Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

Posts

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#26

Yeah, I know ... you say potatoe, I say ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#27

Re: agree on maple

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>I don't know why our experience with maple is so markedly different. I find hard maple to be trecherous. The grain may change half a dozen times in an eight foot board while the next one planes as smooth as glass with no problem. I find tear out with maple to be a problem.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#28

Re: Um, I was teasing

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Hand machining or manual machining is now often used opposite of a CAM operation.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#29

A worthy idea.

bill tindall

>"Ellis should be getting a cut too for hosting the add.... " A worthy idea.

I love reading these things. It is encouraging to hear that a plane costing 10X more than another not only looks more pretty but actually does a bit better.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#30

Re: In reply ..

Dave Thompson

>My chief beef, is seeing LN getting trashed on what appears to me, implausible speculative slander. I don't buy an imposed short time limit for a review as an acceptable excuse, especially when these glossy reviews end up archived for years to come along side non-commercially motivated articles and reviews. LN's higher standard of products have done alot for the neander world, and their relationship with customers is a customer's ideal. It does a disservice to the community and LN to get it wrong. Likewise, if you get that blade hardness tested and find out that there was a quality issue, kudos to you. The community is well served by hearing about it.

FWIW, I have no relationship with LN other than a few years back, I was a happy paying customer.

Dave

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#31

What I don't get is

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>No time to wait for the replacement blade as the owner who hasn't used the plane in a coon's age needs it back right away. But their is time to review it against the Veritas.

Sounds fishy to me.

Curious to know how the LV vs LN review goes. Heck why not throw the Marcoux infill plane in the mix as well.

Cheers

Dan

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#32

Re: What I don't get is

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>No time to wait for the replacement blade as the owner who hasn't used the plane in a coon's age needs it back right away. But their is time to review it against the Veritas.

Dan, don't be so quick to criticise what you do not know enough about. You seem to have a knack for this.

As it happened, if you read what I wrote earlier, I convinced the owner to let me hold onto the LN. Now I am waiting for LN to send the new iron.

Enough. I shall not be party to any more of your childishness. I shall be happy to respond if and when you have something of value to offer.

Derek

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#33

Another comment, perhaps more to the point

woodburnbob

>The review of the Marcou plane has the form of an authoritative, comprehensive, professional, comparative review. Various things tend to raise questions about whether this is so for the substance of the review. I guess that's what you're getting from some forum members right now, myself included.

In following the responses in this present thread we're in now, I spent some time looking at the links to your earlier thread that began with this:


Seeing it the first time it appeared, I thought: If someone using hand planes has never seen this configuration before and not yet found a way to understand it's meaning, either they haven't used many hand planes or they aren't too logically minded. Now I'd add: ...neither of which would be a great credential from which to formulate handplane reviews.

What else could it mean but that the cutting edge isn't straight? I see you eventually discovered how the cutting edge had become curved but still perseverated on the idea of a "soft spot".

One must be vigilant that one's credibility does not develop soft spots due to accelerated ripening.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#34

Re: In reply ..

Michael Brady

>Derek, I don't know you well enough to judge your motives, and I certainly cannot argue with the thoroughness of your process. What is apparent to me is a bias shows through in the context of what you call a "review". I would admit that if someone sent me an LV or Marcou plane and said "keep it for your trouble", I would undoubtedly harbor some warm fuzzy feelings about those items. Unfortunately your enthusiasm for the very fine L-V product line has apparently established it as your standard by which all others are to be measured. Quite frankly, I think we both have a good idea of the result of your upcoming comparison of LVBU vs. LN 4-1/2 smoothers.....and that predictibility is the apparent flaw that has provoked some reaction to your considerable efforts.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#35

Yeah, that puzzled me, too.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#36

OT - don't get me started on THAT

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>When my son inherited his great-uncle's (pre-WWII) metal lathe, he took some intro to machine tools classes at the local community college, and found that the instructors couldn't help him with how to use it. Now, I understand that modern community college classes of this nature must focus on the skills needed in industry, but I was kind of depressed to learn that the instructors didn't know how to use the tools their parents (or maybe grandparents, but I think the instructors were closer to my age than my son's) had used.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#37

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>I thought about posting this elsewhere, but it's going to be inflammatory enough without being directly pointing at any particular person.

First, let me say...

�Thanks� to Derek for taking your time and doing a very nice and fact filled review. It�s too bad that �teaching pigs to sing wastes your time and annoys the pig too.�

Derek, please realize that some of us are NOT pigs and we *can* learn to sing. Please continue the singing lessons, not for the pigs, but for those of us that aren�t.

Next, for the pigs. (Yes, I know, more singing lessons, but hey, I�m willing to waste my time - and if it annoys you, so much the better...)

Do know what someone�s time is worth?

Kind of sad you have such critical and IMO demeaning things to say about reviewers who spend an amount of time that would likely pay for the item they were given. Get that. That $2000 NZ plane could be free given the time writing the review.

Perhaps you're a day laborer earning say, $10 US an hour. No dishonor in that. But in fact, the value of someone's time is no trivial matter.

Personally, I've come to realize the value of MY time more greatly in recent times. Every hour I spend offering advice here or in any of my other "charitable" endeavors means I forgo a very significant sum of money.

In short, for any reasonably paid expert, every hour is easily in excess of $100 lost. (Easily! It could fairly easily be more than $250 US)

Throw in the cost of a hand-plane, and the costs easily get very, very large, when you consider the value of the person�s time AND the cost of buying the hand plane.

Are you willing to pitch in to pay Derek, the say, $100 to read his review? Because to make it worth his time to do it, one wants unlimited time and access to the reviewed material. Time getting it, arranging to ship it back, paying for shipping etc, and doing it all on a timeline is even more expensive.

So, you need to compensate Derek for his buying the plane, gathering the materials, doing the review, taking and editing the pictures (how about the cost of a decent digital camera too) editing the written work, and hosting and producing the web-page too. You'd probably want to pay his two friends for their opinions also.

Fair price for that? $4000 US, perhaps more. Divide that over a few people and $100 a piece doesn�t seem at all unreasonable.

But rather than offering to pay him $100 a piece for the privilege of reading a �unbiased� review, (Which is a completely bogus argument in itself, but I don�t plan to waste even more time going there in any depth...) you all complain and whine worse than a ill-behaved 4 year old.

If you don�t like Derek, or his reviews that he does for us for FREE, fine... simply SHUT-UP and leave it be.

If you�re jealous that he gets some goodies for what you consider free, than go suck up to Mr Lee, Mr Lie-Nielsen, Carl Holtey, or Philip Marcou. When you�ve offered them enough value for them to send you tools for �free� then you�re in.

If you�re so ill-informed that you believe they give out freebies simply to have people like Derek �sell� them here, then frankly you�re so ill-informed that neither I, nor anyone else will be able to help you. (Especially when as Derek�s review says... "It's a wonderfully made plane, but the LV BUS works damn near as well for a quarter the price". [as so wonderfully pointed out by Paul.])

Frankly, I like Derek�s reviews. I find lots of good substance and I think it�s not only impolite to kick sand in his face, but I think you ought to be ashamed of yourselves - not that I think you�ll actually be ashamed.

When you�re each valued for your input and feedback, when you do exhaustive reviews and pay for the materials and such yourself and do what he does - you know what, you�ll probably be getting freebies too. Then you can have the �oh so lovely� experience of having a bunch of louts attack you personally too. (Whooho! Where do I sign up. �Ah, yes, right next to the line for getting your fingers smashed by the lout with the hammer... Hmmmm. Now I just can�t decide - lout with the hammer, or the louts with the bad attitude...�)

In the mean time, I won�t be holding my breath.

Cheers,

Greg

I've donned the asbestos suit and the super protective glasses. Have at it - you have a long ways to go to top Jonathon - so it's nothing I've not experiennced before.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#38

Re: Well Said!

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>Greg,

Maybe a little stronger than I would have put it, but the points are all valid. I am another who is very appreciative of Derek's efforts.

Thanks,

Ted

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#39

Re: Another comment, perhaps more to the point *LINK*

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Here is a response Derek wrote awhile back on the UKWorkshop when somone posted a problem with their LA plane only cutting on one side of the mouth.

Posted: Thu Nov 17, 2005 3:47 pm Post subject:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hi Tom

I have used several bevel up LV planes and have only experienced this on one plane. Has this ever been published in any of his reviews? Cause I would think people should know how to solve this problem whether it happens on a LN, Holtey, Marcoux or LV

Link is included below

Here is Derek's response:

---------------------------------------------------------------------

In my sample, the mouth was out of square by about 0.5mm. I checked the blade for squareness - nope, that was not the problem. Finally I decided that the bed was ever-so-slightly out of square, and decided to fettle this myself. It took about one hour of careful, slow filing, but the end result was a perfectly square bevel-mouth relationship.

It is really quite a simple matter - determine which side of the bed needs to be lowered, then paint the whole bed in Engineers Blue (or scribble with a pencil) to keep track of what you are doing. Then just file carefully, making sure that once you take the one side down, that you file across the bed to level it off. Keep reapplying the Blue. File a little. Test the fit. File a little more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

---------------------------------------------------------------------

This is the same Derek isn't it?


Filing a LA Blade Bed

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#40

Is this a spoof, or are you serious?

woodburnbob

>I have to ask because at one level your post reads like grand satire. Sort of a comically hysterical rant against the Philistines among us. If it is a not-so-gentle parody, my congratulations to you on your creativity and literary voice.

If you're serious, I must blush and wonder if I'm now to be counted among some new porcine friends. In fact, I'm uncertain whether I should busy a defense, or sit back and amuse myself watching a barnyard allegory unfold.

Did you mean I was a pig? Or, did you mean someone else?

For the sake of argument, let's say I am a pig and a lout, as you term it. A lout's an oaf, an awkward and stupid person. I think of louts as big oafs, often with a British accent. But that's beside the point, I suppose.

Incidentally, I did enjoy the pig metaphor and don't take offense. I take it that the metaphor is from a proverb you know on the topic of the futility of misguided action. I guess it assumes a human singing instructor with silly beliefs about pigs, one who comes to learn that wishing something to happen cannot overcome the limits of reality.

I understand what you are saying, but at a somewhat more earthy level. It makes me think of my father, who often said, "You can't make bread out of horse shit". Or, "you can't put a $3 dollar haircut on a two-bit head." Dad was a barber, and he knew a good deal about horse shit.

God, I hope no one cuts out your post or mine. This really is fun. You're wrong about pigs being taught to sing, it doesn't annoy me in the least.

Anyway, you seem to stress 3 main arguments:

1. A person's time has monetary value: I understand your idea that we measure the time consumed, then multiple by an hourly rate, then add the overhead, and thus arrive at what something costs. It's a business model for invoicing. Surely, you don't think it is meant to apply to hobbies, avocations, passtimes, sleeping, making love. The idea is silly.

As to the idea that "the value of someone's time is no trivial matter". You're kidding? A person's time and existence is the most trivial matter in the universe. Ask me again in 100 years.

2. The idea that discussions must be polar. You say, "If you don�t like Derek, or his reviews that he does for us for FREE, fine... simply SHUT-UP and leave it be." Silence is ascent. Your prescription terminates my right of peaceable dissent. Liberty trumps obedience and conformity.

I don't have anything against you or Derek Cohen. Why must I be quiet if I'm civilized and reasonably respectful?

3. The idea that I'm (we're) stewing in jealousy and lust for "goodies" and "freebies". It is an opinion you are free to hold. Reasonable men will make reasonable judgments on the merits of the accusation. None of us can expect more.

One of the really interesting things to me about posting in forums is that what one writes in the heat of passion doesn't die with it. What we write to cyberspace is potentially immortal. That's a precarious price, wouldn't you say.

Oh, I almost forgot. Who's Jonathan? Sounds like there's another entertaining thread out there I've missed.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#41

Re: Is this a spoof, or are you serious?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>As to the idea that "the value of someone's time is no trivial matter". You're kidding? A person's time and existence is the most trivial matter in the universe. Ask me again in 100 years.

But it's all any individual has, therefore it's the most vital thing a person must conserve.

Bob, it appears this group has split into two vocal camps (there are a lot more than two groups, but most are relatively silent): one that likes LV bevel up planes and one that likes LN bench planes [edited]. For some reason, perhaps convenience, the LN lovers have used any reviews by the LV bu lovers as having been tainted by virtue of the reviewers getting free tools (I use the term advisably, nothing really free about them based on the length and quality of the reviews). And often this process has also cast dispersions on LV. All seems somewhat like our ridiculous political dialog to me, on the order of "you disagree with me, therefore you're no patriot;" so whenever I see one of Derek's reviews I cringe for what inevitably follows.

All I know is that I bore myself repeating things I've said multiple times, to the extent that I seldom comment anymore on several topics. So now there's a new group of Derek disparagers; but you're saying the same things, at least outside the LV vs LN debate for the most part. And I don't know what your point is? Derek posted a very well done review in which he stated that he got tools for free for doing the reviews. What's your alternative? That he not do any reviews? That he do them totally for free? Or, what do you want?

I know that I read all tool reviews with care to read between the lines for various biases. I would assume that all adults can do the same.

Pam

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#42

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed

Skip in Falls Church

>Personally, I enjoy Derek's reviews. I sincerely hope he continues to do them. OTOH when it comes to reviews I tend to fall back on my scientific training - chemistry and masochistic enough (in some people's view) to have an undergraduate and graduate degree in the field.

IMO every review is a data point to be added to the bank of information. I treat every review as biased as *every* review is. (Not to mention everyone that criticizes a review.) The real questions are IMO: Is the reviewer aware of his bias and is the procedure used for testing as objective as it can be to accomplish the aims set out in the review. Of course there is a third question and that would be whether the review is fraudulant.

It seems to me that woodworking is very subjective and it is difficult to bend it to scientific standards - I think Lyn is the best person I've seen for doing this. But I think Derek does try for Lyn's standards. From what I've seen of Derek's posts on this board it seems to me that he's relatively experienced and not really inclined to a beginner's mistake - although I'm sure we all make them from time to time. (Of course I'd never admit to one unless caught in the middle of one. :) ) It seems to me that his procedures are designed to accomplish the aims set forth in his reviews. IMO they are certainly not fraudulant.

However, it seems that Derek's reviews are received less kindly than Lyn's. I suspect the reason is that Lyn wrote things more like a scientific report. In scientific writing you're taught to edit out subjective assesments like "Great!" and replace them with a more objective assesment like "x performs at y% of optimal". I suspect that the more subjective assesments that Derek makes irks a few people.

When met with a subjective assessment I tend to disregard it reflexively and look at the procedures used and the results produced. And I'd never rely on a single review to run out and make a major purchase. Personally I've never met a plane I didn't like - even the cheap, crappy ones, :)

Putting soap box up

Skip

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#43

In support of ALL reviews and reviewers

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Circumstances and heritage push me to being a bottom feeder so its highly ulikely I'll ever own any of the wonderful tools reviewed on this forum and others. Once, (an only once) I succumbed to buying a new tool because of a series of useful reviews. Nevertheless, I love reading tool reviews. They provide hours of entertainment, fuel my dreams and aspirations, and also provide occasional nuggets of valuable information applicable to my own tool usage.

So it is very disheartening to see some of the comments made about reviewers' motives. I fear that if enough vitriol is thrown, the reviewers - not just Derek - may decide that their effort just isn't worth the cost. As Pam and others have pointed out, all reviews vcarry a degree of bias. Honest reviewers are carefull to provide anough information that their readers can assess whatever bias exists and read the review in that context.

Many readers of Derek's reviews are well aware that he is a fan of BU planes - he has not been shy about that bias. And Derek has been quite honest in stating that he kept the Marcou S15/BU smoother that he reviewed and didn't pay money for it. But what has the Marcou S15/BU smoother cost Derek? Other than the time involved in the review, it seems that some people have decided that the cost to Derek of this particular plane should be his reputation. That is a very big cost indeed.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#44

You got it Skip

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Skip wrote

---------------------------------------------------------------------

However, it seems that Derek's reviews are received less kindly than Lyn's. I suspect the reason is that Lyn wrote things more like a scientific report. In scientific writing you're taught to edit out subjective assesments like "Great!" and replace them with a more objective assesment like "x performs at y% of optimal". I suspect that the more subjective assesments that Derek makes irks a few people.

---------------------------------------------------------------------

WHat I liked about Lyn's evaluations were that he compared modern day planes to modern day planes. His review of the LV BU smoother (the original review) went head to head with the LN. Lyn's review with the LV #6 went head to head with the LN.

Derek's reviews tend to compare a LV plane to an old Stanley. I know Derek owns a Bedrock 604 with a LN blade and improved chipbreaker and he owns a 50 degree infill plane he built from scratch. Both of these planes he rated higher in his early reviews when compared to the Bailey.

Personally, I have owned a BU plane from the days before LV ever made one and I have had my hands on more LV BU planes then I have LN planes as I live close to 2 LV stores and several of my friends own the LV planes. My opinions are based on my experience.

Dan Clermont (who had a wonderful bike ride home while splashing through puddles and singing in the rain)

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#45

Decommercialization

woodburnbob

>Primarily, I object to the commercialization of the handtool forum. Does anyone really doubt that when a Marcou or anyone else gives someone a tool in exchange for having a "review" written and posted on this forum, that that is not part of a thinly veiled marketing operation. There seems to be no end to the insidious fungus of advertising.

I am aware that many who post to the forum are hot to see all the latest commercial offerings from whatever source, in whatever form. I suppose I had this vague idea that a few voices of dissent might tap the like-minded but silent masses and cause this stuff to be redirected to the classified section or some new section dedicated to various commercial announcements and customer support. Alas, maybe there are no like-minded out there. Maybe it's just me. What a strange and frightening thought.

I think that's about it from me on this topic. I'm going to spend the rest of the night on my superannuation fantasies.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#46

Re: Decommercialization

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Maybe that is what this forum needs is a seperate board on tool reviews

I like the idea.

I spend allot of time analyzing and playing with tools of all sorts. Last month I dragged home a Dewalt planer and compared it to my Delta planer.

This month I have an Adria dovetail saw and am comparing it to the LN I own and my Tom Law shaprened Sorby dovetail saw.

I refuse to post a formal review on them but will give my honeset opinion when others ask questions as to what the differences are. I paid for all of my saws

Also dragged home a Shapton 1000 grit stone and am comparing it to my Norton 1000 grit stone which is pretty much done

Dan Clermont

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#47

Re: Decommercialization

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Hmmm, I'd vote for a decommercialization of the whole dang society, but that's not going to happen. And the whole top edge of these pages are covered with ads. That's just the way it is.

That said, I don't find any tool reviews here particularly commercialized. They're very carefully done, there are no pitches, I don't think they even tell you where to buy.

Pam

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#48

Re: Decommercialization

Mark Nowicki

>You are not alone.

Regards and thank you

Mark Nowicki

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#49

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed

Michael Brady

>That's cool, Greg. Everyone is entitled to a good defense. Your point about the time this gentleman devotes to his articles (I hesitate to use the word "reviews") is significant and he does a good job. I think his intentions are good, as well. My problem with his approach is that he expects to be paid by the maker of the product he reviews. If he deserves, as you claim, to be worthy of compensation; then he should find someone other than tool manufacturers to back him. My personal feeling...just my opinion...is that his motives seem self-serving and a way to get freebee tools while expressing his subjective feelings.

despite what you claim, I believe that only one well-known manufacturer is consistently providing him with free tools. It is the same manufacturer that he invariably finds as superior in his comparitive reviews.

This is what I suggest as a rememdy: Anyone who is paid in cash or in kind by a manufacturer for an article in this forum about one of their tools should be prevented from making comparisons with other, non-sponsored tools. You can call this a review if you want, but real reviewers would never compromise their credibility by letting their subject pay them. My other problem in this particular situation is that the gentleman is a self-annointed expert on the subject of hand-tools. He hits every forum with his articles as if the woodworking world was waiting breathlessly for his opinion. These forums are a great place to air opinions, just as I am doing; but the this type of clandestine commercialism is something that this and other forums need to take a closer look at. This would be somewhat in the vein of the many forums that have disallowed any links to auctions or clasifieds in their forum posts.

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed *LINK*

#50

Re: The Marcou S15/BU Smoother - Reviewed

Paul Erickson

>Hi Derek,

Do the Marcou and LV use the same pitch thread in their Norris adjusters, or is one finer than the other?

cheers, Paul