I hate my shop vac
(But I wouldn't be without it.) It's nosy, it's heavy, it's always in the way, it's incredibly messy to clean and empty. And it constantly gets stuck on it's power cord; I think I hate that the most.
Is there anything to about it?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
I hate my shop vac
(But I wouldn't be without it.) It's nosy, it's heavy, it's always in the way, it's incredibly messy to clean and empty. And it constantly gets stuck on it's power cord; I think I hate that the most.
Is there anything to about it?
Re: I hate my shop vac

Re: I hate my shop vac
Mine's permanently parked at my side man-door halfway down the shop. I bought a reeeeeally long hose from HD. It reaches every possible corner up, down and across and I never get it stuck on anything anymore.
Re: I hate my shop vac
I have a Rockler vortex vacuum attachment. It's like the oneida dust deputy -- turns the shop vac into a two stage collector -- but it works well as a "stand alone" unit alongside the shop vac. The oneida has to be mounted or strapped to the shop vac or it'll fall over and be totally ineffecitive.
Won't make the shop vac quieter but is easier to empty and keeps the vac filter from getting clogged.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Hi Eliot,
If you want a quiet vacuum get a Festool or a Fein.
The Festool has a bigger footprint and is harder to carry but has a variable speed to adjust the suction when sanding. If you don't need that, the Fein is a squarish version of a shop-vac. Both are excellent performers.
Festool has anti-static hoses which prevent dust from sticking and also prevent static buildup from discharging into the motor control and killing it. Don't ask why I know that.
Festools are HEPA by default, Fein is a separate filter purchase. If you sand lead paint or concrete (silica) it can matter, otherwise the standard filter is OK.
The small hose cuffs on the euro vacs clog easily when vacuuming up shavings and larger bits. While designed for tool attachment, they don't excel at general vacuuming. A Lee Valley accessory hose changes that.
For any brand of vacuum I use the filter bags. The filters clog without the bags and can't be cleaned of the finest particles. They also make the emptying process a lot cleaner. Someone mentioned using a cyclone separator - I do that and it it greatly extends the life of a filter bag. The cyclone does take up space but to me it's worth it. People don't like the cost but the bags allow the vac to perform it's best for the longest time.
I will use a broom and pan for big things then vacuum the small bits to get clean.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Eliot, 7 or 8 years ago I purchased a Festool CT26e for all the reasons Steve mentioned. My previous vac was a Fein, which had done duty for 10 years, and was equally excellent. The Fein died as I had a senior moment and plugged my table saw into it! Yeah, don’t go there.
The Festool has been superb. Never skipped a beat. Yes, it has a power cable, but it is long when needed, and I also have long-enough hoses (a few of different diameters).

The set up has an Oneida Ultimate Dust Deputy, which I chose over the Festool version. A friend had both and was adamant that the Festool version did not suck as strongly. Pity, as it is more compact.
I also added, at the time of purchase, a long life bag. Frankly, this is overkill with the UDD since no dust gets to it.
In all these years I have only needed to clean the (HEPA) filters once. It just works.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: I hate my shop vac
You can't possibly hate yours more than I hate the hard plastic hoses on my shop vacs. Darn things are barely flexible. They're so still, when I try to maneuver the hose, it will move the vacuum around instead. I miss the old fabric hose with spiral wire reinforcement.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Bound to be a lot of YouTube experts on shop vacs.
Re: I hate my shop vac
I really like my Fein Turbo II. It works well. It's quieter than most shop vac. It has a long hose and rolls easily. I have no issues with static. The filter bags make clean up easy. My dust collector gets most of the planer shavings. I have a shavings bin under the jointer that catches most of those shavings. The router is the only thing that throws shaving on the floor, but I can suck those up with a hose connected tot he DC system.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Nothing worse than a nosy shop vac....damned things gotta learn to keep outta our bidness!! :o)
Thanks for the laugh!
Re: I hate my shop vac
Your post was the most fun.
So what are you sweeping up after these days?
Re: I hate my shop vac
We're having a very unusually warm, early spring here in Michigan.......so I've been mowing the grass, picking weeds, and raking up last fall's late leaves.......come to think of it, early springs may be overrated.......
I love my shop vac.
The only thing I hated about my vacuum was that the Festool bags were absurdly expensive. The Mullet solves that problem.
Designed by Heath Robinson?
Re: I hate my shop vac
Not sure I have anything to add, but that's never stopped me before. For years I have had a Rigid shop vac. Craftsman before that, really NOISEY. The Rigid kept getting in the way and I broke down and bought a Festool C26. Couldn't imagine spending $600 on a shop vac but I did. Must have really needed it because soon after getting it I noticed an excellent little spot for the Rigid to hide in. Then soon after that I bought another older Festool at an estate sale. So that one is tucked under a bench and dedicated to my belt and disk sander. The CT26 is tucked under my cart that has a MFT style top on it and generally sucks up sanding dust. The Rigid is in the other room with my other bandsaw and serves that. After all that, I do about ninety percent of my cleanup with the hose from my DC which is in a tiny closet outside the shop.
The one thing I would add is I use bags inside all the vacs. I know several people mentioned the cost but since the DC does most of the work I don't really notice. But, Being cheap, I slit the end of the bag open and carefully dump the contents into the trash. Then if there is room inside the vac I clamp the end shut with two sticks and spring clamps. (Generally hate spring clamps but this is a good job for them.) If there is no room for the sticks I use CA and glue the end shut again. You have to be careful with the rigid bags because they are really fragile on the interior. I like the bags, they keep the filters clean and make emptying the vas much easier. It would be really easy if you just through the bags away but my packrat gene won't allow that. When I finally throw one out I practically have a funeral service for it.
I heard they make a muffler for shop vacs but it really cuts the suction.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Am I the only one that has 40 year old Shop Vacs? One in in the inner workshop. The other is in the outer workshop adjacent to the garage. The outer one comes in handy when accumulated snow on the car melts. The snow makes a big puddle in the area that my wife and I use to walk into and out of the garage.
I purchased permanent filters. No more bag replacements. When needed I bring the filter outdoors and blow it clean with an air hose.
Permanent filter
That's a good one!
You can blow the chunks off it but you can't get the fines that are killing the flow. Those are embedded in the filter media.
Filtration is best utilized in stages and a bag is one of those. A very fine filter can go through its capacity without looking any different. Once the particle size is down to microns it won't be anything you can see, blow out, or hose down. The filter may look good but can be full. Cyclone - bag - filter is a pretty effective and economical setup in the long run. The cyclone can just dump into a plastic garbage bag. The $5 filter bag will last a long time when there is a cyclone upstream and the final filter will only have to remove the bits that the bag misses.
Shop-vac and Ridgid use paper bags that tear easily while Festool uses fleece bags that are pretty tough. My wife's vacuum uses bags similar to Festool's and there is absolutely no dust inside the canister when the bags get changed. That's pretty impressive. It has made a big difference for our allergies using the better vacuum (Miele).
It's a tough sell for an expensive shop vac but between the noise reduction and air cleanliness I am happy with the better vacs. I still have a shop-vac in the garage but even outside I find it too noisy and not very powerful.
Re: I love my shop vac.
What type of pipe did you use? pvc dwv and did you have to alter it to fit? Thanks
Early Michigan spring.........
A couple of days ago, I drove the Corvette with the top off in 80° weather......last night, it snowed with snow still on the house roofs and lawns this morning........
Re: Early Michigan spring.........
That reminds me of when I used to go to Dallas on business. In the morning there would be light snow on the roads. In the evening it would be in the eighties.
Re: Response
I used PVC. I did not glue the pipe because they need some wiggle room to open the lid of the festool vac. But now that I have the Mullet vortex, I don't have to change the bag very often at all. It certainly works. FYI, I used PCV 60? connectors from the home depot. They have a thicker wall. They also seem to have a wider inside diameter and smoother flow.
Also, I took off the Mullet wheels and attached the vacuum onto a plywood base that links into the systainer system hold downs. It required a little fiddling.
Surprising Bonuses:
1. The Festool now drags easier when being pulled from the hose. Somehow the directional mechanics are better.
2. Love to watch the trash circling around.
3. Because of the large opening in the Mullet, it is easy to get out stuff that you accidently suck up.
Re: I hate my shop vac
Get the Ryobi coordless shop vac.. You can easily carry it with one hand using its handle. Vac has a 4 ft hose, and 2 onboard attachements. It sucks like crazy...I would say on the order of a shop vac...maybe not as much..but close to it. I like it so much, got one for the shop, one for the garage. Its easy to clean...open two clips and dump it. Can be a wet vac (but I've never used it for such). If your patient you can easily pick one up for <$100, sometimes "scratched" for $60. It has an air filter that can be a pain (like most pleated filters) to clean...but tip: get a pool filter sock and put over filter, and that will make cleaning it really easy.
I hate the normal shop vacs too...just like you say, they get snagged on everything when pulling them around and they need to be plugged in...etc.etc.
Re: Response
I'm using a Duststopper(cyclone top on a 5 gal bucket sold at HD)on a Festool ct22, I used 2" pvc and only had to alter one fitting with a heat gun, thanks for posting your version, it's a great way to get my setup off the floor.