Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Posts

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#51

Unsquare Firewood.

Marv

>DC,

Thinking on my feet here, with very little hands-on experience with planes, strictly from a practical standpoint, if I needed to make a board square-absolute, I could not rely on the balls of my feet and the balance of my body to square up a board closer than 1 degree or 2 degrees even. And it wouldn't matter what kind of plane I was using. About all I would produce would be firewood. But maybe that's just me.

Marv

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#52

Planing by feel

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The important question is not whether you plane an edge square by feel or by eye as opposed to checking with a square. The advantage that experience and feel give is that you can be rather close to square before even checking. A person who does this regularly can plane and then check with a square and be close enough that just a few strokes can bring the work to the desired accuracy. A person who has not worked on these skills can check many times and hope each time that it is not worse than the last time they checked.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#53

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

joel -( tools for working wood)

>The second Larry Williams pointed this out to me I tested it.

On a Stanley bedrock 607 I could feel the effect but I had to pay attention. With a Norris 22 1.2" jointer the plane was so heavy that the effect was masked (even with the higher COG). With a wooden jointer it was obvious where square was.

The Stanley Bedrock I have is lighter than a modern Bedrock copy by any of the current makers. With practice feeling the COG of the bedrock was possible and after a few days of paying attention a few years ago I can now plane square pretty trivially. that is I plane square and then just double check that I'm on the money and I will be. It's like riding a bicycle. Once you learn to balance you don't fall off.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#54

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Larry, that's just the article I remembered, pretty stupid of me not to have checked the WC articles for it.

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#55

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

tstock

>So are we saying that a higher center of gravity is more desirable for sensing square? Mmm...

I fear my earlier Simpson quote slipped by without notice...sort of pointing to any number of things taken by the lay public as scientific fact which are clearly not supported by any good evidence. The notion that a lower center of gravity being better for planing is one of those things that on closer examination seems to need more than a little testing to move out of opinion and into fact.