Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

woodworking for women magazine

Posts

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#26

Re: woodworking for women magazine

Ted Owen, Moderator

>I have just deleted a post baiting the group for a donnybrook. So please be careful with this sensitive thread.

Best, Ted

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#27

Re: Oh Goodie

ThomD

>Fair enough, but I don't care if more people woodwork. Everyone is welcome. It's one thing to descriminate against people who want to enter an activity, but why encourage it. I've been first in the pool on a whole bunch of sports, and not much good came with the entry of the masses. I don't think that woodworking has had it's "River Runs Through It" moment yet, and I hope it doesn't. Just heard today that cycling is the new Golf, oh Goodie!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#28

David Barnett

Science bears Adam out. We hunt. They pick. *LINK*

David Barnett

>Imaging processing in males evolved differently from women and significantly so. Males are generally better scanning at distance, directional orientation, are fascinated with trajectories and better able to hit moving targets. This does NOT mean that there are not plenty of women who can kick our butts at skeet and trap, but 'generally' speaking, men test better at these things. Men tend to filter extraneous* 'noise', both aural and visual, often prefer less complex 'natural' palettes, and I inuitively agree with Adam on style preferences (Bauhaus over dollhouse), but I can't back it up.

Women, on the other hand, test slightly better at remembering conversations verbatim and can better recall seating adjacancies at social gatherings. Women are gatherers and sharp at noticing localized differences so are less apt to munch the oleander. They can find Waldo, especially if Waldo's a berry or a tick. Men are better at finding Waldo through a riflescope. Women are much more responsive to paedomorphism and facial neoteny; large head to body ratio, high forheads, large eyes -- in other words 'cute' stimuli, i.e. babies, although men respond, too. Just not so much, perhaps. Women are better at recognizing subleties in facial expressions, which gives them an edge when the rug rat is feeling puny.

How do these differences relate to woodworking? Well, I've noticed more painted furniture from women artisans and less rigidity in historical mimesis and purism. At least I think I do. In general.

_____________________________

*There, of course, may be broad differences of opinion as to what constitutes 'extraneous'.

http://www.sciam.com/print_version.cfm?articleID=000363E3-1806-1264-980683414B7F0000

http://www.edge.org/documents/archive/edge158.html

http://pinker.wjh.harvard.edu/articles/media/2005_02_14_newrepublic.html

_____________________________


Neotenic stimuli

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#29

Re: Science bears Adam out. We hunt. They pick.

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I of course must present the other generally accepted view of why men and women are different, which is now being referred to as "Intelligent Design". You can read about it in the book of Genesis in the Bible. It's very simple; Adam was created in the image of God, and Eve was created as a companion for him. The two were meant to work together as different but equal members of a team. This is why women are different from men.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#30

David Barnett

Oh, it may have started simple enough,...

David Barnett

>but somewhere down the line things must've got a whole lot more complicated. Still, as far as women go, I'd have to agree that's one intelligent design, all right. Sure as heck works for me!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#31

funny that you should mention cycling...

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>i've had at least three colleagues seriously injured while cycling: one got mugged and ended up with a broken hip, another fell off and separated his shoulder joint and the most recent casualty fell off and injured his back so badly that he can't even walk properly right now!!! i think i'll stick with woodworking which is just SO MUCH safer! ;)

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#32

here, here moses!!!

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>when all else fails go back to THE instruction manual!!! my wife compliments me so PERFECTLY that it's almost scary!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#33

definition

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>An uproar; a free-for-all. Named after Donnybrook fair, held annually in Donnybrook, a suburb of Dublin, Ireland, and noted for its brawls

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#34

Re: One more thing about women

Sgian Dubh

>Adam, the furniture design and making courses that we run at the college of art and design where I work attract a significant minority of young(er) women seeking to make a career in the business after they qualify with a Foundation Degree (FD) in Furniture or BA in Furniture.

Of the thirteen students on the first year of the FD in Furniture three are women, about 23%. I'm not sure what the percentage is on the BA course, but again it's a significant minority, probably about the same.

All students study the same subjects and must fulfil exactly the same requirements to achieve successful pass rates. I don't see much difference between the two groups regarding their interests in the decorative and aesthetic requirements of design in general and furniture in particular. The technical abilities of men and women are only separated by the ability of a specific student, and gender(in my experience) has nothing to do with ability.

I find it of some concern that you allocate to men and women separate and distinct roles, interests and abilities as you do. Slainte.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#35

Really? Surprising...

BarbS, Wenatchee WA

>I'm glad you brought attention to this, because when that magazine first came out, it was heavily criticized over on WomenInWoodworking.com as being far too simplistic, craft-ish (heart cut-outs and tissue box covers or something) and not worthy of its title. I'll have to take a look at a more recent issue; maybe they heard us wailing over there and upgraded their projects. Not offensive at all...thanks for the heads up.

I'm a little confused about someone here finding gallery entries on their website. I found none. Are you sure you weren't over on WomenInWoodworking, which has a beautiful gallery section? Just curious.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#36

Ooh...that's interesting

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>As an old History major, I love that sort of thing, Frank. Thanks.

Best, Ted

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#37

at LAST!!!

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>barb, so glad to hear a female voice on this thread! BTW you were correct about the web site. i had mistaken the woodworkingforwomen.com website as the one for the magazine - what a serious mistake! there is no such gallery on the magazine web site. i was just impressed when i looked in the last few issues and noticed fairly complicated joinery methods like frame and panels as well as half laps, dovetails and the like in addition to the simplistic, craftish projects that you mentioned (mostly scroll saw projects).

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#38

Re: funny that you should mention cycling...

Steve knight

>far safer then being a couch potato or driving a car.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#39

Re: at LAST!!!

Alice Frampton, UK

>so glad to hear a female voice on this thread!

Tha majority of you were doing so well with the sweeping opinons on gender, I didn't like to interrupt... ;~) Richard (Sgain Dubh) made about the only sensible comment in the thread:

I find it of some concern that you allocate to men and women separate and distinct roles, interests and abilities as you do

Get a grip, guys. If you treat people as individuals, not as sterotypes, we'll get those perceived barriers down much more quickly.

Cheers, Alf

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#40

Alice is right, but...

BarbS, Wenatchee WA

>Hi Alice...I always thoroughly enjoy reading your posts, and have learned a lot from you here and on your website. I honestly don't think you and I are representative of our gender as a whole. We're in a very (superior, of course) small minority. Personally, I've found most women who get into woodworking are near my age, with children grown and gone, or without children at all, and they're wanting to do something creative with their own two hands. We mature 'boomers' just aren't content to sit around and wait to bake cookies any more, that's all. I'm glad Sgian is seeing women students equally skilled to the men. He's in a better position to judge both, as he's taught for years. Our guys here on WoodCentral have always been extremely polite and supportive, and I think for both sexes, it matters more what Attitude we bring to the quest, than what our gender is. Just a personal two cents...I'd rather be judged by my work than by reams and reams of protestations and grievances. The guys will joke around, but whenever I need advice, they always step up most helpfully.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#41

Gotta be a first time...

Alice Frampton, UK

>I honestly don't think you and I are representative of our gender as a whole.

Barb, that's my point. Who is? Which is what makes the whole thing so silly. If I gave the impression I'm offended, I assure you I'm not - just amused. I know the folks on here have a heap more sense when it comes to woodworking, which is the important thing :~)

Cheers, Alf

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#42

Re: at LAST!!!

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Don't know, Alf, sure sounds like a donneybrook to me.

Pam

PS I agree, Richard seems to be the only adult male in this thread.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#43

Donnybrook

Alice Frampton, UK

>Well entirely unintentionally, if I was. Perhaps I needed more than one winking smilie...

Now put away your spoon and stop stirring, Pam. You'll get me in trouble :~)

Cheers, Alf

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#44

I'm proved right

Todd Hughes

>Well I don't know how my response that in my consedable experance selling tools that women make up a very small percentage of wood working tool buyers [and from that it could be construed do very little wood working] couldn be consedered as anything but "sensable" as well. Might not be what some people want to hear or like [hey better believe no one more then ME would like more women to buy wood working tools!] but I can assure you it is very true.

I think this thread is a perfect example of how large the women wood working market really is. Over 300 people read the the first post and only 3 women replied. I would be surprised if that wasn't about the total number of women that read it and is about the percentage of women woodworkers out there ,[if that high].

I think it boils down to the simple fact that not many women do wood working and the only reason is because they don't choose to. If they wanted to they would I am sure and the only thing that prevents them is thierselves , no reflection on the women only an observation on what their interests are and are not .....Todd

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#45

Stirring

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Gotta go with what you do best.

Mainely,Bob-Who has found that some folks just don`t have a sense of humor,no matter how many smileys are attached.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#46

Re: funny that you should mention cycling...

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>but not as safe as jogging with both feet on the ground and weightlifting which are my activities of choice - unless i get hit by a car or drop a dumbbell on my foot!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#47

Re: funny that you should mention cycling...

ThomD

>Joggin was never my forte, but for a lot of my friends for whom it was, they blew up their knees, which while not fatal does push you back onto the bike.

I just came back in October from a thousand mile trip on my bike. Always dangerous because every car that passes could have your name on it, but I only had one close call when an 18 wheeler came off the road and onto a lawn and completely on the bike trail, while trying not to hit a stopped car. It all happened about 25 yards ahead of me so it wasn't close, but one could visualize it moved down the road on top of one. Funilly it was a section in Quebec where the bike path was facing trafic, generally one wouldn't even se that coming.

I also had great difficulty getting over the bridges on the Saint Lawrence into Montreal. I had to cross over the busiest imaginable highway bridge with no shoulder. Makes for an advanture.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#48

Thank you, Richard

Johanna in Placitas, New Mexico

>I really don't think anyone can pidgeonhole people by gender. Perhaps one reason more women don't take up woodworking is that they don't have time to do one more thing.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#49

impressive, MOST impressive...

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>thom, didn't realize that you were such an avid cyclist. good to hear that you're keeping yourself in shape. i really do HATE running but it's one of the FASTEST ways to burn off those excess thanksgiving/christmas calories!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#50

Re: impressive, MOST impressive...

Steve knight

>but it may be easier to ride a hundred or two miles on a bike and burn it off. I get about 100 miles a week in commuting. when I fetch wood thats a 8 mile round trip with up to 200# of lumber on my trailer.