allows them to get into the game.

My personal preference is to freehand blades, which I do when I can. But I also recognise that a honing guide is the best way to prepare blades for bevel up planes, rather than being hit-and-miss here. I consider that the old dichotomy of "freehand verses jig" user needs to die. In this day and age there is not only room for both, but that they will/do co-exist for most woodworkers.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: PW honing guides review

#11

Re: stepping in for Joel, here

Joel

>"At the same time I imagine that there are woodworkers who lack the coordination to hone a blade without a jig, and the use of one allows them to get into the game."

if someone really and truly lacks "the coordination to hone a blade without a jig" ) a someone who I have certainly never met, how can they possible expect to have the coordination to saw a straight line?

"But I also recognize that a honing guide is the best way to prepare blades for bevel up planes, rather than being hit-and-miss here. "

hit or miss? - good technique is dead repeatable.

Re: PW honing guides review

#12

2 flat planes

Adam Cherubini

>I still don't understand why we need to have 2 flat planes to make up a sharp edge. I've been flattening and polishing the backs of my tools since I started woodworking and I'm wondering more and more why I continue to bother. We don't do this to carving tools, and in my shop the carvers are the sharpest.

I watched Mack Headley sharpen his try plane iron during the conference. It may have been the angle of the camera, but I would swear he had a 60 degree bevel on that blade. It seemed to work okay when he was done. I've seen him do that before and similarly had a really high bevel angle.

There's a lot I don't know about sharpening and as I've learned more and done more I feel less and less sure anything I've learned is correct. Father forgive me, but I have doubts. Doubts that Leonard Lee exists (just kidding just kidding- I still believe)

Adam

Re: PW honing guides review

#13

guides and sharpness

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Steve Elliot uses guides in his sharpness research to ensure repeatability. There is little question that he can sharpen steel to a refinement well beyond what is practically required in the shop.

I think in all these discussions of sharpness and sharpening we lose sight of the fact that in practical planning the edge is vastly duller when we decide to sharpen than when we started. And in between we were satisfied with performance.

The "training wheels" of guides enabled me to begin using a plane effectively. Now I hand hold with the blade skewed for better support. I am thankful no one talked me into buying a $$$$$guide to get through the training wheels phase. Lamborghini training wheels makes no sense to me.

Re: PW honing guides review

#14

Honing Guides

Steve Elliott

>I sharpened freehand for about 25 years and now use a modified Millers Falls jig for plane blades. I still sharpen chisels freehand.

Sharpening method is a choice where there is no single right answer, you just have to find what works for you.

One thing to keep in mind as a part of this discussion is that honing should be pretty quick. Good grinding technique eliminates most of the work of honing and gives the same result in the end.

Re: PW honing guides review

#15

Outside the box?

Marv

>I'm sure many of you will scoff at this method of establishing the proper angle on a plane iron, but this is how I do it.

I do this on an iron that is horribly out of shape, nicked, etc. I clamp the iron in a drill press vise on edge and grind it on my disc sander. I can get any angle I want and I can grind it perfectly square and I get a flat top surface. It is fast and accurate. It must be done with caution so as to not allow the fine edge to over heat.

Then the honing begins. The back of the iron is honed first to remove the burr that is inevitable when using a disc sander. I remove the burr with wet/dry sandpaper on a flat surface.

I'm not really concerned about a microscopic cutting edge. When I can shave my arm I'm ready to shave some wood. Maybe not scary sharp but good enough is good enough. I have other things to do.

Git-R-Done!

Marv

Re: PW honing guides review

#16

Re: stepping in for Joel, here

Marv

>Hi Joel!

I need a return label.....thanks,

Marv

Re: PW honing guides review

#17

Re: 2 flat planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Adam, I'm a big fan of heresy, but I think this is a little overboard. You know that Headley's plane iron was not 60 degrees because that would not work- the heel would hit the wood before the toe. It could easily have been more than 35. As to carving gouges, when I get a new gouge, I spend much more time on the flute than the bevel. At one time I had a gouge that was too small for my slipstones to get inside. The performance improved when I later got a smaller slip.

Re: PW honing guides review

#18

Re: Honing Guides

Harrelson

>Hi everyone,

I have been reading this thread with great interest and I thought I might make a couple of comments.

As a little background, I have been very interested in sharpening since I was 11 years old. I used to sharpen my buck 110 on an old oil stone I found in the basement. I later went to the North Bennett St. school in Boston and learned their methods. (hollow grinding and free hand on an oil stone). towards the end of my two years there I started using water stones and thought I had discovered nirvana! I still didn't understand the need to flatten my stones though. From there I went to Japan and apprenticed for 8 years to a lacquerer and high end box maker. I ended up staying for 12 years and studying with some of the most amazing blacksmiths, lacquers, woodworkers and carpenters. In all that time I don't think I had a conversation with any of those folks where sharpening did not come up. I spent a lot of time sharpening many different tools. All free hand. I collected lots of stones too.

I spent most of my time with Niikura Mineo an amazing box maker and formally trained lacquerer. He graduated from Kyoto art university and then apprenticed under Kuroda Tatsuaki who was one of the most well known living national treasures.

My other teacher was Kuroda Kenkichi, the son of Tatsuaki. Tatsuaki died just before I went to Japan and his son Kenkichi died a month before I left Japan. I still visit Mineo as often as I can.

Kenkichi was a sharpening maniac! He could talk about sharpening for hours and loved to go out in search of the perfect stone. He believed that we should have a conversation with the wood while shaping it and that sharpening improved the conversation. He taught me that I needed to sharpen more than I actually worked the wood as I approached the end of a project.

Niikura-san taught me to get the first coat of lacquer into the wood before using any sand paper. He didn't want any sanding particles to be embedded in the pores of the wood. That means tear out has to be controlled with sharp tools.

A lot of our tools were carving tools. Sharpening carving tools is the most difficult challenge in sharpening. Wavy buffed edges will not suffice if the tools marks can't be erased with sandpaper. All the wood fibers have to be perfectly sheared to avoid tear. The importance of edge geometry becomes magnified. We solved a lot of our problems by shaping stones to fit our tools.

Towards the end of his life, Kuroda Kenkichi and I often talked about jigs for sharpening. Kuroda-san loved to make small mini planes called "bean" planes. He would cut up large blades and make tiny little blocks to hold the blades. He felt that certain blades required a tool holder to sharpen effectively. when i made trips back to America, he had me buy the smallest vise grip pliers I could find to experiment with. He was gripping the blades and pushing them front to back. We never considered side sharpening. I really wish he had lived to see my Sharp Skate�, I think he would really have loved it because it solves the problems we talked about.

Some tools can be sharpened perfectly by free hand method but some tools are just too narrow, too long, too short or too thin to sharpen free hand. Moreover, as I have been experimenting with the sharp skate for the past 3 years, I have come to realize that no mater how careful I am, the skate produces better geometry than my best freehand effort.

I feel that freehand sharpening is an essential woodworking skill. The control needed to pare very fine joinery can be learned from sharpening. Really fine tuned motor skills are rarely innate, rather they are ingrained from lots and lots of practice. I designed the Sharp Skate to have the feel of freehand sharpening. I wanted it to have very fine, precise control and it had to use all of the stone, especially the edges. The sharp skate is really different sharpening tool. In many ways it can't be compared to jigs that have come before it.

You can work the edge, get on it really hard or back off an go ever so light. You can actually sculpt the edge. For a beginner to achieve that kind of performance with only a few hours of practice has never been possible. Real one handed sharpening is really possible. Right now we only have a few users who have really put the skate through it paces but I think that a year from now the conversations on forums like these will not be so much about weather we need the Sharp Skate but but rather, we will see lots of discussion about the possibilities of the "Sharp Skating". Has anyone tried a drill bit in it yet?

If you are interested in amazing carving and wood joinery, go to www.nihon-kogeikai.com (Japan traditional craft society) and one of my favorites "Zuishin Nakadai" He was the incredible

Peace and good woodworking

Harrelson Stanley

Re: PW honing guides review

#19

Re: 2 flat planes

James Watriss

>I have to agree. The more I learn, the less I know.

I used to think that the cannel of a carving gouge should be honed straight, and never beveled. A classmate of mine who was a professional architectural carver actually sharpens a slight bevel in the cannel of his gouges, so he can steer the gouge over and out of the surface of a convex shape. Flat meeting a bevel, or curve meeting a curve?

I think maybe it's the persistent paradigm of chisel and plane blades that keep the "flat back and flat beveled surface" paradigm in play. It seems many people have chosen either flat grind or hollow grind, and I don't hear many people talking about knife grinds anymore, despite their "steerability." A drawknife actually works better with a slight curve on the back, instead of a flat, so that you can steer it easily out of the wood. Likewise with a low-angle spokeshave.

I imagine that putting a mild knife grind on the back of a plane iron would lend all of the benefits of a "back bevel," but for some reason, it seems more reasonable and approachable to go with a back bevel. I guess that's because it's a bevel, which means it's a deliberate geometry, and not something you can get just by stropping too much.

I suppose if one wanted to get geeky-technical, the edge on a knife grind would be the point of intersection of the two planes tangent to the curved surfaces... or some such nonsense, and then it would seem more approachable, because we're still talking about flat planes, even if it's only in a strictly theoretical sense.

I dunno, I think my knife works better than my words do sometimes. And at this point, I'm probably just splitting hairs.

...which takes a mighty keen edge, I suppose.

:-p

Re: PW honing guides review

#20

Re: stepping in for Joel, here

Marv

>TFWW (Tools for Wood Working) is a great place to shop online. Joel is the boss. Five minutes after sending him an email about an item I bought, my phone was ringing. He was Joel on-the-spot wanting to know how he could best address a problem I had. Best and fastest response I've ever gotten during an online purchasing experience.

Marv

PS...thanks Joel, I have the return label.

Re: PW honing guides review

#21

honing guides

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm decent but not great at freehand sharpening. My recent purchase of the LV Mk II system has noticeably improved my sharpening. Maybe Joel could have taught me to freehand at the level that would equal what I'm accomplishing with the LV, but plane tickets to New York are a lot more expensive than the honing guide was, even with the camber wheel.

Re: PW honing guides review

#22

Chris Scholz

Re: Honing Guides

Chris Scholz

>The other culture that has produced stunning furniture are the old Chinese. Most (all?) of the sharpening appears to have been done free-hand although there is as good as no documentation on woodworking tools available. Recently I run into a 15th century reference where a fellow who commissioned some work complained that the woodworkers spent half of their working time sharpening tools. Not very surprising considering the types of wood that the best furniture is made of.

Based on the little I have learned about 15th century woodworking it appears to me as if the old masters had a rather pragmatic approach to sharpening (and tools in general). My hunch is that our way of thinking about tools and sharpening would be rather foreign to the old masters.

Chris

---

Chris Scholz

Atlanta, GA

Galoot-Tools

Re: PW honing guides review

#23

Re: freehand honing

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The problem I run into with freehand honing is that I don't keep the same angle as the iron is moving across the stone. An angle change of even one degree lower means that the point of the iron is no longer contacting the stone, correct? You would have to remove a bunch of steel again before the edge is being honed. Meanwhile, the iron has tipped 1 or 2 degrees higher so now the edge is actually rounded. Then it has tipped down 2 degrees, so now you are no longer honing the edge, but behind the edge. I would like to read a really good article or perhaps watch a video on freehand honing that actually explains the process, rather than the "Just do it!" answers that I am seeing. Konrad Sauer worked with me a little bit when he was in Edwardsburg and I was intrigued but am sorry to say I have not taken the time to explore freehand honing all that much because of my frustrations with it. The only time I don't pick up a jig to hoen is when I am sharpening carving chisels. To sharpen carving chisels I attempt to keep the same angle on the coarser stones but then intentionally round the edge a little on the fine stone, lifting the angle up as I move the chisel back.

Re: PW honing guides review

#24

Re: freehand honing

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>When I first took up woodworking I was given a book "How to Sharpen Everything" ( including shovels, etc.) and given instructions on sharpening by a friend who could put an edge on a dullard. The master in the shop where I apprenticed also taught me. When I brought in a honing guide, he laughed and asked how it worked. I told him that it was difficult to set up and only worked on the bevel.

I ended up selling the guide after attempting to use it once, too much time to fiddle with.

With the bevel ground at the proper angle I learned to sharpen by feeling the bevel on the stone. I was told to not look at the blade but feel it in proper contact with the stone.

But the single most important thing was to get the back FLAT. More attention was spent teaching me to get the back flat, the bevel is easy you are only sharpening the bevel to the end of the bevel. When flattening the back much more metal is in contact with the stone, so I spend more time on the back than the bevel.

I have not tried any new guides and they might be helpful to get the bevel right but as my master said 'no amount of work on the bevel matters until the back is FLAT!'

Stephen

Re: PW honing guides review

#25

Stephen, Have you tried David Charlesworth's

Parisian, VL

>ruler trick? I believe with the back already reasonably flat, a few back and forth swipes across the stone(s) with the ruler elevating the back of the blade ever so slightly, the back along the edge gets extremely flat with a minimum of work.

Victor - in cold and wet Houston