Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Posts

The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#1

The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! I've detailed the process of drawer building for my cabinet, which was finally accepted by New Hope Arts. Now I can say I'm looking forward to the show. I'll be delivering it this weekend and so I'm going over some parts a little quicker than I normally do. I look forward to your comments.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/11/01/the-floating-credenza-drawer-building/

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#2

question about oak drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Oak seems an unusual choice for drawers, either from looks or function, especially in a cherry cabinet. Why oak?

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#3

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Brian Holcombe

Quarter sawn oak is common for drawer sides, and using red oak in this case I feel the woods are of a similar color spectrum while offering some contrast.

Maybe you could include a suggestion for use with cherry rather than simply questioning my choice.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#4

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Joseph Piotrowski

i was told/read some time ago that drawer slides should be a different wood than the drawer material.

i can't recall the specifics but at the time it sounded good. is that still a correct concept?

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#5

Brian.....finally, a reason to dislike you

roger lance

you have all your hair !!

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#6

Hah!  Thanks for the humor.


Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#7

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Brian Holcombe

It's what I've done to take advantage of woods that I prefer to use for drawer sides, and to add some contrast but I cannot say with certainty.

Truly there are excellent woods for drawer sides and wear components, such as lignum vitea, however they're not so common in drawer building in fact the only person I know of who uses them is Chris Hall.

Hopefully Warren Mickley or William Duffield will chime in WRT to that, they would be more knowledgeable as to the specific drawer side choices and logic as to why they're popular.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#8

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Bruce, a MN Galoot

It doesn't have to do with contrast or any other color reason. When one kind of wooden part slides on another wooden part, one of them is going to wear. It's easier to fix a drawer side or runner than the cabinet it slides on.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#9

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Barry Irby

That's red oak? I can't remember seeing red oak with such prominent rays. I ahve lots of white oak with a strong ray pattern, but not red oak.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#10

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Brian Holcombe

Bruce, the way I make my drawers it is easier to replace the runners. I made the process especially easy in this case.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#11

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Brian Holcombe

It surprised me and two fellow woodworkers but it's definetly red. Doesn't work anything like white oak.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#12

Great stuff!

Tony - Memphis

Makes me very ashamed of what I make and call drawers!

Thanks for sharing.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#13

Re: Great stuff!

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tony!

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#14

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Barry Irby

You can take a piece of red oak that is straight grained and blow bubbles with it, but you can't do it with white oak. That's why bourbon barrels are made of white oak. Hard to imagine air passing through those rays.

Use a piece with lots of rays for the runners. They are hard and slick.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#15

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Okay

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#16

Wood choices for drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The" wood to use depends on what the builder decides is important to the drawer. Looks, wear, strength, ease of working with hand tools and price are four considerations that come to mind. The drawer side choice will be a compromise of these and maybe other considerations.

Period furniture will most commonly have poplar(in the north) or yellow pine ( Virginia and south) for sides. Price, ease of working and wear properties were of importance and looks likely not at all a factor. Other woods that were soft and cheap were used to a lesser extent, for example white cedar that was readily available for a time as conveniently sized shingle stock. These woods were easy to work, inexpensive and they wore faster than the wood used for runners and dividers. Period drawers were designed to be easily repaired when the sides become worn. Worn runners and dividers were not easily repaired. Anyone doing Period construction or even emulating Period construction, as is my case, would likely gravitate to poplar or yellow pine today. The Headley shop, for example, builds Period Correct Virginia furniture and they stock yellow pine for drawer sides. Personally I hate working this wood with its annoying hard- soft grain structure.

If the small amount of Studio Furniture I see is any guide looks is the primary driver for choosing drawer side material for this market. Plain bright woods like maple look attractive in this furniture. Soft maple, that is cheaper and more easily worked also shows up when it is desired to have a contrasting wood to the drawer fronts. Walnut on maple has a striking contrast that can be desirable in these pieces. Sides can even be primary wood. These pieces often have small drawers, or drawers that will not see daily use, so wear is a minor consideration. Ash shows up less than I think it should in this application. If it will look attractive to the perspective client, that can be the main factor driving choice.

English drawers are a special case. Early on they were pine. Later they were quartered white oak and very thin. Maybe they chose oak for strength in thin drawers, I don't know. Now days I see red oak in English reproductions, I suppose because it is cheaper and more readily available. It looks out of place to my eye in a Period mahogany piece because of color and coarseness of grain. When a drawer slip fails in these pieces the thin white oak side saws a groove into the mahogany divider that is impossible to attractively repair. This failure could be an issue to consider in a drawer that will see daily use, or irrelevant in a hall table.

The bottom line of drawer material selection is to decide what is important for your drawer, considering style, drawer use, construction of the piece, etc. Then choose a wood that is the best compromise for your application. Plywood may be the "best" choice. Other's recommendations may or may not be a useful guide depending on whether their goals match yours.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#17

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

Brian Holcombe

If this is white oak I would be genuinely surprised, it is incredibly 'red' in color. I had intended to use white oak and pulled from the white oak pile, only to find when I got it home and under better lighting that it was red. I've compared to what I know to be white oak for a sanity check.

The drawer bottoms were red oak given by a friend when I realized my error, and they match.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#18

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Quarter sawn oak is common for drawer sides"

Other than in English furniture made from mahogany after sometime in the late 1700's or 1800's (I don't know a more exact date) and reproductions of this furniture I have never seen oak used for drawers. Maybe it is common in Japanese or Chinese furniture, a style I never have occasion to see. It doesn't show up in the Studio furniture I see either. Hence, my question seemed fair, and you provided a comprehensive answer.

Your style, novel construction and goals are so divergent from mine that a recommendation from me of what to use with cherry would be of no value to you or the others. But since you asked, the coarse grain of red oak would have been a deal breaker in this refined piece. Red oak won't stay red after some light and air exposure. It will eventually be brown. Other than cherry, I don't know of any wood that will stay red/pink. Even the pink of soft maple turns brown with age. Hence, a pink color would not have been a factor in my choice.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#19

Why not to use oak runnrs

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The pores can capture abrasive junk......after 200 years or less :( Maple is a good functional runner material.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#20

Re: Wood choices for drawer sides

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Bill, that reply is helpful. As I've mentioned in the past, I take no offense to criticisms and have been put under the microscope WRT some of my choices without taking offense, but I generally like to know why. Blogging my work is a learning experience for me in as much as it is anything else.

In this case, I am cherry picking information from a historical context to provide some reasoning and logic behind my decision making. I say that because I do take historical method into consideration, but it is far from the only consideration. I also use methods far more tedious than would be employed at the time.

I had briefly considered using alaskan yellow cedar for the drawer sides and given another project utilizing cherry I may very well do that as it seems like it may well be a nice choice to pair with cherry.

One of the experiences of building studio furniture of my own make and my own design are that I have to live with decisions I make on the fly that have a large impact on the overall project. They're often the thing that makes the work very interesting to me, for instance in this case I poured over the drawer pulls for literally days only to come up with a fairly simple solution.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#21

Re: Why not to use oak runnrs

Brian Holcombe

I used cherry there as well, being that it is a common choice for the wear strips in shoji.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#22

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

In support of Brian ...

I prefer to build drawer sides from quartersawn boards since this is more stable. Importantly, the expansion/contraction takes place across the grain, in other words, this would be in the vertical rather than the horizontal plain.

My choice in Australia is Tasmanian Oak, which is just one of a few names given to a variety of similar eucalypts (because early settlers decided it looked like Oak!). All Tasmanian Oak is quarter sawn since other cuts are unstable in this wood.

I like the light colour, and that it provides good contrast for the dovetails of darker drawer fronts.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#23

Re: question about oak drawer sides

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Derek! Your drawer making inspired me, it was the photos of your oak drawer sides and bottoms which encouraged me to break up with plywood and start using oak, which I did with the Butler's desk, and now continue with this credenza.

I used maple on my Mom's cabinet with plywood bottoms that were then covered in a felt material. I enjoyed both but more so enjoy working with oak, I feel the drawers in The Butler's Desk were a big step in the right direction.

Ellis brought up sycamore, which IIRC is available locally, so if I can find that quarter sawn I may very well give that a shot in my next project.

Also, Alaskan Yellow Cedar is high on my list. There is plenty of history of fine cypress (AYC is a cypress) used in shoji along with cherry wear strips, so I think the two will mesh well.

I think it's important for readers to consider the differences between Studio Furniture, which will be used carefully and an antique chest of drawers which may have been used daily or abused at some point. I'm not building a chest of drawers here, and it's highly unlikely that anyone who owns this cabinet will use it to store clothing or otherwise overstuff the drawers.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#24

Objectives....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I take no offense to criticisms " My objectives are not to criticize your work or how you spend your time. I have a book titled "500 Cabinets", the cabinets selected by experts in the design of furniture. 493 of them are off scale weird to my eye and I wouldn't live with them if someone gave them to me. Conclusion: I am design ignorant and hence should resist commenting on design.

Rather, from your examples I strive to provide alternatives for the readers, in the context of what are usually greatly different design and execution objectives.

Why might this effort be useful to the reader? When I began building furniture I was influenced by everything I read and saw, unaware that the motivation of what someone did could be different from myself. I wasted a lot of time finding the best way to make what I wanted to make. The breakthrough came from spending a week in a commercial shop that built the kind of stuff I wanted to make the way I wanted to make it. The methods I learned were efficient and reliable. I also learned that what gets fretted over on Forums and in magazines may not be important to fret over. I also take every opportunity I get to poke into antiques, but my opportunities are more limited in TN than if I lived in the northeast.

When presented an opportunity to provide information on what to use and/or how to use it I may take it on the chance that someone might find the information useful to their building needs.

A case in point that recently came up. The tapered sliding dovetail has been discussed in every venue from many perspectives. When it came time in the shop I worked in to assemble something where the magazines would call for a tapered sliding dovetail we used a simple straight housed dovetail. Properly sized, it slid together just fine with white glue. No need to fret the construction of a more complex joint and I haven't wasted my time developing a means of executing this joint. On the other hand, some might not want to miss the challenge of making a tapered sliding dovetail joint. The readers now have alternatives to choose from.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Drawer Building

#25

Re: Objectives....

Brian Holcombe

I tend to agree to some extent, I'm always amused at what becomes a talking point on a forum because often times it is something I did not spend much time thinking about.

The drawer sides are a fine example, and something I did not excruciate over.

Resawing is a huge time sink for me, so it's usually a last resort. I can get oak sized appropriately and work with that. Economics and availability plays a hand in what is ultimately chosen.

Sliding dovetails are a good example, I've worked my tools specifically to make them easy to do and minimize how much taper is needed.