Wood choices for drawer sides
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"The" wood to use depends on what the builder decides is important to the drawer. Looks, wear, strength, ease of working with hand tools and price are four considerations that come to mind. The drawer side choice will be a compromise of these and maybe other considerations.
Period furniture will most commonly have poplar(in the north) or yellow pine ( Virginia and south) for sides. Price, ease of working and wear properties were of importance and looks likely not at all a factor. Other woods that were soft and cheap were used to a lesser extent, for example white cedar that was readily available for a time as conveniently sized shingle stock. These woods were easy to work, inexpensive and they wore faster than the wood used for runners and dividers. Period drawers were designed to be easily repaired when the sides become worn. Worn runners and dividers were not easily repaired. Anyone doing Period construction or even emulating Period construction, as is my case, would likely gravitate to poplar or yellow pine today. The Headley shop, for example, builds Period Correct Virginia furniture and they stock yellow pine for drawer sides. Personally I hate working this wood with its annoying hard- soft grain structure.
If the small amount of Studio Furniture I see is any guide looks is the primary driver for choosing drawer side material for this market. Plain bright woods like maple look attractive in this furniture. Soft maple, that is cheaper and more easily worked also shows up when it is desired to have a contrasting wood to the drawer fronts. Walnut on maple has a striking contrast that can be desirable in these pieces. Sides can even be primary wood. These pieces often have small drawers, or drawers that will not see daily use, so wear is a minor consideration. Ash shows up less than I think it should in this application. If it will look attractive to the perspective client, that can be the main factor driving choice.
English drawers are a special case. Early on they were pine. Later they were quartered white oak and very thin. Maybe they chose oak for strength in thin drawers, I don't know. Now days I see red oak in English reproductions, I suppose because it is cheaper and more readily available. It looks out of place to my eye in a Period mahogany piece because of color and coarseness of grain. When a drawer slip fails in these pieces the thin white oak side saws a groove into the mahogany divider that is impossible to attractively repair. This failure could be an issue to consider in a drawer that will see daily use, or irrelevant in a hall table.
The bottom line of drawer material selection is to decide what is important for your drawer, considering style, drawer use, construction of the piece, etc. Then choose a wood that is the best compromise for your application. Plywood may be the "best" choice. Other's recommendations may or may not be a useful guide depending on whether their goals match yours.