Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

Posts

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#26

Gift? Christmas?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Oh, a gift. I don't know for sure, but most C&W planes have a waiting list. Maybe an HNT Gordon Try plane or ECE Primus jointer would be a better idea for this year.

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#27

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I expect you will claim that a low center of gravity is an advantage, but that is another area that is clearly user preference since quite a few users find a low center of gravity to be a liability, especially for jointing. Others find it an advantage.

Sounds like "testimonies" from infomercials :-D

Lower COG = better control, less tendency to tip, in all situations. Period. Please prove me wrong...

I don't know who those "quite a few users" are, but methinks that for many of these people there is reluctance to admit that there is something better out there (compared to what they have). "Hey, can't have bought a lesser tool, that newfangled stuff is just flash not substance, tried and true worked in the past, and I don't need to try that new stuff". You know, a topic we touched upon after the association meeting last night...

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#28

Re: Because.....

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Can I be your friend, plllleeeease? :-)

LN for me, since I have the BUJ already...

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#29

Re: Without issue

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>It's easier to joint a board with a high top wooden jointer than with a low center of gravity metal thing. Personal experience. No infomercial. Sold the dang #7. I don't care what you (impersonal) recommend or buy vis a vis my purchases/recommendations. I don't even much care what you (impersonal) think of my tool set.

And it's sort of rude for you (personal) to suggest otherwise.

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#30

Re: Because.....

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>:-)

Denis, Montreal Smoked Meat for you Buddy!

take care,

Jim

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#31

Re: Without issue

Warren in Lancaster, Pa

>Denis, perhaps you were unable to understand the wear bevel problems I tried to explain to you specifically just two weeks ago. And perhaps you were unable to understand the use of the double iron we were talking about last week. But please don't ask us questions and then make us out to be fools after we have taken time to answer your questions.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#32

Re: Without issue

Paul Kierstead

>Oh what a load of crap, beating out that old "people can't accept something new". The only thing that isn't accepted here is that peoples personal preferences might vary. The discussion at the meeting was exactly the one here, when someone (you in this case) insists there method is the "best" and is unwilling to accept anyone else's experience. Some day it might occur to you that not everyone does everything the way you do and thus end up with a different result without them being unable to accept something new or having an inferiority complex about there tools.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#33

I Don't Agree Denis

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Denis,

I don't agree with your thoughts in the last post you made. I think that as we develop our skills with what ever our tools are we find methods and approaches that give us results that make us happy, or we look for other ones.

I have a wide variety of planes, some wood, some metal, some infills, each allows me to do as I like. I really don't feel that we can generalize that one set of characteristics arcoss a wide range of users will produce consistantly repeatable results....I still use a wooden driver in my golf bag,I still enjoy the feel of that club over that of some of the mosnters they sell now...it's all about feel.

Take care,

Jim

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#34

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>It's easier to joint a board with a high top wooden jointer than with a low center of gravity metal thing. Personal experience. No infomercial.

Woodies were not the topic here, but I'm glad to hear your POV. Is it a matter of performance? Feel? Does your statement apply to face or edge jointing? Please elaborate. I have little experience with wooden planes, so your experience is of interest.

I don't care what you (impersonal) recommend or buy vis a vis my purchases/recommendations. I don't even much care what you (impersonal) think of my tool set.

I don't know what your tool set contains, so I can't pass judgment over it, I sure wasn't targeting you...

And it's sort of rude for you (personal) to suggest otherwise.

Rude to suggest what? I lost you here.

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#35

Re: Because.....

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Schwartz's of course! Yummy! :-)

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#36

Uhh?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Fools? I'm missing something here...

I re-read the wear bevel thread, and I fail to see what I misunderstood... What you explained is real, but just for the record, my irons are sharp, so there is something in play that is missing. Mike W alluded to that if I recall correctly (I read the thread a couple hours ago).

The double iron issue thread I did not read again, but my recollection is that they were useful for medium thickness shavings, provided the cap iron is set just right. That seemed to be the consensus...

But what this has to do with the current topic escapes me...

If I insulted you in any way I apologize, I just don't know how I did that...

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#37

Cecil does not speak for all Nickersons

Chuck Nickerson

>Feel what's good in your hands. Don't be afraid of change.

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#38

Re: Without issue

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Paul, I love your thoughtful and delicate prose :-)

This is not my recollection of last night's discussion, but I believe this is not of interest to the people on this forum. Ping me off-line if you want to pursue this further.

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#39

Re: I Don't Agree Denis

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>You mean drivers were once made out of wood? Allright, allright, just pulling your leg... :-)

No argument about the feel issue. My problem is that often this is used as an excuse to defend one's tool choices, there are some people who will defend their purchases tooth and nail, because they would rather die than admit that there is something "better" (however defined) than what they chose out there. Same applies to cars, sound systems, computers, etc.

I bought a bunch of tools over the years, many of which are not in my shop anymore, even though they were touted as "the best" in their category. In most cases "feel" was not an issue as much as performance...

Anyway, I think I will not get involved in that kind of discussion anymore, as all I get is flak for posting my honest assessment.

DC

Appreciate your level-headed tone, BTW...

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#40

Re: I Don't Agree Denis

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I think the problem is that you've extrapolated from personal, anecdotal experience. Perhaps you've occasionally looked and/or talked to reinforce your choices, that's certainly why someone who's just bought a new car watches ads for that car, why someone who's just bought a new plane reads ads for that plane, etc. No question, we all do this from time to time.

However, it's not that reasonable to assume that everyone here takes the time to offer help/advice based on self reinforcement. So many of us have been around for some years and have tried or are open to an extraordinary number and types of tools. We talk about our experiences, fairly critically as nearly as I can tell, with the intent of helping.

And that's what I complained about above, that it sounded like you were accusing Paul of talking as if he tried to create an infomercial, the goal of which is to sell someone for personal/corporate gain.

Now, as to a high center of gravity woody being superior for jointing, I found that my jointing progressed a level or two in ease and accuracy simply by replacing a #7 with an ECE Primus jointer (701?). About the time I was in the process of getting rid of most of my metal bench planes, Larry Williams mentioned that he thought the height and/or large profile of the woody jointers made square joints easier. I think it's because of the height, easier to tell if something tall is tilting than something short.

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#41

Re: I Don't Agree Denis

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Pam

With regard the high centre of gravity issue when jointing, Larry has said the same thing to me (about high woodies being easier to use). This makes sense to me, and I am not going to dispute his experience or opinion in this regard. I think he is right. But ...

The posts I have made elsewhere hopefully convey the message that we eventually gravitate to a tool (plane) that meets a special need. For some it may be that they respond to the cues for orientation imparted by a higher gravity plane (into which group, incidentally, I include Stanley planes - which you appear to exclude). For others (I fall into this category), orientation per se is not the need, but feedback (i.e. "feel") is. Personally, I do not have any difficulty orientating a low centre of gravity (BU) plane when jointing an edge. I accept that others may not have the same experience.... which is why we will never agree that there will be a one plane that fits all.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#42

Re: I Don't Agree Denis

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>To me, the ability to sense/determine tilt is feedback, the most important for this discussion. There's some other feedback, such as blade state, hand comfort or lack thereof, whether the plane is moving smoothly, and position relative to the board; but those things weren't germane.

And you can't possibly think that I think a single plane can be the be all and end all for any/all. I know you don't think this. :)

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#43

What you got flak for...

Raney

>was not posting your 'honest assessment'. It was for insinuating that those whose opinions differ are closed-minded, and 'selling' their opinions � la infomercials.

"Lower COG = better control, less tendency to tip, in all situations. Period. Please prove me wrong..."

What you get flak for is insisting that your opinion is TRUTH. You claim that 'these people' who prefer traditional BD planes do so because they are unwilling to open their eyes and are merely defending their purchases. Pot - meet kettle.

I prefer BD planes for most typical planing on domestic hardwoods. For tricky grain I prefer a BU plane for its ability to adopt a very high angle of attack with ease. I also prefer them for shooting. This is not defending my purchases - in fact it is the opposite, as I came to this conclusion after having purchased the entire BU plane contingency from LV because of the 'obvious' superiority so many people touted. This was an expensive conclusion for me.

I also dispute that BU planes have the edge re: sharpening. My experience is that I have to sharpen my BU plane blades far more often than BD. After noticing this phenomenon I was made aware of the wear bevel issues, which explain my experience.

I certainly have no problem with BU planes - I still own a BU jack and smoother, and find them to be excellent for the tasks i use them for. I also completely understand (and respect) that others have differing opinions. I think Derek makes very good point for his preferences.

I also note that I am apparently not alone in my preference. i know of many many professional woodworkers who use their planes more in a month than I probably will in a lifetime. Many of them seem to prefer BD for most traditional planing tasks as well.

Perhaps you could adopt a less condescending tone in these discussions, and then you would feel much less 'flak-ridden'?

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#44

Clearing the air a little bit

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I don't want to re-start this thread, but the last streak of comments makes me want to clear the air.

First, the "testimonials from infomercials" bit was intended to be taken as a joke. Obviously this is not the way it was interpreted, next time I'll try to be more obvious... My apologies to those whom my attempt at humor rubbed the wrong way.

The part about the "Lower COG = better control, less tendency to tip, in all situations", is true in the physical sense, it's not an opinion that I'm trying to present as a truth. It's the exact same reason why, all other things being equal, a SUV is more prone to rollover than a sedan. I think I can see why Pam's high top woodie has her preference, but a description of the process would be welcome. Article, maybe?

I will not touch the wear bevel issue here, as I believe it deserves its own separate thread. That will be for another time...

In the end, I guess what I'd like to see is a more scientific approach to tool evaluation. My position as far as tool assessment is concerned ranks performance first (loosely defined as whether a given tool can do a better job at a given task and/or do it more easily, hard to describe in one sentence), then feel, then looks. My Yataiki saws fit that ranking perfectly. Performance? Absolutely wonderful. Feel? It's as if the saw has become an extension of the arm and hand. Looks? Although it is a piece of art, especially considering it is completely made by hand, to the untrained eye it looks not very different from a Gyokucho that costs something like 5-10 times less. Do I care? Not one bit.

Others use a different ranking, and being somewhat opinionated, sometimes I have difficulty accepting "feel" as a rationale for the choice of a particular tool, as it can be too easily used for "self-reinforcement", as I have been "accused" of doing (this is not the case, BTW).

And if I've sounded condescending, my apologies, this was not the intention...

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#45

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

Marv

>It is difficult at best to always express one's self in these forums without coming across in some manner other than intended. We are attempting to communicate a thought, an idea, an opinion or whatever, without writing a book. Most of us are not accomplished writers. Some of us can barely type. We don't include puncuations often enough.

We all need to take into account that we do not have the advantage of facial expressions or body language or those subtle pauses during speech. All of these things play a huge part in communicating with each other. All we have here are words on our screen that many times leaves alot to interpretation.

Before we tear into someone, lets give the writer the benifit of the doubt. Usually, he/she is well meaning.

Marv

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#46

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

tstock

>Everyone knows rock n' roll attained perfection in 1974. It's a scientific fact.

Homer Simpson

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#47

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, I get the SUV analogy and largely agree. Perhaps a well built woody doesn't have a high or appreciably higher cog even though it's tall?

As for the article, Larry et al once had one on their web site. Perhaps he can dig it out.

As to scientific, this isn't an issue with me, guess I've had enough science in software development, nice thing about woodworking is I can ignore everything but feel and visualization. This could change, but hasn't yet.

Pam

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#48

Re: Clearing the air a little bit *LINK*

Larry Williams

>Here's just a little. Try the part about ripping a 1� bevel on the edge of a board and see if you can't feel the difference.


link

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#49

Re: Clearing the air a little bit

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Yeah, I get the SUV analogy and largely agree. Perhaps a well built woody doesn't have a high or appreciably higher cog even though it's tall?

Possible, it would be interesting to test that. One thing is for sure, a woodie is lighter, and the weight is more evenly distributed by design, both factors should help control (defined as the ease of making the plane do what you want).

DC

Re: LN 8 vs Veritas BU Jointer

#50

Mmmm...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Can't argue with anything said here, however it seems to me that the 1 degree bevel test will be felt relative to the bench surface. For instance, I have no clue whether my bench top is perfectly level or not, because it sits on the floor, which can be a couple degrees off too (basement shop). But I'm used to it as a "reference surface", so to me it is "level".

While I think we can get reasonably close to level working freehand, without a reference to compare to I don't think I'd personally be able to detect a one or two degree discrepancy from level or plumb. I'll have to test that one of these days...

DC