Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Bandini-Done

Posts

Bandini-Done

#1

Bandini-Done

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

It's been a long slog filling my son's request for Green & Green "style" Bandini storage bench for his foyer. DIL wanted cherry with a walnut stain (rather than walnut).

This is the original:

and


No doubt I could have saved myself a lot of time (and wood) if I'd simply purchased a set of plans, but they had specified several design changes so I had to wing it.

Here is my "interpretation" of the G&G while incorporating their requests:






Finish is Minwax "Special" walnut stain sealed with dewaxed shellac, toned with dyed shellac, and topped with General's Enduro Semi-gloss.

Comments welcome.

Re: Bandini-Done

#2

Re: Bandini-Done

Barry Irby

That is a beauty. Well worth the effort and the wait.

Re: Bandini-Done

#3

Bandini-Done

Tom Colligan

Comments? Just extraordinary, Mark; really nice.

Re: Bandini-Done

#4

I like your arms better

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I noted the original had a "piano" hinge for the seat lid. Don't know why a piano hinge was used. What did you use?

Re: Bandini-Done

#5

Hinges

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Same, pianos, they just didn't show up in the pics. Each lid also has one of these http://www.rockler.com/adjustable-lid-support to prevent little fingers from getting slammed.

Thanks, Bill. I fussed over the arms and finally decided on the bird's mouth join but it was a hard joint to get right because of the pitch of the back supports. To get a descent joint I had to go to the 2" vertical belt sander to sneak up on the angle across the end grain.

Re: Bandini-Done

#6

Kneale Brownson

Is it camera angle?

Kneale Brownson

Is there a difference in the uprightness of the backs?

I also think your arms are more attractive.

Re: Bandini-Done

#7

Good Eye, Not The Camera

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The uprights are cut with a 15° tilt towards the back plus they are tapered from the 2" of the "leg" section down to 1" at the top. The crown is set to be parallel with the front surface of the uprights but the bottom edge of the crown has a slight bevel so that the back slats will meet it at the top but be set back in the seat deck. The back slats are thus not parallel with the front surface of the uprights.

Those details drove me nuts trying to get them aligned and reasonably tight. I finally had to make the mortises for the slats' bottom tenons into pockets. The glue-up involved packing those pockets with thickened epoxy and letting it squeeze out when the crown/slat assembly was put in place and clamped.

Re: Bandini-Done

#8

Re: Bandini-Done

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Very nice adaptation. Good looking piece. Well done.

T.

Re: Bandini-Done

#9

Re: Bandini-Done

Bart S Goldberg

It looks great Mark! Nice job!

Re: Bandini-Done

#10

Very nice Mark!

Jim Dillon

I love the idea of storage within the bench, and - as a admirer of G&G furniture - your interpretation of the arms. Great job. Jim

Re: Bandini-Done

#11

Thanks, Jim

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Took a bunch of "liberties" with the original design in order to fit the piece to the space and intended use as well as to the "clients'" requests.

Hope Messrs. Green aren't offended. ;)

Re: Bandini-Done

#12

Re: Bandini-Done

jesse cloud

Great job. Your arms are a huge improvement over the original!

Just watch though, now the "client" will want matching end tables, matching coffe table, etc. You're in for it! :\

Re: Bandini-Done

#13

Arm height question

Gary Smyth

The bench I've seen similar to yours had a 2" high leather cushion on the wood seat. The original bench picture seems to have the arms placed higher than the pictures of the new. Is that a visual angle illusion? Is a seat cushion planned?

Re: Bandini-Done

#14

Very well done!

Chuck Nickerson

Personally I really enjoy the challenge of reinterpreting a design.

Re: Bandini-Done

#15

Re: Arm height question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hi Gary,

The arm rest height I used is the standard 8" above the seat deck for adults. No cushions have been planned as this is an entryway item to be used for shoe changing etc. so it would be a pain keeping cushions in place with opening/closing of the storage bins. While I don't have the actual height for the G&G's arm rests, they may look higher because the back elements on mine are almost 50% higher (the crown rail is 45" high) than the original. That visual stretch of the vertical elements would tend to make the gap between seat and rest look smaller, especially on top of the heavier storage box.

Re: Bandini-Done

#16

Reinterpreting Indeed

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When my DIL asked if I could make it, she handed me a photo of a modern knock-off that had stretched the basic design into a defacto 6' couch which wasn't going to fit her space. I had to hunt up the original G&G piece, and then modify from there to meet the design goals.

I started out to reinterpret a reinterpretation, then bailed to went to the original source. ;)

Re: Bandini-Done

#17

Re: Bandini-Done

Sgian Dubh

Interesting Mark. When I compared the original to your interpretation I couldn't help thinking there seemed something a bit 'stiff' about your backrest, which was not in evidence in the original. I couldn't work it out. Did the back rest not lean back, or if it did, was it more upright? Was there something jarring or clumsy in the profiles of the splats? Neither seemed to be the case. Then it dawned on me: I'm pretty sure the original back legs on their outside edges flare or curve outwards slightly above the seat, whereas it looks like yours rise straight, and on noticing that I'd found what appears to be the answer to my perception of slight visual stiffness. Of course, I could be wrong and the photographs of both pieces fail to capture the true likeness of either.

Other than that I think you've worked well to create something that will be much appreciated by your family members. Well done. Slainte.

Re: Bandini-Done

#18

Another Good Eye

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The original that I saw does, in fact, flair the stiles slightly up to the crown rail. That flair complements the original's additional top curve and the slats outward curves. I chose to simplify the top stile/rail joint, allowing the stiles, crown rail, and seat deck to "picture frame" the slatting elements.

Thanks for the observation!

m

Re: Bandini-Done

#19

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Note too that the original's stile/rail joint was a loose tenon joint with slots cut in both pieces and then the joint pinned through both sides. I chose not to go there.

After all, I'm not trying to make a G&G reproduction. Copy work is not my thing.

Re: Bandini-Done

#20

Alan Young

Mark- Very Nice Adaptation

Alan Young

Would like to see it in it's new official residence.

Re: Bandini-Done

#21

Delivery Day

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is the 20th.

If I remember the camera . .

;)

Re: Bandini-Done

#22

Re: Another Good Eye

Sgian Dubh

On the other hand Mark, your version of the armrests is, in my opinion, an aesthetic flowing improvement on the stiff linear appearance of the original, as others have commented. My opinion therefore is that you've perhaps gained a bit ... and lost a bit, so pretty much all square! Slainte.

Re: Bandini-Done

#23

Re: Bandini-Done

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Beautiful! I am sure they will love it!

Re: Bandini-Done

#24

All Good

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Sgian,

Number of things are different in my piece. The legs are quite a bit heavier; had to be to hold plywood tenons as ply was needed for dimensional stability in the box from the increased moisture that's sure to get dumped in the box from muddy sneaks to soccer cleats (the floor is coated with 2 applications of bar-top epoxy).

The G&G Original was obviously not designed or built with children in mind. From a view of furniture and art, I much preferred the G&G piece, slightly funky arms notwithstanding. I also agree with your eye as to my piece being "stiffer". I made those choices so that the piece would take the wear and tear that 2 kids under 6 will dish out over the coming years.

Thanks again for your comments.

Peace :)

Re: Bandini-Done

#25

Re: Hinges

Yonak

That bench is a real beauty, Mark. I especially like the design of the back slats. Speaking of hinges, I wonder why the designers decided to go with lids for the storage areas instead of drawers. Are there somethings that are traditionally stored in there that make top access better ? It just seems to me the hinges may be uncomfortable for seating and a solid seat may or may not be more attractive (unless, of course, if a cushion is used).

Personally, I like the look of walnut-stained cherry. I've done that with some cabinet doors.