Of course it is, Tom and Deirdre
Dirk Vogel
>Hi ! Thank you for your comments. I'm not misunderstanding you; your arguments have yet been posted by many worried woodworkers here, so I'm used to them :-)
"My overall impression is that you are trying too hard to reinvent century old designs."
I did this four weeks ago, look here :
http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl?noframes;read=92471
You must admit that compared with what I planned then, my projects have become quite modest now. The bench is really very classic; I agree that a tailvise declined in three parts is inusual, but I don't trust a simple double screw vise (model : Verita's twin vise ) any more since I'm going to build it with wooden screws.
"You want this lifetime bench to be everything for you always."
After six weeks of planning and discussion, I'm not so sure of that any more. An ideal workbench would be height-adjustable (I didn't find an elegant way to build that only with wood), resizeable (it'd lack of stability if you tried to build this), plane for eternity, and it would dissolve into thin air when you don't need it. ;-) As my tamed project won't held any of those features, it's only an interim solution.
"Vises can and do get in the way; there is a downside to so many chunks between you and the work."
That's the reason because I put away vises where I could : my double screw vise has become an accessory, the Tucker is protuding less than normally the way I planned it, and don't tell me a twin end vise takes more space away than my three vises ... With that kind of solution, you have to stay next to your bench, working laterally, because the two handles of a twin vise get in your way anyway.
"Consider not complicating it so much."
There are reasons for that complexity ... If you're curious, look here :
http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/handtools.pl?noframes;read=92477
"While I'm not cheap, I still cringe at the vice cost alone in Dirk's proposed bench."
Well, I agree that this sort of bench's cost is way beyond what other people would want to spend. I'm willing to pay the price because I consider the bench yet as a composition, not only as an instrument.
"I have one vise. It's not enough, but I do manage to "make it work"."
Perfect ! I never thought my bench is the only way to happiness. But I'm sure I wouldn't be that glad with your solution, knowing of other working possibilities :-)
Thanks again and bye :-)