Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

woodworking for women magazine

Posts

woodworking for women magazine

#1

woodworking for women magazine

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>alright, please bear with me because it is not my intention to OFFEND anyone especially our female comrades... have you guys (or gals) ever read this thing? i was just thumbing through the pages and started nodding my head somewhat CHAUVANISTICALLY when i saw all the scrollwork and pen turning projects when i noticed a plan for a blanket chest that was FRAME/PANEL construction with MITERED corners! another shop bench project required tools included: miter saw, table saw, router table and band saw!!! KUDOS to whoever came up with this idea to broaden our appeal! maybe i can get SWMBO to take up the hammer and chisel alongside me!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#2

Re: woodworking for women magazine

Adam Cherubini

>I spoke with someone from FWW about female woodworkers. Every tool manufacturer and WW publisher would love to discover a new and untapped market. But this fellow seemed to think females are maybe 5% of the the hobby and industry, which is why we dont' see more people catering to the female market. There are probably more neanderthal woodworkers than female woodworkers.

That said, in my opinion, the way to increase the hobby of woodworking is to teach hand tool usage and demonstrate projects that can be made with simple or few tools. I think the expense of power tools along with their high price tags are barriers that keep many would be woodworkers, golfing instead. I think that's the reason we see manufacturers pushing multipurpose (even LN and LV do that).

Though I could be wrong. I took a woodworking class at a local high school years ago and the class was full of women whose husbands weren't getting around to their projects quickly enough.

Adam

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#3

Re: woodworking for women magazine

Marc in Luxembourg

>Don't do that! I repeat do not! Our last refuge, you won't give it up ;-) please!

Marc, who drank a little french Pomerol this evening and isn't so serious anymore

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#4

Re: woodworking for women magazine

R.J.Whelan (Eastern Sierra, CA)

>Take a look at College of the Redwood's list of alumni and check out some of the outstanding work done by these women. If anyone thinks that males have some inherent talent advantage when it comes to hand craft this site will quickly disabuse you of that notion - I wish I was as accomplished as any of these woodworkers ... rj

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#5

Your publisher needs to get out more

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Last time I was up to Center for Furniture Craftsmanship the females were at about 40-50%.Likewise the women in the turning classes I teach are about 20% of total enrollment and climbing.

It`s not uncommon to walk into any of the boatyards up here and find at least one female joiner holding journeyman status.

Somebody needs to bring themselves up to date.

Mainely,Bob

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#6

Re: Your publisher needs to get out more

dennis mcdonaugh

>I don't think you can assume that the percentages of women woodworkers is equal to the percentage of women in your woodworking classes. Men don't like to learn new things in groups and women do so they are more likely to enroll. I'm sure magazine editors and manufacturers have a pretty good idea what their demographic looks like.

From my observations at woodworking stores, shows and forums like this one 5 to 10 percent sounds about right.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#7

Re: Your publisher needs to get out more

dave j

>I was just displaying my tools at a show jointly put on by local artists and the Guild of Oregon Woodworkers. The attendees were primarily non-woodworkers who were shopping for gifts. Many women came by my booth and commented that they "wished they could do woodworking" and were very intrigued by the handtools and the idea you could do woodworking with handtools. We have some local woodworking classes put on by women and taught by women that I encouraged them to check into.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#8

cut it out, marc!

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>if i was eating or drinking anything that split second just before i clicked your message, i would have SPEWED it all over the monitor and keyboard!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#9

Re: woodworking for women magazine

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>RJ, i just checked out the website for the magazine and i must say that i can not even begin to hold a candle to some of the work being doing by our female colleagues. a lot of their work was SHEER ART and had a very david marks flavor to it. next to the pieces i saw in the gallery, well, my stuff is... SUBPAR!!!

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#10

you may be on to SOMETHING, adam!

frank shic (walnut ck, ca)

>adam, do you think that hand tools could spark a woodworking RENAISSANCE in this day and age? you're right that hand tools can be much CHEAPER alternative to their electron burning cousins although the last time i checked the prices on lie-nielsen's web site, their FINE hand tools were comparably priced to at power tools! maybe the ANANT line of hand planes can help change that.

still, it's an ENCHANTING idea that you suggest. i'd LOVE to perform general woodworking demonstrations in the future (after i get good with the tools and retire in about 27 more years!) with hand tools to bring the MAGIC that we all feel to the rest of the unenlightened world.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#11

Re: woodworking for women

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There are some basic differences between men and women, none of which will affect the amount of skill a woman can develop in wood working. I think the only reason more women aren't woodworkers is because it is viewed as a "man's" job in our culture. There are two women and two men in our production furniture line at my day job, and we have numerous other women throughout the shop. They are just as capable as the men are, and probably pay more attention to detail as a general rule than the men do. I think most women fear power tools more than men do; men inherently relish a battle, and most

women do not. Men will look at a table saw and conquer it; women will wonder why there isn't a safer way to cut wood . I agree with Adam, if we teach woodworking from a different angle to women, there are many women not woodworking now that would enjoy it.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#12

My experance

Todd Hughes

>In my experance over many years selling tools is that women make up a very small percentage of the people who buy wood working tools and I would have to think from that that also do wood working.When I used to set up at antique shows and flea markets I did sell a good bit to women but normaly specific things like small hammers, pliers,screw drivers, things that they would use around the house or to fix furniture. Small oil cans were very popular because I think they used them to put thier rings on. Actually had two Martha Stewart clones get into a pushing fight over some once.

.....It got so that I would buy just for this "woman" market and did pretty well. Also a good market for women that do crafts like jewery making and with these tools they probably out bought the men.Interestingly seemed like a good many women blacksmiths though I always got a feeling that most were "artist" blacksmiths rather then ones that did any real work.

...While I did occasionaly sell some tools like planes to women they were always buying them for a gift or to use for decorating and I always asked too because I was interested. In all those years I can't remember one women wood worker that made furniture buying a tool.Can't remember any Black folks either and for that matter very few minoritys though I do think there is a market for cheap user carpenter tools for the "Mexican" workers

I believe if you think about who the avarage wood worker probably today is , a middle age man who works a 9-5 job and comes home and does wood working as a hobby and a way to relax, you can see why not many women would get into it. The same age woman probably has kids to take care and work to do around the house and less real free time.If she has any intersts is probably what her other female friends are doing like painting classes and other art or craft things.Unlike her husband she was never exposed to wood working and never had a desire to do it. Is a shame but I think it would be an uphill battle to change this.

....I do hope that I haven't came across as a sexist as nothing could be further from the truth! I think women should do what ever they want and for most jobs are just as capable as a man. I really like a woman that is handy, When I met my one girlfriend now the first thing that impressed me was that she had a work bench that she used in her spare room ......[well,..maybe it was the second thing !] ....Todd

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#13

I'm speechless :)

Adam Cherubini

>

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#14

One more thing about women

Adam Cherubini

>I'd like to stick my foot in my mouth now:

From my observations, women are oriented toward small things, small patterns and textures. When choosing a rug, a owmn is more likely to find a tiny speck of green in the leaf of a blue corn flower drapery or upholstery and use that as the entre for the green. I believe this has to do with the genetic role of women as foragers, selecting the ripe berries. Men on the other hand usually prefer solid colors; They won't choose the toile or corner flowers. As hunters, their minds aren't open to other things they might encounter along the way. Thus the short trips to the shopping center.

Therefore: In the construction of furniture, men naturally lean toward the flat, clean, deconstructionist styles. Surface imperfections are annoyances, not destinations. Moldings, like corn flowers, are to be minimized or avoided. Arts and crafts/mission, or japanese styles represent male dominated material culture. Baroque, Roccoco and the like are feminine and I think most of you think so.

In conclusion, when building for women, I think we have to recognize their very different tastes. When attempting to attract women to woodwork, aside from window boxes and other utilitarian stuff, they may prefer and actually prove to be superior to men in the production of finely detailed carvings and joinery. I know my wife would no more push a sheet of plywood through a cabinetsaw as she would slide under a truck to do an oil change. But given the chance to carve, or turn, or make a fine joint with a chisel, I suspect her keen eye and nimble fingers would be far more successful to mine.

Adam

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#15

Re: My experance

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>In the words of an old and dear friend "you`re quite a rig".

I can almost hear the politicly correct heads exploding from here.

Keep up the good work.

Mainely,Bob

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#16

Re: woodworking for women magazine

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I think you've missed one good thing about having women in the shop. Allow me to illustrate with a true story. I'd been getting by with an old Craftsman router (OK, not a hand tool, sorry) hanging under the table. Always a problem for me. Now, I'm working on a project with my wife (who's getting pretty good) and I proceed to tell her all the little tricks to get it to work right. Then, as she's routing, the machine drops, bit lowers, have to reset and do the cut again. NOW, after she's experienced the problems and frustration I hear "Why don't you get a new router?" Woohoo!!!! So, the lesson is, let your wives and girlfriends use all the things that frustrate you but you can't justify buying.

Of course, the flip side to the argument is you sometimes need two of every tool. However, I like having my wife around. Just remember to keep pushing safety, especially with two people in the shop. Not as critical with handtools, but definitely with power tools.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#17

What about "Clothcraft for Men"?

Derek

>or "Tailoring for Males"? :>)

P.S. I tried to get my girls involved but failed.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#18

*SCC* redux...Your count is off...

cooper suter

>Todd,

...." my one girlfriend now"......

If that is the previously mentioned Miss Jazz your refering to, from what I noted in the images, I'd say the bench should have been the THIRD thing noted.

Unless you group like items for counting.

Coop.

PS, (SCC= "Sophmoric Comment Contest")

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#19

How old are your girls?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Derek,

If they're not yet grown, don't give up - when they become teens and older, kind of wander out to the shop as you talk to them, draw them along. A lot of people, when they stop being kids, get interested in stuff that's just not of interest when they're little.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#20

Statistics vs. cases

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>That may be true statistically, Adam, but, as you know, there's always a lot of overlap. Hard to explain some of the more elaborate furniture designs as designed by women. Also really hard to explain the French courts during the various Louis that way.

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#21

Re: How old are your girls?

Derek

>Thanks Bill. Thats' my hope. :>)

2 are grown up and one pre-teen - also one in the middle of the alternate gender...

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#22

Hey !

Todd Hughes

>I do all my own clothing repairs and have sewn [by hand of course!] entire period shirts and pants for me in the past.When I was a kid my sister and me had some baby rabbets and when they died I tanned thier hides and made little fur coats for her Barbie dolls. She still has them but a little worse for wear.Made one out of the neighbors cat for my Teddy bear

..I buy a good many vintage women clothing for resale and have to proudly admit to knowing a bit about the subject.[ shamlessly promoting myself now but I do have some splended Chinese silk designer dresses on the ebay currently!] Sure I get some looks and comments walking though the flea market carrying some saws...and a beaded hand bag and a simply wonderful sun dress that I have just bought but who cares? Will confess up too that women just seem to love a man that ain't afraid of sterotypes , just met a gal last week by talking with her about 1940s platform shoes and things look promising! .....Todd

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#23

Re: *SCC* redux...Your count is off...

Todd Hughes

>Different Girl...this is my weekend girlfriend Joanne......

Probably best not to mention what Jazz has in her spare room....Todd

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#24

Women just can`t resist...

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>a man who knows how to accessorize.

You`re a shoe in there Todd,just don`t forget the sword.

MB

Re: woodworking for women magazine

#25

Re: One more thing about women

ThomD

>The nimble fingers thing might be true at some ultimate level if say tying the smalles fly became an olympic sport, but I;m a big guy, and I have never seen anything I can't do with my hands. I always cringe (more than usual), when the golf comentators say of some hulking golfer "he has great touch for a big man" Like everyon over 5' 10" has some tall guy palsy.

I also agree a bit about style preferences, though all such styles were presumably invented by men. Stuff that might get called gay today was just normal course in older times - for the rich. A fair amount of it comes down to who has to do the work. It seemed more practical for me to ape Shaker or Asian influences since 30 years ago it seemed unlikely I would last long enough as an amateur to carve complicated aristocratic boudoir furniture (even if real challenge lies in that direction). To a certain extent we reach across each other's oceans to adopt as sophisticated each others peasant style. Look at the line-ups at Green Gables.