Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Workbench design III

Posts

Re: Workbench design III

#26

Re: wood choice and bench dogs...

ThomD


>As long as the hard wood is tough, glues well, takes screws well etc... There are a bunch of fragile corners in around dog holes. Finishes well.

Also, you are planing a lot of wooden screw holes and there are woods that tap and take threads better than others.

Woods also should be checked for shrinkage. Check the various species against each other.

Also, certain species are simply available in better quality stock. The straighter the stock the better

Re: Workbench design III

#27

Re: wood choice and bench dogs...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>I agree with Dave re. round dog holes. You get lots more flexibility, and I don't find any disadvantages over square dogs.

I would not use guatambu for the top. My base is glued up Guatambu plywood, and for that it works very well. But, I have found that the fibers of Guatambu are easily picked up off the surface. This makes it much easier to catch a tool or a piece of stock in a rough spot in the top and have it dig in, lifting more fiber. This is not a problem with sugar maple or with hornbeam. The wood I use that has the least of this problem is dogwood, Cornus florida, which is used for shuttles for looms. I offer this bit of trivia only to help you understand Guagambu's properties. No way anyone would build a bench top from dogwood, unless it was a very, very small bench.

Why not use European red beech, Fagus sylvatica? It should be readily available on your side of the pond, and relatively inexpensive. Sjobergs uses it in their better benches. I prefer hard maple, but I think beech would be better than Guatambu.

Re: Workbench design III

#28

Re: Less vises - more holes

ThomD


>The tucker flips to 90 degrees every day in my shop, and it has a jaw width of about 4-5 inches so you can swallow the whole board shown in the video in one gulp. Now you want to do a 16" wide blanket box side you are looking for something a little different in either case. But I can get most drawers nice and stable in the tucker. One thing though is while I thought that was a nice trick, I don't really think I would bother with it most of the time vertical works fine for me. Afterall, I'm mostly not using the bowsaw, and I really don't need to angle the piece with most dovetail saws.

Re: Workbench design III

#29

Re: wood choice and bench dogs...

ThomD


>"I agree with Dave re. round dog holes. You get lots more flexibility, and I don't find any disadvantages over square dogs."

Are you using square dogs? Can you list the flexibility?

Re: Workbench design III

#30

I hope this is okay to say

Tom Sontag - St. Louis


>Please don't misunderstand me. I suspect you will end up with an awesome bench that you will be proud to use, but my overall impression is that you are trying too hard to reinvent century old designs. The standard bench designs evolved for a reason. One twin screw on the end ought to be plenty; I would put it on as the end vise. Then if you want the Tucker and another face across from each other, fine. But you are going to put lots of effort into features that will not get used all that much if at all. Plus, vises can and do get in the way; there is a downside to so many chunks between you and the work.

I realize I am late in your iterations for you to embrace this philosophy completely, but I'll wager I am not the only one thinking this either. I know how this happens. You want this lifetime bench to be everything for you always. But remember some exquisite work gets done on Workmates. You are making a functional tool and time-proven designs are extremely functional already.

Simple has worked for so many years. Consider not complicating it so much.

Re: Workbench design III

#31

Re: I hope this is okay to say

Deirdre Saoirse Moen


>Tom, some very good points.

I'm using some folding plastic sawhorses to get quite a lot of work done these days, so yeah, a lot of work does get done on suboptimal surfaces. Weirdly, they're more stable than my current bench, but that's probably because I only put in one of the screws originally and now I can't find the others. :)

While I'm not cheap, I still cringe at the vice cost alone in Dirk's proposed bench, though, though it is better than before.

I have one vise. It's not enough, but I do manage to "make it work" (as Project Runway's Tim Gunn would say).

Re: Workbench design III

#32

Re: wood choice and bench dogs...

Tom MacGregor


>After working for many years in commercial and industrial maintenance on everything from 1930's era woodworking machines to computer powered lasers I've come to one major conclusion: The best tool is the simplest one that makes it easy to get the job done. I like my 3/4" dowel dogs and make custom ones for specific applications. I've added a few holes after using the bench for a year, and the skirt on the long sides of the perimeter can be removed if I ever choose to change, add or modify a vise.

Re: Workbench design III

#33

It's already done ...

Dirk Vogel


>Hi William, I'm sorry, but it's too late, I didn't read your comment about guatambu, and I bought it. I hope it won't work out as a big mistake ... Sugar marple was much more expensive.

I got shelves of 1 1/2" x 6"� 11". my benchtop is planned to be 3 1/2" strong. Do you think it's a good idea to take and glue the shelves horizontally, or should I turn them in a vertical position, cutting them at 3 1/2" ?

The structure under the benchtop is going to be made of hornbeam. Screws for the vises aill be made of pear. I'll use pear also as my fancy wood, it's quite dark :-)

Red beech would have been the wood of choice, but I liked the idea of a bright and a dark wood, and beech is in-between, so there's no big contrast. I really thought of Sugar marpel, but it's sold $ 70 a square foot ...

Re: Workbench design III

#34

Re: It's already done ...

ThomD


>That's a hard price for maple. It has been going up. I've got 100 acres of red oak and maple out there, but not much of my maple is all that nice. I pick it up salvage for about 2 bucks a foot.

Re: Workbench design III

#35

Re: Less vises - more holes

Joel


>I didn't know you had 4" of clear space in a tucker - that would work.

I think my tail vise can open to about 14-16" so I could do a carcass if I wanted.

Re: Workbench design III

#36

Egads!

Dave Thompson


>At $70 per square foot (?BF?), I think I should gather up a container and ship to Germany today and retire.

Mozambique ebony (blackwood), is cheaper here and harder. Though I suspect one would be losing things on the dark surface.

Re: Workbench design III

#37

Re: wood choice and bench dogs...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>Dave's already listed some of the advantages of round dogs in his post above, so I'll try to avoid rehashing those reasons. I do projects in my shop that are not traditional cabinetmaking. I build traditional furniture, too, and haven't missed not having square dogs. I do use my bench as a carver's bench, and also for gluing up bent laminations and other boat work. I find it convenient to be able to use the same holes for three vises, and to be able to use the same pack of dogs in other fixtures, including a workmutt (a custom B&D Workmate 400 with 8/4 "Swiss cheese" maple tops/jaws). I'm quite fond of Swiss cheese benchtops, as epitomized by the Veritas carving bench. In addition to spending less time cranking vise screws, I drop all sorts of tools (awls, burnishers, chisels, gouges, etc.) into them while I'm working. I find it very convenient to be able to use the same set of holes for holdfasts. I like the convenience of being able to make a dog from a piece of dowel wedged into a hole in a block of maple, and then being able to shape the gripping face of the block to a curve or with a bevel, so that I can grip something curved without damaging the curved surface. Each of these has four custom faces to work with before I have to look for another dog. These custom dogs never get lost by falling through the bench. In fact, I've never had that problem with a wonder pup, either. I use the same round dogs in my board jack as well. I stow the extra dogs in the board jack when they are not in use. I've never blown out a round dog hole in solid hardwood (hard maple or red oak), but I have done it with a wonder pup in termite barf, and thus try to discourage others from making tops from solid core doors and other unnatural materials, except as a stopgap measure. For any operation where rotation of the dog might be a problem, I use a planing stop between two dogs, or cut a custom face in a dog block. If a round dog is going to rotate, releasing the work, it wouldn't take much more to force the stock to slip off the corner of a square dog, and probably damage the dog in the process. Better to use a planing stop, I think.

Yes, other benches I work on at times have square dogs. My patternmaker's vise has square (well, really, rectangular) dogs too. I find myself using custom wooden jaw inserts for it with round dog holes much more often than the square dogs. I don't use the iron dogs that came with the patternmaker's vise. I made wooden dogs to fit, and instead of the leaf spring, I equipped them with bullet catches. These bullet catches even work with round dowel dogs, and are quicker to fabricate than a traditional square dog with a wooden spring.

If you are using poppets, foexample for shaping cabriolet legs, or for a springpole lathe, square dog holes are essential, but I use other methods to do these tasks.

Re: Workbench design III

#38

Of course it is, Tom and Deirdre

Dirk Vogel


>Hi ! Thank you for your comments. I'm not misunderstanding you; your arguments have yet been posted by many worried woodworkers here, so I'm used to them :-)

"My overall impression is that you are trying too hard to reinvent century old designs."

I did this four weeks ago, look here :

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl?noframes;read=92471

You must admit that compared with what I planned then, my projects have become quite modest now. The bench is really very classic; I agree that a tailvise declined in three parts is inusual, but I don't trust a simple double screw vise (model : Verita's twin vise ) any more since I'm going to build it with wooden screws.

"You want this lifetime bench to be everything for you always."

After six weeks of planning and discussion, I'm not so sure of that any more. An ideal workbench would be height-adjustable (I didn't find an elegant way to build that only with wood), resizeable (it'd lack of stability if you tried to build this), plane for eternity, and it would dissolve into thin air when you don't need it. ;-) As my tamed project won't held any of those features, it's only an interim solution.

"Vises can and do get in the way; there is a downside to so many chunks between you and the work."

That's the reason because I put away vises where I could : my double screw vise has become an accessory, the Tucker is protuding less than normally the way I planned it, and don't tell me a twin end vise takes more space away than my three vises ... With that kind of solution, you have to stay next to your bench, working laterally, because the two handles of a twin vise get in your way anyway.

"Consider not complicating it so much."

There are reasons for that complexity ... If you're curious, look here :

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl?noframes;read=92477

"While I'm not cheap, I still cringe at the vice cost alone in Dirk's proposed bench."

Well, I agree that this sort of bench's cost is way beyond what other people would want to spend. I'm willing to pay the price because I consider the bench yet as a composition, not only as an instrument.

"I have one vise. It's not enough, but I do manage to "make it work"."

Perfect ! I never thought my bench is the only way to happiness. But I'm sure I wouldn't be that glad with your solution, knowing of other working possibilities :-)

Thanks again and bye :-)

Re: Workbench design III

#39

Square foot = cube foot

Dirk Vogel


>Hi, there was an error on my last posting ;-) I wrote something about square foot, but I meant cube foot (a volume, that is). How is wood priced in USA anyway ? That is to say, what volume unit do you use in these occasions ?

Re: Workbench design III

#40

Re: Square foot = cube foot

Dave Thompson


>Ah, ok. BF (Board Foot) 12"x12"x1". In other words, one board foot = cube foot/12

Re: Workbench design III

#41

curious digression....hornbeam price?

Dave Thompson


>While on this topic. I'm curious about the hornbeam you were looking into. Is that easy to find in Germany/Europe? How much does this sell for in Germany?

In North America, we have american hop hornbeam (also locally called ironwood). It is not an easy wood to find. At least I haven't seen it sold commercially. The trees grow to a max diameter of 10". I made some effort to acquire and mill one of these trees myself since I didn't think I could easily find a seller. I have no idea what this wood might sell for in the US.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Workbench design III

#42

Re: Square foot = cube foot

ThomD


>At that rate 70 bucks is pretty good.

A far as the lamination is concerned,you need to check the grain orientation. If it is quarter sawn, then you could laminate it flat and joint up the boards for width, so you will see a full width of 9 inches on the top. If it is falt sawn you probably need to do them so from the top you see 1.5 inch strips. Either way, orient the grain so you can plane the top, from the tail vise, and not get any tear out or at least the minimum.

Re: Workbench design III

#43

Re: Less vises - more holes

ThomD


>Your tail vise rules!

Re: Workbench design III

#44

Re: I hope this is okay to say

Paul M. in San Diego


>Hi Dirk,

I agree with the people above about the large number of vises on this bench. I'm pretty sure that the extremely close spacing between the three screws on the right side of the bench will cause you much cursing over the years.

When I operate a vise, the handle is never balanced in the middle of the nut as shown in your diagrams. It is always at the end of it's extension so that there is leverage at the end of the handle. But with so many screws on this bench, I think that you will frequently wind up whacking your hand on the adjacent handle when it is also extended to one side.

Please think about the vise operations when the adjacent vises have their handles extending to one side.

-- Paul M.

Re: Workbench design III

#45

Hornbeam price

Dirk Vogel


>I payed $ 1,75 for 1 BF Hornbeam. It's not that easy to find in Germany, too ...

Re: Workbench design III

#46

Re: curious digression....hornbeam price?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>There is a difference between hornbeam and hophornbeam. Tom L-N uses the latter, a much tougher wood, for his chisel handles, but he notes that there are no commercial sources for it. I guess that means he sends Paul Bunyon out into the North Woods to harvest it for him. Also, it would take a whole lot of labor, and glue, to make a bench top out of it. The performance of said benchtop might just be worth the effort.

I'm not knocking hornbeam. If you have access to it, it would make a fine bench top, if the numbers published by the USDA FPL are any indication.

Hophornbeam and hornbeam are closely related, but are in different genera. Eastern Hophornbeam is Ostrya virginiana. There are several species of hornbeam. The only native New World species is American Hornbeam, Carpinus caroliniana. There are several species of Old World hornbeams. The species most probably available to Dirk, which is also planted in the U.S., is European Hornbeam, C. betulus.

None of hornbeams likes to grow straight and tall, and thus, extracting straight grained lumber of substantial size (enough for a massive, easily maintained workbench) can be a problematical.

The bench builder needs to make compromises between durability and stability, local availability, the value of his labor, and local cost per bf (or cc).

Re: Workbench design III

#47

Re: curious digression....hop-hornbeam info?

Dave Thompson


> If you have access to it, it would make a fine bench top, if the numbers published by the USDA FPL are any indication.

William, It sounds like you may have access to the info I've been seeking this past month, specifically hardness values on american hop hornbeam (ostrya virginiana).

I recently picked up USDA Forrest Product Lab's book "Wood Handbook: Wood as an engineering material" 1974 edition. While it goes into ridiculous details of more things than I ever need to know about wood, such as dielectric constants of woods, the effects of beta and gamma radiation on wood, and covers many north american and importated species, it doesn't say anything about hophornbeam. Could you post the name of your reference?

BTW, my "Trees of the Northern United States and Canada" identification book mentions there are 8 Ostyra species, 3 native to north america, hop hornbeam included.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Workbench design III

#48

thanks

Dave Thompson

Re: Workbench design III

#49

Re: curious digression....hop-hornbeam info?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>I'm going to have to redo the research. The specific values I have found for some of the species that are not commercially significant, like hophornbeam, were probably not published in FPL-GTR-113, nor in Hoadley's Understanding Wood. However, the concepts and explanations presented in these publications are necessary to understand what the numbers published elsewhere mean, whether you are building a carving mallet, a carpenter's mallet, a chisel handle, an axe handle, a baseball bat or a roof truss. Some of the parameters presented are much more esoteric, and I also have not figured out what applicability they might have to what I want to do with the wood.

I'll get back to you if I can find (but not tonight) the source for numbers that seemed to me at the time to be most applicable to tools useful for bashing steel cutting edges into wood.

Re: Workbench design III

#50

grain orientation

Dirk Vogel


>Ok, I'll check that, but I'd be very surprised if that wood was cut otherwise than flatsawn ... It's ununderstandable, but that's the only way you can buy wood here in Germany : flatsawn. No quatersawn wood, let's forget about riftsawn wood ... :-(