Re: Without issue
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Incidently, you missed the 2 best ways to alter the cut: Less cut (easy on both) and sharpen the blade (easier on BU if a chip breaker is used, which it is in this case).
True, and it is of all planes, so that's not a factor in choosing one over another unless one is noticeably more difficult in these respects.
If one insists on having a do-all plane then yes, a Veritas BU plane is probably the way to go,
Well, not everyone is able and/or willing to spend $$$ on many planes like you (and I) do :-)
but I think they made their mistake right up front there.
For actual flattening of a board (not final smoothing), unless you insist on using the same plane for flattening as for smoothing (and it's not so hard to have 2 or 3 planes, is it?), mouth adjustment is a red herring; you are very unlikely to change once set sensibly.
I said that earlier, if you have a plane for each task the throat issue is less of a factor. Still, the fact that one can open the throat wide open to clear the shavings, then coming back to the same original opening, is of value to me, and the BU planes allow that while the BD...
You won't be going lower then 45 degrees for flattening either (well, it is damn unlikely).
Mighty convenient for end grain, though. I know, not part of the original equation, but there nonetheless.
In realistic, real world flattening, BU's only real advantage is less mucking about is sharpening; I'll admit that part is definitely an edge (can't help myself :) )
Funny, while true, somehow it doesn't bug me that much.
Well, for greather then 45 degrees, generally a steeper microbevel is less hassle then a back-bevel, but again, that would rarely be an issue for flattening boards.
Depends on the type of grain one encounters...
Otherwise, as in almost all cases, the style of construction isn't really all that dominant, it is the user preference.
This is where we differ...
DC
And we didn't touch the center of gravity issue...