What kind of rasps are you buying
Chuck Nickerson
>that match the quality and variety of shaes offered by Auriou?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What kind of rasps are you buying
Chuck Nickerson
>that match the quality and variety of shaes offered by Auriou?
I'm a Winter Person
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>Hi Glenn,
I am a winter person...so it has little impact on myself. A friend recently moved to Norway. Len is 45 and says he is constantly being run off the X-country ski tracks by older skiers....he's working out hard this summer to be ready for this years season.
:-)
A warm shop and good music would be my winters dream.
Take care,
Jim
I'm with you here
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>I'd rather have -30 than +30 (Celcius). When it gets cold you just add another layer of clothing, when it get too hot, well, there are limits to what you can do :-)
Besides, there's no mosquitoes, wasps, etc. to bug you in the winter...
DC
Bring on the snow!
Auriou was based in Saint-Juery.
Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)
>Google is your friend. The Auriou website is here.
Regards,
Ian.
I see Todd's point of view - rasp alternatives
David Barnett - SW Florida
>Although you were obviously addressing Todd, here's a few alternatives to Auriou, many which are as good if not better, and all far less costly. Rasps are probably (along with burnishers) my favorite tools and I have a lot of both. While I've owned and used Auriou rasps in several shapes and grains (I love the modeler's rasps), they're okay on hard microcrystalline waxes (for cire perdue, etc.) and wood, but they don't hold up well to stone, plaster, investment or even woods species with high silica content. They're also not good candidates for resharpening due to their case hardening and lower carbon metallurgy, allowing for easier production; stitching and heat treating, at the expense of longevity.
Milani handcut rasps and rifflers are a worthy option. Unlike the inferior Austrian or Hungarian attempts, these are high carbon, nicely cut, well heat treated and tempered for stone, plaster, investment and wood species with high silica content. They last and last, cut beautifully, quickly and smoothly, cost 1/3 to 1/2 the price of an Auriou, and last two to three times as long. They come in a broad range of sizes and styles and can go from wood to stone to wood again, esp. in their first half-life. I usually dedicate them to stone in their second half-life, and not on soft material (soapstones or alabasters). I only carve harder marbles and limestones. As the teeth are bidirectional in most styles, they'll cut on both the push and pull strokes when it's useful to do so, although I learned to lift on the backstroke and still tend to do so. The can usually be sharpened a couple cycles. The Aurious do not take well to this with their soft core and thin case hardened shell.
While the Milani rasps are mostly based on sculpting tradition (they do make fine cut half-rounds and cabinet rasps) , F. Dick rasps excel at cabinetmaking and patternmaking tasks. I use on them on wood only, where they last and last. I also love their files, which you can purchase from www.riogrande.com, a large jeweler supply. These are cut to a more acute angle than so-called 'Swiss pattern' files, which allow for facile and smooth cutting of not only non-ferrous metals (silver, gold, brass, copper, et al), but also ivory, lapis, coral, dense woods (LV, rosewoods, ebonies, et al) and tough resin laminates such as micarta. I mention the F. Dick files as they are my go-to followups to rasps on wood.
Then there are the Kutzalls. I think these are the most versatile of all rasps. They cut rapidly in any direction, almost never were out as they're made with structured carbide teeth, and can be unclogged quickly and safely with a torch. These are the modern workhorses of the rasp family and pay for themselves in no time flat.
Finally, you could try making a rasp or two on your own. It's far easier (and kinda fun) to make a fine cut rasp than you might imagine, esp. with all the hyperbole and high prices from rasp manufacturers. You can do this with a firebrick, a MAPP torch (even a cheap propane plumber's torch for smaller to medium sized rasps), and a hammer. You can stitch with a simple homemade punch (just a rod of tool steel/drill rod, a worn file, screwdriver shank, center punch, etc.). Over the years I've made needle rasps, small to medium sized straight and curved rasps, and I'm totally satisfied. They're far better than the cheaper Euro or Chinese rasps I've tried and cost next to nothing. Helps if you use a Magnivisor and vise, but you can manage without either. You can practice on brass or mild steel, if you feel the need. I promised someone in chat recently that I'd email some tips reasonably soon. Maybe I'll post them, too, if anyone's really interested.
Anyway, I just wanted to say that although I'm sad to see a toolmaker bite the dust, even if they were a bit pricey, there are alternatives every bit as serviceable and for less spondulix.
Oh... and don't forget variously shaped sanding sticks. They're extremely versatile, cheaply made of scrap wood and scrap sandpaper, and can produce excellent results. I use coarse through ultrafine papers and some with leather or hard felt with polishing compounds. I doubt there's a jeweler, goldsmith, silversmith, gunsmith who doesn't depend on them, but they're equally useful for woodworkers and machinists. (My favorites are 3M polishing papers and films that range from 220 to 8000 grit, are accurately graded and can even be washed and used over and over (get them from www.ottofrei.com or www.riogrande.com).
dF. DICK in cooperation with the Swiss filemaker VALLORBE/GROBET
http://www.fine-tools.com/feile1.htm
L�Antica Ferraria di Villamagina
http://www.ferrariavillamagina.com/default_ENG.html
Milani rasps & rifflers
http://www.fine-tools.com/feile8.htm
http://2sculpt.com/hand_rasps.html
http://www.sculpt.com/catalog_98/files-rasps/milanirifflers.htm
http://www.sculpt.com/catalog_98/files-rasps/milanirifflers.htm
http://www.bradsculpture.com/supply/tools08.asp?pg=1
Kutzall carbide rasps & rifflers
http://www.sculpt.com/catalog_98/files-rasps/rebit.htm
Sculpture House Italian Rifflers
http://www.sculpt.com/catalog_98/files-rasps/SHRIFFLERS183.htm
I'm interested
Frank D. in Montreal
>Thanks for that informative and well-thought-out post, David. I'd much appreciate seeing any info you have on rasp-making if you care to post it.
Thanks
Jack Guzman from Maine
>David,
Thanks for the enlightenment and a helpful list of sources.Sometimes I'm too easily swayed my tool hype.We need more posts like yours.---Jack
Thank you,
Greg B�tit, Vergennes VT
>Thank you! What great information! Your post made it worth while wading through this long thread.
greg
Re: I see Todd's point of view - rasp alternatives
BobStrawn
>Thank you, David,
Data such as your just provided is a treasure.
Bob
Treatise on raspology-Article candidate
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>I learned more in this post about rasps than the sum of all I knew before. Thanks!
Wow!
Paul Kierstead
>You come through again. This gets saved in my files; very valuable information as I try to creep towards things more free-hand.
Saved in your files or in your rasps? :-)
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>
Excellent expos�! A question
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>This is definitely worth of an article...
My question is, what do you think of mill files, such as the Nicholson Supershear or the ones sold by LV? I didn't see them mentioned.
Thnx,
DC
Spite? Not a chance - more likely exchange rate
Derek
>Some people sure show their biases by the particular words they choose to use.
Closing his family business, which they have had for generations, is unlikely done for spite.
I suggest you re-think your position/opinion.
Every story has 2 sides. Unless you get both sides, you do not have the story.
It is more likely that he was forced by creditors to do so. This is bankruptcy, not a voluntary closing. Bankruptcy is forced on poeple and businesses.
I'm guessing (since I do not actually know) that the dramatic fall of the dollar has killed this business. I'm guessing that they sold rasps to the US market in dollars. When the dollar fell too much against the Euro, they could not get enough payment in Euro's to pay their bills.
Not quite what I said
Frank D. in Montreal
>Hi Derek,
As far as I can tell I don't have an opinion/position. All I really said was that we don't know the whole story (much like you said). I was answering to Marv's comments who seemed to imply that since the employees refused to work overtime they didn't deserve to work. I said that we don't know exactly what happened, and that if an owner were to shut down for that reason only it would merely be out of spite (in other words it doesn't make any business sense).
The other "version" (rumor) of what happened regarding the North American market was given to me by a French retailer (I'm also a French citizen and go to France every year). No one knows the full story, and I can tell you that all the French citizens that I've spoken to (who know what Auriou was) don't really believe the version about the employees refusing to work overtime.
Great stuff, Dave, as usual. Many thanks.
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>
Re: Bankruptcy in Europe
Michael Recchione
>I don't find the OT explanation believable. Even with France's worker protection rules, a guy that's made his living sitting at a special bench and raising teeth on a piece of steel has to know that ultimately he's going to have to start from scratch somewhere else if he loses his job - that's not exactly a high-demand skill in the general market.
I'm inclined to believe the exchange rate explanation - that's got to hurt, when you're committed to delivering a product at a price that gave you a decent margin when you agreed to it, but that forced you to take a loss on every item you sold by the time you delivered. If that goes on long enough, you've only got two choices: reneg on your commitment and raise the price after the fact (which you're not likely to get away with), or shut down and try to cut your losses.
Sorry to see a good toolmaker go under.
Perhaps I read your post to quickly but
Derek
>I certainly did not mean to offend you either. Perhaps I was bothered by a number of posts which insinuated bad motives against the owner with few or no facts to back them up.
Even if the company went under because the employees refused to work overtime, it is likely it was the banks or other creditors who insisted on this rather than the owner. They may have been looking for a way to make the company profitable enough to get payment. In fact, it is likely that there was one or a small number of secured creditors who proposed this restriction.
I do not know French law, but I would be extremely surprised if the owner profits from bankruptcy in any way.
Personally, I feel bad for everyone involved except the banks.
Re: Bankruptcy in Europe
Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX
>Michael, there are any number of ways deals with retailers can be made. For example, the goods could be an assignment in which the manufacturer only gets paid when the goods are sold; which provides minimal protection for the manufacturer and none vis a vis currency fluctuations. Then the manufacturer would have to rely on insurance of some sort, or s/he could simply refuse to transfer the funds to his/her country and deposit them in a American account.
Or, the deal could be the retailer pays his half, more or less, to the manufacturer on receipt of the goods, in which case the manufacturer receives his/her funds immediately and there would be little exposure to currency fluctuations.
We'd have to get the retailers to reveal their deals, but there's little motivation for them to do so. I personally am not at all uncomfortable not knowing what really happened, it's not necessary for us to believe any one theory. I agree completely with your view that it's highly unlikely that the problem was with labor refusing to work overtime.
Pam
Re: Perhaps I read your post to quickly but
Frank D. in Montreal
>No offense taken at all Derek,
In fact I realized that we pretty well agreed, and that I might not have been as clear as I thought, so I basically took the opportunity to clarify.
Use Ice!
Brad in Ottawa
>You put your beer on ice in the summer and it makes the heat dissappear!
Brad
PS - Although in the summer you can't put the beer outside in a snowdrift to keep it cold for a party!
Re: I see Todd's point of view - rasp alternatives
wayne anderson
>David,
I would like to echo the comments and the thanks of others. A wealth of info, which I immediately printed for future reference.
Could you elaborate on heat treating a rasp please? Also, I was wondering if I could turn old files into something useable again by softening, shaping, and re-hardening. (I have a 5 gallon bucket full of used files).
Thanks again!
wayne anderson
send them to be resharpened
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>It costs but a fraction of the new price
Re: I see Todd's point of view - rasp alternatives
Bob Entwisle in NJ
>David,
Thanks for the great info and links!
With all the hyperbole, speculation and general lament concerning the demise of Auriou, It seemed as if I might have to give up woodworking, but thanks to you I now have a new �Files and Rasps� favorites folder and am confident that I can safely (respectfully) forget about Auriou and get on with my life.
I would also be interested should you care to share your knowledge of making rasps etc.
Bob (_in_NJ)
Re: Bankruptcy in Europe
Tony Zaffuto
>I own a powdered metal parts fabrication business. In excess of 65% of parts I make go to primary automotive--gears, structural parts, etc. have about 35 production employees.
I am the sole owner of the business and supply to customers that have no loyalty to suppliers. Our competition is world wide. In the end, I am responsible for the continuation of my business.
What irks me is that Auriou knew in advance the cards he was dealt, yet he did nothing to prevent receivership. Closures do not happen overnight and usually show trends that are years in the making.