Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Posts

LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#1

LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

I am tossing my thoughts back and forth on selecting a bench jointer. I like the characteristics of the LN 8 and read great things about the Veritas BU jointer.

I want a jointer that can be used with out issue for flattening a board across grain or with the grain. I'm leaning one way, but would like to hear about the selection process others have made given these choices, or, others.

Thoughts are appreciate one way or another please.

Take care,

Jim

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#2

I vote for the C&W jointer, you'll love it.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#3

Why, both of course :-)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Seriously now, I have a hard time coming with a recommendation...

The BUJ is one sweet piece of equipment, I own one. As you probably already know, the mouth is set back like a #8, and makes the plane very well balanced, better than a #8 IMO. #8s have all that length back of the tote, which makes them a bit unwieldy at the end of the stroke.

OTOH, the LN #8 is one monster of a plane, and will go through anything without a hiccup. With the Canadian $ the way it was a couple years ago, a LN was out of my reach, so I settled for "second best", and got myself a Stanley #8 (Type 6), had the sole machined flat (a heresy in some quarters), and installed a LN replacement blade and cap iron. In terms of performance, a friend who owns the LN told me that my setup was very close in performance to the LN's, and cost me a third of the price.

The LN weighs 10 lbs. That's a lot of weight to move around when working on panels, and the extra wide iron doesn't help. I think the LN is a bit overboard for that task (unless you have arms like Popeye's...)

I thus decided to dedicate my #8 to doing edges, with a straight iron. The width allows me to match-plane thick stock. For working on panels, I prefer the BUJ, for its balance, its lower weight, and its adaptability to the wood at hand by just swapping the iron. I use it with a small camber, suitable for that task.

I'm quite happy with my setup.

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#4

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I want a jointer that can be used with out issue for flattening a board across grain or with the grain.

Hi Jim

Question: Would it make a difference if you took the cross grain flattening out of the equation?

When I flatten across grain I use the Veritas LA Jack with a slightly cambered 25 degree bevel (= 37 degrees of attack).



If you have a LA Jack, then the focus moves to edge jointing and planing faces. If you do not own one, then the ability of the BUJ (with LA set up) to plane cleaner across grain is important.

I have used a Stanley #8 but do not the LN version. The weight of the Stanley did not feel excessive, however this may not mean anything as the LN is heavier. Frankly I like hefty planes for the hard woods I work, and since I am not using them all day long, the weight in the occasional jointing time is not a negative.

I have compared the Stanley #7 with the Veritas BU Jointer. It was not hard to like just about everything about the BUJ. I would rather pull out that plane than the Stanley #7 (and mine is a very nice #7, which does still get used). Link to my review below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Comparison of BUJ (reviewed) and Stanley #7

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#5

Re: Why, both of course :-)

Brent in Montreal

>Jim...I definately have to go with Denis here. Both have their sweet spot. More importantly, you, and I, know that you're going to end up buying both eventually anyway :).

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#6

I second the wooden jointer idea...

James Watriss

>Much easier on the forearms/elbows if you have to do a lot of flattening.

If price is an issue, look for old wooden ones on the 'bay. Great if you have more time than money, too. Old wood doesn't move as much as fresh wood does, and the old irons were SWEEEET.

My personal fave is an old razee jointer I found, with pitch covered end grain... my guess is that it was used by a boat builder... the handle is the most comfortable I've seen, and it's 28" long. Think I paid $40.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#7

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Raney

>Fwiw, I owned the BUJ for about 6 months and replaced it with a LN 8.

The BUJ is a fantastic plane, but in the end it came down to the fact that I am a strong convert to cambered jointer blade for edge jointing. While this is possible on a BU plane (Derek has done a nice job showing this) I still find it more of a PITA than its worth.

If I were in the school that joints with a straight blade i wouldn't have bothered with the switch.

As to the poster who found the #8 unbalanced, I can't say I agree. Personally, I think the further set-back mouth on the BUJ worked very well, but I think this is true at least in part due to the lower center of gravity and/or more 'upright' tote angle.

There is also the undefinable 'Feel' about the LN... for whatever reason - psychosomatic, balance, weight, wanting to justify the extra expense or (most likely) a combination of all of these - I just love the #8.

Also, please understand that I do not do all my stock prep by hand anymore. The extra weight of the 8 is a good thing for me, but I would probably sing a different tune if I were professionally preparing stock by hand. A few steady hours of face jointing and those extra pounds become VERY significant. If I were jointing by hand for long periods of time I would definitely be looking for a wooden jointer.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#8

Without issue

Warren inLancaster, PA

>Jim, I am wondering about your phrase "with out issue". With a power jointer it seems that weight and length contribute to the ease and quality of work. With a hand plane length is helpful, but must be supplemented by the users skill. I have several times read on this forum where someone used a large jointer plane and was confused because their board was not automatically flat.

I use a number 7 plane for edge jointing. Because weight is an "issue", I use a wooden trying plane for "face jointing". The #8 is the clumsiest plane I ever used. I would be tempted by the Primus jointer and possibly the C & W for edge jointing for weight and comfort.

I think a bevel up plane would have issues taking a moderate shaving on a board with figure or grain reversals, especially if the board were a delicate wood like pine, poplar, butternut or a soft mahogany.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#9

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I think a bevel up plane would have issues taking a moderate shaving on a board with figure or grain reversals, especially if the board were a delicate wood like pine, poplar, butternut or a soft mahogany.

Why is that so? I don't follow you here...

The BUJ is more adjustable more quickly than BD planes, so it will adapt easily to any grain situation. Getting a camber requires a bit more work, but not that much, and that's basically a one-time operation anyway.

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#10

Re: Without issue

Warren inLancaster, PA

>A high angle cut does not work well for the more delicate woods. If you want to get a feel for this, try working Eastern white pine with a scraper or a scraper plane.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#11

Re: Without issue

Paul Kierstead

>The BUJ is more adjustable more quickly than BD planes

I am not sure I follow you there.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#12

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>OK, but the BUJ comes with a 25 degree blade, giving it a 37 degree effective angle compared to 45 for a BD plane, and changing the angle on a BU plane is just a matter of adding a micro-bevel (or grind a new bevel if so inclined) ...

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#13

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Two things you can do to change the plane's working characteristics: adjust the throat and change the effective angle of attack. On most BD planes you can't get a lower effective angle than 45 degree. Higher than that you either grind a back bevel or change the frog. On a BU plane one could go down to 32 degree (but the edge would be fragile at that 20 degree angle, for sure), and go up to any angle you want by changing the blade or grinding a bevel. That's the more adjustable part.

When it comes to adjust the throat, Bedrock planes are fairly quick to adjust, but the depth of cut changes at the same time, requiring an extra adjustment. On Bailey planes one has to remove the blade assembly, guesstimate how much the frog needs to be moved, put the blade back in, and repeat if the adjustment was off the mark. At least depth of cut is not affected (in principle).

On BU planes (I'm talking about Veritas BU planes here), loosen the front knob (or separate knob for the BUJ), move the frog using the stop screw (no screwdriver needed), and tighten the front knob. Quicker to much quicker than with BD planes, depth of cut is unchanged, and no tools needed.

If you have dedicated planes for each task then throat adjustment is not much of a factor, but when using the same plane for different tasks, and/or wood species, and/or grain orientations, using different blades (say, switching from a "jack" blade to a "smoothing" one in the same plane) the BU planes makes adjustments faster to make.

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#14

What, no K&S Jointer? :>)

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#15

Taking issue "without issue"

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>I think a bevel up plane would have issues taking a moderate shaving on a board with figure or grain reversals, especially if the board were a delicate wood like pine, poplar, butternut or a soft mahogany.

A high angle cut does not work well for the more delicate woods. If you want to get a feel for this, try working Eastern white pine with a scraper or a scraper plane.

Hi Warren

I think that you are missing the point, or that the point of the #8 (or #7 if one prefers) verses the BUJ has not been clarified.

First off, the BU planes can be set up at any angle, not necessarily a high cutting angle (as your post suggests). If a 45 degree angle of attack was the preferred set up, then all the planes, BU and BD, could do so as equals.

Secondly, if a low angle set up is preferred, such as for cutting across the grain, then the BU planes have the advantage here. As I depicted, my LA Jack is planing Cherry at 37 degrees.

While these comments may appear to be favouring the BU over the BD plane, this is not really my intent here. I was just attempting to comment on the issue you raised.

My preference for a jointer is not based on BU verses BD configurations. Forget this for the time being. I think that the BUJ and a #7 have a different centre of gravity, and ultimately one chooses the plane that feels most comfortable. My bias is for planes with a low centre of gravity.

While I like BU planes for cross grain, my favourite jointer for edge jointing is a 30" high angle razee woodie I built myself. It has the low centre of gravity I noted and, in spite of being dense Jarrah, is as light as a feather.



I also like using the HNT Gordon Trying Plane, which is the length of a #6.



For face grain, the Veritas BU Jointer is a good choice for me. I can swap blades as needed. Below, the BUJ flattening a Jarrah tabletop..



Incidentally, I often use these HA planes on softwoods and they work very well. In fact, some of the cheap pine I have used has more grain reversals than the hardwoods, and this responds better to a HA than a LA setup.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#16

Because.....

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>it's going to be a Gift for a friend of mine, it's not for me.

:-)

Take care,

Jim

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#17

Application

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

With out issue means that it's the right tool choice for flattening.

The plane will be a gift for a friend who does similar WW that I do, so I want to get the best gift for his application.

Right now I have a 607 that I use for a similar process.

Take care,

Jim

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#18

Ahhhhh!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>You shouldn't have!!!

Well, I'll be sure to act surprised anyway..... :>)

Later,

Dominic

What do you mean it's not for me?

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#19

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Cecil Nickerson

>Hi Jim, I would look at the Lie-Nielsen 7 1/2 if you're leaning towards bevel-up. It's been a solid performer for me and actually looks like a plane. O.k., I loathe the design of the Lee Valley lineup, but that;s just me. Take care, Cecil.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#20

Re: Without issue

Paul Kierstead

>I thought you were replying in the context of the thread (flattening boards), not in the very general sense.

Incidently, you missed the 2 best ways to alter the cut: Less cut (easy on both) and sharpen the blade (easier on BU if a chip breaker is used, which it is in this case).

If one insists on having a do-all plane then yes, a Veritas BU plane is probably the way to go, but I think they made their mistake right up front there.

For actual flattening of a board (not final smoothing), unless you insist on using the same plane for flattening as for smoothing (and it's not so hard to have 2 or 3 planes, is it?), mouth adjustment is a red herring; you are very unlikely to change once set sensibly. You won't be going lower then 45 degrees for flattening either (well, it is damn unlikely). In realistic, real world flattening, BU's only real advantage is less mucking about is sharpening; I'll admit that part is definitely an edge (can't help myself :) ). Well, for greather then 45 degrees, generally a steeper microbevel is less hassle then a back-bevel, but again, that would rarely be an issue for flattening boards.

Otherwise, as in almost all cases, the style of construction isn't really all that dominant, it is the user preference.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#21

Cecil and I agree on one thing...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>We both loathe the design of the Lee Valley lineup. I have the early 7-1/2 with out the adjustable mouth, and it has a bit of a wide mouth. I'm sure the newer adjustable mouth would be a good choice.

One cool thing about the LN is you should be able to use Paul Hamler's scraper insert in it.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#22

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Rob Cosman

>Jim, I have thought it over long and hard, made my pro vs con list, shopped around, tried em all and decided you will only be happy with the boss of the shop, LN #8!

Cheers

Rob :)

(with orderform in hand)

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#23

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>LOL!

Of course, this suggestion is from a totally unbiased point of view, right? :-)

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#24

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Incidently, you missed the 2 best ways to alter the cut: Less cut (easy on both) and sharpen the blade (easier on BU if a chip breaker is used, which it is in this case).

True, and it is of all planes, so that's not a factor in choosing one over another unless one is noticeably more difficult in these respects.

If one insists on having a do-all plane then yes, a Veritas BU plane is probably the way to go,

Well, not everyone is able and/or willing to spend $$$ on many planes like you (and I) do :-)

but I think they made their mistake right up front there.

For actual flattening of a board (not final smoothing), unless you insist on using the same plane for flattening as for smoothing (and it's not so hard to have 2 or 3 planes, is it?), mouth adjustment is a red herring; you are very unlikely to change once set sensibly.

I said that earlier, if you have a plane for each task the throat issue is less of a factor. Still, the fact that one can open the throat wide open to clear the shavings, then coming back to the same original opening, is of value to me, and the BU planes allow that while the BD...

You won't be going lower then 45 degrees for flattening either (well, it is damn unlikely).

Mighty convenient for end grain, though. I know, not part of the original equation, but there nonetheless.

In realistic, real world flattening, BU's only real advantage is less mucking about is sharpening; I'll admit that part is definitely an edge (can't help myself :) )

Funny, while true, somehow it doesn't bug me that much.

Well, for greather then 45 degrees, generally a steeper microbevel is less hassle then a back-bevel, but again, that would rarely be an issue for flattening boards.

Depends on the type of grain one encounters...

Otherwise, as in almost all cases, the style of construction isn't really all that dominant, it is the user preference.

This is where we differ...

DC

And we didn't touch the center of gravity issue...

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#25

Re: Without issue

Paul Kierstead

>I expect you will claim that a low center of gravity is an advantage, but that is another area that is clearly user preference since quite a few users find a low center of gravity to be a liability, especially for jointing. Others find it an advantage.